BS Rookie Review Round 13

Written by Big Sexy on June 26 2012

Be sure and check out Nath’s SC STATS (on top menu) complete with all Break Evens and player stats with simple search functions.  Now with NEW functionality to load up your own team and check out you personalised team-stats.

My Top Five Rookie’s (<$200k) of the week:

1)    H Crozier (Mid/Fwd 131k) Crozier looked great at the start of the game this week, but faded hard, however, he’s still a cheap DPP.  Crozier had the 11 disposals with 4 marks and a tackle for an ordinary score of 40. His previous two scores were 62 and 21.

2)    S Gibson (Mid $94k) Gibson spent a ridiculous amount of time in the green vest and scored a total of 9 points…. So I couldn’t give top billing despite his 94k price tag.  I will give you a reminder that Gibson is a mature age rookie who was highly rated during the NAB Cup.  It took him a while to get his first run, and after three season on the Hawks rookie list.  Gibson’s first run saw him get 18 disposals and took 5 marks finishing with 56. 

3)    T Hine (Def 113k)  Hine just had the bye, and has just played the one game, but he also played a solitary game way back in round 11 last year.  In his first run of 2012 Hine had 16 disposals, a couple of marks and a couple of tackles topped off with a goal reaping a reasonable 50.  Wait another week if you can, but he is a defensive option if you’re desperate.

4)    T Campbell (Ruck $94k) With dip-stick Minson coming back I don’t expect Campbell will get another run…… but he did smash out a sensational 89 points and had 11 disposals with 4 marks.  He’s just a filla in the rook-review as likely to have poor JS. 

5)    J Patton (Fwd 196k) He was the number 1 draft pick, and continually likened to Brown-dog, it’s clear he will be a good player given time.  He will likely have great JS as he will be given every opportunity.  He’s been pretty solid with 7 & 8 disposals in his first two runs combined with a goal and 2 tackles in each game saw him get scores of 62 and 63…. But…. and there is a HUGE ‘BUT’, his starting price of $196k removes any value whatsoever…. So again, he’s a rook-review filla.  Then again, it depends what you’re looking for.

If you’re travelling north to see Melbourne take on Brisbane this weekend, there are plenty of cheap Brisbane hotels still available if you’ve left your booking until the last minute!

Here is the rookie data:

R13 SC SC Average Games Player Pos Price Team
89 89 1 T Campbell Ruck $94k WBD
96 67 4 J Elliott Fwd $227k COLL
39 64 4 S Shaw Def $212k ADEL
62 62 2 J Patton Fwd $196k GWS
61 60 5 S Darley Def $220k GWS
72 57 4 M Williams Mid $182k COLL
81 54 4 S Edwards Def $183k GWS
53 48 7 J Brennan Def $191k WCE
40 41 3 H Crozier Mid/Fwd $131k FREO
30 37 7 C Smith Mid $139k WBD
55 34 4 N Wilson Fwd $136k GWS
9 32 2 S Gibson Mid $94k NM
37 32 3 C Dell’Olio Fwd $111k ESS
23 25 2 M Whiley Def $113k GWS
DNP 74 1 A Miles Mid $113k GWS
DNP 62 1 B Warren Fwd $159k NM
DNP 59 3 J Crisp Mid $147k BRIS
DNP 58 3 L Spurr Def $162k FREO
DNP 58 2 L Sumner Mid $151k GWS
DNP 55 1 N Haynes Mid/Fwd $166k GWS
DNP 51 2 K Stevens Mid $135k WCE
DNP 50 4 J Bootsma Def $191k CARL
DNP 50 1 T Hine Def $113k GC
DNP 49 3 A Black Fwd $196k NM
DNP 47 1 E Yeo Mid $106k BRIS
DNP 47 4 A Tomlinson Def/Fwd $196k GWS
DNP 46 1 J Fitzpatrick Ruck $177k MELB
DNP 44 5 A Phillips Ruck $172k GWS
DNP 44 3 A Moore Def $190k PORT
DNP 44 2 T Walsh Fwd $113k SYD
DNP 43 1 J Tynan Def $106k MELB
DNP 42 7 C Hampton Mid/Fwd $199k GWS
DNP 40 3 J Mellington Fwd  $178k FREO
DNP 40 8 J Townsend Def $199k GWS
DNP 38 7 B Smedts Fwd/Def $172k GEEL
DNP 38 3 W Hoskin-Elliott Mid $183k GWS
DNP 37 3 J Paine Fwd/Def $127k COLL
DNP 37 1 J Bruce Fwd $113k GWS
DNP 36 7 I Folau Fwd $192k GWS
DNP 35 1 D Gorringe Ruck $192k GC
DNP 35 1 S Schultz Mid $113k GWS
DNP 35 3 A Young Fwd $129k PORT
DNP 35 3 B Wilkes Def $125k STK
DNP 31 3 J Lyons Fwd $124k ADEL
DNP 30 5 P Seedsman Mid $141k COLL
DNP 30 2 G Horin-Smith Fwd $113k GEEL
DNP 27 1 J Schroder Mid $113k GEEL
DNP 25 2 A Maric Fwd $164k RICH
DNP 24 3 K Ugle Fwd $114k COLL
DNP 24 2 J Boumann Def $113k HAW
DNP 22 2 Z Skinner Fwd $113k WBD
DNP 21 2 D Pearce Mid $106k WBD
DNP 20 4 B Hill Mid $108k HAW
DNP 18 1 R Neates Mid $113k WCE
DNP 17 2 P Yagmoor Def $106k COLL
DNP 17 1 T Ledger Mid $113k STK
DNP 16 2 A Magin Fwd $142k GC
DNP 16 1 J Simpkin Mid $113k GEEL
DNP 15 1 M Buntine Def $176k GWS
DNP 14 2 B O’Hanlon Fwd $106k RICH
DNP 12 1 L McCarthy Fwd $106k GEEL
DNP 9 2 B McKenzie Mid $111k NM
DNP 5 1 S Kerridge Fwd/Mid $106k ADEL
DNP 5 1 H Cunningham Mid $94k SYD
DNP 37 4 A Sexton Mid/Fwd $166k GC



Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

25 thoughts on “BS Rookie Review Round 13”

  1. I know Campbell has low JS, but I need to downgrade Giles. Is there any better option now or in coming weeks that anyone is aware of?


  2. Okay, can someone clarify for me has Patton been getting those scores in about 2 & half quarters before being subbed off,? think with a bit of match fitness under his belt will provide a great F7 and is actually great value at that price.The only thing I’m not sure of is his match time minutes, where do I find that ?


  3. This one’s primarily for Nathan, our resident stats guy, but if anyone else can shed some light on this please do.

    I’m curious about the differences between the breakevens on different SC related websites.

    Picking a player at random i picked Sam Shaw.

    Five different websites have his BE at:
    SCTalk – 16
    Too Serious – 20
    YSCC – 22
    Fan Footy – 22
    Footy Wire – 22

    I’m really curious to know the reason behind the difference and which website is the most accurate. I hope it’s SCTalk but i just want to know with a level of accuracy.


  4. Tommy Couch looks unlikely (probably for the first time this season) to get a game for the Dees after a pretty poor performance in the two’s…

    I really want him to get a game!



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *