Poll – Danger vs Mac

Written by Schwarzwalder on July 27 2018

One spot left in your midfield and you’ve narrowed it down to these two guys………………..

 

Which player would you rather have in your team over the last five weeks?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
1
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

13 thoughts on “Poll – Danger vs Mac”

  1. Pointless poll. Decent teams should already have Danger, plus their prices aren’t even comparable.
    A better poll would be Macrae vs Gaff or Neale

    13

    6
    1. hey Pete

      Some of us don’t have Danger as he has been significantly overpriced all season, until perhaps the last few weeks. So we punted on Macrae early instead, who massively over-delivered until his hammy went ping. I then traded him out as i couldn’t afford $620k sitting on the bench for weeks and so now have neither. I can only pick one of the two with only two trades left, so for me, this is a brilliant poll and will greatly inform my decision thanks to the community’s response.

      There are a lot of polls on here that don’t serve specific interest for me, but i will always participate as it can help others who wish to see how significant numbers vote on a big decision. Taking part for me, is far more important than simply serving individual needs. Those that get the most votes in the Polling Station early in the week, see their wishes come to life. True democracy innit 😉

      Maybe just vote as you would if you had neither in your team. It’ll help those of us who are pondering this very question.

      Cheers

      27

      0
      1. Dangerfield is in 43% of teams and $586k
        Macrae is in 7% of teams and $540k

        It’s not really comparing apples with apples, and would affect very few teams that happen to both not have Danger and have an extra $50k+ sitting in the bank.

        I’m glad it’s helpful to you, but doubt there would be many others from the SCtalk community it would help

        5

        2
        1. All good mate. I was only trying to make a generic point rather than one that relates to a specific poll.
          My point is that I reckon it is always helpful to respond as if it IS a scenario you are faced with, so that others who it does effect can make better informed decisions.
          I appreciate that I am now in a relatively weak position (having neither) and will bring in Danger when I am forced to do so by ensuing carnage, but for now I have to HOLD THOSE TRADES 🙂

          6

          0
          1. I do respond too. I just think that there might be other polls that are more important this week, being the last chance for many teams to make finals or top 4.
            Perhaps a poll on whether to use up your last trade or not. Whether to trade out Webster/De Goey or hold. Whether to upgrade Stef to Grundy or hold. Just a few that come to mind

            3

            2
            1. Pete you are carrying on.
              Shwarzy is most likely just putting up a poll that someone specifically asked for earlier in the week in the what you would liked Polled thread.

              If you want one of the polls you suggested then you should have posted it in the Poll thread on Monday. The Contributors on the site are tireless workers and basically write for the site for nothing or a very small nominal fee.

              SuperCoachtalk is the best SuperCoach site going around and I am just afraid that not every thread will be to your liking or will not be related to you, but usually always it is related to some SuperCoach players or has been specifically requested by a Forum Member.

              4

              1
              1. To be fair to Pete we see lots of polls here ignoring players with high percentage ownership because they generally aren’t a consideration.

                I dont have any issue with this or anything else from the poll thread because the whole point is to address someone’s needs, but I do see where hes coming from.

                0

                0
              2. Sorry Death Adder but your argument is flawed. I’ve posted in that “polling station” the last 3 weeks and not had one addressed. So I just have to post my thoughts here I guess

                0

                3
                1. Sorry Champ…….I’ll get those polls happening for you next week! Should still be relevant…..

                  2

                  0
  2. Danger’s last two games:

    Fremantle at GMHBA Stadium (SC preliminary finals) & Gold Coast at GMHBA Stadium (SC Grand Final).

    8

    0
    1. P Dangerfield:
      Avg VS Freo since 2012: 142.5 from 8 (low of 72 and a high of 188, 1/8 below 100, 7/8 120+, 5/8 140+, 2/8 185+)

      4

      0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *