Trade Or Hold – Rd22

Written by Schwarzwalder on August 16 2018

At the time of writing, there were still question marks hovering over the following two guys………….

Michael Walters looked to be in trouble when he seemed to pull a hammy against the Blues in the last five mins of the game.ย  Scans have revealed that there is no tear and are treating it as a lower back injury.ย  Will he make the trip to Geelong this week?

Josh Kelly was caught by Tex Walker in a sling tackle and has had concussion problems during the week.ย  It’s still unclear whether he’ll line up on the weekend.ย  Would the Giants risk him this close to Finals?

It’s a do-or-die clash this week in the Prelim Finals of SuperCoach………what would you recommend with these two popular players?


What to do with Michael Walters (FRE)?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...



What to do with Josh Kelly (GWS)?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

4 thoughts on “Trade Or Hold – Rd22”

  1. You forgot to say ‘ Assuming you’ve got trades left !’
    If I had trades left(which I don’t) I would trade both.
    Sonny-has a habit of being out for 3-4 and comes back in 1, doesn’t generally blow it away until the week after.
    Kelly- Only Robbie Gray has played well the following week after being knocked out, most like Merrett, Martin and Andrews took anywhere up to 6 weeks to come good.


  2. Is Kelly to Menegola smart??? Means Dusty goes on field with coniglio and Menegola can swing forward pushing Westhoff to bench loophole



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *