Breaking Even – Rd7

Written by Schwarzwalder on April 30 2018

A popular feature at SCT, we’ve shortlisted the most SC-relevant players for you as a handy guide (mainly those owned by 5% of teams or more, with a few exceptions).

For the Supercoach newbies out there, the Breakeven is the score needed by each player to hold his price.  If they score above that Breakeven value, their $$ value will rise.  If they score below that Breakeven point, they will lose value.  Sorry if I’ve overlooked something.  Be sure to let me know in the Comments below and I’ll update it as soon as I can.  If you have any questions about Breakevens, don’t hesitate to ask in the Forum and I’m sure our friendly SCT Community will help out.

 

LAST NAME, First Name (TEAM) (Price, Average): BE

All MID DPPs are listed under def/fwd/ruck (as appropriate)

DEF-FWD DPPs are listed as defs

RUCK DPPs are listed as rucks

 

PREMIUM DEFENDERS (>$500K)

WITHERDEN, Alex (BRL)($500 400, 96): 80

SIMPSON, Kade (CAR) ($521 500, 109): 97

HURLEY, Michael (ESS) ($549 700, 105): 99

YEO, Elliot (WCE) ($532 000, 100): 108

LAIRD, Rory (ADE) ($576 800, 117): 133

 

MIDPRICE DEFENDERS ($300K-$500K

DOEDEE, Tom (ADE) ($337 300, 88): 17

SICILY, James (HAW)(DEF/FWD) ($448 700, 105): 30

HOWE, Jeremy (COL) ($463 300, 95): 46

SEEDSMAN, Paul (ADE) ($429 200, 94): 47

BRAYSHAW, Angus (MEL)(DEF/MID)($333 400, 75): 52

MURRAY, Sam (COL) ($327 400, 76): 54

SAAD, Adam (ESS) ($343 200, 62): 55

FINLAYSON, Jeremy (GWS) (DEF/MID)($355 900, 88): 57

BONNER, Riley (PTA) ($314 500, 73): 70

RYAN, Luke (FRE) ($431 900, 90): 79

SHAW, Heath (GWS) ($435 900, 91): 80

LLOYD, Jake (SYD) ($459 700, 91): 89

McGRATH, Andrew (ESS) ($323 700, 64): 96

SAVAGE, Shane (STK) ($483 700, 102): 97

HIBBERD, Michael (MEL) ($438 600, 78): 101

RANCE, Alex (RIC) ($472 700, 91): 104

McGOVERN, Jeremy (WCE) ($458 700, 85): 120

TUOHY, Zach (GEE) ($418 200, 75): 172

 

BUDGET / ROOKIE DEFENDERS (<$300K, * = two games played)

DUMAN, Taylin * (FRE)($123 900, 69): -65

COLE, Thomas * (WCE)($170 400, 83): -64

MURPHY, Lachlan (ADE) ($153 600, 58): -53

MIRRA, David (HAW)($165 700, 67): -27

O’BRIEN, Lochie (CAR)(DEF/MID)($184 600, 49): 9

NAUGHTON, Aaron (WBD)($282 300, 59): 27

RICHARDS, Ed (WBD)($240 900, 60): 41

COFFIELD, Nicholas (STK) (DEF/MID)($234 000, 58): 54

GUTHRIE, Zac (GEE)($205 100, 45): 83

 

PREMIUM MIDFIELDERS (>$500K)

CRIPPS, Patrick (CAR) ($573 500, 121): 46

NEALE, Lachie (FRE) ($523 400, 101): 59

MERRETT, Zach (ESS) ($506 100, 83): 75

TRELOAR, Adam (COL) ($591 200, 116): 75

SELWOOD, Joel (GEE) ($535 300, 111): 89

BONTEMPELLI, Marcus (WBD) ($544 000, 102): 99

PENDLEBURY, Scott (COL) ($572 000, 110): 108

FYFE, Nat (FRE) ($630 800, 120): 109

MACRAE, Jack (WBD)($596 100, 123): 115

CONIGLIO, Stephen (GWS) ($549 500, 116): 117

ABLETT, Gary (GEE) ($620 700, 117): 127

OLIVER, Clayton (MEL) ($570 500, 111): 145

DANGERFIELD, Patrick (GEE)($640 000, 112): 151

KELLY, Josh (GWS) ($602 400, 105): 154

MITCHELL, Tom (HAW): ($601 900, 126): 156

MARTIN, Dustin (RIC) ($608 000, 119): 182

CROUCH, Matt (ADE) ($561 300, 85): 182

SLOANE, Rory (ADE) ($553 700, 92): 191

 

MIDPRICE MIDFIELDERS ($300K – $500K)

KELLY, Timothy (GEE) ($367 600, 99): 39

ARMITAGE, David (STK) ($318 000, 67): 66

O’MEARA, Jaeger (HAW) ($438 700, 88): 125

PARKER, Luke (SYD) ($482 500, 98): 132

ZORKO, Dayne (BRL) ($430 100, 66): 172

 

BUDGET / ROOKIE MIDFIELDERS (<$300K, * = two games played)

BAILEY, Zachary (BRL)($153 300, 38): -7

CUNICO, Jordan (GEE)($246 100, 80): 15

BRAYSHAW, Andrew (FRE)($237 100, 53): 18

CLARK, Hunter (STK) ($180 300, 38): 34

HOLMAN, Nick (GCS) ($263 500, 71): 35

FOGARTY, Lachlan (GEE)($294 800, 70): 36

BANFIELD, Bailey (FRE) ($269 900, 62): 41

DAVIES-UNIACKE, Luke ( NTH)($191 700, 39): 45

 

RUCKS

SIMPSON, Dawson (GWS)($290 300, 84): 3

LYCETT, Scott (WCE)($397 700, 83): 11

COX, Mason (COL)(RUCK/FWD)($281 400, 53): 30

GAWN, Max (MEL) ($608 000, 131): 42

ENGLISH, Timothy (WBD)(RUCK/FWD)($285 400, 65): 47

MCEVOY, Ben (HAW) ($463 000, 96): 72

NANKERVIS, Toby (RIC)($475 000, 97): 86

GOLDSTEIN, Todd (NTH)($442 700, 88): 98

SINCLAIR, Callum (SYD)($517 200, 107): 107

JACOBS, Sam (ADE) ($440 400, 84): 111

WITTS, Jarrod (GCS) ($475 300, 94): 112

NAITANUI, Nic (WCE) ($480 300, 96 ): 112

MARTIN, Stefan (BRL) ($532 700, 102): 127

GRUNDY, Brodie (COL) ($631 100, 126): 146

KREUZER, Matthew (CAR)($543 300, 73): 172

 

PREMIUM FORWARDS (>$500K)

MUNDY, David (FRE)(FWD/MID)($522 100, 103): 108

HEENEY, Isaac (SYD) (FWD/MID)($560 400, 109): 115

GRAY, Robbie (PTA)($581 500, 117): 119

McLEAN, Toby (WBD)(FWD/MID)($515 000, 105): 122

MENEGOLA, Sam (GEE)(FWD/MID) ($552 000, 97): 136

GREENE, Toby (GWS) ($514 600, 93): 153

FRANKLIN, Lance (SYD) ($514 200 103): 155

 

 

MIDPRICED FORWARDS ($300K – $500K)

PARFITT, Brandan (GEE)(FWD/MID)($432 600, 104): -5

FISHER, Zac (CAR)($373 100, 88): 17

DELEDIO, Brett (GWS)($473 500, 95): 17

STRINGER, Jake (ESS) ($355 300, 68): 54

STEPHENSON, Jaidyn (COL)(FWD/MID)($322 600, 68): 56

KENT, Dean (MEL)($329 400, 82): 60

CADDY, Josh (RIC) (MID/FWD) ($438 800, 92): 60

SMITH, Devon (ESS)(FWD/MID)($452 100, 94): 78

LAMBERT, Kane (RIC) ($474 200, 85): 85

CHRISTENSEN, Allen (BRL)($363 300, 78): 87

CURNOW, Charlie (CAR) ($423 300, 91): 87

BILLINGS, Jack (STK) (FWD/MID)($400 100, 77): 105

DAHLHAUS, Luke (WBD)(FWD/MID)($455 000, 83): 107

DUNKLEY, Josh (WBD)($368 600, 76): 117

DANIHER, Joe (ESS)($378 000, 60): 118

PETRACCA, Christian  (MEL) (FWD/MID)($439 400, 86): 119

HOGAN, Jesse (MEL) ($456 400, 93): 154

WALTERS, Michael (FRE)(FWD/MID)($460 100, 86): 158

KENNEDY, Josh J. (WCE) ($463 500, 64): 188

 

BUDGET / ROOKIE FORWARDS (<$300K, * = two games played)

RYAN, Liam (WCE)($194 100, 80): -88

HIGGINS, Jack (RIC)(FWD/MID)($196 900, 75): -45

GILES-LANGDON, Zac (GWS)($163 300, 57): -28

GUELFI, Matt  (ESS)($177 500, 68): -27

ZURHAAR, Cameron * (NTH)($190 200, 66): -18

FRITSCH, Bayley (MEL)($238 000, 65): -7

McKAY, Harry * (CAR)($207 800, 63): -3

GALLUCCI, Jordan * (ADE)(FWD/MID)($219 400, 65): 0

RIOLI, Willie (WCE) ($210 200, 49): 1

LIPINSKI, Patrick * (WBD)(FWD/MID)($204 000, 60): 1

GOWERS, Billy (WBD)($220 800, 54): 5

RATUGOLEA, Esava (GEE)($246 700, 61): 6

FOGARTY, Darcy (ADE)(FWD/MID)($174 000, 45): 14

VENABLES, Daniel (WCE)($170 500, 45): 16

HENRY, Jack (GEE)($217 800, 54): 27

CROWDEN, Mitch (FRE) (FWD/MID) ($221 700, 53): 28

WATERMAN, Jake (WCE)($267 000, 65): 29

GARLETT, Jarrod (CAR)(FWD/MID)($212 500, 51): 32

RAYNER, Cameron (BRL)(FWD/MID)($290 900, 55): 61

9
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

38 thoughts on “Breaking Even – Rd7”

        1. I don’t think tagging has ever been particularly successful on JPK. He doesn’t really run, he just sort of appears where the contested possessions are. It’d be like tagging a bigger, stronger version of diesel Williams.

          Short of holding him, or off ball shepherding which would lead to a free kick, you’d be better off to just rely on his recent poor form and tag the other ball magnets (eg Parker, with Hanners out).

          He really only had one huge quarter.

          But hey, you gotta find a job for Jzcobs I guess. I’d go for Parker or Heeney myself.

          2

          0
    1. Merrett has averaged around 110 the last two seasons, and I reckon he’s likely to do that from here on in.
      I’d therefore only pay 100k more for Macrae if he’s likely to keep this average of around 120 for the rest of the season (which would be a significant improvement on his past averages for the year)

      10

      3
  1. What does everyone think of
    TOUHY AND BONNER- OUT

    DUMAN AND HURLEY- IN

    Thumbs UP or nah

    Also comment if you think I should instead get a Premo mid for 620K or a Fwd Premo for 620k
    I can basically get any premo in any position but I’m unsure which line to improve on

    18

    5
    1. Crouch is definitely on my radar when he finally bottoms out in a few rounds. The quintessential fallen premium.

      5

      0
      1. He also does better in the 2nd half of the season. I have been thinking he might be last in the mids, depending on how else the other options are doing

        5

        0
          1. Not sure why you would trade Kelly when he’s pumping out tons every other week, surely you have bigger problems to deal with

            7

            0
  2. Justin Westhoff ($511800) Premium Forward / Mid – BE 51

    The highest scoring forward so far this year deserves a mention.

    Very durable as only missed 1 game in 6 years & definitely needs to be strongly considered.

    15

    1
      1. My new news on Buddy is a potential 4 to 6 weeks.

        I traded him to Higgins last week.

        Sorry guys but Buddy needs to go.

        8

        1
        1. I decided to skip on Higgins after he got dropped after he kicked a couple of snags on debut. Not sure if his job is locked in, but I am half thinking about:

          Buddy –> Higgins
          Holman –> Danger / Macrae / Hoff

          Considerations:
          – Will they keep playing Higgins and will he continue to score, I already have forward line depth issues without introducing this
          – Danger is going to drop more $ with that BE, Hoff may be affected by Ryder, and Macrae looks solid

          1

          1
    1. I got Westhoff in Round 2 for Ryder.

      I will have to cover him for his China Bye.

      At least he has DPP so I can park him on my Mid bench that week.

      lowest score of 82 makes him reliable with a huge ceiling (147) this week.

      Get on The Hoff Train!

      5

      0
  3. Possible trade this week, can go Coffield into Howe? Coffield b/e basically at his average and Howe probably the cheapest he’ll be all year, but can he be a top 6 defender?

    T/U – do trade
    T/D – hold off trade

    Thanks

    1

    4
  4. Does anyone rate Howe?
    I have 295$k – 25 trades
    Tu-I can do bonner and walters for Howe and westoff.
    Td-Or should i go bonner for hurley or Yeo
    Wait a week then downgrade walters to rookie and barry to 2nd rookie save cash crouch and martin
    Comment- another option??

    0

    2
    1. I reckon Walters should be your focus. Not sure Westhoff is the best option tho. Depends who you don’t have already, but presume you don’t have Mundy who should be a better long-term option. Westhoff will likely average less once Ryder is back up and running.
      How much would you then have left for a DEF, ie Bonner + cash?!
      Good luck

      1

      0
      1. Fwd line..
        Heeney-mclean-petracca-smith
        Frisch-guelfi-henry
        Inj: walters

        Backline
        Laird-simpson-sicily
        Finlayson-doedee-murray
        Bonner-mirra

        If i trade to mundy $187 500
        I could go Hurn-Witherden-savage – howe etc

        0

        0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *