Open Forum for discussion and last minute decisions….
Oh, and try to keep it clean.
0
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
The original and the best. Your #1 resource for daily AFL SuperCoach tips and analysis.
Open Forum for discussion and last minute decisions….
Oh, and try to keep it clean.
Doodle
Have already made some pretty poor choices on who to start thus far in the season (Shiel, Ellis, Morris), so I need a bit of help with this one.
Which rookie should I start?
Thumbs up, Hall against the Crows.
Thumbs down, Smedts agains Fremantle out west.
Cheers guys 🙂
Thumbs up C.Guthrie (D) + J.Redden (M)
Thumbs down M.Clarke (D) + S.Thompson (M)
Really liked Guthrie as a cheap defender but am worried he’s going to cop the vest… thought he had a starting spot in the Geelong backline sewn up by now.
Posted this in the previous thread, didn’t realise we had a new one for Friday night. Apologies if some have read it on the old post.
Ok, really want Pendlebury from the get go, but leaves my def a little weak. So…
Pendles/Smedts – Thumbs up
Selwood/Dempsey – Thumbs down
Selecting one of these two to keep my current structure. Comments appreciated.
M4 Position?
Thumbs Up – J.Watson ($574,600)
Thumbs Down – J.Redden ($557,600)
Cheers 🙂
Team set, just so i won’t be locked out like people were on saturday night.
T/U Ledger
T/D Smith
Lord help me haha
This is it boys 3 months of research. Hoping to win my $1200 work league
TheRustyFishHooks
Remaining Cap: $19,600
DEF: B Goddard, B Deledio, H Shaw, G Broughton, B Lake, B Ellis, T Bugg, B Smedts, S Morris
MID: S Pendlebury, G Ablett, M Murphy, J Selwood, D Shiel, J Magner, C Smith, T Ledger
RUCK: S Mumford, J Redden, J Giles, O Stephenson
FWD: L Franklin, A Goodes, N Fyfe, D Martin, J Porplyzia, D Smith, T Dickson, A Kennedy, A Hall
Also $10 dollars on Hale to kick the first goal at $12.50, dont mind if i do.
Who to start on ground:
Thumbs up: Hall
Thumbs down: Dickson
Good luck to all the coaches for the 2012 season, i’m off to the pub to watch the game.
Somebody has probably already said this, but Pfeiffer is listed as an emergancy for Sundays game against St Klida….
http://www.afl.com.au/teams/tabid/16469/default.aspx
And also:
I have bugg as (emg) on the bench, and also morris on the bench, so both my defenders on my bench have already played. OPTION 1: Should i get smedts or boumann for D7, or OPTION 2 Find cash to get Marty Clarke. Or OPTION 3: Get a non-playing defender so bugg gets the points.
Thumbs up: OP 1 (If option 1, comment if i should get smedts or boumann?)
Thumbs down: OP 2
Comment: OP 3
What should i do with pfieffer? Do i keep him and hope he plays soon or do i swap him for maybe Milera
Thumbs Up keep Pfeiffer Thumbs down Milera
What does everyone think of McCarthy from port. Fantastic in NAB and should be a regular in the midfield as he plays for port.
thoughts?
Scott Thompson, thumbs up?
Matthew Pavlich, thumbs down?
okay boys need your help here, who do i drop? thanks 🙂
pfeffier
smedts
dickson
hall
I’ve got the same question at the moment. Boumann or Smedts? I’ve gone for Smedts but not sure. So looking forward to lockout so I can stop agonizing over my team!
Whatever happened to thê little red/green lights on SC site so you can see who is and isn’t playing. Or do they appear 1 hr before lockout
When the HS site crashes??
Boumann or smedts. Apologies if already polled. Thanks
Up- boumann
Down- smedts
Captain choice
Thumbs up Cox
Thumbs down Ablett
thanks PA. not paying HS for gold and their digital pass for inaccurate sc scores.
a hall – up
t dickson – down
Done and Done…finally can only make 3 max changes a week!
Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Birchall, Clarke, Ellie, Bugg (Smedts, Morris)
Mids: Pendlebury, Ablett, Selwood, Coniglio, Ledger, Magner (Shiel, Smith)
Rucks: Cox, Mumford (Giles, Redden)
Forwards: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Martin, Porplyzia, Smith, Kennedy (Hall, Dickson)
Hopefully it can win the work league…what do people think?
also
cley smith – up
ledger – down
here’s one
dangerfield – up
sidebottom – down
Pendlebury & Yagmoor Thumbs UP
Swan & Clarke Thumbs DOWN
1st option means I play 3 rookies in defence, as opposed to 2 with the 2nd option :/
I crunched some numbers to find that Swan and Pendlebury both averaged the same (129) last season if you take out Swan’s 4 games under injury prior to Arizona. Interesting.
Gunston and Seedsman are 2nites subs.
join my comp top 350000 only 134640 g/l
Just when i thought my team was sorted Matty Primus stuffs things up by naming pfeiffer as an (emerg) so i gave pfeiffer the flick and put smedts in the fwds so for my last position in the backs who should it be?
Thumbs up Peter Yagmoor Thumbs Down Jackson Paine
Is it important at the start of the year to have a duel postion player to connect the fwds/mids? I need a final rookie in my midfield
Heads up Kerridge and therfore duel postion
Thumbs down Clay Smith and no duel position
Who has better JS, Boumann or Yagmoor?
aaron hall or Pfeiffer (even though he is not playing)
Will Pfeiffer be included in the near future
Is pfieffer an emergency?
forgot about this thread so i put this in the team one. but everyone is over here so
spewing pheiffer didnt get named in the team this week.
Threw in J paine from collingwood as a replacement. Anyone know much about him? hes only 106,000 and is a fwd/def named center half forward. Knowing my luck he will be dropped next week
Had Murphy as VC, do I put C on Couch to take his 125 doubled or put it on Ablett?
Take the 125 – Up
Ablett for Captain – Down
cheers guys
Gotta laugh when Lenny posts who is better hall or dickson the result is even at 7 each. When Rowdy asks hour later it’s 2 to hall and 5 to
Dickson! Take what I want from those varied results!
Subs:
Hawthorn: J.Gunston
Collingwood: P.Seedsman
For final F9 position
Thumbs up – Smedts
Thumbs down – Hall
Got Dickson already…and btw went C Smith in front of Ledger at M8
Downgraded Pfeiffer to Couch, freeing up cash for Smedts to Clarke.
Was $2000 away from being able to do Yagmoor > Clarke.
Now tossing up between Yagmoor and Paine for D9 as I can only afford one of the $106,000 kids.
Hey guys, all the best!
Could I get a hand with this one:
Thumbs up for Wingard
Thumbs down for Ledger
NEED HELP PLEASE
Thumbs up Thomas Ledger
Thumbs down Clay Smith
Need to pick one to play on the ground
Thumbs up – Redden
Thumbs down – Stephensen
Cheers guys!!!
another league if anyone wants
309274
Alright, starting on the field?
Aaron Hall (against Adelaide in Adelaide) – Thumbs Up
Tory Dickson (against West Coast in Melbourne) – Thumbs Down
Will pfieffer play, be good, and have good job security? Or should I swap him for hall from GCS. This is for a position on my bench this week, but next week the player chosen will probably start on the ground.
Thumbs up- Bring in hall and have a spare $20K as a bonus
Thumbs down- Keep pfieffer
Polling booths have gone beserk! Here’s mine:
Hayes – TU
or
Brad Ebert – TD
Last poll for the pre-season!!! For D7!
Smedts – Thumbs Up
Boumann – Thumbs Down
Thumbs up- Swanny
Thumbs down- J.Selwood and $60K
I already have pendles on my team. Comment thoughts as well 🙂
Ok last poll guys
Thumbs up Bouman Thumbs down paine
Thumbs Up: Swallow and Hill
Thumbs Down:Sidebottom and Cassisi
PA’s first poll for the year
Sick of polls — TU
Love polls and can’t get enough of them — TD
Thanks guys/girls.
Who to start on field, magner or wingard?
3 minutes until lockout ……
Why the hell do I have masten!!?
Priddis – Thumbs up
Mitchel – Thumbs down
QUICK!!
2012 Supercoach team is in. No more tinkering.
Last minute changes:
Pfeiffer > Couch
Smedts > Clarke
Game on.
Last post forgot to do the thumbs up and down so.. Thumbs up to start wingard or thumbs down to start magner
pens down
Rioli, early contender for mark of the year. WOWWEE!
Anyone have SC Scores?
Peter Yagmoor, y u no have disposals?
Love it how ‘quiet’ Buddy’s been in the first half according to the channel 7 commentators. He’s on 57 points at the main break!
Also. Yagmoor, get some Ballmoor.
What are the half time supercoach scores
Starting to feel a little sick. My sc team not doing well, at all!
So glad I kept Pendlebury. Watching this game is just a reminder of why he’s worth $700K. Just hit the ton in the live SC scores.
Guess there’s worse players to have as captain-by-default-thanks-to-lack-of-other-options than Scotty P… going on 130 points midway through the 3rd.
Who got subbed for the HAwks??
Mitchell is a gun!!! But should have got Pendles..
Glad I spent the extra coin today and slotted in Pendles
Why did i pick Hale?????????
Thumb up – He will come good
Thumb down – What was I thinking!!
Who said Pendles wasnt worth the $$$ 3 quarter time and his on a whopping 139
Bloody shattered I didn’t get Pendles. 141 at 3/4 time….
Buddy, and Pendles are tearing it up just need Shaw to lift a bit
2 Words
Scotty Pendlebury 🙂
All locked in and pretty happy:
Def: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Broughton, Lake, Ellis, Bugg (Smedts, Morris)
Mid: Ablett, Swallow, Selwood, Watson, Caddy, Coniglio (Shiel, Magner)
Ruck: Mumford, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)
Fwd: Franklin, Fyfe, Johnson, Martin, Porplyzia, Smith, Dickson (Kennedy, Hall)
$3,500 remaining
Unlucky to all those who didn’t put buddy and pendles in the team Coz they were hoping for a price drop…..
10 Scott Pendlebury 167
18 Darren Jolly 109
13 Dale Thomas 96
32 Travis Cloke 96
11 Jarryd Blair 95
36 Dane Swan 93
39 Heath Shaw 87
12 Luke Ball 85
22 Steele Sidebottom 76
34 Alan Toovey 75
1 Alex Fasolo 70
6 Tyson Goldsack 68
31 Chris Dawes 63
8 Heritier O’Brien 60
20 Ben Reid 56
28 Ben Sinclair 49
9 Martin Clarke 49
33 Jackson Paine 42
23 Lachlan Keeffe 40
14 Luke Rounds 38
40 Paul Seedsman 11
38 Peter Yagmoor 5
23 Lance Franklin 136
5 Sam Mitchell 124
33 Cyril Rioli 115
14 Grant Birchall 101
37 Brendan Whitecross 98
4 Matt Suckling 96
12 Brad Sewell 95
7 Michael Osborne 90
40 Broc McCauley 88
18 Brent Guerra 87
16 Isaac Smith 85
20 David Hale 83
3 Jordan Lewis 82
9 Shaun Burgoyne 68
22 Luke Breust 67
6 Josh Gibson 66
21 Shane Savage 62
24 Ben Stratton 46
10 Chance Bateman 40
19 Jack Gunston 39
25 Ryan Schoenmakers 36
31 Jarrad Boumann 18
Probably been asked a million times but when can we see who our league opponent is? After the round?
I don’t know why people think getting pendles cheap later in the year is a good idea???? You just missed out on 165 points first game LOL…. He won’t drop below 650k all year!!!! Magner upgraded to pendles will take three years!! LOL
Wonder how many poor souls took the advise of the “experts” SC gurus down at the Hun?, who told them not to pick both Pendles and Buddy. Would of cost them at least 300+ points just for 1 round so far.
1135/12/GAJ
Premiums getting the job done.
Good quality defensive cash cows look like they’ll be hard to come by this season.
Sigh.. 1234/13…
Trusted my gut and went without Pendlebury & Swan…
Kept Shaw for some reason.. argh
Newman’s 66 hurt the other night too.
1136/11/Gazza
5 premiums, 2 mid pricers & 4 rooks
Should give 2000 a nudge
do we have to wait till lockout is over to see everyones teams?
12/1124…..8 prems incl. skip and 2 rooks to go
very pleased so far
1239/13/GAJ
5 premiums inc (C) & 4 rookies to play
Buddy & Pendles, thank you for your exceptional efforts tonight
GO HAWKS!
It’s late. I’m pi55ed. Carn the mighty Hawks!
1212/13/GAJ
6 Prems, 2 Midpricers & 1 Rookie to come.
So glad I paid up for Pendles. Hoping I feel the same way about Massive aswell.