Community Team – Ruck Structure

Written by Schwarzwalder on February 23 2016

If you‘re reading this then you are already part of our TEAM. This one-of-a-kind experiment is gathering the greatest SC minds in the football world to form the ultimate Supercoach team. Everyone & anyone on the site can cast a vote!

Decisions thus far:
Team Name – GaryWhyYouLyon@SCT

When figuring out the team structure, the Ruck line is a crucial piece of the puzzle. Determining the correct Ruck Structure will have a massive impact on the Team Structure overall. Below are a couple of polls related to the Ruck line for GaryWhyYouLyon@SCT. (We will select the players themselves closer to Rd1). Right now it’s important to set the parameters we’d like to see on our team. These questions might even help you reflect on your own teams in terms of what you want/need. Choose wisely as these results will be locked in to determine final team selection! (Final team will be announced just before Rd1). I’ve opted for the more popular choices from our Rate My Team Thread.

 

Sorry, there are no polls available at the moment.

 

Sorry, there are no polls available at the moment.

 

These polls will close on Thursday afternoon, next poll will follow (overall team structure).

 

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

41 thoughts on “Community Team – Ruck Structure”

  1. My Ruck theory this season is based around having Martin from the get-go, and Lobbe gaining 100k in 6-7 Rounds while Goldy loses 100k (and then toss in another 100k I kept up my sleeve). I’m fair at maths but I just dont know how to work out what each player has to average per week for that to happen. It is the ONLY way to not start with Goldy though. If its not doable, I change my vote to absolutely YES we must start with Goldstein.

    0

    0
  2. I just don’t rate Lobbe enough to see him improving on his average. I think best case for him this year would be an average of 80.
    Martin and one of Nic Nat/Jacobs for me. Or if we go the midpricer option, one of Tippet/Sinclar, I rate Tippet higher.

    0

    0
  3. Martin (Bris) and Lobbe (Port) will leave the bench ruck to whoever plays round 1 at minimum wage, preferably ruck/fwd.

    0

    0
  4. If you going premo/mid it’s gotta be stef & lobbe, or else we need to see a good showing from tippett or lycett.

    If going dual premo go stef and gawn.

    Sandi out for rnd 1 does make goldy look better.

    We should seriously consider Grimley at R3 and use either Petracca or Trengove as our early round donut.

    0

    0
  5. I like Goldy at R1.
    Nic Nat/Martin/Jacobs seem to be around the same mark.
    I’m leaning towards Nic Nat as I think he can improve on last year where as I believe Martin and Jacobs (and to an extent Goldy) are at their peak.

    0

    0
  6. It’s a contentious issue every year and this year is no different. We’re tending towards a ‘Set&Forget’ structure without Goldy at this stage. But there’s still time for that to change. As stated earlier, we’ll leave the poll open till Thursday afternoon. Everyone should get a chance to cast their vote till then. Next poll will look at overall team structure.
    Let the debate continue…….

    0

    0
  7. Don’t know if anyone’s picked up on it, or if it even matters, but both Brisi and Kangas have the same bye in Rnd. 15..

    0

    0
  8. Those of you who are considering not going in with Goldy, then start again, this is absurd talk as you must factor in a couple of things.

    Firstly Goldy has a decent amount of early games, using him as your VC with a loophole in toe and when he goes huge not having him in your team and more importantly as your VC will be the beginning of the end as you will be playing catch up.

    Secondly all that talk of if Goldy drops $100k which is highly likely I might add, however do you put a value on trades because you should and its estimated each trade is worth around $150k so what’s the logic in this?
    Not to mention its more then likely your R1 is scoring you 20 points minimum less each week compared to what Goldy is scoring you.

    Granted what I am saying is all hypothetical, however statistically speaking what I am suggesting makes perfect sense, I personally chose to follow stats over what if’s every day of the week.

    Oh and my Ruck selection will be Goldy & Martin or Goldy & Nic Nat, definitely NO Lobbe. That being said I wish yo ALL the best of luck.

    0

    0
  9. After reading this whole thread and firmly in favor of stef Martin and NIC Nat, I’ve been convinced I need Goldy and starting without him would be detrimental overall.

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *