Most Underrated

Written by Motts on May 13 2010

Yesterday we had the Most Overrated poll, today we’re going the other way. I’ve named one player from every club which seriously limited me (because believe me I would’ve loved to have named about 4 from The Blues) so don’t go posting cranky comments because I’ve missed out one of your guys. Just add his name below. 3 votes allowed.

Supercoach Talk Champion - Rd 6 (5 selections)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

52 thoughts on “Most Underrated”

    1. I rate him highly for what its worth.

      Aaron Joseph, Eddie Betts, Paul Bower, Kade Simpson and Heath Scotland.

      0

      0
        1. HAHAHAHAHA well put Deano.

          Eddie’s having a massive year tho. Heath Scotland still makes me ill however.

          0

          0
        1. the question is why didn’t you draft Buddy instead?

          might’ve won the flag last year if you did.

          0

          0
          1. griffen has definitely stepped up this year and starting realise his potential, at least you didn’t choose Tambling!

            0

            0
  1. Adam Selwood – if he was playing in a medium to strong Victorian team he would be rated at least as highly as Joel. Has all the same attributes but can also play tall.

    0

    0
      1. Alright, I admit I’m an Eagles member but I maintain my statement on Adam/Joel has significant credibility.

        Have you seen those thighs on Hurny PA? Mmmmmmmmmm…….

        0

        0
    1. At the eagles i would say Lecras. Should be in the all Aust team. Selwood a good tuff versatile mid but his kicking lets him down. I think most can see JK’s potential to be a star and i doubt he’s under-rated

      0

      0
  2. James Polkinghorne – He isn’t even at the stage of being underrated. Most people don’t even know who he his. He has been a shinning light at the Lions (yes i am a Lions memeber) he just does everything you want a player in his position to do. He will be one you hear a lot more of when names like Black and Power are gone.

    0

    0
    1. I’ve heard of the guy but you’re right, wouldn’t know him if he fell out of the sky and landed on my be-scarved head. He’s listed as a forward though, Mavs, why are you mentioning him in the same breath as midfielders? Don’t you mean Brown and Fevola?

      0

      0
      1. Not at all, he only plays fwd at the moment because that is where he is needed. But he has had the a few stints in the midfield and has shown that’s where he will end up staying once he gets a little more experience. It’s his aggression whilst having poise that’s makes him stand out.

        0

        0
        1. He started the year in the 2’s, didn’t he? He is going to be a player, not sure he is there yet, though.

          0

          0
    2. Glad you brought him to our attention Mav – now with Pokinghorn, Cox and Swallow we can have a bit more fun with Mottsy!

      0

      0
    1. why is that Paul, you have no bench coverage & you’ve spent your two trades this week already?

      0

      0
      1. Avg 130 points per game, bench will be lucky to get 60-80 points. It’s not worth trading him out. I’ve got Brennan and Mummy to worry about along with wanting to upgrade Ladson this week, that’s all.

        0

        0
        1. Unless it is a long term absence, I certainly wouldn’t be advocating a Chapman trade. 60-70 pts is a big loss, but if you’ve got the bench coverage at least you don’t get a doughnut. I don’t have him in my SC team, but, have him in my DT, so I’ll need to monitor this situation as well.
          Brennan & Mummy are concerns for you, no question & I wish you well solving that dilemma.
          I’ve got my own dilemma working out a suitable trade for Rioli & Bob Murphy.
          Surely Ladson can be held onto for another week?

          0

          0
          1. 3 forced changes is possibly the worst outcome for us SC’s, possibly only rivaled by running out of trades & then having players injured/dropped/rested/suspended.

            Which line do you have best bench coverage for? That would be the bloke you don’t trade.

            0

            0
  3. Max Rooke. If that man was at any other club he would be recognised as their hardest-at-it and skillful small forward (St Kilda and Doggies perhaps excepted). In fact, he’d probably play out of the mid-field. With Chappy, Ablett and everyone else who fits the bill at the Cats, he’s forgotten.

    0

    0
    1. Interesting call. With the cats playin the lions, I should be at least glad that he isn’t playing then because we have a few problems down back.

      0

      0
  4. North’s Changes
    In: Pratt, Smith, Greenwood
    Out: Leigh Adams (hamstring), Liam Anthony (shoulder), Ben Warren

    0

    0
  5. Jobe Watson i no he turns it over by foot a bit but u cant underestimate his ability to win the ball (#1 contested ball winner 2010) plus his leader ship is great.

    Liam Anthony: this kid is a gun and i have never herd any one talk about him on this site, i no he is injured now but if u watch him he is pure class and young to.

    0

    0
        1. In: Amon Buchanan, Matt Maguire, Joel Patfull, Andrew Raines
          Out: Josh Drummond (knee), Jared Brennan (ankle), Pearce Hanley, Travis Johnstone

          0

          0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Underrated

Written by Motts on

Yesterday we had the Most Overrated poll, today we’re going the other way. I’ve named one player from every club which seriously limited me (because believe me I would’ve loved to have named about 4 from The Blues) so don’t go posting cranky comments because I’ve missed out one of your guys. Just add his name below. 3 votes allowed.

Supercoach Talk Champion - Rd 6 (5 selections)

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

52 thoughts on “Most Underrated”

  1. Adam Selwood – if he was playing in a medium to strong Victorian team he would be rated at least as highly as Joel. Has all the same attributes but can also play tall.

    0

    0
  2. James Polkinghorne – He isn’t even at the stage of being underrated. Most people don’t even know who he his. He has been a shinning light at the Lions (yes i am a Lions memeber) he just does everything you want a player in his position to do. He will be one you hear a lot more of when names like Black and Power are gone.

    0

    0
  3. Max Rooke. If that man was at any other club he would be recognised as their hardest-at-it and skillful small forward (St Kilda and Doggies perhaps excepted). In fact, he’d probably play out of the mid-field. With Chappy, Ablett and everyone else who fits the bill at the Cats, he’s forgotten.

    0

    0
  4. North’s Changes
    In: Pratt, Smith, Greenwood
    Out: Leigh Adams (hamstring), Liam Anthony (shoulder), Ben Warren

    0

    0
  5. Jobe Watson i no he turns it over by foot a bit but u cant underestimate his ability to win the ball (#1 contested ball winner 2010) plus his leader ship is great.

    Liam Anthony: this kid is a gun and i have never herd any one talk about him on this site, i no he is injured now but if u watch him he is pure class and young to.

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *