195 thoughts on “Trade Talk II – Round 9”

  1. Better trade:
    TU: Daicos > Petracca/Walsh
    TD: Martin > Oliver
    Dont have the funds to go daicos too oliver unfortunately

    9

    31
  2. Steele > Macrae
    MacDonald > Clark

    TU – Use 4th trade boost (20 trades remaining) to upgrade Whitfield
    TD – Keep Whitfield (21 trades left, 2 boosts)

    27

    30
  3. Getting Laird and brother it feels fantastic.

    As for the downgrade to make it happen; Gibcus to

    T/U: Khamis
    T/D: Thompson

    52

    20
  4. Holding Cogs and Butters till I get all rookies off field, so who goes first

    TU – Daicos
    TD – Martin

    40

    31
    1. I’m in the same predicament, but leaning towards Martin going first since he has the R12 bye and Daicos has R14. Whichever one doesn’t go this week will be there until their bye for me, and this arrangement suits my bye structure better

      15

      0
  5. This got a very mixed thumbs reaction so putting it up here again with context.

    Martin > Clark
    Gibcus > Sicily

    Martin is M8 for me as of now, I have 3 MID rookies on the bench. My D4 is Daicos, the DEF line needs bolstering.

    Also, Martin and Gibcus are both Rd 12 byes – I need to prepare for my byes and Rd 12 needs the most love.

    25

    13
    1. Again, seems the reaction is very mixed lol. Curious to hear people’s thoughts. I don’t think I have anyone else to downgrade for Clark. Am I overestimating how good of a pick-up he would be? Is Sicily not the guy?

      5

      4
      1. I’m really thinking whether Clark is a must now with Steele an unexpected trade. I’m pretty happy with current rookies, but will look to trade Cogs and Hayes by r12. Clark is suddenly not as important, though a round 14 upgrade via Daicos looks inviting.

        3

        10
    2. @Jov – g’day!!

      Not sure why so many thumbs down (maybe some people read your post incorrectly thinking you were asking for a thumbs up or thumbs down on your two trades???), but those two trades look good to me.

      Nick Martin has been an awesome rookie. A good case could be made to keeping him as he is consistent & a couple of years older than most rooks – but he did play a bit forward on the weekend?

      And IMO he definitely plays his best footy as a wing / midfielder – not as a forward.

      Clark should be a great SC rookie, so in theory he can be your M8 for a while – he is mature aged, tackles hard, and wins a heap of contested footy (plus he was a sensational leader in the WAFL).

      And whilst Gibcus is getting better & better, Sicily is absolutely on fire & will be a top 6 DEF – plus champion data seem to also love him (which definitely helps) 🙂 🙂

      12

      6
      1. Hi Brett any chance you could call Truck and let him know that Martin is not a FWd.
        Much obliged

        17

        0
        1. @ Bomber – sorry, but might struggle with trying to persuade Truck to play Nick Martin in the MIDS

          Used to have some favour with the previous coach – but not this one 🙁 🙁

          4

          3
        2. I commented on exactly this point elsewhere. I also said I could coach bombers for lots less than Truck !!

          4

          5
  6. Hey lads, legit .2k off getting laird so is Sam Walsh the next best option to replace steele ?

    Already have mcrae, neale, cripps, touk, petraca & Rowell

    Walsh doesn’t really suit my byes but may have to bite the bullet

    24

    7
  7. Steele > Laird
    Cogs > Clark
    Daicos > Docherty
    360k itb for upgrades to premos (SDK > Stewart & N.Martin > Dusty/Parker)

    TU – Use last trade boost (16 trades remaining) to upgrade Daicos
    TD – Keep Daicos (17 trades left, 1 boost)

    23

    1
  8. Steele + JHF > Laird + Clark
    Leaves $424k in the bank + 18 trades, so do I..

    TU: Use boost Dixon > Premo ruck (Either Witts or Gawn most likely) get Hayes off the field.
    TD: Give it a week to save the boost.

    11

    11
    1. Gawn going down $75k over two weeks, and looks to be being nursed…..and why not. Gonna be real cheap after R14 I reckon.

      9

      4
      1. Max Gawn
        Rd 9 Price $669k
        Rd 9 BE 140

        Rd 9 Score 73
        R9:$669k->$640k ($-30k)
        Rd 10 BE 221

        Projected Score 115
        Rd 10:->$592k ($-47k)New BE 162
        Rd 11:->$571k ($-21k)New BE 109
        Rd 12:->$574k ($3k)New BE 112

        15

        0
  9. Out = Steele, Butternut* & Sinn
    In = Laird, Doc & Clarke

    TU
    TD
    * not convinced Butters roll will change for the better long term & feel his score was more a reflection of playing Nth than anything .

    210k ITB for Oliver next week trade.

    Cheers All !

    5

    7
  10. Thoughts on Brad Crouch in the midfield? Averaging 103 with 140 last week. Only one poor week (Cairns). No Jack Steele meaning he’ll be getting more of the ball

    17

    11
    1. He is a fine option mate, however you will be buying him saying you believe he is going to be top 8 mids. I think he will be lucky to be top 16 tbh. I think the top 8 all averaged over 115 last year. So we just gotta pay up for our premo mids this year!

      11

      0
      1. I agree Damo.

        If your super flush with trades he may work as a stop gap for 6 weeks while Steele is out. You won’t want him in your team after that. Most good teams will have a Petracca or Brayshaw at M8 by years end. Crouch will cost you wins if you’re forced to keep him long term.

        4

        0
        1. He’s kicked at 53 per cent efficiency or lower in six matches this year. His overall kicking efficiency of 51.7 per cent is the worst of top 20 ball winners in the competition.

          3

          0
    2. You can excuse that poor week in Cairns..it was super hot, humid, steamy, wet & greasy weather! (as usual for the Tropics)

      4

      0
  11. Gidday all,
    I am suggesting its a hold on all GWS trades until we see what the new coach does. Just maybe he plays then in their correct positions as he needs wins to boost his coaching future.

    10

    3
  12. Gidday all,
    I am suggesting its a hold on all GWS trades until we see what the new coach does. Just maybe he plays then in their correct positions as he needs wins to boost his coaching future.

    10

    4
  13. do i go cogs> laird via dpp and ward>clark
    r13 bye would look very sketchy
    my team would look like this:

    def: short, hewett, zorko, dawson, sinclair, mccartin (de koning, thompson)
    mid: neale, mills, oliver, laird, miller, macrae, cripps, brayshaw (mccomb, hough, clark)
    ruc: witts, preuss (hayes)
    fwd: dunkley, heeney, brodie, de goey, butters, n martin (rosas, hamilton)

    2

    2
    1. Not ideal… but also not terrible. Preuss will max out right around the same time Gawn bottoms out. You may in fact even make money.

      If you think Preuss is a keeper, then he’s still cheap. His injury risk is no better/worse than Witts or Darcy.

      5

      2
  14. Need to trade Steele
    Tu Sicily
    Td Walsh
    Both suit byes for me
    Comment Wines POD or Petracca

    8

    19
  15. Should I do my last back upgrade
    Tu) Pendlebury
    Td) Doherty
    Comment – Zorko
    Or
    Or my last Fwd line upgrade
    Liberachi ??

    2

    15
  16. Hard to split this, communities thoughts?

    Tu) SDK & N. Martin/Cogs -> Clark and Laird
    Daicos on bench as bye cover, Clark M8

    Td) McComb & N. Martin/Cogs -> Clark & Brayshaw
    Daicos & Clark looped at M8 this week.

    14

    4
  17. OUT: Steele, Cogs and B Hough (been stuck with him for yonkd due to injury trades)

    TU: Doc, Laird, Clark
    TD: Dusty, Dawson, Clark

    Comment: Other suggestions?

    21

    1
  18. My other trade scenario:

    Out: Steele, Rowell, NOD
    In: laird, Sicily, Clarke

    Completes my Backline, have Daicos and Dekoning stuck on my def bench. Clarke becomes my M8 for just this week. N Martin at F6 my other rookie. Next week Daicos to any bubble defender then Durdin into a 550K Mid.

    So Cognilio survives the chop. History shows he is inconsistent and averages low 90’s to low 100’s.

    6

    2
  19. TU: martin>laird
    TD:mcdonald>B smith(should get forward dpp in two weeks)

    If I trade out Martin I am left with Rosas on field, if I trade out mcdonald obviously I have Martin on field.

    4

    9
  20. Gibcus > Khamis… along with;

    Tu;
    De Koning > Hewett
    Coniglio > Laird

    Td;
    Coniglio > Hewett
    Jack Hayes > Witts
    (Currently Gawn r1 & Sam Hayes r2)

    3

    19
  21. If you had neither in your team, to replace Steele :
    TU: Brayshaw
    TD: Petracca

    Average & breakeven both about the same. Brayshaw 20K cheaper, but comes with the WA Covid risk. Both capable of going BIG, and both capable of games below 100. Only one spot remaining in my mids.

    5

    17
    1. I think Bont and Bailey smith are on track right now, however, don’t know if that will remain in the next couple weeks.

      There is an article on the herald sun website I’m pretty sure, however I am not subscribed, so cant tell you who else.

      4

      0
    2. The magic number is 35%
      Marcus Bontempelli – Time in Position Midfield 63%, Forward 37%
      Max Gawn – Time in Position Ruck 72%, Forward 28%
      Rowan Marshall – Time in Position Ruck 70%, Forward 30%
      Robbie McComb – Time in Position Midfield 43%, Forward 57%
      Jayden Short – Time in Position Defence 65%, Midfield 23%, Forward 3%
      Darcy Cameron – Time in Position Ruck 46%, Forward 54%
      Bailey Smith – Time in Position Midfield 63%, Forward 37%
      Ben Hobbs — Time in Position Midfield 28%, Forward 72%
      Tom Mitchell – Time in Position Midfield 74%, Forward 26%
      Connor Rozee – Time in Position Midfield 49%, Forward 51%
      Patrick Dangerfield – Time in Position Midfield 78% Forward 22%

      11

      0
      1. Might be worth adding to the CBA and kick in article for next week, assuming it’s not too arduous of course.

        2

        0
  22. Thoughts on:

    OUT:
    Steele
    Cogs
    H. Dixon
    (Still have Daicos, Bowey, JHF)

    IN:
    Mills
    Sicily
    Greg Clark

    Leaves me 220k itb for English next week hopefully

    13

    0
  23. out: Steele, JHF & Daicos
    In: Laird, Dawson & Clark
    19 trades left – 2 boosts

    tu – yes
    td – no

    19

    0
  24. Currently my side is looking like
    B: Short, Crisp, Hewett, Ridley, Daicos, Bench- De Koning, Dean

    M: Neale, Mills, Oliver, Macrae, Cripps, Dunkley, Steele, Rowell, Bench-McComb, Hamilton, Clark

    R: Gawn, Preuss, bench-Hayes

    F: Parker, Brodie, Cogs, Butters, N Martin, M Rioli Bench- Rosas Curtis

    W/$474.9k in the bank 21 trades and 1 boost

    Need to replace Steele so contemplating
    Tu-Touk
    or
    Td- Laird
    Any other trade suggestions I can make please reply

    7

    2
    1. Steele to Miller, Martin to Laird (via Dunkley switch), then possibly Rosas to Khamis/Thompson (via SDK switch), bringing Rioli off your field

      4

      0
    1. Max Gawn – Time in Position Ruck 72%, Forward 28%.

      He would have to spend a large amount of time in the forward line in his next two games to get to 35%.

      Looking unlikey.

      1

      0
      1. G’day CT. Out of interest, where do you find these stats on %age playing time split between positions??

        2

        0
  25. Hey coaches, I’m thinking of bringing McGovern into my defence this week.
    I currently have : Crispy, Hewett, Zorko and Ryan as premiums, McCartin would be my D6. I can afford any other premo except Stewart. McGov would leave me 115K for future trades…but concerned about continued H/S protocols affecting WC. If I get Sicily I’m left with 17k. Dawson is another in great form…

    T/U: McGov and 115K itb
    T/D: Sicily and 17k itb
    comment: Dawson and 78k itb

    2

    14
  26. Tu;
    Stephens > Laird

    Td;
    Cogs > Hewett
    Jack Hayes > Witts
    (This will mean I use my final trade boost)

    6

    4
    1. Any better way to use your cash to do 2 upgrades rather than an expensive upgrade from Stephens to Laird?

      0

      0
      1. I am already downgrading gibcus to Khamis. That’s my first trade. Deciding on the following…

        0

        0
        1. Ah ok, well aside from that if money allows it, you should try trade a 300k+ rookie to a premo (or possibly 2 rookies to 2 premos with a trade boost).

          Personally I feel that’s better use of the 430k youd need to go from Stephens to Laird, that should allow you to get two 550k premos onfield that avg 105+ rather than one 120 avg + one 50 avg rookie

          0

          0
          1. Appreciate the input mate. I understand what you are saying and I feel like hewett is a great piece at the moment. I want to try and get the best players obviously in each line, I feel as though laird will average more than someone like a Brayshaw who is well priced. I would rather wait a week and get the better premium if that makes sense. Cheers!

            2

            0
  27. JHF to Clark is locked in, then:

    TU: Stephens & Martin to Khamis (via DPP) & Laird
    (Results in Daicos D6, Smith M8, McCartin F6)

    TD: Daicos & Martin to McGovern & Cameron
    (Results in McGovern D6, Clark M8, Cameron F6)

    5

    0
  28. Who is likely to pick up DPP fwd status that could finish top 6 for the remainder of the season?

    0

    0
    1. I haven’t read the Hun article, but I believe Baz is very close, Bont & Boak are maybes, and Gawn is an outside chance if he spends bulk time forward for the next two weeks. If all get DPP, the top forwards probably look something like:

      1. Gawn
      2. English
      3. Bont
      4. Dunks
      5. Boak
      6. Baz
      7. Parker
      8. Libba
      9. Heeney
      10+. Treloar, Brodie, Martin, Goldstein
      …daylight…
      Cogs

      4

      0
      1. Thanks CA, I’m thinking Baz now (low BE) then Boak after that low score washes through his price (maybe even if he doesn’t snag DPP). I’ve also carried English on the bench.

        0

        0
        1. I think if you can get Baz now, you’ll be way ahead of the pack come round 12, when everyone else is paying $580k for him. He has West Coast in two weeks and could peak right after his bye.

          The risk is obviously if he plays pure mid for the next two weeks and misses out on DPP. We could easily get Bevo’d.

          The other problem is squeezing another Dog into our teams.

          1

          0
  29. TU: Gibcus, Steele, Cogs out for Dawson, Tracca, Clark +137k
    TD: Gibcus, NOD, Steele out for Buku, Dawson, Clark+455k

    2

    6
      1. If you can, try to hold McCartin for at least 1 more week with a low break even of 13.

        He should go up by around $25,000 this week.

        Personally I think you should get rid of NOD & Steele & Gibcus (rather than Cogs) – but can you bring in Dawson, Petracca & Clark if you get rid of those three players?

        5

        0
        1. Unfortunately not Brett, that would be ideal but im 6k short. Not many other options below Tracca worth bringing in, unless I trade Daicos ahead of Gibcus, I can then afford Trac.

          0

          0
  30. Have held Whitfield this far to my teams demise. Is there any hope with the new coach or is he destined to keep falling?

    TU theres hope. hold him to the bye
    TD He’s absolutely done – use the trade

    6

    7
    1. His bye is R12. Not really worth sideways trading R12 premium players at their bye as you only get 2 scores out of the traded in player over the byes. Therefore trade now if you are going to trade him I reckon. Or hold till after the byes and pray.

      2

      1
  31. Never had a round with as many trade-options as this.

    Latest proposal.

    Martin, Rowell, Daicos -> Brayshaw, Laird & Clark.

    Zorko D6, (only “rookie on-field” Clark M8, Preuss R2, Cogs & Butters still in Fwd-line.
    16 trades & no boosts left.

    4

    0
    1. Yep – there is some hard calls coming with blokes like Nick Martin, Nick Daicos, McCartin, Preuss, Rowell, Cogs, Butters etc

      Do we try and keep some of them for long term cover – or do we use the cash they have made to upgrade them (excluding Butters of course as his price has gone backwards).

      If that is Fremantle’s Brayshaw, then I like those trades 🙂

      But I prefer Petracca over Brayshaw (at pretty much the same price) if you don’t already have him.

      2

      0
      1. Cheers Brett, yep Andy Brayshaw.

        Interesting to see the Andy vs Tracca debate this last week. I’m personally onboard the Andy train but both solid picks.

        Solid points with the names re – keeper discussion. Really comes down to how many trades left for coaches and how cash-gen is looking.

        1

        0
  32. I think many Supercoaches fears have unfortunately come to fruition this season, seems that the extra trades and trade boosts has made it too easy for everyone to (a) get to full premo very quickly, and (b) sides becoming very similar.

    Supercoach will always be enjoyable for mine, but I’m hoping some readjustments are made next year post covid.

    I think other changes are necessary as well such as kick-ins having reduced scoring.

    Does anyone else agree? And if so what potentially changes do you think would make the game a little more interesting?

    11

    2
    1. 100% agree. The days of relying on Daicos to be a D6, Rowell M8 for example are long gone.

      Reducing trades and trade boosts both need to go IMO.

      Kick-ins are out of the control of SC, and in the hands of Champion Data, no dramas with that.

      4

      0
      1. I do think the DPP changes are good, perhaps teams will start to feel different if Bont, Gawn, Smith etc gain DPP, “if” they happen which looks unlikely.

        2

        0
    2. Agreed. Been a little demoralising since the start of the season for me when every league matchup I was in only had 6-7 unique players.

      4

      0
    3. I agree teams are currently looking very similar but have enjoyed the extra trades and DPP changes.

      I was completely over SC and how subjective the scoring was last year and contemplated not playing in 2022 after playing for 10+ years. But those changes have brought some enjoyment back and got me back into it.

      Reckon teams will start to see more variety after the byes and towards the back of the year with some burning their boosts while others have saved them.

      Agree also about kick-ins. Never understood why they score so much.

      5

      0
    4. I want to see the VC gone. Will open up scoring a lot I think and make people gamble more.

      7

      6
  33. Bigger priority to trade out:

    TU – Luke Ryan

    TD – Nick Daicos

    If you take out Ryan’s outlier 157 game, Daicos has been scoring better this season + still may have money to make whereas Ryan is bleeding cash every week, seems to also be nursing an injury. He’s also a POD so it hurts me much more if he scores poorly.

    13

    0
  34. OUT: Gibcus, Martin, Daicos
    IN: Docherty, Clark, Thompson/Khamis(?)

    Sicily, Short, Crisp, Doc, Hewett, Chapman (SDK, Thompson/Khamis)
    Neale, Oliver, Miller, Macrae, Cripps, Keays, Brayshaw, Clark (McComb, Carroll, Rioli)
    Witts, Preuss (Hayes)
    Dunkley, Heeney, Moore, Brodie, Cogs, Butters (McCartin, Rosas)

    $360k in the bank, 15 trades left.

    Considering my next few trades (order subject to BEs):
    Hayes to a ruck/fwd $102k loophole (plus $200k)
    McCartin to English (minus $250k)
    McComb to a fwd/def $102k loophole (plus $150k)
    Chapman to Stewart (minus $170k)
    Preuss to Gawn (minus $100k)
    $190k to turn Cogs or Butters into a premo mid

    Leaving me with 9 trades and the following team:

    Sicily, Stewart, Short, Crisp, Doc, Hewett (SDK, Thompson)
    Neale, Oliver, Miller, Macrae, Cripps, Keays, Brayshaw, XXXXX (Carroll, Rioli, mid/def)
    Gawn, Witts (ruck/fwd)
    Dunkley, Heeney, English, Moore, Brodie, Cogs/Butters (Rosas, fwd/def)

    Means I can use SDK to cover an out on any line through DPP manipulations.

    1

    0
  35. OUT: Gibcus, Martin, Daicos
    IN: Docherty, Clark, Thompson/Khamis(?)

    Sicily, Short, Crisp, Doc, Hewett, Chapman (SDK, Thompson)
    Neale, Oliver, Miller, Macrae, Cripps, Keays, Brayshaw, Clark (McComb, Carroll, Rioli)
    Witts, Preuss (Hayes)
    Dunkley, Heeney, Moore, Brodie, Cogs, Butters (McCartin, Rosas)

    $365k in the bank, 15 trades left.

    Considering my next few trades (order subject to BEs):
    Hayes to a ruck/fwd $102k loophole (plus $200k)
    McCartin to English (minus $250k)
    McComb to a fwd/def $102k loophole (plus $150k)
    Chapman to Stewart (minus $170k)
    Preuss to Gawn (minus $100k)
    $195k to turn Cogs or Butters into a premo mid

    Leaving me with 9 trades and the following team:

    Sicily, Stewart, Short, Crisp, Doc, Hewett (SDK, Thompson)
    Neale, Oliver, Miller, Macrae, Cripps, Keays, Brayshaw, XXXXX (Clark, Carroll, Rioli)
    Gawn, Witts (ruck/fwd)
    Dunkley, Heeney, English, Moore, Brodie, [Cogs/Butters] (Rosas, fwd/def)

    Means I can use SDK to cover an out on any line through DPP manipulations.

    5

    0
  36. Is anyone keeping track of who has had Covid in recent months (& thus less likely to fall victim anytime soon)? It may become as significant a factor as proneness to injury. Note that even Crisp may miss this week.

    0

    0
    1. Hi Tryhard,
      Crisp most likely has the flu as does Steele Sidebottom.

      I am unaware of any data base that has the information about players who have had covid.
      Except the Government health department and they would never break confidentiality.

      The AFL always refer to “cases” as Health and Safety Protocols. I guess maintaining confidentiality.
      Pre -season there was little information from clubs. I guess someone could go through season injury reports to collate a list but it would be incomplete and of little value. IMO.

      Having covid previously doesn’t preclude the chance of another infection. (different variables)

      1

      0
  37. Steel out.
    TU -Sic, finishes backline. Lloyd my worst defender.
    TD- bont, due to go on a hot run soon underpriced and of course possible DPP. Leaving a spot for another uber mid.

    8

    7
  38. What is the best option for Hugh Dixon? I have him as my R3 and have no ruck in my forward line.

    0

    0
  39. Can anyone please point out where we can obtain stats regarding a player’s field position coverage percentage? E.g Bailey Smith might be playing 65% mid, 35% fwd – where do I find that sort of info out?
    Chaos Theory I’m looking at you!

    4

    0
    1. It was just in the Herald Sun article but as someone who doesn’t pay, you can find it on Twitter which is where all the most up to date SuperCoach information gets shared. Definitely game changingly helpful being on there for data.

      2

      0
  40. Hey guys,
    what is Zorkos role at the lions over the past couple rounds? Have missed their games the past couple of weeks, however, Zorko has 3 round average of 115 and is looking like a nice option. This is following a pretty bad start of the year.

    Role change or just hitting some form?

    cheers

    5

    0
    1. He’s left the half back line with Coleman returning and now playing a blended MID-FWD role. Getting great purchase with those bursts on ball and then, of course, when he comes up to stoppages.

      Good bye as well, I like him as an option. Injury profile a concern but capable of spitting out 120s.

      Abs opened Fallen Premiums with him, I’d give that a read as well:

      http://supercoachtalk.com/the-fallen-premiums-rd-10-2022/

      5

      0
      1. Yep I got him last week and he was good. I’ll be nervous as a long tailed cat in a room full of rocking chairs for the rest of the year though. Age and injury history are against him, but if you can ignore that he’s a fantastic scorer!

        1

        0
  41. Need to trade Steele and I’ve already got Neale, Oliver, Macrae, Miller, Laird and Cripps.

    There’s been a lot of talk about trading in Petracca and Brayshaw who are both viable options. However, I’ve been looking at Parish whos had only 2 scores below 100 which have both been in the high 90’s.

    Who’s the best option?

    T/up- Parish

    T/down – Petracca

    Comment – Brayshaw or anyone else

    9

    11
    1. Don’t go Parish, James.

      I started him and been an absolute headf*ck. A ways off his damaging CP best last year. He’s stuck playing a ridiculous system that boxes the Dons midfield into overusing, being handball happy and rarely biting off anything audacious I50.

      Add to that, his effort has just been poor. Laid one tackle last week only 300~ MG from 31 touches.

      Wouldn’t go Racca either. His style of play means he’s a perennial butcher and often subtons. Nothing more frustrating than seeing a premo MID get 30+ and not ton.

      Brayshaw a solid Top 8 pick, sure, but if you can ball out for Mills or Laird then that’s the play imo.

      4

      3
      1. Appreciate your input Gunboat. I agree the Dons are playing some poor football atm and Parish isn’t thriving as much as he could be. But he’s still got an average of 114.7 which is actually 0.6 points higher than last year! And he is still churning out some decent scores. Wouldn’t say he’s been the worst pick.

        I also agree with your take on Petracca.

        I already have Laird in my team and am thinking of picking up Mills after his bye in hope that he falls in price.

        Feel like Brayshaw might be the way to go at this stage then. Hoping Fyfe’s return doesn’t affect him too much!

        2

        0
        1. Have you looked at Walsh James? He’s my pick this week at least and isn’t likely to butcher the ball as much as Petracca

          1

          0
          1. Was considering him too but his bye is in Round 12 and I’m already quite low on players for that round unfortunately

            0

            0
          2. I was considering bringing him in too but his bye is in Round 12 and I’m already quite low on players for that round

            1

            0
  42. Upgrading Martin to a premium in my forward line, if English is back is he a better option then Parker ?

    TU – English
    TD – Parker

    Is Parker still getting a lot of midfield time? Haven’t seen Sydney’s game as of late

    0

    8
    1. English will not be playing this week.

      Tim English (flu) “Still very low in energy. He’s easing himself back into some training. We will be conservative in his re-load & confirm his return to play once he’s healthy & training with intensity.” Chris Bell, Head of Sports Med.

      Luke Parker had 18 CBAs last weekend, the highest for Sydney.

      3

      0
    1. Both are Top 6 locks and eventual must haves.

      Stewart R13 bye, Sicily R14.

      Maybe let that decide, Matt? Very little between them. Both very fun to watch as well.

      2

      2
    1. I think so. But if English plays, I might go to him and consider waiting a few weeks on Mills for a hopeful price drop

      0

      0
  43. $38,400 ITB, 21 Trades Left (2 Boosts)
    DEF: J. Sicily, J. Crisp, J. Short, J. Sinclair, G. Hewett, H. Chapman (P. McCartin, S. De Koning)
    MID: L. Neale, C. Oliver, J. Steele, J. Macrae, T. Miller, P. Cripps, N. Daicos, J. Carroll, (J. Horne-Francis, J. Ward, R. McComb)
    RUCK: J. Witts, B. Preuss (S. Hayes)
    FWD: J. Dunkley, W. Brodie, S. Coniglio, Z. Butters, N. Martin, L. Parker (M. Rioli, J. McEntee)

    Ran a rookie as M8 last week (scored 29), b/c JHF DNP. Not risking that again, therefore thinking:

    Steele > Laird
    Cogs > Cheapest FWD/DEF DPP Player (Enables swinging McCartin/SDK to D6, and $$$ for the 2 premo mids)
    JHF > Possibly Parish (Suggestions? $33k short of Mills)

    What do you blokes reckon?

    Cheers

    0

    1
  44. News that Whitfield is out an Crisp injury cloud with 260 in the bank
    Whitfield to Dawson
    Steel to Petracca
    Rowell to wines

    Skip on the rookies this week

    2

    4
    1. Mcrae said crisp will be named but also feel like he could be a potential late out if he’s no good

      5

      1
  45. Trades 23 (2 Boosts)
    337k ITB
    DEF: Sicily, Short, Crips, Hewett, Dawson, Daicos, (McCartin, SDK)
    MID: Neale, Oliver, Macrae, Cripps, Steele, Brayshaw, Brodie, Rioli jr, (Stephens, Hamilton, Uwland)
    RUC: Gawn, Preuss, (SHayes)
    FWD: Dunkley, Heeney, Cogs, Butters, Martin, Curtis, (Dixon, Rosas)
    Need help. No idea what to do. Was thinking something along the lines of Steele -> Laird, Stephens -> Clark or something.
    Ideas appreciated.

    1

    0
    1. Cogs to Premo defender.

      Cogs out. SDK/Mccartin to Fwd

      Stephens to G Clark. Time to bite the bullet on Stephens

      also maybe boost to move steele to another Primo mid

      1

      0
  46. TU – Daicos to Lloyd
    TD – N.Martin to Dusty

    Bye structure is solid as a rock regardless of who I bring in

    5

    5
  47. Trades for this week…
    T/U – Steele to Laird + Whitfield to Dale
    T/D – Steele to Walsh + Whitfield to Sicily

    4

    14
  48. Okay ladies and gents
    with everything we know now. ie cogs starting on ball
    Who do we trade, one has to go….

    T/U – Cogs

    T/D – N. Martin

    Get clicking legends

    4

    13
  49. Nick Martin -> Who? Can afford anyone, have Sicily, Hewett, Crisp, Short, Dawson, Macrae, Laird, Oliver, Brayshaw, Cripps, Neale, Dunkley, Heeney. Can DPP for any position except ruck.
    Thanks

    0

    0
  50. Also prioritise trading out
    Dixon and having a 630k to upgrade
    Or
    Martin and having 770k to upgrade

    9

    2
  51. Better trade to make;

    TU;
    Jack Hayes > Witts
    (Sam Hayes becomes r3, however this means Rioli/rosas loophole at m8)

    TD;
    Stephens > Bontempelli
    (Sam Hayes becomes r2, Nick Martin becomes f6 which means no Rioli or rosas needed on my field)

    5

    2
  52. Last week traded out Bowey & Dixon > Miller (via N.Daicos DDP) & Rioli
    Obviously Steele is something that needs to go but is there anything else that I should do.
    My current team before trades:
    DEF: Sicily, Crisp, Hewett, Ridley, N.Daicos, McCartin (Gibcus, Sinn)
    MID: Neale, Oliver, Miller, Macrae, Cripps, Steele, Brodie, JHF, (Ward, McComb, Hollands)
    RUC: Gawn, Preuss (S.Hayes)
    FWD: Dunkley, Parker, Cogs, Butters, N.Martin, Durdin (M.Rioli, C.MacDonald)
    $57,400 in the bank, 25 trades left, three trade boosts left
    Any feedback/advice is greatly appreciated

    1

    0
    1. Ward to Clark in midfield, non playing player to best rookie available and Clark could be played on field if required. Huge cash generation as well.

      0

      0
  53. Who has the best job security going fwd ?
    TU – Buku Khamis
    TD – Rory Thompson
    I’m thinking Rory but not sure. Thanks.

    0

    11
  54. Coniglio named in the midfield – Trade or hold?

    Leaning towards hold for the Wet Toast game then assess for Brisbane the week after.

    7

    2
    1. Hey Nelson,

      Cogs has a 146 BE! Unless you are tight on Trades, have bigger priorities or $ ITB I’d say Ta ta!

      2

      0
      1. Yeah agreed mate, if we hold onto Cogs this week it means that we basically need to hold him till we are full premo meaning he will be a luxury trade later on. Very tough situation!

        0

        0
  55. Do Sydney have a tagger? If so you think they would go to cripps or Walsh?
    – may be bringing Walsh in so just a bit worried

    1

    4
  56. Cash strapped and 19 trades left no boosts

    Whitfield/ Steele >

    Sinclair/ DMartin

    Or just

    Steele > Hewitt / Sicily/ Docherty etc

    Hold Whitfield for now

    0

    4
    1. Do you have clark?

      Bring in the cheapest Keeper you can for steele and use the money on your next upgrade

      0

      1
      1. Thanks Just some guy. I have Clark went early and there aren’t any good rookie downgrades atm.

        I was thinking to get Wines and have 50k left for next upgrade but If I did that I’d have to field Daicos, Dekoning and W-Milera in def with no cover.

        My backline is my biggest issue:

        Stewart, Crisp, Lloyd, Daicos, Dekoning, W-Milera( Whitfield, Skinner)

        0

        0
  57. Already gone Dixon and Steele to Laird and Clark. Use my last trade boost to go SDK to Walsh?

    T/UP: YES
    T/Down: NO

    14

    2
  58. Some forced trades this week, good chance to balance my premiums for the byes though.

    Steele > Macrae
    Macdonald > Clark
    Whitfield > Dawson

    4

    1
  59. TU allows me to get both Laird and Mills but I let go of Daicos and have to loop Durdin or Rosas at F6.

    TD sees me go Petracca instead of Mills and allows me to keep Daicos at D6 whilst swinging McCartin to F6. (Not quite enough for Khamis)

    TU:
    Steele > Laird
    Coniglio > Mills
    Daicos > Khamis
    45.3k ITB

    TD:
    Steele > Laird
    Coniglio > Petracca
    Durdin > Cleary
    4.4kITB

    1

    4
  60. Hey Gents,

    Help required which option is better
    TU:N Martin to Rory Laird
    TD:C MacDonald to Andrew Brayshaw

    Cheers

    4

    6
  61. T/U – Dixon to Dawson (get McCartin off field)
    T/D – Dixon to A.Brayshaw (get Martin off field)

    Still have 2 x DEF, 2 x MID & 1 x FWD upgrade left

    2

    3
  62. Hey everyone!

    Steele -> Laird
    MacDonald -> Clark
    O’Driscoll to….

    I’m tossing up between bringing a DEF or FWD but wondering how worried I should be about bringing in a Round 12 player. I’m already on 17 playing.

    TU: Bite the rd. 12 bullet and make the trade (Docherty, Dusty, Sinclair, etc.)
    TD: Grab someone else playing rd 13/14(Dawson, Heeney, Dale, etc.)

    Any advice welcome.

    Thanks!

    1

    6
  63. Who to vice captain
    TU – walsh
    – Cripps

    Bloke I’m versing will most likely vc cripps but feel like he might get some attention tonight

    1

    2

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *