Game Chat – Melbourne v Richmond

Written by Thommo on August 3 2019

Where and when: MCG, Saturday August 3, 7.25pm AEST

What it means for Melbourne: With the pressure increasing on both Simon Goodwin and Melbourne’s playing list, a top-four scalp would open the valve somewhat. It would also be only the Demons’ third win in their past 11 games.

What it means for Richmond:  The Tigers’ percentage took a battering at the start of the season but has slowly been on the improve. Saturday night could be a chance to boost it further.

The stat: Final term fade-outs have been a big issue for the Dees recently. Over its past four matches, Melbourne has conceded an average of 28.5 points in the final quarter, while managing an average of just 13.3 itself.

The match-up: Michael Hibberd v Dustin Martin

Hibberd held Martin to just 17 disposals the last time these sides met, the superstar Tiger’s second-lowest tally for the year. The Dee, ranked 191 in the AFL Player Ratings, is versatile enough to take on Martin (11th overall) whether he’s forward or in the middle.

It’s a big week for: Simon Goodwin

After storming to a preliminary final last season, it’s been a disastrous year for Goodwin and his Melbourne charges. The Dees have now dropped a game below Carlton in 17th place and are staring down the barrel of falling 13 places in 12 months.

Thommo’s Tip: Richmond by 40 points.

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

38 thoughts on “Game Chat – Melbourne v Richmond”

  1. NO LATE CHANGES

    FINAL INTERCHANGES
    Melbourne: James Harmes, Michael Hibberd, Jake Melksham, Kyle Dunkley
    Richmond: Dan Butler, Jayden Short, Jack Graham, Mabior Chol

    1

    0
  2. surely Goodwin’s taking the pizz with that team lineup and they wont start that way?? Oliver in the goal square and preuss and petracca in the centre??

    0

    2
    1. Said before not to take any notice of the team lineups due to the insignificance and tendency nowadays to list several players out of position.

      8

      3
      1. yeah and Robbie Gray still started at FF … you weren’t right then and my first words were “surely he’s taking the pizz …”

        I don’t expect them to start that way … but neither do you need to write so finitely all the time Adam …

        9

        8
          1. Ugh. “Ladies”? Really, Shmee? This isn’t the 1950s. Or did you just walk off of the set of Mad Men? Macca’s a bit fiesty, so what.

            7

            1
  3. Satan Oliver’s playing on after dislocating his finger, will probably stop him handballing at all costs lol.

    2

    1
  4. close game!!

    Melbourne Demons: 3.1.19
    Max Gawn 39
    Sam Frost 33
    Jake Lever 30
    Clayton Oliver 27
    Michael Hibberd 27
    Jordan Lewis 26
    Corey Wagner 25
    Christian Petracca 25
    Nathan Jones 24
    Harrison Petty 17
    Bayley Fritsch 16
    James Harmes 16
    Jay Kennedy-Harris 16
    Oskar Baker 15
    Jack Viney 15
    Jake Melksham 13
    Oscar McDonald 13
    Christian Salem 12
    Jayden Hunt 11
    Kyle Dunkley 6
    Angus Brayshaw 5
    Braydon Preuss 1

    Richmond Tigers: 3.2.20
    Nick Vlastuin 33
    Dustin Martin 33
    Jack Graham 33
    Daniel Rioli 31
    Bachar Houli 29
    Jason Castagna* 29
    Shane Edwards 28
    Ivan Soldo 24
    Jack Riewoldt 24
    David Astbury 21
    Dion Prestia 21
    Kane Lambert 21
    Brandon Ellis 18
    Jayden Short 17
    Mabior Chol 16
    Shai Bolton 15
    Nathan Broad 14
    Josh Caddy 14
    Liam Baker 13
    Dylan Grimes 11
    Tom J. Lynch 8
    Daniel Butler 5

    2

    0
      1. did you trade Houli in mate? Could be a nice pick up based on his last few weeks … B Smith hurting me thus far … need him to score better than Sicily … left him out …

        1

        0
        1. I’ve had Houli since the byes, lovin’ life.

          Smith’s role too up in the air, he’s gotta go if you have the trades.

          1

          1
          1. yeah, 7 at Qtr time … left him on field as my own gut call … but also the thread this morning the thumbs said to play the def’s and not take Siciliy … may cost me badly …

            0

            2
  5. Got the VC on gawn… I guess like half of supercoach.

    Rounds been a bit of a trainwreck thus far.

    1

    0
  6. Tight one at the G …

    Melbourne Demons: 6.2.38
    Max Gawn 69
    Clayton Oliver 63
    Sam Frost 53
    Jordan Lewis 51
    Christian Petracca 49
    Bayley Fritsch 46
    Michael Hibberd 46
    Jake Lever 41
    Nathan Jones 39
    Jay Kennedy-Harris 39
    Kyle Dunkley 33
    Angus Brayshaw 33
    James Harmes 33
    Jack Viney 33
    Oskar Baker 31
    Christian Salem 28
    Harrison Petty 28
    Corey Wagner 27
    Oscar McDonald 26
    Jayden Hunt 25
    Jake Melksham 18
    Braydon Preuss 10

    Richmond Tigers: 6.5.41
    Dion Prestia 66
    Shane Edwards 59
    Dustin Martin 52
    Nick Vlastuin 51
    Bachar Houli 51
    Jayden Short 49
    Jack Graham 48
    Jason Castagna* 47
    Kane Lambert 44
    Tom J. Lynch 44
    David Astbury 40
    Ivan Soldo 40
    Nathan Broad 40
    Daniel Rioli 38
    Shai Bolton 37
    Josh Caddy 35
    Liam Baker 35
    Mabior Chol 23
    Jack Riewoldt 22
    Brandon Ellis 21
    Dylan Grimes 18
    Daniel Butler 14

    2

    0
  7. Tigers gettin it done now …

    Richmond Tigers: 11.9.75
    Dustin Martin 110
    Dion Prestia 101
    Bachar Houli 95
    Shane Edwards 80
    Jack Graham 75
    Nick Vlastuin 73
    Ivan Soldo 73
    Kane Lambert 67
    Jason Castagna* 67
    Tom J. Lynch 66
    David Astbury 60
    Jayden Short 58
    Daniel Rioli 52
    Nathan Broad 48
    Josh Caddy 48
    Shai Bolton 47
    Jack Riewoldt 40
    Liam Baker 39
    Dylan Grimes 31
    Brandon Ellis 27
    Mabior Chol 24
    Daniel Butler 20

    Melbourne Demons: 7.4.46
    Max Gawn 103
    Clayton Oliver 90
    Michael Hibberd 73
    Jay Kennedy-Harris 71
    Jordan Lewis 69
    Bayley Fritsch 63
    James Harmes 61
    Sam Frost 59
    Nathan Jones 59
    Christian Petracca 59
    Jake Lever 54
    Jack Viney 54
    Christian Salem 53
    Oskar Baker 45
    Kyle Dunkley 43
    Harrison Petty 43
    Oscar McDonald 43
    Angus Brayshaw 42
    Corey Wagner 41
    Jayden Hunt 31
    Jake Melksham 23
    Braydon Preuss 22

    2

    0
  8. Big Maxxie failing as a VC choice at this stage – needs to pull 40 points out from somewhere in the last 8 minutes …

    1

    2
    1. Scores have not moved for a while in this quarter as far as I’m aware so updates should be provided shortly.

      6

      0
  9. Rain played a big part – but Tigers far too good. – may be some scaling to come … these only total 2720????

    Richmond Tigers: 13.15.93
    Dustin Martin 115
    Dion Prestia 110
    Bachar Houli 102
    Shane Edwards 93
    Jack Graham 85
    Ivan Soldo 85
    Kane Lambert 77
    Nick Vlastuin 74
    Tom J. Lynch 73
    Jason Castagna* 68
    Jayden Short 62
    David Astbury 62
    Daniel Rioli 55
    Josh Caddy 52
    Nathan Broad 52
    Shai Bolton 47
    Liam Baker 44
    Brandon Ellis 42
    Jack Riewoldt 40
    Dylan Grimes 31
    Mabior Chol 28
    Daniel Butler 24

    Melbourne Demons: 9.6.60
    Max Gawn 105
    Clayton Oliver 96
    Michael Hibberd 86
    Jay Kennedy-Harris 75
    Jordan Lewis 75
    Bayley Fritsch 74
    Sam Frost 69
    Christian Petracca 65
    James Harmes 64
    Nathan Jones 60
    Jack Viney 60
    Jake Lever 57
    Angus Brayshaw 54
    Christian Salem 54
    Oscar McDonald 51
    Harrison Petty 45
    Oskar Baker 45
    Kyle Dunkley 43
    Corey Wagner 43
    Jayden Hunt 36
    Braydon Preuss 22
    Jake Melksham 20

    1

    0
  10. made gawn capt before grundy VC again
    such a hard process when you have a job & work nights
    better if just pick 2 capt’s & highest score gets the double points

    0

    4

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *