How Many Left?

Written by Motts on June 28 2010

Who are the best VC / C choices for Rd9? (three choices)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

12 thoughts on “How Many Left?”

  1. 10 left.
    This week I will make 2 trades:
    Kreuzer will go out and still making up my mind who to get (other ruckman is Sandilands).
    I will get rid of Barry Hall and pick up Pavlich. Freo have 5 of their last 8 games at Subiaco, also 5 of their last 8 are against bottom 8 teams, so get on the freo boys!

    0

    0
    1. yeah i will be making 2 trades this week as well, then i will be holding off as long as i can…im wanting to upgrade Martin to Pav in the next few weeks…

      0

      0
  2. oi Motts!

    is Sam Jacobs going to be Carlton’s main ruckman for the rest of the season. Just pondering whether to get rid of nic-nac now, and Jacobs is the only ruck i can afford.

    cheers bud.

    0

    0
    1. Hold tight for now Matt. Jacobs will probably get picked, but, they might still go Warnock.
      The other thing is that even if Jacobs is picked, he is no guarantee to stay in side – ditto if they pick Warnock, so, you can’t rely on Jacobs.
      That might change in a week or two, so, look to one of your ruck bench to cover you for a couple of weeks so you can make a reasoned judgement on Jacobs.
      If you have to trade Nic Nat this week, then still hold off till after selection, but Jolly, Tippett (3×110+ in the last 4 wks), maybe Mummy, Jamar, H.Mac or the Richmond ruck, Graham, I think will serve you well.

      0

      0
      1. thanks HGL. sage words.

        i’ve been eyeing up jolly and tippett but would have to use 2 trades to get them, which is annoying.

        0

        0
    1. I’m pretty sure the answer is no to that, we will be locked out before we find out the Sunday teams…

      0

      0
  3. Click on “View results” above and you will get a reasonably good sample size for a mean result. 4-8 is the usual number at this time of the year so you’re in touch with the masses.

    0

    0
  4. I’ll Be Missing You — Round 14

    ADELAIDE
    Nathan Bock (adductor) – test
    Brett Burton (knee) – TBC
    James Craig (hamstring) – indefinite
    Trent Hentschel (hamstring) – 2-3 weeks
    Chris Knights (foot) – indefinite
    David Mackay (ankle) – TBC
    Andrew McLeod (knee) – TBC
    Brad Moran (knee) – indefinite
    Andy Otten (knee) – season
    Sam Shaw (back) – 2 weeks
    James Sellar (knee) – 2-3 weeks
    Daniel Talia (knee) – season
    Will Young (knee) – 2-3 weeks

    BRISBANE LIONS
    Jed Adcock (foot) – 3 weeks
    Donald Barry (sinus) – TBC
    Callum Bartlett (knee) – season
    Jonathan Brown (abdominal strain) – 2 weeks
    Jamie Charman (ankle) – season
    Xavier Clarke (knee) – test
    Josh Drummond (knee) – indefinite
    Mitch Golby (knee) – season
    Matt Maguire (foot) – 1-2 weeks
    Ash McGrath (hamstring) – test
    James Polkinghorne (thigh) – test

    CARLTON
    Chris Johnson (wrist) – 1 week
    Matthew Kreuzer (knee) – season
    Brock McLean (knee) – 3 weeks
    Rhys Oโ€™Keeffe (back) – indefinite

    COLLINGWOOD
    Nathan Brown (shoulder) – 2-3 weeks
    Jack Carter (ankle) – test
    Brad Dick (shoulder) – test
    Nick Maxwell (calf) – test
    Sean Rusling (calf) – test

    ESSENDON
    David Hille (hamstring) – test
    Jason Laycock (foot) – season
    Angus Monfries (hamstring) – test
    Tayte Pears (pancreas) – TBC

    FREMANTLE
    Greg Broughton (hamstring) – 1-2 weeks
    Des Headland (knee) – 1 week
    Chris Mayne (ankle) – 2 weeks
    Luke McPharlin (knee) – 2 weeks
    Brock O’Brien (quad) – 1-2 weeks
    Nick Suban (elbow) – test

    GEELONG
    Marcus Drum (achilles) – 2-4 weeks
    Tom Hawkins (foot) – 1 week
    Steve Johnson (hand) – 3 weeks
    Steve Motlop (shoulder) – indefinite
    Brad Ottens (foot) – 1 week
    Max Rooke (knee) – indefinite
    Harry Taylor (foot) – test

    HAWTHORN
    Max Bailey (knee) – indefinite
    Campbell Brown (knee) – test
    Rhan Hooper (hamstring) – 3-4 weeks
    Simon Taylor (fractured leg) – 1-2 weeks

    MELBOURNE
    Max Gawn (knee) – 1-2 weeks
    Jordan Gysberts (back) – 2 weeks
    Rhys Healey (hamstring) – 4-5 weeks
    Daniel Hughes (ankle) – test
    James McDonald (hamstring) – 1-2 weeks
    John Meesen (ankle) – indefinite
    Ricky Petterd (shoulder) – season

    NORTH MELBOURNE
    Liam Anthony (shoulder) – indefinite
    Aaron Black (hip) – indefinite
    Ben Cunnington (broken nose) – test
    Majak Daw (knee) – 3-4 weeks
    Ayden Kennedy (foot) – 1-2 weeks
    Scott McMahon (groin) – test
    Drew Petrie (foot) – 1-2 weeks
    Ben Ross (hip/groin) – indefinite
    Matthew Scott (general soreness) – test
    Josh Smith (groin) – test

    PORT ADELAIDE
    John Butcher (back) – test
    Brett Ebert (ankle) – test
    Robbie Gray (back/hamstring) – 1 week
    Hamish Hartlett (quad) – 1 week
    Nathan Krakouer (groin) – 1-2 weeks
    Marlon Motlop (foot) – 2-3 weeks
    Michael Pettigrew (knee) – 6-7 weeks
    Nick Salter (calf) – test
    Jacob Surjan (knee) – 2-3 weeks
    Warren Tredrea (ankle) – 6-7 weeks

    RICHMOND
    Matt Dea (foot) – indefinite
    Nathan Foley (leg) – test
    Tom Hislop (knee) – indefinite
    Luke McGuane (ankle) – test
    Kelvin Moore (ankle) – test
    Graham Polak (concussion) – test

    ST KILDA
    David Armitage (knee) – test*
    Raphael Clarke (hamstring) – test*
    Robert Eddy (knee) – TBC
    Jason Gram (groin/hamstring) – test*
    Nick Riewoldt (hamstring) – 3 weeks*
    Jesse Smith (ankle) – indefinite

    SYDNEY SWANS
    Craig Bolton (achilles) – 3 – 4 weeks
    Daniel Bradshaw (knee) – test
    Tadhg Kennelly (knee) – test
    Jake Orreal (back) – season
    Mark Seaby (ankle) – 4 – 5 weeks

    WEST COAST
    Sam Butler (foot) – 6 weeks
    Darren Glass (abdomen) – season
    Ash Hansen (hip) – 5-6 weeks
    Shannon Hurn (calf) – 1-2 weeks
    Jordan Jones (ankle) – 4 weeks
    Daniel Kerr (hamstring) – 5 weeks
    Mark Nicoski (shoulder) – season
    Adam Selwood (AC joint) – test
    Luke Shuey (virus) – indefinite

    WESTERN BULLDOGS
    Ayce Cordy (shoulder) – season
    Lukas Markovic (shoulder) – test
    Shane Thorne (knee) – 7 weeks

    *Estimate only. Club has not provided official timeframe.

    0

    0
  5. ST KILDA
    Jason Gram (groin/hamstring) test
    Nick Riewoldt (hamstring) test
    David Armitage (knee) 3 weeks
    Raphael Clarke (hamstring) TBC
    Robert Eddy (knee) TBC
    Jesse Smith (ankle) indefinite

    Posted on HS this arvo

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

How Many Left?

Written by Motts on

Who are the best VC / C choices for Rd9? (three choices)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

12 thoughts on “How Many Left?”

  1. 10 left.
    This week I will make 2 trades:
    Kreuzer will go out and still making up my mind who to get (other ruckman is Sandilands).
    I will get rid of Barry Hall and pick up Pavlich. Freo have 5 of their last 8 games at Subiaco, also 5 of their last 8 are against bottom 8 teams, so get on the freo boys!

    0

    0
  2. oi Motts!

    is Sam Jacobs going to be Carlton’s main ruckman for the rest of the season. Just pondering whether to get rid of nic-nac now, and Jacobs is the only ruck i can afford.

    cheers bud.

    0

    0
  3. Click on “View results” above and you will get a reasonably good sample size for a mean result. 4-8 is the usual number at this time of the year so you’re in touch with the masses.

    0

    0
  4. I’ll Be Missing You — Round 14

    ADELAIDE
    Nathan Bock (adductor) – test
    Brett Burton (knee) – TBC
    James Craig (hamstring) – indefinite
    Trent Hentschel (hamstring) – 2-3 weeks
    Chris Knights (foot) – indefinite
    David Mackay (ankle) – TBC
    Andrew McLeod (knee) – TBC
    Brad Moran (knee) – indefinite
    Andy Otten (knee) – season
    Sam Shaw (back) – 2 weeks
    James Sellar (knee) – 2-3 weeks
    Daniel Talia (knee) – season
    Will Young (knee) – 2-3 weeks

    BRISBANE LIONS
    Jed Adcock (foot) – 3 weeks
    Donald Barry (sinus) – TBC
    Callum Bartlett (knee) – season
    Jonathan Brown (abdominal strain) – 2 weeks
    Jamie Charman (ankle) – season
    Xavier Clarke (knee) – test
    Josh Drummond (knee) – indefinite
    Mitch Golby (knee) – season
    Matt Maguire (foot) – 1-2 weeks
    Ash McGrath (hamstring) – test
    James Polkinghorne (thigh) – test

    CARLTON
    Chris Johnson (wrist) – 1 week
    Matthew Kreuzer (knee) – season
    Brock McLean (knee) – 3 weeks
    Rhys Oโ€™Keeffe (back) – indefinite

    COLLINGWOOD
    Nathan Brown (shoulder) – 2-3 weeks
    Jack Carter (ankle) – test
    Brad Dick (shoulder) – test
    Nick Maxwell (calf) – test
    Sean Rusling (calf) – test

    ESSENDON
    David Hille (hamstring) – test
    Jason Laycock (foot) – season
    Angus Monfries (hamstring) – test
    Tayte Pears (pancreas) – TBC

    FREMANTLE
    Greg Broughton (hamstring) – 1-2 weeks
    Des Headland (knee) – 1 week
    Chris Mayne (ankle) – 2 weeks
    Luke McPharlin (knee) – 2 weeks
    Brock O’Brien (quad) – 1-2 weeks
    Nick Suban (elbow) – test

    GEELONG
    Marcus Drum (achilles) – 2-4 weeks
    Tom Hawkins (foot) – 1 week
    Steve Johnson (hand) – 3 weeks
    Steve Motlop (shoulder) – indefinite
    Brad Ottens (foot) – 1 week
    Max Rooke (knee) – indefinite
    Harry Taylor (foot) – test

    HAWTHORN
    Max Bailey (knee) – indefinite
    Campbell Brown (knee) – test
    Rhan Hooper (hamstring) – 3-4 weeks
    Simon Taylor (fractured leg) – 1-2 weeks

    MELBOURNE
    Max Gawn (knee) – 1-2 weeks
    Jordan Gysberts (back) – 2 weeks
    Rhys Healey (hamstring) – 4-5 weeks
    Daniel Hughes (ankle) – test
    James McDonald (hamstring) – 1-2 weeks
    John Meesen (ankle) – indefinite
    Ricky Petterd (shoulder) – season

    NORTH MELBOURNE
    Liam Anthony (shoulder) – indefinite
    Aaron Black (hip) – indefinite
    Ben Cunnington (broken nose) – test
    Majak Daw (knee) – 3-4 weeks
    Ayden Kennedy (foot) – 1-2 weeks
    Scott McMahon (groin) – test
    Drew Petrie (foot) – 1-2 weeks
    Ben Ross (hip/groin) – indefinite
    Matthew Scott (general soreness) – test
    Josh Smith (groin) – test

    PORT ADELAIDE
    John Butcher (back) – test
    Brett Ebert (ankle) – test
    Robbie Gray (back/hamstring) – 1 week
    Hamish Hartlett (quad) – 1 week
    Nathan Krakouer (groin) – 1-2 weeks
    Marlon Motlop (foot) – 2-3 weeks
    Michael Pettigrew (knee) – 6-7 weeks
    Nick Salter (calf) – test
    Jacob Surjan (knee) – 2-3 weeks
    Warren Tredrea (ankle) – 6-7 weeks

    RICHMOND
    Matt Dea (foot) – indefinite
    Nathan Foley (leg) – test
    Tom Hislop (knee) – indefinite
    Luke McGuane (ankle) – test
    Kelvin Moore (ankle) – test
    Graham Polak (concussion) – test

    ST KILDA
    David Armitage (knee) – test*
    Raphael Clarke (hamstring) – test*
    Robert Eddy (knee) – TBC
    Jason Gram (groin/hamstring) – test*
    Nick Riewoldt (hamstring) – 3 weeks*
    Jesse Smith (ankle) – indefinite

    SYDNEY SWANS
    Craig Bolton (achilles) – 3 – 4 weeks
    Daniel Bradshaw (knee) – test
    Tadhg Kennelly (knee) – test
    Jake Orreal (back) – season
    Mark Seaby (ankle) – 4 – 5 weeks

    WEST COAST
    Sam Butler (foot) – 6 weeks
    Darren Glass (abdomen) – season
    Ash Hansen (hip) – 5-6 weeks
    Shannon Hurn (calf) – 1-2 weeks
    Jordan Jones (ankle) – 4 weeks
    Daniel Kerr (hamstring) – 5 weeks
    Mark Nicoski (shoulder) – season
    Adam Selwood (AC joint) – test
    Luke Shuey (virus) – indefinite

    WESTERN BULLDOGS
    Ayce Cordy (shoulder) – season
    Lukas Markovic (shoulder) – test
    Shane Thorne (knee) – 7 weeks

    *Estimate only. Club has not provided official timeframe.

    0

    0
  5. ST KILDA
    Jason Gram (groin/hamstring) test
    Nick Riewoldt (hamstring) test
    David Armitage (knee) 3 weeks
    Raphael Clarke (hamstring) TBC
    Robert Eddy (knee) TBC
    Jesse Smith (ankle) indefinite

    Posted on HS this arvo

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *