The Polling Station

Written by Schwarzwalder on May 29 2017

At SuperCoachTalk we endeavour to keep all our various polls as relevant as possible.  Many polls are requested each week and we do our best to accommodate our Coaches where possible.

If you have any polls you’d like us to organise this week, then place the ‘poll topic’ in the Forum below.  We’ll do our best to work all these polls into our schedule over the next few days.  So what would you like to see, Coaches?  Dusty vs Pendles?  Best FWD option over $480k?  Let us know………

 

* A poll on number of trades left will be up shortly *

2
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

39 thoughts on “The Polling Station”

  1. Perhaps, in conjunction with the number of trades remaining poll, a poll on how many trades coaches are planning to make across the bye rounds would be greatly appreciated.

    I myself will be planning to make 7 or 8 trades over the next few weeks to nab a few bargain premiums and leave me with a close to completed team once the bye rounds are over!

    6

    0
  2. Fielding 16 this week holding Stewart and Barrett they have more cash to be made, Newman will be a straight swap for Lloyd in round 13 too. Taking a hit this week

    1

    2
  3. I wouldn’t mind seeing a ranking poll just to see how everyone has gone in the first half of the season and then one after the byes to see how well people did at avoiding the carnage

    10

    0
  4. What to do with Stef Martin if Archie keeps playing. Archie only played 3 games last year, and Stef was going at 1/2 his normal SC scoring (which he did again this weekend). Will Archie get more games? Should I use the byes to just bite the bullet and trade him out?

    12

    0
    1. Yeah this would be good in the Trade/Hold section and maybe the same for JJK depending on how severe his injury is

      7

      0
  5. After round 13. I’d like to see a comparison ranking between round 10 pre bye to after round 13 bye.
    Also in the comments section, did you trade hard to get your byes right or just try and wing it.
    This could show beginners how important it is to get your byes right.

    Rd 10 rank ?
    Rd 14 rank ?
    Traded hard Y/N

    5

    0
  6. Not so much a poll but more a request. As I read all the sites re SC [SCT #1]I would like to see the current ratings of the Authors of the writeups [ie Schwarzwalder, Motts, Huttabito, Farther Dougal, Jack Reylonds, Shortys Supercoach, Lepdog etc]

    2

    0
    1. Good idea! I can incorporate that into SCT Leagues Update. I’ll keep it to SCT Contributors only, otherwise too time consuming…….

      6

      0
  7. Over the bye period I would be interested in seeing the top 8 defender, top 10 mids, top 4 rucks and top 8 fwds poll. I think this was done during preseason but it would be interesting to see how much it has changed in 10 weeks.

    5

    0
  8. Will do our best to use as many polls as possible this week. Can probably incorporate a few into Burning Question & Trade Or Hold. Thank you!

    3

    0
    1. Do it and don’t look back. He still teases with a good quarter but thats about it.

      Watching the game on the weekend he just doesn’t get the love from teammates anymore.

      3

      0
      1. He demanded the ball once and he was given it, now they don’t give a stuff about him. I’ll put up with his crap scores and hope he turns it around.

        1

        0
        1. They just don’t need him like they use to. The kids are all growing up and taking more responsibility. There was a moment yesterday he kicked it, ran his gut out over 100m to get a cheap kick over the top and they just bombed it long into their forwardline. Once upon a time, they would have given it to him and he would be the one getting the inside 50 and score assist. The lack of cheap handball receives plus the less point kicks ins and the points speak for themselves. I was a huge Shaw advocate at the start of the season but there’s enough data now. 20 games for an average less than 87, if he did than Rd1-23 last season, he would have barely been looked at prior to Rd1 lockout.

          4

          0
  9. Bye Planner Poll: some comments made re the qualifying score for “Gun” status.

    If I can change it to a basis of average score for year (or three round average or ???) then what would be the scores? eg:

    DEF – 90+
    MID – 105+?
    RUC – 95+?
    FWD – 95+? 90+?

    Cheers!

    2

    0
  10. Ty Vickery’s new hair cut will translate to:

    TU: A more ‘streamlined’ forward performance
    TD: No change (a spud is a spud)

    2

    11
  11. On a more serious note, some good suggestions above 😉

    Perhaps a poll of players to avoid as trade in targets? (Due to fixture, injury history, role change, finals fixture (for leagues) etc)

    2

    0
  12. I would love to see a poll for how many hours the supercoach people spend on determining there side from week to week
    Myself 1 hour a week, its what u put into it is what u get out of it, that’s why l am going in a nice way shithouse

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *