So we’re 5 rounds in – who’s been your best and worst trades so far this year? I’m not talking about blokes you had at the start of the season.
Related Posts:
Best/Worst Trades
Previous post: Motts Movers R5 – The Mids
Next post: Corporate Boxing
Coaches Online
Recent Comments
- Gunndog on Thursday Chit Chat
- DamenS on Rate My Supercoach Team
- David on Thursday Chit Chat
- SoftSocks on Rate My Supercoach Team
- El Greco on Rate My Supercoach Team
- tappy on Bye Strategy 2012
- Happy Go Lucky on Rate My Supercoach Team
- Deano on The Brisbane List – Forwards
- Frank on The Brisbane List – Forwards
- Big Sexy on The Brisbane List – Forwards
- Motts on The Brisbane List – Forwards
- Motts on Thursday Chit Chat
- Big Sexy on The Brisbane List – Forwards
- Motts on The Brisbane List – Forwards
- BigRuss on Thursday Chit Chat
Official Sites
Popular Posts
- Rate My Team - Before Final Lockout (1452)
- The 2011 Bargains (852)
- Rate My Supercoach Team (749)
- My SuperCoach Team 2011 (527)
- R5 Progress Scores (507)
- Trade Talk R12 (471)
- R9 Trading (418)
- Rate My Supercoach Team (397)
- Off And Racing In R18 (391)
- Rate My Team - Pre-Season 2011 (374)
Useful Sites
-
Latest Ramblings
- The Brisbane List – Rucks
- The Brisbane List – Forwards
- Thursday Chit Chat
- Target Test – Jason Porplyzia?
- Target Test – Alan Didak?
- The Dockers
- Breakouts
- Target Test – Johnno Brown?
- Didak Out For A Month
- 2012 SCT All Girl Supercoach Leagues
- Yarran v Adcock
- Kennedy v Hurley
- The Unloved Ones
- Rookie Chat
- The Geelong List – Midfielders
-
Categories
- Analysis (53)
- Captain Selection Critical (66)
- Competition News (107)
- Ducks Guts (11)
- Injury Update (74)
- Motts' Movers (203)
- Polls (238)
- Progress Scores (40)
- Punting (31)
- Random Stuff (93)
- Rate My Team (15)
- Rookie Review (50)
- Rustees Draftees (18)
- Strategy (58)
- Team of the Week (1)
- Trade Talk (142)
- Uncategorized (103)
- Video Clips (1)
- Weekly Teams (63)
Get It By Email
Meta
-
-
SuperCoach Talk Tipping Competition
-
Looking For Something?
-
Latest Forum Discussions
-
Get smart with the Thesis WordPress Theme from DIYthemes.
{ 32 comments… read them below or add one }
Jury is still out on my worst – it could be J Brown but at the same time I can’t tell you how happy I was to get Tippett out of the side.
Would have to give the best title to Pav who has scored 139 and 112 since I brought him in and has gone up almost $29k.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
You got rid of Browndog, for whom ?
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
No, I brought him in.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Oh yeah.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Thax Motts,
Best Trade so far has been Ball — Coons, couldn’t stand having Ball in my side after he’s weak efforts.
Worst Trade ( Thus Far ) has got to be BBBBH — Brennan, watching Bazza kick a bag last week was bitter sweet to me and then Brennan woeful performance was the icing on the cake.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Best trade would has to go to either ball for rischetelli or Tippett to sandilands. My heart is now full with content.
Worst trades have been Hall to the dud dangerfield and another woeful mistake of mine was trading Mitchel to James mcdonald after his 130 game, he then scores 50- I know, I’m a fool.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Worst trade- Boomer out for some player i cant even remember.Just shake my head as Boomer keeps topping 100 every week.Only saving grace is I know I’m not on my Pat Malone.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
since ive only used 2 trades, both of them have been good. RIewoldt out for Chapman, and Jackson trengove out for silvagni who has made me heaps of money. very happy indeed!!
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
How about a thread on coaches’ best non-trade? After BBBH’s opening two scores of 60 and 43, those who stuck by him would be rapt with his subsequent scores of 132, 72 and 119.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Thax for rubbing it, Iron.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Just focussing on the positives.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
My stuff up so far has been Jolly out for Seaby. Jolly might now be a keeper as a second ruck – he’s looking a lot better and has stopped giving away silly free kicks in ruck contests.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Fair enough, I’m just pissed cos I had the choice between BBBBH and Murphs.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Best : Shuey to GAJ.
Not great : Riewoldt to Peterson which gave me the money to get GAJ in. Pods/Rock would have been much better choices.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Only made two trades both after Roo’s injury in Rnd 3.
1) OUT: Roo, IN: J Brown .. thinking i should’ve gone Pav now but long term i’m thinking that J Brown will be good enough
2) OUT: M Brown, IN: Malceski .. glad i pulled this change. M Brown’s consistent but a consistent 70ish whilst i got in before Malceski went from mid priced to expensive.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
I have made 4 trades!
OUT Tippett ($425,900) IN Brown ($525,400)
OUT Farmer ($159,500) IN Silvagni ($83,400)
OUT Pendlebury ($563,100) IN Ablett ($727,700)
OUT Riewoldt ($595,700) IN Rioli ($417,700)
Starting to think bringing in Rioli was a massive mistake
already thinking I might trade him out – think his pubis ostiobis el gayiss is still playing up and restricting him alot
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
wow, i’ve still only made one trade (riewoldt for brown), though i do still own tippett, dangerfield and ball…..
tippett should have gone, but if adelaide start winning, he will score ok i think. ball and dangerfield look like they will get the axe this week for judd and davis. i think.
tippett could be on the move for sandilands next week, but i’m not sure i’ll be able to summon up the cash for that one, unless someone like hunt has a good week and increases a lot.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
you’ve only used 1 trade but now you’re stck with 3 dudds. Earlier in the season, tippett for sandi would’ve only cost you $100k – now it’ll cost you $300k!!
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Worst: BBBB Hall for J Brown after round 2. Should have ditched Medhurst instead of Hall.
Best: Chapman in Ziebell out.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
best trade would have been presti for malceski after round 2.
wasted trade was probably trengove to barlow after 2 rounds but worst would probably be rioli for riewoldt would of rathered brennan even though bad performance on the weekend.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
I’m not really happy with ANY of my FIVE (5) trades…except maybe getting Chappy…apart from that they all fit in the ‘worst trades’ category
IN Seaby OUT Tippett.
IN Ballantyne OUT Hall.
IN ROK OUT Voldt.
IN Chapman OUT Ballantyne.
IN Rockliffe OUT T. Walker.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Need some help! Seriously need another premium in my forward line. Who should I go for outa these???
- Pav
- Didak
- Harvey
- Goodes
- Rok
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
If money’s no object get ROK
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Best:
Tippett out, Kreuzer in.
Worst:
Ziebell out Rockliff, In
It was out of Ziebell or Dangerfield to get Tom Rockliff, should’ve gone Dangerfield.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Know a bloke who traded Boomer Harvey out after his stinker and brought Nick Riewoldt in. =FAIL!!
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Higgs bought him in as part of the Voldt trade worked perfectly
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
16 trades left suggesstions on which one to go for
Chaplin in – Hooker out
Rocky- Meds
OR
Grundy
& Rocky
OR
Maguire
& Sylvia
OR
Maguire
& Houlihan
and other ones
my DEF is J.Gram, Firrito, Taylor, Hooker, Waters, Malceski, Frawley (Silvagni, Nason)
FWD- Meds, Betts, Higgs, Gian, Byrnes, Petterd, Rioli (Pods, Roberts)
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
My worst trade has to be Rioli. Picked him up the thursday night after selection only to read the next day that he was injured. Two low scores since I picked him up has me contemplating benching him for either Rocky or Pods.
My best trade would have to be Grundy. I traded him in and he after a poor first week he lit it up last week and I hope he’ll continue on the same path. Funnily enough, I traded for these two in the same deal, dealing out Roo and Medhurst.
I am also very happy with the Jamar trade simply b/c he is not Kurt Tippett ( :
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
This week’s trades for me:
IN Sylvia OUT Ball
IN O’Keefe OUT Selwood
Had $130k spare and wanted to use it. Hopefully my midfield is now all 100+ scorers consistently, although I doubt Trengove can do that. But Ablett, Dal Santo, O’Keefe, Sylvia, Trengove,
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Oops, clicked Submit when I wasn’t done.
Barlow and Palmer and Bastinac as emergencies. I’m very happy
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Out – Hall
In – Byrnes
= disaster
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Best trade for me so far would have been:
OUT- Swan, IN- GAJ
Worst trade is a stinker:
OUT- Tippett, IN- Dangerfield
Like or Dislike:
0 
0