Game Chat – Carl v Ess/Adel v Melb

Written by MJ on April 18 2015

Good afternoon gentleman, just combined the two games as kick off times are fairly similar. The Dons will be feeling exceptionally confident after their impressive victory over reigning premiers Hawthorn last week. It’s hard to see the Blues sniffing a victory in this one. The Crows have gotten off to the perfect start in 2-15 under Phil Walsh and they should account for a young Demons outfit who succumbed to GWS last week. Kick off is 1.45pm at the MCG (AEST) and 1.40pm at Adelaide Oval (ACST).

Justin’s tip: Essendon by 54 points, Adelaide will be far too strong, Crows by 61 points.

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

111 thoughts on “Game Chat – Carl v Ess/Adel v Melb”

  1. Adelaide vs Melbourne players: Lumumba, Sloane (VC), Van Berlo, Ellis-Yolmen, Vandenberg, Hogan, Garlett and Salem.

    errrrrrr…. that wraps up every rookie on my field other than Kamdyn McIntosh.

    0

    0
  2. 3 spots on field – who gets them out of Cripps/Heeney/CEY/Vandenberg/Newton …

    CEY I assume is a given. Do we put Cripps on field?

    0

    0
  3. Miller to NVB so Cripps can ride it out on the bench

    Just one other trade locked in this week – GAJ to Fyfe

    Thumbs Up: Sweet
    Thumbs down: don’t waste the trade, miller will come good

    Thanks SCT!

    0

    0
  4. Hey guys,

    Out of these four, who would you bench?

    T/U -> A Saad
    T/D -> K McIntosh

    Comment -> Ibbotson/Malceski

    Forgot to make the switch from N brown to McIntosh on Friday so I had to swap out Hamling for McIntosh instead. Now I am tossing up between these four for 1 bench spot (so 3 will be on field).

    0

    0
  5. Last minute trade before the Adelaide game starts

    TU Ablett/Goodes -> Wines, Smith
    TD Ablett -> Sloane, save the trade

    Is Wines too much of a downgrade from Ablett?

    Thanks guys

    0

    0
  6. Who to start and who to have as emergency:

    Vanders (TU) or CEY? (TD)

    I can swap one with heeney via lambert depending on his score, not need to start one of them

    0

    0
  7. I need one on the pine who should it be
    CEY,Vanderberg,or Heeney
    I’m thinking Heeney just because I think it could be his turn for the vest
    Thoughts?

    0

    0
  8. Tossing up with what to do with my second trade. Any advice much appreciated guys..
    Miller – NVB T/U
    Newton – Rich T/D

    0

    0
  9. Have Lonie and Tom Lamb on my bench. With Lonie getting injured in yesterdays game, I don’t have any fwd bench coverage. So I was thinking Lamb to:
    T/U – Jaden McGrath
    T/D – Cam McCarthy

    0

    0
  10. Really don’t like to sideways trade but I just don’t see beams doing well for a while considering swapping him to Sloane
    T/U Trade to Sloane
    T/D Your silly Twitch??!!

    0

    0
  11. QUARTER TIME
    Carlton 2.4 (16)
    Essendon 3.4 (22)

    CARLTON
    9 Patrick Cripps 30
    36 Cameron Wood 29
    23 Lachie Henderson 27
    15 Sam Docherty 26
    35 Ed Curnow 23
    41 Levi Casboult 22
    44 Andrew Carrazzo 21
    4 Bryce Gibbs 21
    17 Sam Rowe 21
    1 Andrew Walker 20
    42 Zach Tuohy 18
    33 Andrejs Everitt 16
    28 Tom Bell 16
    14 Liam Jones 14
    6 Kade Simpson 13
    3 Marc Murphy 12
    13 Chris Yarran 10
    46 David Ellard 8
    27 Dennis Armfield 7
    5 Chris Judd 4
    38 Ciaran Byrne 0 (SUB)
    40 Michael Jamison 0

    ESSENDON
    40 Ben Howlett 47
    5 Brent Stanton 37
    17 Jake Melksham 33
    11 David Zaharakis 31
    4 Jobe Watson 28
    21 Dyson Heppell 24
    29 Patrick Ambrose 23
    7 Zach Merrett 22
    12 Mark Baguley 21
    31 Dustin Fletcher 20
    32 Travis Colyer 20
    18 Michael Hurley 19
    13 Adam Cooney 17
    6 Joe Daniher 17
    22 Jake Carlisle 16
    2 Tom Bellchambers 14
    26 Cale Hooker 13
    1 Michael Hibberd 13
    9 Brendon Goddard 11
    3 Paul Chapman 11
    35 Martin Gleeson 10
    14 Jason Ashby 0 (SUB)

    0

    0
  12. hmmmm, i went vandenberg as my emergency over cripps. i was going to use as a loophole if he scored well. maybe i picked the wrong one.

    0

    0
  13. QUARTER TIME
    Adelaide 3.1 (19)
    Melbourne 3.4 (22)

    ADELAIDE
    9 Rory Sloane 46
    5 Scott Thompson 39
    7 Nathan Van Berlo 37
    28 Cam Ellis-Yolmen 27
    14 David Mackay 26
    33 Brodie Smith 23
    27 Tom Lynch 22
    32 Patrick Dangerfield 21
    23 Charlie Cameron 19
    26 Richard Douglas 18
    18 Eddie Betts 17
    45 Ricky Henderson 15
    24 Sam Jacobs 15
    10 Matthew Jaensch 14
    15 Kyle Hartigan 13
    12 Daniel Talia 12
    47 Jake Kelly 12
    16 Luke Brown 12
    29 Rory Laird 5
    4 Josh Jenkins 2
    11 Matthew Wright 0 (SUB)
    13 Taylor Walker 0

    MELBOURNE
    12 Dom Tyson 44
    37 Aaron Vandenberg 38
    2 Nathan Jones 32
    18 Daniel Cross 30
    19 Ben Newton 29
    20 Colin Garland 28
    8 Heritier Lumumba 24
    36 Jeff Garlett 24
    4 Jack Watts 22
    39 Neville Jetta 21
    25 Tom McDonald 21
    16 Dean Kent 17
    3 Christian Salem 16
    40 Mark Jamar 15
    6 Chris Dawes 13
    1 Jesse Hogan 13
    17 Sam Frost 13
    24 Jay Kennedy-Harris 11
    23 Bernie Vince 8
    14 Lynden Dunn 7
    38 Jeremy Howe 3
    10 Angus Brayshaw 0 (SUB)

    0

    0
  14. HALF TIME
    Carlton 5.7 (37)
    Essendon 10.4 (64)

    CARLTON
    44 Andrew Carrazzo 62
    36 Cameron Wood 61
    3 Marc Murphy 51
    4 Bryce Gibbs 44
    9 Patrick Cripps 44
    1 Andrew Walker 41
    5 Chris Judd 41
    17 Sam Rowe 38
    27 Dennis Armfield 37
    23 Lachie Henderson 34
    42 Zach Tuohy 34
    15 Sam Docherty 32
    28 Tom Bell 29
    41 Levi Casboult 28
    6 Kade Simpson 27
    33 Andrejs Everitt 25
    35 Ed Curnow 22
    46 David Ellard 21
    14 Liam Jones 21
    13 Chris Yarran 16
    40 Michael Jamison 3
    38 Ciaran Byrne 0 (SUB)

    ESSENDON
    40 Ben Howlett 70
    4 Jobe Watson 59
    5 Brent Stanton 57
    26 Cale Hooker 55
    11 David Zaharakis 55
    21 Dyson Heppell 47
    1 Michael Hibberd 46
    18 Michael Hurley 46
    17 Jake Melksham 41
    3 Paul Chapman 41
    9 Brendon Goddard 40
    6 Joe Daniher 40
    7 Zach Merrett 40
    31 Dustin Fletcher 39
    12 Mark Baguley 38
    32 Travis Colyer 38
    13 Adam Cooney 37
    2 Tom Bellchambers 30
    29 Patrick Ambrose 26
    22 Jake Carlisle 22
    35 Martin Gleeson 21
    14 Jason Ashby 11 (SUB)

    0

    0
  15. HALF TIME
    Adelaide 5.3 (33)
    Melbourne 4.6 (30)

    ADELAIDE
    9 Rory Sloane 78
    5 Scott Thompson 66
    12 Daniel Talia 50
    14 David Mackay 49
    15 Kyle Hartigan 43
    7 Nathan Van Berlo 43
    18 Eddie Betts 42
    45 Ricky Henderson 42
    28 Cam Ellis-Yolmen 41
    26 Richard Douglas 40
    27 Tom Lynch 40
    47 Jake Kelly 39
    33 Brodie Smith 35
    32 Patrick Dangerfield 29
    10 Matthew Jaensch 28
    13 Taylor Walker 27
    23 Charlie Cameron 26
    4 Josh Jenkins 26
    16 Luke Brown 25
    29 Rory Laird 25
    24 Sam Jacobs 20
    11 Matthew Wright 0 (SUB)

    MELBOURNE
    8 Heritier Lumumba 71
    38 Jeremy Howe 59
    20 Colin Garland 58
    2 Nathan Jones 48
    12 Dom Tyson 46
    23 Bernie Vince 45
    4 Jack Watts 44
    18 Daniel Cross 41
    36 Jeff Garlett 40
    37 Aaron Vandenberg 39
    19 Ben Newton 39
    1 Jesse Hogan 38
    3 Christian Salem 36
    14 Lynden Dunn 34
    39 Neville Jetta 34
    25 Tom McDonald 33
    10 Angus Brayshaw 28 (SUBBED ON)
    6 Chris Dawes 26
    40 Mark Jamar 24
    16 Dean Kent 20
    24 Jay Kennedy-Harris 17
    17 Sam Frost 11 (SUBBED OFF)

    0

    0
  16. Chris yarran is a d!ck. malthouse is the worst coach going around. Lets his playmaker get taken away from the contest with ease

    0

    0
  17. THREE QUARTER TIME
    Carlton 7.12 (54)
    Essendon 14.6 (90)

    CARLTON
    44 Andrew Carrazzo 81
    36 Cameron Wood 79
    3 Marc Murphy 66
    9 Patrick Cripps 66
    5 Chris Judd 64
    4 Bryce Gibbs 63
    27 Dennis Armfield 54
    33 Andrejs Everitt 53
    17 Sam Rowe 53
    23 Lachie Henderson 50
    1 Andrew Walker 49
    41 Levi Casboult 48
    28 Tom Bell 48
    15 Sam Docherty 45
    6 Kade Simpson 43
    42 Zach Tuohy 43
    46 David Ellard 34
    13 Chris Yarran 31
    35 Ed Curnow 30 (SUBBED OFF)
    14 Liam Jones 27
    40 Michael Jamison 16
    38 Ciaran Byrne 4 (SUBBED ON)

    ESSENDON
    4 Jobe Watson 102
    40 Ben Howlett 89
    5 Brent Stanton 82
    11 David Zaharakis 82
    26 Cale Hooker 76
    21 Dyson Heppell 76
    18 Michael Hurley 76
    1 Michael Hibberd 70
    31 Dustin Fletcher 64
    9 Brendon Goddard 63
    32 Travis Colyer 60
    6 Joe Daniher 56
    35 Martin Gleeson 56
    17 Jake Melksham 55
    13 Adam Cooney 54
    12 Mark Baguley 52
    3 Paul Chapman 51
    2 Tom Bellchambers 51
    7 Zach Merrett 50
    22 Jake Carlisle 49
    29 Patrick Ambrose 44
    14 Jason Ashby 13 (SUB)

    0

    0
  18. THREE QUARTER TIME
    Adelaide 9.4 (58)
    Melbourne 6.9 (45)

    ADELAIDE
    14 David Mackay 103
    9 Rory Sloane 101
    5 Scott Thompson 101
    26 Richard Douglas 88
    28 Cam Ellis-Yolmen 65
    33 Brodie Smith 62
    45 Ricky Henderson 59
    13 Taylor Walker 58
    27 Tom Lynch 56
    16 Luke Brown 54
    12 Daniel Talia 52
    7 Nathan Van Berlo 52
    32 Patrick Dangerfield 52
    15 Kyle Hartigan 49
    18 Eddie Betts 48
    24 Sam Jacobs 48
    10 Matthew Jaensch 44
    47 Jake Kelly 41
    29 Rory Laird 35
    23 Charlie Cameron 32
    4 Josh Jenkins 32
    11 Matthew Wright 0 (SUB)

    MELBOURNE
    8 Heritier Lumumba 99
    20 Colin Garland 85
    38 Jeremy Howe 82
    36 Jeff Garlett 76
    2 Nathan Jones 76
    25 Tom McDonald 75
    23 Bernie Vince 64
    12 Dom Tyson 63
    18 Daniel Cross 60
    10 Angus Brayshaw 54 (SUBBED ON)
    1 Jesse Hogan 54
    40 Mark Jamar 53
    37 Aaron Vandenberg 52
    4 Jack Watts 49
    3 Christian Salem 48
    6 Chris Dawes 45
    19 Ben Newton 40
    14 Lynden Dunn 39
    39 Neville Jetta 39
    16 Dean Kent 38
    24 Jay Kennedy-Harris 22
    17 Sam Frost 12 (SUBBED OFF)

    0

    0
  19. Looks like another round I’m going to lose primarily because of Kade fricking Simpson.

    Someone remind me why I keep picking up this spud every year?

    0

    0
  20. FULL TIME
    Carlton 11.18 (84)
    Essendon 16.9 (105)

    CARLTON
    3 Marc Murphy 103
    44 Andrew Carrazzo 102
    36 Cameron Wood 97
    9 Patrick Cripps 89
    5 Chris Judd 85
    33 Andrejs Everitt 77
    4 Bryce Gibbs 77
    6 Kade Simpson 74
    17 Sam Rowe 73
    1 Andrew Walker 67
    27 Dennis Armfield 67
    28 Tom Bell 66
    23 Lachie Henderson 65
    41 Levi Casboult 61
    42 Zach Tuohy 60
    15 Sam Docherty 57
    46 David Ellard 54
    14 Liam Jones 47
    13 Chris Yarran 40
    35 Ed Curnow 34
    40 Michael Jamison 30
    38 Ciaran Byrne 21

    ESSENDON
    4 Jobe Watson 143
    40 Ben Howlett 114
    5 Brent Stanton 111
    26 Cale Hooker 108
    18 Michael Hurley 106
    21 Dyson Heppell 101
    11 David Zaharakis 98
    1 Michael Hibberd 85
    31 Dustin Fletcher 81
    9 Brendon Goddard 79
    32 Travis Colyer 76
    2 Tom Bellchambers 74
    17 Jake Melksham 73
    35 Martin Gleeson 71
    7 Zach Merrett 71
    12 Mark Baguley 69
    6 Joe Daniher 67
    13 Adam Cooney 60
    29 Patrick Ambrose 60
    22 Jake Carlisle 59
    3 Paul Chapman 58
    14 Jason Ashby 21

    0

    0
  21. FULL QUARTER TIME
    Adelaide 12.8 (80)
    Melbourne 7.13 (55)

    ADELAIDE
    14 David Mackay 132
    9 Rory Sloane 132
    5 Scott Thompson 131
    26 Richard Douglas 110
    28 Cam Ellis-Yolmen 102
    27 Tom Lynch 94
    18 Eddie Betts 83
    33 Brodie Smith 81
    13 Taylor Walker 79
    16 Luke Brown 77
    32 Patrick Dangerfield 76
    45 Ricky Henderson 73
    10 Matthew Jaensch 71
    24 Sam Jacobs 70
    12 Daniel Talia 66
    7 Nathan Van Berlo 64
    15 Kyle Hartigan 55
    47 Jake Kelly 51
    29 Rory Laird 51
    4 Josh Jenkins 40
    23 Charlie Cameron 34
    11 Matthew Wright 20

    MELBOURNE
    8 Heritier Lumumba 107
    20 Colin Garland 105
    2 Nathan Jones 101
    38 Jeremy Howe 100
    36 Jeff Garlett 99
    25 Tom McDonald 96
    12 Dom Tyson 84
    18 Daniel Cross 83
    23 Bernie Vince 81
    4 Jack Watts 68
    40 Mark Jamar 68
    10 Angus Brayshaw 65
    3 Christian Salem 64
    37 Aaron Vandenberg 63
    19 Ben Newton 63
    1 Jesse Hogan 59
    6 Chris Dawes 55
    14 Lynden Dunn 54
    16 Dean Kent 47
    39 Neville Jetta 46
    24 Jay Kennedy-Harris 43
    17 Sam Frost 13

    0

    0
  22. SUper happy with my rookies for the first time this week. Missing a point here or there but overall pretty good!

    Pity Lumumba is on the pine this week!

    0

    0
  23. Geez, wish I had Ellis-Yolmen on field now instead of Van Berlo. Keep picking the wrong rookies on field each week.

    0

    0
  24. Posted scores on SC website don’t look too good? NVB = 46, B Smith = 58, CEY = 79, Hogan = 42, Vanden = 46 Salem = 46 … Lamumba = 76, Cripps = 89 all pretty poor scores if they are correct (except for Cripps)??

    Trades didn’t pay off at all if that is the case!!

    0

    0
  25. Supercoaches, stop sweating the scores straight after the match….they always take a while to update.

    As has been said above MANY times, trust Chonks. He knows what he’s doing.

    0

    0

Leave a Reply to Thommo Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *