Friday’s Final Thoughts

Written by Duck on April 27 2012

Only a few hours away now …. anyone need any last minute questions answered / trade advice?

Either way, if you have something to share, whack it in the comments or over in the Coaches Box – Live Chat …. over there >>>>>>

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

100 thoughts on “Friday’s Final Thoughts”

  1. My final thought is this……
    What the F is going on with all the injuries??!?!!?
    It is far too early to be copping donuts and yet I will be taking two right up the Kyber. Backs and Rucks are doing me in this week.
    Karma needs to pay me back by giving me my multi this week.

    0

    0
  2. Current thoughts – Mumford has to go, Wingard is looking like he’s done.

    Mumford -> ??? (someone cheap – Big O?)
    Wingard -> ??? (premium – Jelwood/Mitchell?)

    or

    Mumford -> ??? (someone cheap – Big O?)
    Wingard -> Treloar and bank 700k for upgrades next week

    Have NicNat, Giles and Redden fleshing out the ruck department at the moment.

    Comments?

    0

    0
  3. Thinking Mummy to Roughhead later swapping him forward (BE 104 so won tget him much cheaper i dont think) & Ledger to Treloar for some DPP. Havent got old Mac though so im a bit torn whether to get him or Treloar.

    0

    0
  4. Making my first two trades this weekend fellas!!!!

    Really need your help….Not convinced on a decent replacement on Mummy but will play with a zero if I dont …1-3 ruck strategy already….

    My two planned trades are

    Treloar – Dickson
    Old Mac – C Smith

    Thumbs up – Make only on of those trades and trade Mummy for HMac

    Thumbs down – Make both and wait for Mummy or Sandi or Redden and Big O next week and cop the zero…

    P.S – My opponent already has a fair advantage with Pendles vice, Sidebum vs my Jobe and one more premuim as Heater is on my bench…..

    Would welcome any comments also

    0

    0
  5. I have a slight dilemma. I want to trade Coniglio > Treloar for these reasons:
    1. Extra 100K banked.
    2. Mid/Fwd DPP
    3. To swap Treloar into the Fwd line for A.Kennedy so i don’t have to play young Jeremy Cameron on-field (yes, it’s getting that desperate)
    But… I also want to go Sandilands to Kreuzer. If i make these i will only have 19 trades left. Thinking maybe i’m better off just copping a donut in rucks. I really want Treloar for the Mid/Fwd dpp. I’m torn :/ and would love some thoughts!

    0

    0
  6. 21 trades left
    Thumbs up C.Smith>Jmac or Treloar
    Thumbs down>Save a trade and wait for other rookies to come through

    0

    0
  7. Has anyone thought how devastating it’s going to be next year without a cheap and reliable 3rd ruckman? Last two seasons we’ve enjoyed Zac Smith and Giles. I remember relying on Jackson Trengove several seasons ago only to be delivered scores of 16.

    0

    0
  8. Aiming to move Treloar in, but for who ? Which one of these guys is least likely to get a run over the next month or two ?

    Trade him in for :
    Clay Smith (thumbs up)
    OR
    Tom Ledger (thumbs down)

    0

    0
  9. wanting to bring in Treloar into my forward line just for some extra cash but I’m not so sure. I have Milera, Kennedy and Devon in my forwards already so what do you guys think?
    thumbs up: don’t trade
    thumbs down: do trade
    comment who you think i should trade out?

    0

    0
  10. Ablett dilemma??? Have bout 300000 so am thinking trading ablett and shiel for 2 premiums? Thoughts?
    Trade – up
    No trade – down

    0

    0
  11. Trade consideration this week
    Shiel/Smith>Jmac for a quick cash downgrade then Ellis>Geary to strengthen the backline.
    Thoughts?

    0

    0
  12. i just posted something before but forget it. unfortunately i went for the four rookie ruck with giles, redden, stephenson and rowe. regretting it now. do you think redden will get games from now or do i downgrade porplyzia or dangerfield to treloar in order to get kreuzer? please i need urgent help

    0

    0
  13. Treloar or Old Mac i cant decide i have no DPP link in the mids so Treloar seems the best choice. But Old Mac has job security.

    0

    0
  14. i have four options.
    1) Pavlich > Treloar, Redden > Sandilands
    2)Dangerfield> Treloar, Redden >Ryder
    3)Porpoise > Treloar, Redden >Kreuzer
    4) D. Smith/ A.Kennedy/ T.Milera> Treloar, Redden> Maric

    Comment on what you think the best option is. cheers.

    0

    0
  15. Going:
    Ablett —> McDonald
    Dickson —> Treloar

    Hopefully (sorry to all those who have ablett) GAJ is out for 3 which will give Magner a chance to reach his highest price.

    Next week Pendles in for probably Caddy (maybe Coniglio). That will be a straight swap.

    Then the week after downgrade rookie, upgrade rookie to Ablett, leaving about $100-200,000 in the bank with 5 gun mids!

    Thoughts?

    0

    0
  16. Round 5 is over for me already il be gettin 2 guaranteed donuts Hall,and Kennedy and i Traded out Mummy for Nic nat and now i have $222,000 in the bank so i should make my first upgrade in a couple of weeks. Ill be putting the C on Smurf tonight its a bit of a risk up in perth but i think it could pay off.

    0

    0
  17. Traded mummy for Kreuzer last week instead of sandi, hoping that Kreuzer rips through a sandi-less freo tonight 🙂

    0

    0
  18. About to cop second donut of the year for Sandi who i traded for Mummy who got me the first donut.
    Made 2 trades second was Treloar in should i cop donut or trade Sandi?
    t/u trade

    t/d donut

    0

    0
  19. Rucks are doing my heads in this year. I have sandi, mummy Giles and redden. Not sure whether to get rid of mummy cos there isn’t much out there IMO.

    0

    0
  20. got 200+ with sidebum as v/c do i keep that or give boyd the c hoping he smashes WSG he let me down against the Dees do i keep the faith?

    0

    0
  21. Anyone trading Ablett out..
    You’ll regret it big time come the end of the season.
    One of my mates decided to trade him out this week, and put him back in in 2-3 weeks time.

    The current state of supercoach has driven some people to insanity…

    0

    0
  22. My team ‘I like dumplings’ is below

    B Goodard, Lids, Scotland, Lake, Clarke, Bugg, Morris
    EMG – Ellis
    Reserves – Mohr

    M Pendles, GAJ(Capt Loophole), Murphy, Selwood, Magner, Shiel
    EMG Trelor(capt loophole)
    Reserves – C Smith

    F Franklin, Chapman, Fyfe, Martin, Dangerfield, Porps, D.Smith
    EMG – Cameron
    Reserves – Kennedy

    R Giles Big O
    Reserves – sandi, redden

    TUP- Should i trade to get J Mac in or is it too many GWS players?
    TDOWN – trade Sandi to Nic Nat
    Comment – No trade

    0

    0
  23. He is injury prone but one of the best kicks you will see, I was on him from the start selected r1 for the price i couldn’t say no just like Lenny.
    If they got that knee right he could be in top 6 backs IMO

    0

    0
  24. Fyfe is in!!!

    Fremantle v Carlton at Patersons Stadium, 6.45pm
    NO CHANGES

    FINAL INTERCHANGES
    Fremantle: Greg Broughton, Michael Barlow, Jack Anthony
    Substitute: Lachie Neale
    Carlton: Jordan Russell, Ed Curnow, Jeff Garlett
    Substitute: Kane Lucas

    0

    0
  25. so whats everyones final verdict on fyfe??

    do we hold and hope, risking financial loss (thumbs up)
    or
    do we cut now and bring in a j selwood or j lewis etc.??? but chew a trade?
    (thumbs down)

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *