Progress Scores – Rd3

Written by Schwarzwalder on April 6 2019

Another massive game from Neale, Rozee kicks five, the Eagles reign supreme at the G, Dees struggling at 0-3, plenty to discuss………. More importantly, how’d you start in SuperCoach in Rd3?

Score / # of players / VC

3
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

101 thoughts on “Progress Scores – Rd3”

  1. 523/5/Danger

    Danger, Mcrouch, Milera, Constable, Smith

    Happy with supercoach, not with the crows. Couple of tough loophole decisions to make

    5

    0
  2. 646/5/Danger

    Danger, MCrouch, Kelly, Constable and Clark all scored as expected or better. Very happy with that start.

    4

    0
  3. 607/5/Bines

    Danger (VC), Constable, Clarke (E), M Crouch, B Smith
    Will keep the loophole for both Danger and Clark.
    Have added in the additional numbers.

    Happy with the start; need Westhoff, Goldy, and Darling to fire this week.

    4

    1
  4. 453/4/ Danger

    Danger, MCrouch, TKelly, Constable
    Will take Dangers score even though I’m almost certain Grundy will top that against Hickey/Vardy. I’m not taking any chances after Rd1 debacle

    3

    0
    1. Also need help, Currently holding Ridley but need to trade him out before tonight. Have the cash to go Ridley to Worpel via Burgess and lose my D/F link or bank some cash and go Ridley down to Rozee.

      TU: Ridley >Worpel
      TD: Ridley> Rozee

      6

      5
      1. Haydyn,

        It doesn’t make sense why Ridley has been culled from the Dons. He should get a call up in the next week(s) and reckon he stays in the side after that. If you have to trade, I would hold for a better and less expensive Cow, or until Ridley returns to the side, unless you need to field a player this week.

        If you have to field a player, and think Worpel is a top-10 Forward, pull the trigger. Do not waste the trade on Rozee. Won’t generate the cash required.

        2

        2
  5. 611/5/Danger

    Danger, Laird, Kelly, Constable, Clark

    Really tempted with Macrae but have learnt from not taking Cripps Rd1 so will just bank Danger’s points.

    2

    0
  6. 418/4/Fyfe

    Danger VC, Kelly, Constable, Laird – tempted to bank Danger’s score.

    TU: take Danger’s score – everyone else has
    TD: wait for Fyfe – he’s playing St Kilda at Optus and will score 130+ anyway

    5

    6
    1. I think take the points early in the year players Still getting into their work. No need to get greedy 128 is good enough for me.

      I wouldn’t be surprised to see a lot of people risk on Gawndy, Oliver or McRae, as the have the potential of going HUGE.

      4

      0
      1. Yep I’ll risk it. Going Macrae for my captain. If he can’t get 140+ at home against Gold Coast he hasn’t got out of 1st gear. Now that I’ve jinxed him…..

        1

        3
  7. 534 from 6 captian l neale. Max gwan. Looks like he have a surberb score hope he hits over 200. And I laugh at all you guys that traded gawn out. And Goldie will score big to.

    0

    6
        1. Spent those big bucks on macrae for a reason. Back him in.
          I’m leaving him perma captain and only taking loophole 140+’S. Going by last year and his form so far should get a captain score 125-140+ every week, but hoping for the big one.
          If you aren’t going to captain him trade him and put the money somewhere else. (smiley face)

          2

          2
  8. Considering trading out Walsh for Rockliff, don’t have another option to get rid of and ultimately it’s a good upgrade for $200k that should yield 30 extra points a week.

    T/u – Do it
    T/d – Walsh is a gun who’ll knock out 120 against GC next week

    17

    15
  9. Thoughts on LDU? Could this possibly be a breakout second year player? Job security? All comments appreciated.

    0

    0
    1. Brad Scott is notoriously fickle and unreliable on these matters. Ahern’s somehow out of the team despite his form late last year yet Turner gets a game each week. Also, we’ve 0-2. If we move to 0-3 changes might happen and 1st in 1st out can often be the case. Also, Anderson is on his way back soon and Dumont’s back this week. That’d have to effect LDUs possession count.

      Buyer beware is all i’d say.

      0

      0
  10. Thought on Hind —> Scrimshaw?
    – Have to C Fyfe though as i dont have any other loopholes for Danger

    1

    1
  11. 702/6/ Danger
    Interesting week in terms of my season as held onto 30 trades keeping Martin and Heeney in the end.
    Could back fire but also assist me as Kelly was my trade in option but now also looking towards Dahl next week if Martin or Heeney struggle again.

    1

    0
    1. 790/ 7 / Danger
      Same here PBuzz held on to both and almost moved on Ridley until I saw he was late in.
      Still have the 30 trades!

      1

      0
  12. 470 / 3 / Danger

    Season defining weekend as i hold onto Dusty, Dunkley and Heeney. Only trade I’ve made was Hore into Rozee.

    Missed Constable’s near ton as he’s parked on my pine.

    1

    0
  13. 829/7

    Played: P Dangerfield (C), C Constable, R Laird, R Sloane, new recruit B Smith, Z Merrett and C Oliver.

    Yet to play:
    Saturday: L Whitfield, X Duursma, Z Williams, L Neale, S Walsh, Z Butters, B Grundy, I Heeney, J Darling, D Moore, W Setterfield, W Drew
    Sunday: T Goldstein, J Scrimshaw, N Fyfe

    1

    0
  14. 828/7/Dangerfield C (incl.)
    Early trade (Ridley>LMcCarthy) may yet bite me on the arse! Few too many Thursday night

    #schoolboyerror #shouldknowbetter

    3

    0
    1. Hi All Saints

      You are going to be tough to beat in our Supercoach battle league match up

      To date our same players have played except you have Gawn and I have Goldstein.
      I have also Macrae, Billings , Scrimshaw, Martin to play vs your unique picks to my team of Neale , McCarthy, Libba and Dunkley.
      Good luck

      Tempted to put c on Macrae but can’t risk it

      2

      0
  15. Corrective trade, Failed with trying to play Savage as a pod in my defence, should I trade heeney to worpel freeing up cash to bring in either whitfield or Sicily (I’m not 100% sold on worpel being a top 8 forward by seasons end) or just trade savage to Williams? My gut is telling me to keep heeney.

    TU – Downgrade Heeney to Worpel, then bring in Sicily or Whitfield for savage

    TD – Keep Heeney and just trade Savage to William’s

    Any respones would be appreciated lads!

    0

    4
  16. Drew and Setterfield cost me, while not having Neale hurts but he isn’t owned by too many so it’s ok.

    On track for 2400+ which I reckon is par this round.

    0

    0
  17. 2082/Cripps
    Still to come: Fyfe, Libba, Scrimshaw and Parker

    Looking at a 2400+ score which would be nice, unless a couple of them spud up but I don’t think it’s too much to ask 318 out of those 4 players.

    Dusty > Neale trade was great!

    8

    0
  18. 1979/19/ Dangerfield

    Yet to play:
    Sunday: T Goldstein, new recruit J Scrimshaw, N Fyfe

    Very happy with the majority of the team bar J Darling, W Setterfield and W Drew the only 3 scoring below 65 and combining for 123 points. 3 to go tomorrow and hoping Goldy can amend last week’s below par performance to help me reach 2250+.

    2

    0
  19. 1881-Macrae(c), Dunkly, wilkie, parker.
    Couldn’t loophole danger due to work. Was always going Macrae anyhow seeing as i was putting up an about par score and was hoping for a bit of an edge, but as the scores started rolling in i wanted to vc danger to play safe but was too busy and missed the collingwood lock out. But Macraes’ a champ, not too worried.

    Hoping dunkly finds some form(SC) against gold coast. Feel parker is due for a quiet one but is highly owned. Wilkie??? at leased i have an emergency 60 on bench.
    Lol, have rocky. HAHA new as soon as everyone jumped on he’d fall apart. Getting Whitfield asap.

    3

    0
  20. 1714/15/Danger

    Projected 2380, not sure if it’ll be that high but with Fyfe, Steele, Dunkley and Macrae yet to come it should be over 2300 so can’t complain.

    1

    0
  21. 1805/16/Dangerfield

    Goldstein, Luke Ryan, Liberatore, LDU, Parker, and Scrimshaw yet to come, so I’m probably looking at somewhere in the mid-2300s at this point.

    2

    0
  22. 2020/19/ Cripps

    Another ‘what could have been’ week sitting at 1491/12 at 7pm. Thinking I was a sneaky chance of making it into the SCT Cup.
    Insert Crisp, Darling and Drew. Haha oh well

    Hopeful of 2300 but doubtful. Goodluck coaches

    0

    0
  23. 1674 from 17. With Macrae(C), libber, steele, collins and LDU to come.

    probably 2200-2250 range. Which is looking subpar for this round?

    1

    0
  24. 1645 / 15

    Libba, Macrae, Billings, Steele, Parker, Scrimshaw, Collins still to play.

    Captain decisions:

    T/U : take Danger’s 128
    T/D : take a punt on Macrae vs GC

    2

    8
  25. 1751 from 17, captian l neale. Pretty pissed of with all the port players I have. Rocky ko scored 36. Hoff 35 and the shit rookies again from that club giving such shit scores. Only 5 left need at least 2 to 3 players score 150 p.us for me to get any type of score. Pissed off

    0

    4
  26. I have Goldie billings Walters parker and s Collins. What u guys think I score any chance of 3 players go over 140

    0

    8
  27. 1956 / 18 – Projected 2,412

    Still have Macrae (C), Libba, Goldy & Parker to play

    Laird, B. Smith & rookies only letting me down this round so far

    2

    0
  28. 1676 / 16 / Danger

    To come … Dunkley, Libba, Goldy, Cousins, Scrimshaw, Parker.

    Bloody Dusty has done his dash and he’ll be goneski. Brought Rozee in for Hore with 1 minute left on the clock.

    Mostly though I’m disappointed at falling for the shenanigans from GWS in the preseason that Whitfield’s role was going to change. Had him in my team all preseason but switched to Harris Andrews when I heard that news. Cost me big time yesterday!!

    Unlikely to even nab a wildcard birth into the SCT Cup which is disappointing. Might have to rewrite the rules for 2020 to stipulate that Roo Bloke gets a guernsey regardless of how shite his start is.

    6

    0
      1. I can make it happen Schwarz. If SC scoring can be hidden behind a cloak of secrecy, maybe I can do the same with the SCT Cup qualification criteria. See you in the GF Schwarz!

        3

        0
  29. The TEAM

    2094 / 19 / Gawn

    Macrae, Collins and Parker to play for the TEAM on Sunday. Looks like being a solid week for the TEAM…….

    8

    1
  30. Had a hit and miss round like many, but not too many misses.

    1851/18 with macrae captain, dunkley, scrimshaw and collins to come. Got Clark as emergancy.
    I’m assuming that will be par/sub par this week, hopefully macrae goes bananas.

    Negatives- setterfield, drew, darling. Might have a look at unloading darling next week, think I’ve got this selection wrong.
    Traded out dusty for neale so I can’t complain

    2

    0
    1. I’ve got Darling too CJ. I think if you picked him up though you keep him for a few weeks. The low scores are expected from the key forwards but will hopefully be offset when he kicks 8 and scores 150 against one of the struggling teams.

      2

      0
      1. I totally agree ash, I will have a look nevertheless though. Rd4 isn’t really a trading round anyway.
        I always think if you have made a mistake in this game, you have to acknowledge it, fix it, move on.
        He was fortunate to reach 50in the end. I’ve got no other concerns, used 1 trade so far. Maybe I drop him to Rozee? Pocket the cash, make some cash from Rozee and move on and get that d/f dpp which can’t hurt for the short term

        1

        0
  31. Tu- bank dangers score or
    Td- Captain Macrae
    Playing for a league win in a close one. I’m 70 in front with Macrae to play. My opponent has Scrimshaw, B.Scott and Fyfe. Thoughts appreciated , cheers Tiger.

    5

    5
  32. 2056/18/Coniglio!!!
    Libba,Collins,Goldy,Parker to come.Not taking Danger hurt but not as much as picking Coniglio instead of Whitfield!!!!

    1

    0
  33. 1865/18/Dangerfield VC, with Libba ,Collins, Fyfe and Parker to come.
    Had Walsh on bench, Scott is too.
    Too late to change C.
    Should get 2000, hoping (dreaming) for 2100.

    0

    0
    1. 1895 / 18 / danger
      Funny old game this, decided to hold dusty and heeney and also didn’t trade ridley early and benched setterfield for drew.
      Pretty happy sat arvo after heeney and setters and dustys first qtr as well .also ridley was going to go for rozee!
      Not complaining just pointing out the rollercoaster nature of the game.

      1

      0
  34. Roo bloke I hear you. All preseason I had Lloyd, Whitfield , Witherden as my 3 stayers in Def. got nervous on all 3. Should have stuck to my guns, Next year I am finalising my team before JLT bar injuries. Why is GWS so secretive when they haven’t won anything yet?

    3

    0
      1. Ended up staying away from all def and going strong fwd and changing my structure to start with only Z.Williams and B. Smith + Moore and Cunningham + rookies. I should be ok post byes . Still need Billings and Mundy to show up now that Heeney is back. Just a slow start but early full premos…

        1

        0
  35. 2142/19/danger

    macrae, scrimshaw and parker to play
    had neale but didnt captain him 🙁
    drew and setterfield on field but projected for 2437
    hopefully will be a good week if the last three players reach or get over their projected scores.

    1

    1
  36. 2053/19/Dangerfield
    Fyfe, Parker Scrimshaw to play

    After bringing in Lycet for Jacobs
    Need Parker to fire after bringing in for Hore

    0

    1
  37. I was on track for a brilliant score with 10/1162 until last night’s games. Poor scores from the 3 Port rookies and Darling’s 50 leave me on 18/1812 with Macrae (C), Scrimshaw, Steele and Parker to go.

    Will need Parker and Scrimshaw to replicate last week’s scores, 110~ from Steele and Macrae to go absolutely HUGE in order to put up the competitive score I was on track for.

    0

    1
  38. 2417/Neale/21

    Was possibly on track for cracking 2500 but alas Parker seems to have gone AWOL, not that I’m complaining! Must admit though, tried to get the loophole on Danger but missed by milliseconds and locked me out..

    0

    0
  39. Ended with 2215 poor scores from a few players I dont wish to name in westhoff and rocky unlucky got knockout. Thank God lachie neale and danger gerlong boys to. Also kade. Simpson should retire crap again

    0

    2

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *