Clarke v Guthrie

Written by Motts on March 21 2012

This one by popular demand. Who gets the nod out of these two high priced rookies?

Sorry, there are no polls available at the moment.
0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

19 thoughts on “Clarke v Guthrie”

  1. good work! lol
    can u have both at the expense of Morris from tiger land?? JS would be a lot higher I would assume?

    0

    0
  2. Tossing up for the last 4-5 defender spots between, hargrave, dempsey, bugg, morris, ellis, clarke and darley. Who does everyone reckon go with?

    0

    0
  3. Thanks for doing that Motts I know you are super busy this week AND it’s nearly lockout time on top of that, so thanks.

    Pretty sure Guthrie had a higher overall average though real through the NAB cup in terms of Points (was using DT stats tho’) – I wrote it out last night but don’t have it on me at the moment. I think he averaged 6 or so points more. I do think Clarke may have a higher JS, isn’t there an injury or two at the pies that could see him called in? I think Guthrie has been ok, so not sure if I need to “save” the difference in my salary cap by getting Clarke instead because I still have 2 more rounds to sort the rooks out before they go up.

    * In my team I cannot afford both.

    0

    0
  4. Ive got both in my all rookie defence:) I’m trying something different this year as every team I look at has the same defenders and very similar set-ups so I’ve loaded up mids and forwards to see if I can get a head start;)

    0

    0
  5. I’ll happily keep you posted if I can do if with enough rookies in round 1 which I think there will be. Just to add I came 2278 last year and 2 thousand odd year before. I think I need a point of difference this year because alot of teams are looking very similar (more so than in the past), just check rate me team on here and you’ll see what I mean:)

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *