SC Finals Wk1, 2013: Rate My Team

Written by MJ on September 5 2013

The team sheets are in and we now have the chance to finalise our sides for the inaugural SC Finals competition.

Who will be lining up for you this week?

Make sure you join the SCT League if you havenโ€™t already: 714272

Good luck for R1 of SC Finals, and all the best to your club if they are playing this weekend!

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

64 thoughts on “SC Finals Wk1, 2013: Rate My Team”

  1. Mid pricers galore in my line up:

    Ellis, Colquhoun, Grimes
    Pendles, Swan, Murphy, Sewell
    Mumford
    Pavlich, Chapman, Rohan

    Any suggestions?? would be much appreciated ๐Ÿ™‚

    0

    0
  2. Gibbs, Colqhoun, Duigan (if in final 4 on i/c – currently extended bench)
    Pendles (C), Selwood (VC), Hodge, Murphy
    Roughy
    Chappy, Didak, Rohan

    A solid team that would be relying on a bit of luck from returning old stars such as Chappy and Didak & future stars in Rohan & Colqhoun. What you all reckon? Any proposals for changes as i only did this team tonight.

    0

    0
  3. Catta’s Clan, MK15……so far

    Birchall, Richards, Colquhoun
    Pendles, Swan, Murphy, Chapman
    Sandilands
    Roughead, Didak, Rohan

    Whatcha think SCT coaches?

    0

    0
  4. This is my team at the moment, will still play around with it a bit before first lockout….

    Gibbs, Ellis, Grimes
    Pendles, JPK, Fyfe, Murphy
    Sandilands
    Chapman, Didak, Rohan
    $9,200

    0

    0
  5. Birchall, Richards, Colquhoun
    Swan, S.Johnson, K.Jack, Murphy
    Grundy
    Chapman, Stewart, Rohan

    Stewart and Rohan are both sub possibilities.. my only concern. Richards is a solid, gets it done type of scorer. im happy with that for now.

    0

    0
  6. Ellis, Richards, Colquhoun
    Pendlebury(C), Selwood (V), Beams, Anderson.
    Sandilands
    Pavlich, Chapman, Rohan.

    Just need to make sure Anderson isn’t in the vest.

    0

    0
  7. Have changed the team a hundred times, will probably change again before kick off tonight. As it stands right now:

    Richards, Colquhoun, Grimes
    Swan, Selwood, K.Cornes, Burgoyne
    Grundy
    Bartel, Chapman, Rohan

    Still not 100% with Selwood, the Crowley tag might swing my way of thinking. Trying to stick with some experienced campaigners in the midfield. I’ll figure it out soon enough;-)

    0

    0
  8. Mackie, T. Richards, Grimes
    Pendlebury, Bartel, Hodge, B, Kennedy
    Sandilands
    Stokes, Rioli, Didak.

    Will need to make a couple of adjustments as Kennedy is out for the Pies and Rioli is a question mark. Wanted Selwood but scared off with the prospect of Creepy Crowley running with him.
    Any suggestions for Kennedy and Rioli would be greatly appreciated.

    0

    0
  9. Enright, Ellis, Colquhoun
    Swan, Johnson, Martin, Murphy
    Sandilands
    Chapman, Didak, Rohan
    Not sure if im going to get time to check this weekend so hope Didak is not the sub!

    0

    0
  10. So a guy that has had zero attention and is coming off a SC hundred is Aaron Young from Port.

    Has played three games (one a sub) and scored 63, 30 (green vest) and 104. Priced at $190,400.

    I can’t for the life of me recall ever having seen him play (he also played 12 games last season).

    People’s thoughts in relation to Didak, Menzel and Rohan? He is the only sub-$200k forward to have a SC ton this year and the other upside is nobody is picking him.

    Vest chance maybe? I’m actually hoping so, as I’d like to see Colquhoun avoid it so he can run around for my side on the weekend.

    Could be a very interesting PoD if he does avoid the vest though.

    0

    0
  11. Richards, Yarran, Grimes
    Pendles, JPK, K Simpson, M Murphy
    Mumford
    Bartel, Didak, Rohan

    Pendles was the only lock for me, after that i picked the Midfield based on opposition – JPK loves playing his old club and both Simpson and Murphy have been awesome against the Tigers for last few years.

    0

    0
  12. ellis, colquhoun, grimes
    pendle, selwood, bartel, murphy
    sandilands
    johnson, didak, rohan

    obviously bulked up midfield at the expense of the other positions- thoughts?

    0

    0
  13. Just went bonkers and changed my entire squad with the exception of Pendles. Taking a massive gamble, but I think that I can do that given it isn’t the official supercoach season. My gamble is picking leadership types. Here goes nothing. Now before all the thumbs downs come, there are reasons behind my madness which I will include beside each one.

    DEF – T.Richards (coming off 114 & 99/finals vet), N.Maxwell (5y ave. 91 against port, 83 in finals, capt of pies), N.Duigan (cheapest DEF that will get a game, in leadership group)

    MID – Pendles (captain in waiting, most reliable player in the game), J.McVeigh (3y ave. 108 in finals, capt of Syd), L.Hodge (when fit, is a weapon come the crunch, capt of Hawks), M.Murphy (undervalued, capt of Carl)

    RUCK – A.Sandilands (undervalued, VC of Freo, no competition from Geelong ruck)

    FWD – M.Pavlich (undervalued, can go large, capt of freo), P.Chapman (undervalued, big stage perfromer), A.Didak (cheap show off, has shown he can score with the vest, if he starts with it i’ll switch to A.Young)

    .

    0

    0
  14. First attempt for this seasons finals. Trying a balanced team to help with trading the way through based on the teams I think will be eliminated and have byes etc. Feedback please:

    Mackie, Burgoyne, Ellis
    Swan (C), JPK (VC), Murphy, Sewell
    Sandi
    Cappy, Didak, Rohan

    0

    0
  15. Some great logic there. Captains certainly earn their money in the finals. On a similar chain of thought, Port’s captain Boak could go very big & Newman (ex C) should have a big one in his first (and maybe last) final appearance.

    0

    0
  16. My team at the moment
    Enright, Birchall, Colquhoun
    Pendlebury (captain), Bartel (vice-captain), Chapman, Ellard
    Sandilands
    Stokes or J Lewis, Pavlich, Didak
    Thumbs up: Good/Great team
    Thumbs down: Crap

    0

    0
  17. My team at this stage, $31k in the bank

    D: Ellis, Richards, Grimes
    M. Pendles, Swan, Stevie J, Murphy
    R: Sandi
    F: Chappy, Didak, Rohan

    Thoughts??

    0

    0
  18. Currently in Korea so won’t be able to follow too closely this weekend.

    What do you think as it stands?

    T Richards, Maxwell, N Duigan
    Pendles, Stevie J, Cotchin, Murphy
    Sandilands
    Pav, Chappy, Rohan

    Thanks

    0

    0
  19. Mackie, Ellis, Colquhoun
    Swan, JPK, Hodge, McLean
    Sandilands
    Roughead, Didak, Rohan

    I think McLean and Mackie are really well priced for what they can produce and are good PODs. Kennedy always seems to lift when playing against his old side.

    0

    0
  20. What do you think about starting with JPK and keeping some money as he always goes really well against the hawks and then trading him to barlow/selwood (whoever loses) next week. Also who would you put VC?
    T/U Stevie J
    T/D JPK

    0

    0
  21. Well boys being not the real deal my team is slightly weighted to a particular team.
    (Wonder who that is) but reads as follows.

    Chaplin, Stratton, Grimes.

    Pendles,C Hodge VC, Chapman, Sewell,

    Mummy,

    Jordan Lewis, Rioli, Rohan. Rioli does not come up reckon Steven Motlop get the run or Jack Gunston with no Buddy

    Backs very dicey, but would have to say the have been a nightmare all year so worth a gamble on some cheaper mid range options in this game.

    0

    0
  22. GOT b ellis Colquhoun grimes
    m pendlebury swann j kennedy and chapmen
    ruck mumford

    fwds cloke think he will smash ports back men didak and rohan

    what you think of that team

    0

    0
  23. Ellis, T. Richards, Colquhoun
    Swan, Pendlebury, Sewell, Josh p. Kennedy
    Grundy
    D. Martin, Didak, Rohan

    Farley confident with this team, Kennedy has a great record in finals. Any possible changes I can make. Only disconcern is Didak and Rohan for the green vest

    0

    0
  24. Heyy so..

    B: Gibbs, Ellis, Rivers
    M: Pendles, Jelwood (C), JJK, Menzel
    R: Mumford
    F: Stokes, Didak, Rohan

    Appreciate any advice thanks

    0

    0
  25. after reading everyones comments , i dont feel so bad that rohan scored so low , thats because everyone else seems to have him in there team . ๐Ÿ™‚

    0

    0
  26. had make a few changes hope they will pay off took ellis out bought in sam couqulian then bought in oliie wines for ebbet took a chance on wines and lastly was tossing up between cloke and west off went with the hoff think he will surprise the pies back line tonight

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *