Polling Station – Rd7

Written by Schwarzwalder on April 30 2018

It’s that part of the week again where you control the content at SCT.  Which polls are important to you right now?  Which polls would you like to see ahead of Rd7?  # of trades left?  Ruck replacements?  Time to get rid of a rookie?  We’ll do our best to fit them into the schedule before Friday night………..

1
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

34 thoughts on “Polling Station – Rd7”

  1. – Forward line must-haves
    – What to do with Buddy
    – Midfield must-haves
    – Grundy yes/no
    – Rookies to begin upgrading

    14

    0
  2. Not relevant this year but for future years.
    At the beginning of a season have a pole for the-
    Def,heath shaw/hibberd
    Mid, zorko
    Fwd,Billings
    Nominations. These guys are train wrecks ruining seasons by being so abysmal that they are sucking the fun out of the game on a weekly basis. Rant over.

    3

    9
    1. The weekly Rookie Review and Cow Corner are brilliant, definitive guides for all things rookie related.

      I feel Polls should be used more for ‘hot topic’players or categories not specifically covered in the awesome weekly updates we’re lucky enough to get. Contributors do way too much every week as it is.

      Not having a go, just saying the info is already here. You can always add the ones you’re considering to TradeTalk threads to get a better sense of comparative JSs.

      Good luck.

      3

      0
    1. $133k ago he was worth the risk. Very low chance of seeing out the season so the cash gain + points early on is what he had going for him. Feels like he has lost most his value now.

      12

      0
  3. Poll on Robbie Gray get him in now or after his bye
    Poll on Touhy hold or trade
    Poll on Parker hold or trade
    Rookie poll would also be great

    Also like to let you guys know me and many others are incredibly grateful for the work you guys put in and the effort
    It is highly appreciated

    9

    1
  4. If you had to downgrade to one of the following rookies this week who would it be:

    1) Spargo

    2) Mutch

    3)Worpel

    11

    0
  5. Thinking Sicily has been on the end of the Clarko stare for his last indiscretion…..actually act of stupity!

    At $448k & most of the so called Premium Forwards spudding it up ( yes Billings )

    Is Sicily a must have?

    4

    4
      1. As a long serving Hawk supporter & 23 year member, not convinced Hutta!

        In saying that knowing Clarko, do it once ohh well it happens, do it twice not happy Jan…do it a third time & that little angry Clarko will seriously rip him a new one!

        6

        0
      2. I hear you Hutta but, if you have someone on the bench who will give you 70 in his absence, then yes he is worth having. I had Naughton 78 covering him last week. A bit lucky maybe, but it will return better than anyone who’s currently ranked #6 on DEF averages or worse. A flog I know, but a gun and keeps it exciting that’s for sure.

        3

        0
        1. Indeed. Assuming that he doesn’t miss any games through injury, and that he averages 100 from here on out (3 of his 4 games this year have been 110+, so this would appear quite achievable), then even if he misses 3 more games through suspension, a bench player who scores 60 during each of those suspensions would give him an effective average of 93 from round 7 onwards.

          0

          0
          1. Yeah but you just know he’s going to get suspended during the bye rounds, throwing your plans totally out of whack!

            0

            0
  6. I’d be interested to see how many rookies do coaches have on the playing field currently, (so not sitting on the bench), before any trades made for this round.

    3

    0
  7. How about the debate on real dealers?!
    Shine On or Fade to Grey
    List the likes of Deledio, Treloar, Robinson, Westhoff, Savage, Billings, Hibberd etc.
    Using the same list, pick three(?) who will shine on and three who will fade to grey.
    Could be interesting … and fun

    2

    0
  8. If you have most of the other big scorers (Mitchell, Martin, Cripps, Fyfe, Oliver, Macrae, etc.), is Dangerfield an absolute necessity?

    1

    0
    1. Good question. Everyone will say no. He’ll bang out 150 this week and we’ll all scramble for cash to get him in 😉

      1

      0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *