Help our SC Punters

Written by Big Sexy on August 13 2010

Iceman has a Premiership dilemma….. Iceman has 3 important Leagues & made 1 prelim.  Should he use 2 trades now to try to get into the other 2 prelim or just 1 to make sure he has 22 on the park so he can definitely win 1 league GF?

FoTW Trade Options - Rd12 (max two)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Ben needs some advice with a knockout final against his arch rival (housemate) in his $$ league.  A must win.  Ben is thinking of these trades
Rioli > Didak
Webberley > Fisher

Is Tom Rockliff a must-have trade IN for your MID?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Ben’s current team looks like this:
Goddard, Hodge, Malceski, Enright, K.Bradley, B.Sheppard, Waite (Webberley, J.O’Brien)
Swan, Abblett, Selwood, Gibbs, Judd, Bartel (Lewis Jetta, Gysberts)
Jolly, Warnock (Sandilands, Trengove)
Pavlich, ROK, Hall, Franklin, Rockliff, P.Davis, Riewoldt (Rioli, Gumby)

Max wants to know who’s better Broughton or Fisher?

Who are the best downgrade options 'on the bubble' for Rd12? (max three)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

29 thoughts on “Help our SC Punters”

  1. Iceman all or nothing
    Ben how much money do you have I have rioli and think he will be handy when he returns but I’m in the prelim already
    Max I like fisher

    0

    0
    1. Hi Bill,
      I’d like to keep Rioli but he’s still out for another week and my opponents team is strong!
      Those will be my last two trades and will use up all but 10k. I would have preferred Lake over Fisher, but just dont have the cash. If you have any better suggestions, i’m all ears.

      0

      0
  2. Iceman will be playing a tough opponest come GF day so he’s best to strenghten his team now so as to have no injury trades for when he plays the “best” team in that league.

    Oh that’s me.

    0

    0
    1. Thanks for the post Bigsexy. Didn’t have the site up on Fri as was in the office & Salmon didn’t tell me about the post.

      Result = Made 2 trades & should win both Leagues but don’t worry boys I may still have some trades on Ice.

      0

      0
  3. I have only one trade left and have two questions:

    1. Who should I trade out: Podsiadly or Fyfe?

    2. Who should I bring in Didak or Riewoldt?

    0

    0
  4. Iceman we are in exactly the same position… I’m thinking about going for broke as one of the elimination finals I face is in the LoEC and I want to avoid going out in straight sets especially considering I’ve held top all year! I have the coverage but some key outs makes me think if I don’t trade I’ll have a considerably weaker team… Hmmm the big decisions that will consume my Friday.

    0

    0
  5. help! (please)
    i have one trade left!
    thinking of upgrading either cooney, bastinac or trengove … i can get swan (although some reports he isnt playing this weekend), didak, swallow, cross …. what’s your thoughts???

    0

    0
    1. if you don’t have to trade don’t as there are 3 weeks to go – check out your opponents team and only trade if you think you won’t win with your current team. If you are looking to be coming up short then upgrade trengove, bastinac, cooney in that order of preference. I think cooney should only miss one week. Look at a DPP mid if you do trade that can give you some backup say for Fwds given you will have no trades left – e.g. Didak, Harvey, Goodes.

      0

      0
  6. Ben ideally I’d upgrade gumby to didak And save your last trade but it is a must win and ultimately you have to give yourself every chance. How much cash do you have left

    0

    0
    1. got 2 trades and 260k in the bank. Upgrading Gumby would be ideal, but wouldn’t leave me with enough cash to do much else with my remaining trade (except use it in later rounds to cover injury). As this knock-out match is so tough, i really feel i need to use the last two trades now for a double upgrade.

      0

      0
  7. Ok ben another thought is trade rioli for daisy Thomas then use the extra cash to upgrade webberley to someone like kelly

    0

    0
  8. Ben if you downgrade rioli to daisy Thomas you should then have enough to upgrade webberley to lake but ultimately it’s up to you and depends on who your against

    0

    0
    1. Not a bad option, i guess it comes down to which Premium i want. I’m loath to include Pies in my team, but based on current form, Dids seems to be the best option.

      0

      0
  9. Motts, Help please!!! I met you at the Blues game lat week. We were sitting next to each other. We were high fiving every Blues goal!!! hehehe…I have 2 trades left and not sure what do to. I also have about $54000 in the bank.

    Current team line-up:
    Goddard, Hodge, Malceski, Gilbee, Hunt J, T Hunt, B Nason, (H Taylor, C Heath)
    Ablett, Hayes, Gibbs, Judd, D Martin, Wellingham (Trengove J, Jetta L)
    McIntosh, Warnock R (Sandilands, Lobbe M)
    Chapman, Didak, Pavlich, Fyfe, O’Keefe, Pods, Higgins, (Watts, Casboult L)

    My opponent has a stringer team than mine, but I don’t think he has any trades left so he may have a couple of players missing.
    I’m tossing up whether to trade Harry Taylor for Enright and then trade Trengove for ?? maybe Pendelbury, Boyd or Murphy M (cos I’ll just have enough)
    What should I do? Any suggestions much appreciated.
    Thanks

    0

    0
    1. if you can do taylor to enright and trengove to pendles, do it! Pendles has essendon, adelaide and hawthorn left…should score well. Plus, enright is one of the best defenders around, and is cheap as…

      0

      0
      1. agreed. only suggested Stevens cos of his price and his form over the last 4 games is more consisten. All 100+ compared to fishers eratic 100+ to sub 50

        0

        0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Help our SC Punters

Written by Big Sexy on

Iceman has a Premiership dilemma….. Iceman has 3 important Leagues & made 1 prelim.  Should he use 2 trades now to try to get into the other 2 prelim or just 1 to make sure he has 22 on the park so he can definitely win 1 league GF?

FoTW Trade Options - Rd12 (max two)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Ben needs some advice with a knockout final against his arch rival (housemate) in his $$ league.  A must win.  Ben is thinking of these trades
Rioli > Didak
Webberley > Fisher

Is Tom Rockliff a must-have trade IN for your MID?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Ben’s current team looks like this:
Goddard, Hodge, Malceski, Enright, K.Bradley, B.Sheppard, Waite (Webberley, J.O’Brien)
Swan, Abblett, Selwood, Gibbs, Judd, Bartel (Lewis Jetta, Gysberts)
Jolly, Warnock (Sandilands, Trengove)
Pavlich, ROK, Hall, Franklin, Rockliff, P.Davis, Riewoldt (Rioli, Gumby)

Max wants to know who’s better Broughton or Fisher?

Who are the best downgrade options 'on the bubble' for Rd12? (max three)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

29 thoughts on “Help our SC Punters”

  1. Iceman all or nothing
    Ben how much money do you have I have rioli and think he will be handy when he returns but I’m in the prelim already
    Max I like fisher

    0

    0
  2. Iceman will be playing a tough opponest come GF day so he’s best to strenghten his team now so as to have no injury trades for when he plays the “best” team in that league.

    Oh that’s me.

    0

    0
  3. I have only one trade left and have two questions:

    1. Who should I trade out: Podsiadly or Fyfe?

    2. Who should I bring in Didak or Riewoldt?

    0

    0
  4. Iceman we are in exactly the same position… I’m thinking about going for broke as one of the elimination finals I face is in the LoEC and I want to avoid going out in straight sets especially considering I’ve held top all year! I have the coverage but some key outs makes me think if I don’t trade I’ll have a considerably weaker team… Hmmm the big decisions that will consume my Friday.

    0

    0
  5. help! (please)
    i have one trade left!
    thinking of upgrading either cooney, bastinac or trengove … i can get swan (although some reports he isnt playing this weekend), didak, swallow, cross …. what’s your thoughts???

    0

    0
  6. Ben ideally I’d upgrade gumby to didak And save your last trade but it is a must win and ultimately you have to give yourself every chance. How much cash do you have left

    0

    0
  7. Ok ben another thought is trade rioli for daisy Thomas then use the extra cash to upgrade webberley to someone like kelly

    0

    0
  8. Ben if you downgrade rioli to daisy Thomas you should then have enough to upgrade webberley to lake but ultimately it’s up to you and depends on who your against

    0

    0
  9. Motts, Help please!!! I met you at the Blues game lat week. We were sitting next to each other. We were high fiving every Blues goal!!! hehehe…I have 2 trades left and not sure what do to. I also have about $54000 in the bank.

    Current team line-up:
    Goddard, Hodge, Malceski, Gilbee, Hunt J, T Hunt, B Nason, (H Taylor, C Heath)
    Ablett, Hayes, Gibbs, Judd, D Martin, Wellingham (Trengove J, Jetta L)
    McIntosh, Warnock R (Sandilands, Lobbe M)
    Chapman, Didak, Pavlich, Fyfe, O’Keefe, Pods, Higgins, (Watts, Casboult L)

    My opponent has a stringer team than mine, but I don’t think he has any trades left so he may have a couple of players missing.
    I’m tossing up whether to trade Harry Taylor for Enright and then trade Trengove for ?? maybe Pendelbury, Boyd or Murphy M (cos I’ll just have enough)
    What should I do? Any suggestions much appreciated.
    Thanks

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *