Last Minute Queries – Rd7

Written by Schwarzwalder on May 3 2019

Questions? Questionables? Questionability? Quizzes? Quizzing? Quizzed? Quandaries? Queries? Queried? Quagmires? Q & A? FAQs? Quick answers!!

Who comes in for Robbie Gray?  Who is the better downgrade option between Young & Hayes?  Is it time for Constable to go?  Would he make much more cash anyway?  Will Fyfe be cheaper this year?  Whatever you need to know, the SCT Coaches are here to help…………

2
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

91 thoughts on “Last Minute Queries – Rd7”

  1. T/U Scrimshaw and Collins for Sicily and hayes

    T/d Constable and Scrimshaw for coniglio and hayes

    Both via durssma to backline.

    Open to other option if better out there. Missing Whitfield, scrimshaw, Clark ( if not named) down back.

    21

    1
  2. Kinda forced to trade scrimshaw as I got no coverage due to having whitfield and McKay as my loophole. Do you guys think scrimshaw to hayes and parker to caleb Daniel is safe? I dont really trust hayes and Luke beveridge Haha yet I’m leaning towards bringing in two Bulldogs. Thumbs up or nah?

    7

    0
  3. who to bring in for scrimshaw
    T/U Jake Lloyd
    T/D James sicily

    really want to get lloyd in my team but I do need to start planning for byes, currently have 24 players available rd 12, 18 in rd 13 and 17 in rd 14

    22

    2
  4. Should I be trading Constable over Atkins ?? Hayes will come in and likely be on field, Im skeptical about trading constable as he’s been playing as my M7 with EmergencyLoophole as M8.

    TU: Yes
    TD: No

    5

    12
    1. Gibbons should make about 20k more than Fyfe this week, if thats the trade you are considering it would be safe to hold off for one more week, unless you really wanted Fyfes score to count for this round. Will score you’d think like 70 more than Gibbons so that is quite a difference, only real downside comes at the chance of injury or Gibbons playing mid and dropping another big score. If that happens then he will have quite a bit more $$$ to make

      2

      0
  5. T/U – Hold Collins this week and bring in Answerth next week (miss out on Young)
    T/D – Collins to Young this week and ‘someone’ to Answerth next week (assuming he’s picked)

    11

    7
  6. Which rookie to field?

    T/U: T. Atkins
    T/D: M. Gibbons

    Current mids: P. Cripps. M. Crouch, S. Cogniglio, T. Liberatore, D. Sheed, S. Walsh & S. Stack.

    14

    10
  7. Trading Constable to Hayes and unsure of what to do with my second trade. $250k and 28 trades after trading out constable and was thinking of doing Burgess to Young for more cash next week. Any suggestions appreciated !!

    Def: Laird, Williams, Whitfield, Wilkie, Duursma, Hore EMG: Burgess, Clark
    Mid: Cripps, Treloar, Fyfe, Cogs, Brayshaw, Crouch, Stack, Constable EMG: Atkins, Sparrow, Scott
    Ruck: Grundy, Gawn EMG: Sweet
    Fwd: Danger, Heeney, Dunkley, Drew, Parker, Petruccelle EMG: Setterfield, Schultz

    T/up – Do the Burgess trade

    T/down – Save the trade

    Comment – Other trade options

    3

    11
  8. TU Butters and Collins –> Hayes and C. Daniel via Moore (65k bank)
    TD: Constable and Collins –> Fyfe and Answerth (33k bank)

    3

    2
  9. Scrim -> Lloyd
    Constable-> boak

    TU : pay premium price worth it.
    TD : look for more value in Sicily/laird or Daniel/kelly

    5

    3
  10. What would you prefer for Scrimshaw?

    TU – LYoung (Lockhart on bench)
    TD – Hayes (Lockhart on field)

    I can bring in Hayes for Scrimshaw but it would mean playing Lockhart on field in DEF with both Whitfield and Burgess out. However, Scrimshaw-Young leaves Lockhart on MID bench.

    0

    8
  11. Another option I have is
    TU: Collins and Constable –> Sicily and Hayes (30k bank)
    TD: Collins and Butters –> C. Daniel via Moore swing and Hayes (60k bank)

    3

    1
  12. Trading Collins and a mid rookie to Hayes and T.kelly via Moore
    Who to trade

    Tu) butters

    Td) Atkins

    3

    5
    1. Alternatively I could trade scrimshaw and field Collins over Clark but worried about Collins high BE

      TU) trade scrimshaw

      TD) trade Collins

      0

      5
  13. Was planning on trading Collins out before the news of Scrimshaw, so now I can’t decide. Collins will probably drop cash this week, whereas Scrimshaw won’t, and will be back next week (and will go up in price once he returns). I won’t be copping a zero, as Scrimshaw is my only non-playing defender at the moment.

    TU: trade Collins
    TD: trade Scrimshaw

    6

    2
  14. Don’t have enough for an upgrade this week. My first trade will be B.Scott to W.Hayes. Should my second trade be: Balta to Bolton, or Collins to Rozee?

    0

    3
    1. Josh,

      Well done on making it this far without making any trades.

      Scott > Hayes is solid.

      I recommend to hold your other trades until there are some potential targets (i.e. Stocker?)

      2

      0
  15. Still can’t decide if i should hold or trade Libba?

    Atkins out for Hayes is a definite… then which trade would you do:

    T/U – Scrimshaw for Daniel (va Moore DPP) – 43k in bank

    T/D – Libba for Fyfe – 138k in bank

    Comment: any other suggestions?

    8

    0
  16. What’s Answerth’s job security like? LDU and Constable getting dropped in the same week has complicated my plans ever so slightly.

    2

    0
  17. Constable & Atkins to Hayes & T Kelly??
    It’s really Butters or Constable if I get Kelly in
    Can go Clarke to Answerth a week early
    Is Kelly worth sacrificing trading out Constable & Atkins…….

    TU: Yay
    TD: Nay

    3

    3
  18. T/ u Bolton
    T/d Hayes

    Will have to field who ever I select

    Leaning to Hayes however I lose dpp status
    If I select him as Hayes comes in by moving Setters to forward line

    3

    2
  19. TU Fyfe and S Bolton in
    TD T Kelly and W Hayes in (Already have Dahlhaus, Heeney and Danger on same bye week)
    Comment Fyfe and any other DEF/FWD rookie (please suggest)

    0

    4
  20. Every week these rookies don’t get named makes me regret not bringing in Stack or Ross.
    My patience is wearing thin Scott & Setterfield

    9

    0
        1. Hately still only 1 game, emergency this week, not sure why he’s not getting another run after his debut.

          0

          0
  21. FELLAS!
    JPK? What are the thoughts here.
    Very tempted!
    94, 136, 113, 95, 110, 115 in his past few.
    AVG 110

    8

    1
  22. shhhh,
    don’t put the mozz on him Anthony,
    1% of teams
    had him all year, super happy with his output so far

    7

    0
  23. TU – Fyfe
    TD – Neale

    Fyfe better BE and cheaper but injury/suspension risk higher. Likely end up with both at some point of the season.

    6

    2
  24. Newbie Question ; can or do I have time to change Captains after the 1345 game finishes & the 1635 game starts? Or is this part of the lockout?

    0

    0
    1. As long as none of the players involved in your switch have already started playing, you are fine.
      After the first bounce of any game, the players involved in that specific game are LOCKED until the round is completed.
      Hope that makes sense and good luck!

      0

      0
  25. Thanks allsaints, any idea roughly what time the 1345 game finishes? Looking to
    VC – Gawn / C – Neale?!? My team is crippled by injuries, omissions & poor coach choices this week (the latter is not refined to this week alone) – trying to nail my Captains choice!

    0

    0
  26. I hate bringin in players with the R13 bye 🙁
    Even considering Cameron over kelly to avoid another R13 bye in my team..
    But lloyds consistency can’t be knocked

    Tu Lloyd
    Td Sicily

    4

    3
  27. Unsure who to trade for Hayes, Constable or Scott. Constable gives me more money for an upgrade next week but his scoring potential is higher if he gets back in the team.

    T/U Constable
    T/D Scott

    1

    10
  28. How does the emergency player work? If I have butters and crips as emergency players do I get the lowest score out of those two?

    1

    0
    1. If you put the E on two players on the SAME line (eg DEF line) you will get the lower of the two.
      What are you trying to do? And which players are involved?

      0

      0
      1. Thanks allsaints. Just thinking about the vc loophole. I was going to loophole butters and Cripps but it would mean I get butters score of 30 instead of Cripps score. All good I worked out I can use Setterfield. He is listed as an emergency for the game.
        Thanks for setting me straight.

        0

        0
  29. Anyone think I should be bringing in Shai Bolton as a downgrade?
    It would have to be for Pettrucccccccccccelle, Parker, or B. Scott.

    Current FWD – Danger / Heeney / Kelly / Rozee / Pettrucc / Parker // Cavarra / Drew

    2

    0
  30. Need to get the best score possible for Constable loophole …

    T/U – Take Hayes 49pts

    T/D – Risk taking whatever Gibbons scores

    0

    2

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *