It’s that time of the week again, the teams a due out and we’re all hanging on what names get the go-ahead especially with a few big names missing. Whack them up in the comments and win eternal praise from the team here at SCT, and we’ll update the main post shortly.
Collingwood v St Kilda
Collingwood
B: N.Brown, B.Reid, B.Macaffer
HB: M.Clarke, H.Shaw, H.O’Brien
C: S.Sidebottom, D.Swan, D.Thomas
HF: J.Elliott, T.Cloke, Q.Lynch
F: B.Kennedy, T.Goldsack, S.Dwyer
Foll: D.Jolly, S.Pendlebury, J.Blair
Int: A.Krakouer, J.Witts, J.Thomas, P.Seedsman
Emg: A.Fasolo, J.Russell, M.Williams
In: A.Krakouer, D.Jolly, J.Thomas, J.Witts, B.Kennedy
Out: A.Toovey (Knee), B.Hudson (Leg soreness), J.Russell (Omitted), A.Fasolo (Omitted), B.Sinclair (Omitted)
New: B.Kennedy, J.Witts
St Kilda
B: N.Wright, S.Fisher, S.Gilbert
HB: S.Dempster, D.Roberton, J.Geary
C: N.Dal Santo, L.Hayes, B.Murdoch
H: D.Armitage, R.Stanley, L.Montagna
F: J.Saunders, N.Riewoldt, J.Koschitzke
Foll: B.McEvoy, C.Jones 4, J.Steven
Int: S.Ross, A.Saad, S.Milne, A.Siposs
Emg: T.Hickey, J.Newnes, J.Webster
In: S.Milne, A.Siposs
Out: T.Dennis-Lane (Omitted), T.Lee (Achilles)
Essendon v GWS Giants
Essendon
B: M.Hibberd, T.Pears, C.Dempsey
HB: K.Hardingham, C.Hooker, B.Goddard
C: M.Baguley, J.Watson, D.Zaharakis
HF: J.Merrett, S.Crameri, J.Melksham
F: A.Davey, S.Gumbleton, B.Stanton
Foll: T.Bellchambers, B.Howlett, N.Kommer
Int: H.Hocking, L.Jetta, D.Hille, D.Myers
Emg: E.Kavanagh, N.O’Brien, N.Lovett-Murray
In: L.Jetta , T.Pears , J.Melksham , N.Kommer
Out: J.Winderlich (Rested) , T.Colyer (Omitted) , D.Heppell (Groin) , J.Carlisle (Ankle)
GWS
B: A.Kennedy, T.Mohr, J.Bruce
HB: A.Corr, S.Gilham, T.Greene
HF: R.Palmer, J.Cameron, A.Tomlinson
F: D.Smith, S.Frost, T.Adams
Foll: J.Giles, A.Treloar, D.Shiel
Int: C.Hampton, S.Coniglio, S.Reid, Z.Williams
Emg: T.Bugg, S.Edwards, T.Downie
In: S.Gilham, C.Hampton, J.Bruce, T.Adams, J.Townsend, S.Frost, A.Corr
Out: B.Thornton (Omitted), S.O’hAilpin (Calf), P.Davis (Back), T.Bugg (Omitted), L.Whitfield (Soreness) , L.Plowman (Omitted), N.Haynes (Omitted)
New: A.Corr
North Melbourne v Port Adelaide
North Melbourne
B: S.McMahon, S.Thompson, M.Firrito
HB: A.Mullett, N.Grima, J.Macmillan
C: D.Wells, S.Atley, S.Wright
HF: A.Black, M.Daw, T.Hine
F: L.Thomas, D.Petrie, L.Adams
Foll: T.Goldstein, A.Swallow, J.Ziebell
Int: R.Bastinac, B.Cunnington, S.Gibson, W.Sierakowski
Emg: D.Currie, L.Anthony, L.Hansen
In: W.Sierakowski
Out: L.Anthony (Omitted)
New: W.Sierakowski
Port Adelaide
B: C.Heath, A.Carlile, L.Stevenson
HB: C.O’Shea, T.Jonas, D.Cassisi
C: Bra.Ebert, T.Boak, H.Hartlett
HF: C.Wingard, J.Westhoff, P.Stewart
F: J.Neade, J.Schulz, R.Gray
Foll: M.Lobbe, O.Wines, K.Cornes
Int: B.Renouf, M.Broadbent, A.Monfries, K.Mitchell
Emg: S.Colquhoun, J.Butcher, A.Moore
In: K.Mitchell
Out: J.Trengove (Foot)
Adelaide Crows v Hawthorn
Adelaide
B: B.Rutten, D.Talia, A.Otten
HB: L.Brown, B.Reilly, D.Mackay
C: S.Kerridge, S.Thompson, B.Smith
HF: R.Douglas, S.McKernan, J.Lyons
F: J.Porplyzia, T.Lynch, J.Jenkins
Foll: S.Jacobs, P.Dangerfield, R.Sloane
Int: M.Jaensch, M.Wright, B.Vince, R.Henderson
Emg: R.Tambling, L.Johnston, J.Petrenko
In: J.Porplyzia, S.McKernan, J.Lyons
Out: J.Petrenko (Omitted), T.Walker (Knee), R.Laird (Thigh)
Hawthorn
B: J.Gibson, B.Lake, L.Hodge
HB: G.Birchall, B.Stratton, B.Guerra
C: I.Smith, S.Mitchell, B.Hill
HF: S.Burgoyne, L.Franklin, P.Puopolo
F: L.Breust, J.Roughead, J.Gunston
Foll: M.Bailey, J.Lewis, B.Sewell
Int: L.Shiels, D.Hale, J.Simpkin, M.Osborne
Emg: T.Duryea, K.Cheney, M.Spanghe
In: B.Sewell , J.Simpkin
Out: C.Rioli (Hamstring) , S.Savage (Omitted)
Richmond v Geelong
Richmond
B: S.Morris, A.Rance, T.Chaplin
HB: D.Grimes, R.Petterd, B.Houli
C: C.Newman, T.Cotchin, M.White
HF: B.Deledio, S.Edwards, D.Jackson
F: L.McGuane, J.Riewoldt, T.Vickery
Foll: I.Maric, D.Martin, N.Vlastuin
Int: B.Ellis, J.King, S.Grigg C.Knights
Emg: J.Batchelor, S.Tuck, R.Nahas
In: T.Chaplin, S.Morris, J.King
Out: R.Nahas (Omitted), J.Batchelor (Omitted), B.Helbig (Hamstring)
Geelong
B: A.Mackie, T.Lonergan, C.Enright
HB: J.Corey, H.Taylor, T.Hunt
C: M.Duncan, J.Bartel, S.Motlop
HF: A.Christensen, S.Johnson, B.Smedts
F: P.Chapman, T.Hawkins, J.Podsiadly
Foll: M.Blicavs, J.Selwood, J.Kelly
Int: C.Guthrie, G.Horlin-Smith, T.West, M.Stokes
Emg: M.Brown, J.Murdoch, J.Thurlow
In: P.Chapman, T.Hawkins
Out: J.Rivers (Knee), J.Caddy (Omitted)
Gold Coast Suns v Fremantle
Gold Coast
B: T.McKenzie, T.Murphy, D.Prestia
HB: D.Stanley, R.Thompson, G.Broughton
C: M.Rischitelli, G.Ablett, J.Harbrow
HF: H.Bennell, TJ.Lynch, A.Hall
F: Z.Smith, S.Day, B.Matera
Foll: C.Dixon, K.Hunt, D.Swallow
Int: J.Lonergan, J.O’Meara, J.Brennan, M.Shaw
Emg: D.Gorringe, J.Hutchins, T.Sumner
In: H.Bennell, J.Lonergan
Out: S.May (Hamstring), J.Hutchins (Omitted)
New: J.Lonergan
Fremantle
B: L.Spurr, Z.Dawson, M.Johnson
HB: G.Ibbotson, L.McPharlin, C.Pearce
C: T.Mzungu, R.Crowley, N.Suban
HF: M.Barlow, C.Mayne, H.Ballantyne
F: H.Crozier, J.Hannath, M.Walters
Foll: J.Griffin, D.Mundy, M.De Boer
Int: D.Pearce, P.Duffield, C.Sutcliffe, A.Silvagni
Emg: L.Neale, T.Sheridan, Ta.Smith
In: P.Duffield, A.Silvagni, C.Sutcliffe, H.Crozier
Out: K.Bradley (Knee), S.Hill (Quad), N.Fyfe (Suspension), L.Neale (Omitted)
Sydney v Brisbane
Sydney
B: N.Malceski, H.Grundy, N.Smith
HB: M.Mattner, T.Richards, J.McVeigh
C: L.Jetta, R.O’Keefe, B.McGlynn
HF: D.Hannebery, S.Reid, K.Jack
F: A.Goodes, M.Pyke, J.Bolton
Foll: S.Mumford, J.Kennedy, L.Parker
Int from: T.Armstrong, C.Bird, J.Lamb, M.Morton, D.Rampe, T.Walsh, J.White
In: M.Morton, J.White, J.Lamb, T.Walsh
Out: A.Everitt (Omitted)
New: J.Lamb
Brisbane
B: J.Patfull, D.Merrett, A.McGrath
HB: E.Yeo, J.Clarke, J.Adcock
C: P.Hanley, T.Rockliff, M.Golby
HF: J.Polkinghorne, J.Brown, D.Zorko
F: S.Mayes, M.Leuenberger, A.Cornelius
Foll: B.Longer, B.Moloney, J.Redden
Int from: J.Green, R.Bewick, M.Paparone, J.Lisle, A.Raines, R.Lester, J.Crisp
In: P.Hanley, J.Lisle, R.Lester, J.Crisp
Out: S.Docherty (Omitted)
Carlton v Melbourne
Carlton
B: C.Yarran, M.Jamison, L.Henderson
HB: Z.Tuohy, D.Armfield, S.White
C: K.Lucas, M.Robinson, K.Simpson
HF: C.Judd, A.Walker, J.Garlett
F: E.Curnow, S.Hampson, J.Waite
Foll: R.Warnock, M.Murphy, B.McLean
Int from: H.Scotland, A.Carrazzo, T.Bell, E.Betts, S.Rowe, D.Ellard, J.Cachia
In: J.Waite, D.Ellard, J.Cachia, T.Bell
Out: B.Gibbs (Hamstring)
New: J.Cachia
Melbourne
B: L.Dunn, J.Frawley, D.Terlich
HB: J.Grimes, T.McDonald, C.Garland
C: J.Trengove, J.Viney, M.Jones
HF: J.Howe, C.Sylvia, D.Kent
F: R.Bail, M.Gawn, S.Byrnes
Foll: J.Spencer, J.McKenzie, N.Jones
Int from: S.Blease, J.Strauss, C.Pedersen, D.Nicholson, M.Evans, L.Tapscott, A.Davey
In: L.Dunn, J.Strauss, J.Spencer, J.Viney, D.Kent, D.Nicholson
Out: M.Jamar (Groin), D.Rodan (Omitted), J.Watts (Hamstring)
New: D.Kent
West Coast Eagles v Western Bulldogs
West Coast
B: M.Brown, D.Glass, S.Hurn
HB: B.Waters, E.Mackenzie, S.Wellingham
C: A.Gaff, M.Priddis, B.Dalziell
HF: J.Hill, J.Darling, C.Masten
F: N.Naitanui, JJ.Kennedy, M.LeCras
Foll: D.Cox, S.Selwood, L.Shuey
Int: J.Brennan, A.Hams, D.Kerr, C.Sinclair, M.Rosa, W.Schofield, As.Smith
In: M.Rosa, W.Schofield, S.Wellingham, As.Smith, N.Naitanui
Out: S.Butler (Calf), J.Cripps (Omitted)
Western Bulldogs
B: D.Morris, J.Roughead, L.Picken
HB: J.Johannisen, M.Austin, T.Young
C: J.Macrae, M.Boyd, A.Cooney
HF: J.Stringer, D.Addison, K.Stevens
F: L.Dahlhaus, L.Jones, J.Tutt
Foll: W.Minson, N.Lower, T.Liberatore
Int: M.Wallis, D.Cross, P.Veszpremi, C.Smith, D.Pearce, C.Howard, L.Markovic
In: D.Addison , L.Markovic , C.Howard , D.Pearce
Out: B.Goodes (Suspension)
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
COLLINGWOOD
In: A.Krakouer, D.Jolly, J.Thomas, J.Witts, B.Kennedy
Out: A.Toovey (knee), B.Hudson (leg soreness), J.Russell, A.Fasolo, B.Sinclair
ST KILDA
In: S.Milne, A.Siposs
Out: T.Dennis-Lane, T.Lee (Achilles)
Essendon v Greater Western Sydney
Etihad Stadium, Saturday May 4, 1.45pm
ESSENDON
In: L.Jetta, T.Pears, J.Melksham , N.Kommer
Out: J.Winderlich (rested), T.Colyer, D.Heppell (groin), J.Carlisle (ankle)
GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY
In: S.Gilham, C.Hampton, J.Bruce, T.Adams, J.Townsend, S.Frost, A.Corr
Out: B.Thornton, S.O’hAilpin (calf), P.Davis (back), T.Bugg, L.Whitfield (soreness), L.Plowman, N.Haynes
North Melbourne v Port Adelaide
Blundstone Arena, Saturday May 4, 2.10pm
NORTH MELBOURNE
In: W.Sierakowski
Out: L.Anthony
PORT ADELAIDE
In: K.Mitchell
Out: J.Trengove (foot)
Adelaide v Hawthorn
AAMI Stadium, Saturday May 4, 4.10pm
ADELAIDE
In: J.Porplyzia, S.McKernan, J.Lyons ?
Out: J.Petrenko, T.Walker (knee), R.Laird (thigh) ?
HAWTHORN
In: B.Sewell, J.Simpkin
Out: C.Rioli (hamstring), S.Savage
Richmond v Geelong
MCG, Saturday May 4, 7.40pm
RICHMOND
In: T.Chaplin, S.Morris, J.King
Out: R.Nahas, J.Batchelor, B.Helbig (hamstring)
GEELONG
In: P.Chapman, T.Hawkins
Out: J.Rivers (knee), J.Caddy
Gold Coast v Fremantle
Metricon Stadium, Saturday May 4, 7.40pm
GOLD COAST
In: H.Bennell , J.Lonergan
Out: S.May (hamstring) , J.Hutchins
FREMANTLE
In: P.Duffield , A.Silvagni , C.Sutcliffe , H.Crozier
Out: K.Bradley (knee) , S.Hill (quad) , N.Fyfe (suspension) , L.Neale
Sydney Swans v Brisbane Lions
SCG, Sunday May 5, 1.10pm
SYDNEY SWANS
In: M.Morton, J.White, J.Lamb, T.Walsh
Out: A.Everittt
BRISBANE LIONS
In: P.Hanley, J.Lisle, R.Lester, J.Crisp
Out: S.Docherty
Carlton v Melbourne
MCG, Sunday May 5, 3.20pm
CARLTON
In: J.Waite, D.Ellard, J.Cachia, T.Bell
Out: B.Gibbs (hamstring)
New: J.Cachia
MELBOURNE
In: L.Dunn, J.Strauss, J.Spencer, J.Viney, D.Kent, D.Nicholson
Out: M.Jamar (groin), D.Rodan, J.Watts (hamstring)
West Coast v Western Bulldogs
Patersons Stadium, Sunday May 5, 4.40pm
WEST COAST
In: M.Rosa, W.Schofield, S.Wellingham, As.Smith, N.Naitanui
Out: S.Butler (calf), J.Cripps
WESTERN BULLDOGS
In: D.Addison, L.Markovic, C.Howard, D.Pearce
Out: B.Goodes (suspension)
haha well thats about a nail in the coffin for me. no good news for me!
Holy shite, Dochtery, Winderlinch, heppell,Laird and even Hutchins all out, man there are going to be some donuts this round…
I give up
Viney’s the only good news out of that lot!
FML!
Saunders JS ????
Goodes, Gibbs. Heppell, Pittard all out, will have 2 dougnuts in DEF.
My trades were Hoff – Stevie J, Blicavs – Gawn.
Now i’m thinkin I should trade Gibbs – Shaw/Duffield/Scotland and Blicavs – Gawn.
I do have the Cash to go Gibbs – Birchall, but I want to use that for the future. What do I do?!?! Please help..
Wow what a massacre !! Bye rounds have come early !
IF i was to trade Gibbs… Whose my best option? I already have Goddard, Birchall and Heppell! Anyone?? Hartlett maybe??
Gibbs to Dixon or Hartlett? Dixon gives me cash in the bank, Hartlett leaves very little!
Get off the weed, Big Sexy, they’re last weeks lineups 😉
Anyone else notice the teams are from last round?
Stevenson too
NOOOOOOO
Went:
Pittard>Shaw
Danger>Hartlett and swapped him and Gibbs to save the donut
Only have 10K left, painful. Knowing how this week is going, I’ll get some subs on top of this.
Brought Dwyer into the mids. Traded Dwyer for Hartlett and then swapped him with Heppell. Thats one sorted
Shaw in for Gibbs. Thats two sorted
Another trade please..
Ended up ok for me. Have gotten Stevie J in and have managed no donuts with kommer named. SO even if he gets the vest, will still got some points.
What do you do if you have Gibbs, Heppell, goods, pittard and Hutchison??????
Looks like i’ll get away with it
Bench Gibbs and Goodes, Trade Pittard for Shaw.
Thank GOD I moved Goodes to the MID a few weeks ago … only 2 outs in the DEF (Gibbs & Pittard) … SAVED (well, so far).
Heppell out hurts. Had a feeling atleast one of heppell goddard and watson might be rested. Was going to trade out dwyer for gawn. But i really have no choice, i probably have to drop goodes (along with walker) if i still want to upgrade to a top mid. Goodes has been really good, and still lots if room to grow, but two weeks out gives me a little more reason to cash him in.
Going to pick up vlastuin, along with either of these prem mids. Which should i get?
T/u watson
T/d cotchin
All good for me. Got cover on my backline and can now upgrade to Stevie J and improve my forward line. Fingers crossed whoever I am playing this week has a donut or two! 😉
Blicavs to Gawn
Wanted to do Dwyer to Stevie J
but ended up doing Goodes to Harlett – thought goodes still had a good 100K left in him.
going to have one donut..
return of Nic Nat???! good to see.
I wonder if there is anyone with the following backline!?
Gibbs, Heppell, Watts, Goodes, Pittard, Hutchins, Docherty, Laird
Survived this sort of.
Wanted to trade Cyril this week, but looks like I have to hold fire for another week and rely on Neade Score as replacement. So Stevie J for the good of my team you are next week.
In Gawn out Bilcav
In Heater Shaw out Pittard
Goodes Heppell occupy the pine, thank god I did not have Gibbs and went Hartlett instead.
A lot of people at the start complained about 30 trades making the game too easy, and i agree in theory…but this is why they did it
I have escaped the dreaded backline donuts by selling Blicavs, moving Goodes to the mids and buying Vlastuin for defence.
During the week I did a tentative trade selling Hawkins and buying Stevie J. Now that Hawkins has been named to play I’m not sure. I have been bleeding trades like a haemophiliac at a cut-throat shaving contest, but I think I will keep it.
T/u Stevie J will kill it in his 200th
T/d keep your trades.
I’m only 600 off the leader so want to make a move and not cop a donut like people above me on the ranks might get. So going:
Blicavs -> Gawn
Goodes -> Scotland
Scotland has dream run coming up, he is a POD and he has always been reliable in the past and will look to redeem himself after missing first few games. Age is a worry but no guts no glory and he was going to come in at sometime this year.
Thumbs up or down will help my choice. Thanks.
Just avoided no doughnuts
Went
Gibbs -Dixon
Pittard- Vlastuin
Hopefully vlast keeps his JS he ripped up nab
Like most people my backlines in a bit of strife this week.
Don’t quite have enough cash to upgrade Pittard to a premium and am holding off trading Goodes yet.
And with Laird and Docherty not named my only two options are:
Pittard to Wright (St. K) who would be averaging 59 if it wasn’t for the week he was sub (T/U)
OR
Keep Pittard and take a donut this week (T/D)
I have a Dilemma; Your help will be much appreciated!
T/U: Cop 2 donuts and 1 possible vest, knowing I can still win as I’m playing a team that averages 1300 a week (how?!)
T/D: Make 2 trades, for the sake of the ranking and score
Sigh… I give up, I couldn’t be a head coach…too stressfull
These AFL coaches clearly have other people in their supercoach team than most of us.
Liking that Vlastuin is named as a follower and think hes a definite downgrade option this week.
scotland names on bench.. any worry?
Just saw the teams wow!
my outs:
Pittard
Goodes
Gibbs
Heppel
Hutchins
Fyfe
Crouch
Anybody else feel a little hard done by seeing K.Mitchell back?
Keep changing my mind but here goes:
Viney out for B.Goodes switch to the mid bench. This way I keep him without potentially scoring a doughnut in the backline.
Upgrade to Dixon in DEF.
A.Goodes -> Kerridge.
A.Goodes not doing much more than 80pts per game and possibly past his prime now. Dixon has been a standout so far this year and will hopefully continue his good work for the Suns.
Too many choices.
is this nuts?
trade danger to vlaustin and pittard for shaw
covers 0’s and opens def mid change up also cash up to $246000 in bank
effectivly swapping danger to shaw and pittard to vlaustin…
Does anyone know much about Sierakowski? What’s his JS like, is the most likely vest candidate? I know it’s hard to tell for a guy who hasn’t played a game yet but I’m not sold on any of the downgrade options in defence this week. Don’t know if Valastuin is worth the extra 50k and if I go Pittard to Vlastuin I may not have the cash for the Gablett upgrade next week.
done!!!
Fyfe downgrade to Sounders
Goodes to mid, Sounders to def
Pittard uprgrade to Shaw
conclusion : Fyfe & Pittard out, Gibbs & Heppel SAFE!
Best backline premium right now?
I can afford anyone and already have Goddard and Hartlett
Well what a crazy round!!
Heppell out
Gibbs out
Goodes out
Pittard out
I think Goodes, Heppell and Gibbs will be in the top 10 defenders so I’m going to keep them and take a 0.
Pittard is out for Ashley McGrath.
i have the 4 usual outs listed above too. toying with the idea of trading danger for heath shaw by moving goodes to my midfield.
hate to trade a premium but this will save one donut, ill dump danger before losing more cash and get shaw as he bottoms out.
thoughts??
Ok boys, shaw or dixon?
Shaw: Thumbs up
Dixon: Thumbs down
any cheap defenders?
Just the 1 donut for me
Gibbs – Birchall seem necessary?
Probly going to upgrade Pittard – Gibbs in a few rounds anway.
Gibbs has a BE of 130. Could drop to 460k odd.
I have heppell Pittard goodes and Gibbs! What to do?
Taken from CFC Facebook post 2 hours ago
“Out at this stage is Bryce Gibbs, who suffered hamstring tightness in last Sunday’s match against Adelaide, with the 22 to be finalised tomorrow afternoon”
A late inclusion? Probably more wishful thinking than anything…
Can’t decide between –
Up: Dixon $477K, Av 115
Down: Shaw: $484K, Av 90
Figures tell me Dixon, cheaper & better average, but Shaw a proven performer over the years whereas Dixon a relative newcomer to higher scores. Thoughts?
Thoughts on Michael Hibberd?
Everyone appears to be getting H Shaw, but for 470K I think Hibberd is a bargain!
I can afford Birchall (just), but would like to save some money for Viney>Priddis next week. I guess he’ll just have to wait 🙂
1 definite zero for Boom Town this week, short term pain for long term gain!!!! Gonna go swan as VC. I recon he’s gonna go 150 plus and cover my dougnut! He’s a big game player!!
775,000 for 2 players one defender, one forward
was originally planning – H. Shaw & Winderlich but winderlich is out and ideas??
Out blicavs , Goodes . In Gawn Vlastuin . , pocket 250k for a premium upgrade next week?
Turns out my only playing defenders are Goddard and O’Shea and Terlich….. great…
Dixon is he worth putting in my team will he drop?
No donuts this week so am thinking of:
Blicavs => Gawn
Dangerfield => Swan
Will leave 21 trades left
Thumbs Up: Do it
Thumbs Down: I’ve used too many trades
so i had pittard gibbs hepps and goodes and fyfe missing in the mids as well as evans on extended bench……bugger…..
so i traded pittard for vlastuin
and dwyer for h shaw swapping goodes into the mids.
leaving me with only evans sub score if he plays….
#cantwaitforthisweektobeover #round6byeround
if you have any better suggestions be my guest. im not really worried about winning/losing games. my team is 49th, rank is all im concerned about
Survived most of the carnage thus far. Pittard >> Dixon to save a donut, and a luxury downgrade of Blitzer >> Gaaawwwnnn
Thoughts running through my head tonight:
It’s looking at this stage like I’ll be trading Goodes and one of Pittard/Hutchins, sparing Gibbs.
1. Goodes & Pittard > H.Shaw & Rookie other than Vlastuin
2. Goodes & Pittard > Enright & Vlastuin
4. Goodes & Hutchins > Enright & Rookie other than Vlastuin
Anyone with me on any of these alternatives?
Concerns:
– Is Vlastuin worth the extra coin ($50k less cash generation)?
– JS and scoring potential on DEF rookies appears very low.
– Worth getting one of the cheaper rookies to afford H.Shaw (the original plan)?
– Can Enright return to his historic average to warrant a keeper for the season?
Community DESPERATE HELP REQUIRED. Back: Gibbs, Pittard, Plowman OUT. Mids: Whitfield, Fyfe, Goodes OUT. WHAT THE HELL DO I DO???? I have 23 trades left and $370k in kitty. Need to use 2 trades to be competetive but who for who?? HELP PLEASE!
whose the best option for pittard out of enright, harry taylor, pearce hanley, c dixon ?
I have already used the reverse trade button about 20 times!
I’m thinking either…
TU/ Crouch and Gibbs out for Ablett and Vlaustin (or another DEF rookie?)
TD/ Blicavs and Pittard out for Gawwn and Shaw
I Have Viney in my mids to cover any donuts, but need to do atleast one backline trade to avoid a donut, and I am planning on hanging onto Goodes.
Thoughts?
Gibbs out, Shaw in?
Heppell, Gibbs, Goodes, PIttard and Hutchison all out in the backline, should I trade Gibbs as he is no certain to return in the next week or two?
How it this
Out
Colquhoun & Pittard
IN
Vlastuin & Shaw
means I can keep Gibbs & Heppell and save a possible doughnut.
Who’s this player “donut” I’m hearing so much about over the last 24 hours 😉
have gibbs, goodes and hepppell out- gonna stick to my original plan of blicavs to gawn and an up grade of brown or dwyer. i figure upgrading these guys to a premo will almost cover the donut anyway, and then i don’ have to sideways trade….. question is which one and to who? leaning towards brown as dwyer playing weaker opposition this week…..
brown (thumbs up)
dwyer (thumbs down)
Not happy about heppell
Okay didnt want to use trades this week but its going to happen. So going Fyfe to JPKennedy
Would like some advice on trade 2:
T/U Do i go Gibbs to Dixon
T/D Do i give up on Hutchins and trade to Vlastuin
Either option will make about same amount of cash on the difference.
Anyone looking at Beau Waters as a defensive trade this week?
Birchall or Dixon
Hows this: Plowman and Whitfield OUT, move Blicavs to mid, bring in Gawn and any defender I like: Birchall, Hartlett, Hibberd
TU Good
TB Crapola