Most of us will have to resist the urge to trade this week with finals just round the corner, but for those who are facing must win games to make the 8 or even the top 4 to secure the all important double chance, trading may be your only option. Considering most of our budgets are strained to their limits, you’re probably not looking at the $500-$600k range, but rather searching for a bargain, who has the potential to produce 100+ games.
Defenders:
Heath Scotland (D/M) $484,400; 101.13, BE 77.
Showed why he’s been a Fallen Premiums favourite of mine with a 127 on the weekend against the Dogs. May be the last time he gets mentioned as his price looks set to jump over $500k again very soon.
Michael Johnson (D/F) $414,700; 92.38, BE 103.
Was averaging 98.7 for the season before Fremantle’s bye in round 12, which elevated him to premium status after never showing much in previous seasons. Despite a few quiet games since, he remains the 4th highest scoring defender in terms of overall points this season. Falling $80,300 since his bye, he now represents great value for money for those who can tolerate Ross Lyon’s antics. Gives added flexibility if you still have Billie Smedts as D/F swingmen.
Alex Rance $388,100; 88.75, BE 53.
Was at the Richmond v North game on Sunday and was very impressed with Rance’s first 3 quarters, which he kept Petrie to a couple of touches and racked up plenty himself. Scored 91 and 96 in his last two and has fallen $97k since round 4. Scored 108 against the Blues in Rd 1, whom Richmond have this week. I like him as a selection and am kicking myself that I chose Newman last week over Rance.
Jack Grimes $379,900; 83.00, BE 13.
Went massive with a 138 on the weekend off 32 possessions and 11 marks. Averaged 94.3 in 2009, which was essentially his debut year after only 1 game in 2008. Has been a pretty good DT defender this year with a healthy 89 average, but only 83 in SC, which shows he’s winning plenty of footy but disposal efficiency could be an issue. I’d generally steer clear of Melbourne players, but if you feel like a punt, he certainly has the potential. Melbourne still have Gold Coast and GWS to play also.
Sam Fisher $366,500; 80.09, BE 111.
Played a key position role on Adam Goodes last week and still managed to pump out a 92. Should improve when Jason Blake returns to the side in a few weeks as it will free Fisher up as a loose man in defence. This price is an absolute bargain for a blue-chip defender over many seasons. Great potential to go big, and should score well enough for his price-tag. May not churn out the 100s like we’ve been used to playing full back though, so be wary. Has Melbourne and GWS to play in SC finals.
If you’re not keen on any of these, wait for:
Matt Suckling $402,400; BE 146
Shannon Hurn $440,600; BE 134
Brendon Goddard (D/M) $435,400; BE 132
Beau Waters $488,700; BE 130
Midfielders:
Scott Pendlebury $593,900; 125.08, BE 110.
Snuck Pendles in here in case you’ve got the funds for him. At less than $600k he is an absolute steal. Got GWS this week too so get on now if you’ve been saving up for him.
Tom Rockliff $490,800; 108.06, BE 95.
Young Tommy has dropped below $500k after that 69 three weeks ago. Cheapest he’s been all season after starting the year off at $615,600. Could be a handy POD in finals as he can go very large as witnessed by his 5 139+ games this year.
Marc Murphy $452,100; 105.40, BE 59.
Can’t go past this man at such a ridiculous price. Will get the hard tag while Judd is still out, but still scored 108 with Picken in his hip pocket all night. He’ll save you $150k over the top range midfielders, which can be used for another upgrade elsewhere. Gold!
Mids with massive breakevens:
Joel Selwood $574,800; BE 167
Nick Dal Santo $463,700; BE 149
Andrew Swallow $555,200; BE 144
Jobe Watson $583,900; BE 139
Dale Thomas $483,900; BE 137
Ruckmen:
Todd Goldstein $490,900; 94.43, BE 118.
Has been super consistent over the last few weeks while not setting the world on fire with his scoring. 90, 93 and 95 over the last three weeks isn’t amazing, but will keep your score ticking over. Got the best potential out of all the ruckmen under $500k. Jonathon Griffin is also an alternative, with a similarly consistent scoring pattern.
Tom Bellchambers $377,000; 85.09, BE 18.
Not a premium in any sense of the word, but has scored 102 and 114 in his last two with Ryder out of the equation. Is an option if you want to finally jump off Shane ‘injury prone’ Mumford, but word is he should only miss the one week, maybe two with bone bruising in the knee. You never know with big men though, so Tommy Bellchambers could be your get out option if you don’t have the funds for a top-liner.
Rucks who’ll be cheaper in coming weeks:
Dean Cox $623,800; BE 237
Ivan Maric $552,900; BE 163
Nic Naitanui $521,500; BE 147
Jarryd Roughead (R/F) $540,900; BE 127
Forwards:
Steele Sidebottom (M/F) $493,500; 108.75, BE 120.
High breakeven, but plays GWS this week. Some suggest his young body is slowing down after an arduous season with some lower scores in his last month, but this can present value for canny SC players. Steelebutt tipped over $600k post round 9, and can now be purchased at less than $500k. If you still think he’s got what it takes to run out the season strongly, consider him.
Not too keen on many other forwards for under $500k this week. I’d have a look at Brent Harvey, Dustin Martin and Nick Riewoldt, around the $450k range as former 100+ averaging players if you’re in the market, but only Harvey showed any form out of those guys last week with a 107. Also, keep an eye on Stewart Crameri for $340,600 if you’re in need of a cheaper forward, averaging 100 up until round 10, but only returned 61 against Geelong in his first run back from injury.
Forwards with high breakevens to look out for:
Kurt Tippett $352,500; BE 192
Paul Chapman (M/F) $512,600; BE 182
*Nathan Fyfe (M/F) $484,500; BE 153* Watchlist him. Returns this week.
*Adam Goodes (M/F) $461,600; BE 139* Has been a disappointment for those, like myself who jumped on after his 148. 75 and 71 over the last two weeks will see his price tumble.
Travis Cloke $334,100; BE 137


{ 39 comments… read them below or add one }
Bring in Murphy or Pendles? Murph saves me valuable cash, but Pendles has GWS, and is a steal for under 600k.
T/U Pendles
T/D Murphy
Thanks
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
18
9
Depends if you only have one more midfield spot to fill. If you have two then go Murphy for now. If only one spot to fill then Pendles could easily average 20+ more points than Murphy so maybe go Pendles as the bloke seems unaffected by the tag.
Like or Dislike:
1
0
Another great article, MJ. Very nice work indeed.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
14
0
I’m developing a man-crush on MJ I’m loving these articles so much!
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
6
0
Great write up MJ. Murphy is certainly an absolute steal at that money. Stand in captain as well which i see as a positive.
Chappy & Fyfe great potential bargains on the horizon.
Goddard on the way to 400K in a couple of weeks will be interesting as on paper he has a good run in SC finals. However Jordan McKenzie tagging him again in the Melbourne game at the MCG in Rnd 20 may extend his patchy form.
Like or Dislike:
1
0
Have a mere two trades left and $21,000 dollars in cash!
Wanting to either trade Giles or Tippett this week but after their huge recent price collapses, there is no true quality trade options within my price cap.
Anyone have any possible suggestions please! Have no bench cover for Tippett as Buddy is on the pine, but I am simply over his head bashing!
Cheers.
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Tippet to Couch. Frees up a about 250k. Couch good JS and dpp. Then if
Need be giles to any ruck with the cash u have left. That’s of
Course if u not already got Couch!
Like or Dislike:
3
0
Bye bye Daisy. Hello Pendles.
Like or Dislike:
3
3
Hidden due to low comment rating. Click here to see.
Poorly-rated. Like or Dislike:
2
10
Wait a week on fyfe then get him. He may be sub this week to ease him back in ala barlow and mundy earlier this season.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
4
0
100% agree with Nick. Fyfe has a huge BE & will come crashing down in price. Furthermore FURL has stated in today’s write up on AFL.com.au that he is looking to shift Fyfe into various positions like he did with Goddard. Fyfe for me, but wait a couple of weeks for both testing out his shoulder + getting a cheap price.
Like or Dislike:
2
0
Does that mean that FURL will use Fyfe like Broughton is being used??? Noooooooooo…………………………..
Like or Dislike:
0
0
T/U: Beams and Murphy
T/D: Scott Thompson and Fyfe
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
16
1
Thumbs up for sure Rileeeey, 2 great additions to any team.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Hey guys just a quick poll who would you grab already have 1 M/F in mids
T/U- Couch
T/D- Miles
Hot debate. What do you think?
7
9
At this stage of the season JS and cheap price are the determining factors. Can see Couch playing every week while we never know what’s going to happen with the expansion teams.
Like or Dislike:
3
1
Is Murphy capable of getting 110-120 with a hard tag?!?
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
11
2
He got 108 against one of the best ( Picken ) if not the best tagger in the comp last week, bear in mind that was only his 2nd game back from a LTI.
Like or Dislike:
3
0
I’m on him this week. Will have to contend with Jackson and Raines before Judd comes back, but I think he should still go alright.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Great write-up MJ, well done!
Just off topic, did anyone else receive an email this week to say that your digital pass is going to expire in 5 days? I signed up for the 2 month free trial 3 weeks before the start of the season, to be told nearly 5 months later that it’s about to expire?!?
Thanks for the free ride HS
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
5
1
Did anyone else laugh to themselves reading that the Cloke camp were knocking back the Pies 5 year contract offer at $800-$850K a year as they objected to it being performance based?? Why would Trav & his dad worry about signing up for a perforance based on current form!! Poor Trav would be dipping into his massive collection of $ 5 notes fairy quickly if it was 100% performance based.
Like or Dislike:
4
1
Like or Dislike:
2
1
Yiorga, this is bizarre. I had finished typing the comment below when AFL360 this morning put up the ‘who would you rather be – David Cloke or Damir Dokic’. Must be great minds think alike!
When we look back after Travis Cloke retires I wonder if we will say that Damir Dokic did a better job of managing his child’s career than Trav’s old man did for his boys?
Would love Trav to rebel and sign a 2 year contract with the pies so he can concentrate on playing and then relook at things at the end of next year.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Collingwood should hold its ground IMO Andy. I reckon with the cash saved from Cloke the Pies could nab a gun key position youngster from GWS/Suns for half the price.
Like or Dislike:
1
0
I agree with that in a way Yiorgy but their premiership window is now. While Joke has been rubbish this year if they had to rely on Dawes and a twenty year old to run their forward line they’d be waiting at least another two or three years before they were genuine contenders again.
Like or Dislike:
1
0
True Fish but having this whole saga go on has to unsettle the team somewhat. They’re better to make a clean break IMO. Pies premiership window will be open for a few years yet.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
Hidden due to low comment rating. Click here to see.
Poorly-rated. Like or Dislike:
0
12
Was planning of trading Smedts and Stanton to couch and swan, but after reading this am now thinking of Giles and Stanton to Murphy and Bellchambers. I only have 4 trades left. What does everyone think?
T up Murphy and Bellchampers
T down Swan and Couch
Comment any advice would be great cheers
Hot debate. What do you think?
5
3
I have 3 trades left: Do I Trade Mumford to Bellchambers OR Dal Santo to Murphy (Dal Santo has let me down of late).
T/U: Mummy>Tommy
T/D: Dal Santo>Murphs
Thank you fellas.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
6
2
Wit only three trades I’d hold fire
Like or Dislike:
3
0
Is there a point in holding on to trades if I’m just losing points? Mummy is doing sh*thouse, and this injury will only hold his scores back further…
Like or Dislike:
1
4
Hidden due to low comment rating. Click here to see.
Poorly-rated. Like or Dislike:
1
9
What do you guys think of Scott Gumbleton’s JS as opposed to Anthony Miles’?
T/U Gumby will play more games
T/D Miles has better JS
Thanks
Hot debate. What do you think?
5
6
Hey guys, Want to upgrade Giles and broughton but only have 160k in the bank. Was thinking broughton to Fisher leaving enough cash for Griffen or goldstein. I think griffens job security is better with Hmac playing VFL this week but unsure. What do you all think?
T/U Griffen
T/D Goldstein
Hot debate. What do you think?
5
3
Roos coach Scott did come out a couple of weeks back & say that when HMac comes back, he will come back as a forward & Goldy will be left as is. That said, Griffen the safer option for sure.
Like or Dislike:
1
0
What about when Sandipants comes back??? Both have the same amount of worry attached to them I think.
Like or Dislike:
1
0
Need Help, 3 trades & $435k left struggling in rucks currently have Jenkins & Giles with Ryder & Stephenson on the pine . Do I trade out Giles for a premium this week(thumbs up) or wait a week for their prices to drop?(thumbs down)
Like or Dislike:
1
0
Trade Giles now, he’s going to drop just as much as a premium that you’re thinking of trading in with a BE of 111.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
thanks for that MJ
Like or Dislike:
0
0