Trade Talk R11

Written by Schwarzwalder on May 28 2017

The Bye Rounds are now upon us. Have you managed to get your structure right? What moves need to be made for Rd11?

4
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

153 thoughts on “Trade Talk R11”

  1. Greenwood in. Reid out.
    S. Selwood in. WHE out via dpp or SPP out, depending on BE’s. Neither will be in my side in 2 weeks and neither is likely to be in my best 18 scores this week. Flip a coin really.

    The third trade is yet to be decided, may rely on naming of the teams, or BE’s of premos.

    Not sure if going 2 down 1 premo or 3 down this week.

    3

    10
    1. Scott Selwood feels like a fools gold pick. He’s certainly capable of being SC relevant but it’s been 4 years since he’s been able to stay healthy. Unless you’ve got trades to spare I don’t think the risk is worth it.

      18

      2
      1. The other side of this discussion about Scooter is that he can average 85, and get to $430K+ (ie makes the magical gain of $150K +).

        He is a tackling machine, is playing a mostly MID role, and plays in a pretty good side.

        He will still need to be traded out (or maybe kept for M9), but in a tough year for cash generation, he might be a good choice for some teams (particularly if you have 17+ trades).

        21

        4
      2. He is a player who has proven he can make a 105-110 average for a season. At that count he’s certainly a way better option than SPP at the same price.

        Long term fitness has been an issue but at this point he looks pretty good. He has had a LOT of time off to recover.

        I’m not talking about him as a premium – he’s purely in M8/M9 territory and mostly for cashflow and beneficial byes. -48 b/e means if he can keep near his current average he will make almost 150k in two weeks.

        But I’m certainly not averse to keep him until luxury trade time at the end.

        My top 8 mids now read:
        Sloane, Dangerfield, Murphy, Pendles, Dusty, Joel Selwood, Fyfe, Scott Selwood at M8 (although his average is 107 and thus should be rated above Fyfe).

        In the end though it’s as much about pushing Dahlhaus and Steele into the forwards as it is about improving the mids. Steele and Dahlhaus at mid 90’s per game seem as good as we are going to get as forwards (which is where I always planned them) but have been covering midfield spots until fallen premiums came up.

        5

        2
      3. He can score very well, but will also take on a tagging role. Surely he’ll be tagging Sloane this week? He can still score reasonably well, but don’t be expecting a ton.

        3

        0
  2. Currently planning
    Out: McCarthy, Newman, SPP
    In: Bolton/Ainsworth, Scharenberg, Cousins

    or if Sandi isn’t selected again he will be traded (instead of SPP) to a loophole moving Witts to R2.

    Will free up approximately 600,000 or around 800,000 if Sandi is traded.

    Will allow Hampton to Docherty, Turner to Dahlhaus and WHE to Macrae in RD12.

    10

    8
      1. Newman loses his 151 from breakeven next game. So he and Otten are pretty much timed for perfection on a bang bang double upgrade.

        I will come out of the byes with Docherty and Jake Lloyd in those positions and only have to tip $200k in.

        7

        0
  3. Out mbank and ballic, In scharenberg and bolton. Not ideal but need guys on field and cash in bank. I think scharenberg will be better long term than perryman so going early.

    Planning to upgrade barrett for my final premo mid, current ones are pendles, danger, selwood, jpk, hanners, titch, fyfe.
    T/u dusty this week
    T/d bont next week

    6

    27
    1. Needed Dusty LAST week at 525k. Still hood buying at 555.

      This week Sloane is a better buy than Bont.

      And with Wallis back I don’t think Bont or Dahl will score as well as they did early in the season.

      4

      0
      1. I went jpk over dusty week b4. But he is still a decent price this week.
        Am considering whether to trade fyfe to neale or sloane after the byes.

        3

        2
  4. Trades this week will be:
    Out: Balic and Hampton
    In: Cousins and possibly Ryan of Freo. Not convinced about Perryman although JS looks okay. Scharenberg, I rather pay $50K less for someone who will just be a bench warmer.
    Following week will be:
    Out: WHE, Shaw & SPP
    In: Docherty, Bont and possibly Zorko who I had hoped to get cheaper as a POD.
    Soooooooooooooo sick of seeing Shaw’s 70/80’s compared to Docherty tonning up pretty much every week.
    Those trades will set me up for the first couple of bye weeks and allow a little time to fix round 13.

    4

    1
    1. We’d all rather pay 50k less for a bench warmer. Do you intend a never to play loophole player, or one who might play and make cash, because Perryman is only 10k cheaper?

      1

      0
      1. Did the same last year and went bang. I’d love him to pick up form but I doubt he will. But if you are desperate for a radical change in your side he is certainly cheap. He did get 30 odd in the first qtr so there are some signs he might be on the verge of it…. but at this stage I would avoid him too.

        But not yet prepared to rage trade him.

        0

        0
    1. Could be a good D5 or D6 for the remainder of the year, depending on who else you have in your backine

      2

      3
        1. I think mcniece was only used during the anzac day run of short breaks as we rested a number of players through that periods so they wouldnt burn out.
          Plus Dea has come back in team now and seems to be playing his role well. I don’t ser mcniece coming back unless dea/baguely get injured or have huge form drops.

          1

          0
    1. I used Perryman a week ago based on Job Security and DPP.

      But Scharenberg will be better, or McNeice if named.

      Cashfliw is better done elsewhere this year. The backs have been shocking bar Stewart who I traded too early, and Newman and Otten who I didn’t.

      1

      0
  5. Out: Parfit & Eddy (unless a miracle happens and he is named then it will be parson)
    In: Sloan & Greenwood

    Undecided on a 3rd trade (if mcneice gets named then probably), will have a think about it during the week.

    With these 2 trades it leaves me with $180k itb and 18 trades.

    Looking at moving out SPP & WHE the following week for rocky & scharenberg. Might even make a 3rd then also (prob parsons for $) but too far ahead to be sure.

    3rd week out otten and tarranto for fallen Def & Fwd.

    Thats the plan so far doubt it will be that simple haha.

    Also have Fyfe and Priddis to think about after the byes as Neale will be lookin very attractive by then if they keep underperforming.

    5

    0
  6. Thoughts on trading Newman with his breakeven at 80 for Shai Bolton via DPP

    Leaves me with $437 600 and 15 trades going into round 11. Double upgrade next week

    12

    3
        1. Rumour going around as of yet is only rumour.

          At this point it is only known that he suffered concussion.

          The recovery time on concussion varies from person to person.

          For anyone to say he needs 2-3 months off for concussion they are talking out their bum at this stage.

          1

          0
  7. Out

    Eddy, picket and Fisher

    In

    Greenwood, Bolton and Scott selwood…

    Then I will only have 1 donut in the fwd, 0 ruck, 0 in mid and 2 in def. Total donuts 3.

    I will have a rubbish team though , parsons/perryman/myers on the field

    16 trades left after this , 65 k in bank

    2

    7
  8. Are Robbie Gray or Ollie Wines worth a look given the need for value this year?

    Helps with the byes as well

    4

    15
    1. Wines maybe but not Robbie yet.

      If Robbie recovers full fitness he might look good as a fallen premo but there are no signs yet.

      2

      1
  9. One lock for me this week is Pickett -> Bolton, which gives me 20 playing. Knowing this, should I trade out SPP or Barrett? Barrett is hitting his stride with a breakeven of 12, but SPP has already had his bye – so who would you trade out?

    Thumbs up – SPP

    Thumbs down – Barrett

    17

    11
      1. Agree BKW

        Those relying on Bolton to play this week will need to have a back up plan.

        I didn’t see the game, but with the stats that he had, I still can’t believe that Bolton scored around 65 in his first week?

        Doesn’t get a lot of the ball – so looks to be relying on most of them being contested possessions.

        Butler two weeks out with a groin is a concern for his owners though.

        0

        0
      2. If Bolton doesn’t play… “I’ll find another” – Walder Frey

        Yes, I’m a little excited about GoT coming out soon

        6

        1
  10. Joelwood in this week but who goes out? I am thinking Fisher since he has a bye and cannot seem to score well anyway. What do you think?

    Up – Fisher
    Dn – SPP

    32

    3
    1. Fisher has a B/E of 20 but lets face it is not going to make much anyway.

      SPP is stuck in the 60 point doldrums and is maxed out. He’s unlikely to feature in your best 18 on field during the byes unless you completely mismanaged your bye structure.

      Trading BOTH out to take advantage of Greenwood, Bolton, S Selwood on the bubble or even Cousins to build a post Rnd 11 warchest if named is a sensible strategy

      6

      5
        1. I do. If you read the above a lot of people don’t.

          107 average, 112 points and 17 tackles last week. Coaches and Champion Data love tackles.

          Yes, he’s been out with injury a bit but he was certainly a VERY SC relevant player in the past.

          Has the potential, has job security if fit, and is still young enough to have a big impact. I also suspect Menegola or Blicavs is more likely to get dropped than Selwood.

          It’s a risk, but at $280k and -48 breakeven I don’t think it is as much of a risk as say Shai Bolton who would be at best 50/50 of playing this week, and probably only 10% chance of playing after the bye when Butler should definitely be available.

          Even Greenwood is no guarantee of job security either.

          2

          3
          1. Disagree on Greenwood’s job security. I think it is very high. He’s ahead of a couple in the current 22 and Knight, Menzel and Hampton are not going to get Greenwood’s spot even when they return to full fitness.
            I also believe Greenwood’s style of game helps Rory Sloane. He’s more inclined to block taggers than other Crows mids.

            4

            2
          2. Burnt by Swallow and O’meara already, not sure I have it in me to try for third time lucky.

            Also, I have one premo mid spot remaining … I think Joelwood is ripe for the picking and a proven performer. It is possible that SSelwood will increase by $150K but Joelwood may also climb to 600+ over that time.

            Hmmm. Much to consider me thinks.

            3

            0
            1. I had O’meara too – and burnt by Roughy as well. As well as Hannan, Stewart, Eddy, Hibberd and Barrett who all got traded out early when they stalled or I needed to avoid a donut.

              But then again I also got burnt by: Danger, Shaw, Dahlhaus, Treloar, Fyfe, Beams, NRoo – and picked up Pendles at what I thought was bargain basement but learnt was second floor ladies lingerie.

              It’s been that kind of year. Even burn man Higgins has burnt me with a week off injured.

              But some of the midpricers have also been amongst the best players – Nankervis, Witts, Oliver, Murphy.

              You just have to make your own call.

              4

              0
        1. Rest assured Wognuts I have worst players that SPP but not all are in the mids and not all a ready to cull.

          1

          0
    1. Quite possibly. But if he does you think it’s at best one or two weeks before the return of Lycett. After which they have Lycett, Petrie, Vardy, McInnes and McGovern all capable of playing big boy up forward in JJK’s absence.

      As such, while i was positive on him with Petrie and Lycett out, he’s now looking like he won’t earn enough games.

      Unlikely to be a spot for him as a defender with Wellingham coming back too.

      3

      1
        1. More likely that they’ll swing McGovern forward and bring on Barass or McKenzie down back. Think the Gov looks more dangerous playing full time fwd than any of the Pettis, McInnes or Vardy. Even once Lycett is back I’d expect Petrie or Vardy to get the flick.

          0

          2
  11. SPP > Sloane
    WHE > Greenwood

    Midfield complete: Sloane, Danger, Pendles, Bont, Selwood, JPK, Treloar and Fyfe. Possible future luxury Fyfe > Neale/Mitchell

    15 trades left, 20k in the bank.

    Will probably hold next week before RD13 going Newman, Otten and Parsons to Lloyd, ? and Yeo

    5

    3
  12. some people may not like this but dont trade brett eddy,
    will get a game had 4 sausage rolls on the weekend (4.3) and had 19 possies, he will get a gig soon, be patient

    12

    5
  13. Worth trading out Fyfe just to get Sloane?

    TU: Yes, Sloane will only get higher. Fyfe is under performing
    TD: No, Fyfe is fine. Save trades

    8

    24
  14. Only fielding 16 not sure if i’ll do any trades, Barrett/Stewart still making cash i also want to swap Newman for Lloyd in round 13 so i might take a hit this week

    3

    2
    1. Can always trade Newman out this week and buy Scharenberg, then cash out Otten for Lloyd when Lloyd bottoms out.

      No guarantees yet that Lloyd plays Round 12 or 13…

      1

      0
  15. I’m planning on a MID upgrade either this week or next and can’t decide who to target:

    TU – Sloane this week

    TD – Rocky next week (assuming he’s back)

    16

    7
    1. Tough call. I was gonna go Rocky because a tag doesnt work on him (unlike Sloane).

      But Rocky will get injured again before end of season.

      I’m thinking both – Fyfe out for Rocky next week.

      1

      3
  16. Butler and Eddy Out, Witts (via nank) and greenwood in

    after next week, trading WHE to yeo.

    Went witts because he is a decent price, fairly consistent and already had bye.
    Thoughts? thanks.

    4

    2
  17. Had 2 trades planned for this week but made 3 just to field 18 players (Carnage). Don’t usually operate this way but trades worked with long-term strategy:

    Butler > Greenwood
    Hampton > Scharenberg
    Fisher > Sloane

    Brought in two cash cows and a premo for 3 liabilities so pretty happy overall.

    10

    2
    1. I’m considering the exact three trades (except it is Marchbank out & not Hampton).

      As HH says though, I don’t like getting any rookies in until they are ready to play their third game (especially ones with an injury history like Scharenberg).

      Therefore, might just go Fisher and Butler out for Scooter and Greenwood. And then get Scharenberg next week if he gets picked to play his third game next week.

      However, this will mean that I miss Sloane this week, and he is going to rise in price again (BE = 49).

      Decisions to be made!!

      0

      0
  18. Out: Balic, Barrett
    In: Greenwood, Danger

    Unsure whether to trade out SPP or Barrett as Barrett can make more money but SPP has already had his bye
    I have 21 players on the field but Mcneice is one and hopefully the rest play as they all played last week except for Sandi

    TU Barrett
    TD SPP

    3

    9
    1. Cash is king this time of the year. If you have 20+ players named this week, I would be inclined to extract as much cash as possible and hold onto Barrett.

      8

      0
  19. Parker.
    Picked him to go elite this year but seems to have eaten a sack of potatoes in the pre-season. Still getting the ball a bit but not looking anywhere near as dangerous in the packs or up forward as last year.
    T/up: Hold
    T/down: Cull him while he’s still at a ‘decent’ price

    10

    17
  20. OUT: Newman, Fisher and Pickett
    IN: Shaz, Bolton and X

    This is where it gets tricky. X can either be Dusty, to complete my MIDS and then end of byes, Stewart/Berry becomes Lloyd/Ryan to complete my team. Or Scooter, with a little bank. Team won’t be finished til after the byes in this situation and it will cost me more trades in doing so.

    Tempted to just go Dusty…

    9

    0
  21. Currently have a ruck combo of Ryder, Witts, Sandi and Nank in the fwds. Considering trading one out to strnadica to free up some cash.

    T/U: Do it.
    T/D: Save the trade.

    18

    1
  22. Fisher – Greenwood
    Barret – Bolton

    Undecided on if a third trade will be made. Hoping Sandi is named or he might need to go.

    Shaz could come in this week for Newman or Berry depending on team announcements as well.

    1

    3
      1. It depends on how many non-round-11 bye players he has; if he is in a position of having to do what he can to survive round 11, then trading Barrett may be his least bad option, with or without his low B.E.

        1

        1
  23. What is wrong with FYFE this season. Have no spots left in the midfield

    Currently Danger, Z Merret, Pendals, Beams, Cripps, Trelor, Bont & Fyfe.
    Really want to get Sloane in and considering he is the cheapest he will be for a long time 586k BE of 49, considering offloading Fyfe for Sloane.

    TU : Go for it
    TD : Golden rule never sideway trade premiums.

    17

    21
    1. Fyfe had 10+ clangers this week so that would have affected his score, but i would personally hold him and upgrade everyone else first so you have a full premium team and then you can start the sideways trade to make those minor improvements

      10

      0
      1. Fyfe lost 65 points due to his clangers. If he hit the target he would have gained points so it’s really 100 point turnaround. He’s never been the cleanest of players so for him to still get 78 in the pouring rain, i’m impressed. Last 5 weeks doesn’t look good but a post bye luxury upgrade for me if he doesn’t improve.

        7

        0
        1. Fyfe at least seemed to get a decent amount of ball. Mundy, Neale and Walters were unseen and scored less than 150 S/C between them.
          Sandilands didn’t play, which didn’t help and the rain was unbelievable at times.
          I’m holding Fyfe.

          3

          0
    1. Depends on who it is for but most would avoid him as it could be fool’s gold just like Matera was.
      Depends on your trades as well as he would need to make you 150K before it would be worth because do you genuinely think he will he will be consistent and go 500k plus

      3

      4
      1. I’m genuinely surprised on how many believe in Selwood, will be very interesting to see how many take the leap of faith

        2

        0
        1. Everyones situation is different. I originally planned to do it but after looking into it today I don’t have the trades in hand to warrant it.

          1

          0
  24. Pick one of Pendles vs Selwood for me.
    I have 8 R13 premos out already vs 3 R12 Premos.

    TU: Selwood
    TD: Pendles

    20

    9
    1. If trading Sloane is means you still have 18+ players for the round 14 bye then definitely Sloane

      If not, then go Martin

      4

      1
      1. Yeah, there’s no question that Sloane offers better value, so it will probably come down to bye balance in the end.

        0

        0
    1. with this trade, i will have 236k in the bank.
      Or, as an alternative, should i trade out just balic and butler for sloane and greenwood, but only 16k in the bank.

      20

      1
    2. I have done the exact same 3 trades in. Didn’t burn Fyfe for them.

      I dunno why all the hate for Scooter, but I do get why people think trading out Fyfe might not be a great move.

      No one else you can chop for Selwood?

      0

      0
  25. These are my trades for the moment

    OUT: J.J Kennedy, Z. Fisher, J. Parsons
    IN: J. Cameron, J. Cousins, H. Greenwood

    I was tossing over whether I should get rid of Kennedy or not. Two things that made me decide to do. Firstly, even though he is out for 3 weeks (supposedly), when a player comes back from a calf injury they can take a fair while to fully get back into form. Secondly, I would be in a bit of trouble this week if I had kept him, because this week takes out more players than the other two bye rounds do.

    Will be getting rid of Marchbank next week and upgrade him to Hibberd, and the week after I HOPEFULLY will be able to get Scott Selwood for SPP.

    6

    5
  26. This week:
    Out – Newman, Barrett, WHE
    In – Scharenberg, Greenwood, Sloane

    Next week:
    Out – Otten, SPP, Preuss
    In – Docherty, Rockliff, Strnadicia

    Barring the inevitable injuries of course. But if that goes to plan I just need 1 ruck to be fully premium.

    7

    1
  27. is Barrett to S.Selwood a good option?

    T/U: Yes, he will generate more cash and get good scores

    T/D: No, a waste of a trade!

    4

    18
  28. What to do with JJK? (only traded him in last week!!!)

    TU: Hold – only missing 2 games plus his bye, will come back strong
    TD: Trade to P Ryder
    Comment: trade to someone else – T Lynch?

    Thanks folks

    10

    4
    1. I’m erring on the side of holding JJK but also wondering if its a good opportunity to nab Sloane before his price skyrockets again.

      TU – hold JJK and conserve trades with only 16 left
      TD – be bold, get Sloane and finish off MIDs

      4

      8
    1. Hadn’t seen the rookie article yet, apologies.

      Any further input from fans of either side still welcomed! Bolton looked way too skinny to get regular games imo but I only saw a few minutes of the Richmond game this weekend.

      3

      0
  29. Thoughts on the below?…
    Thinking:
    Mitch Hibberd -> Scharenberg
    Balic -> Selwood
    Petracca -> Bolton
    Should leave me enough cash in round 12 to go:
    WHE -> Wallis
    Otten -> Docherty
    And then in round 13:
    Newman -> Lloyd

    6

    3
  30. As of now I have 14 players playing in R13. To fix that I need to start now. I’m doing fine for R11 and R12, although I have managed to get 7 defenders for R12 and no real way to fix that, so I am going to have to loophole during the byes, which is annoying! Anyways, I want to try and keep JJK so am thinking I will hold him and if I need to trade him out to avoid a donut then I will but otherwise I’ll keep him.

    The players not playing R13 I am willing to trade out are:

    Hampton – Not playing at all
    Eddy – Not playing at all
    Otten – Want to keep until R13
    WHE – Want to keep until R13
    Hardwick – Want to keep until R13
    Sandilands – Injured and out on R13
    JJK – If I have to, won’t play at least until R14.

    Since JJK in means the difference between his score and the 18th score I would otherwise get, him being out is not so bad as long as I have 18 on field. Well, if one is Fishes, that might be a lot, but still.

    This round:
    Otten –> Scharenberg (bye on R13, but only decent downgrade, and good long term it looks like, nice to have him R11 and R12. Must do to afford the other trades.)
    Eddy –> S. Selwood (bye on R12, and even if he tags should score ok and make money)
    Sandi –> Ryder (plays all three bye rounds, and in form. )

    Leaves me with 16 trades and $30,300 going into R12.
    21, 21+1, 16 byes.

    Leaves Otten, WHE, and Hardwick to make 19 on R13, or if I swap a forward to Cousins via DPP to make 18, with JJK on the block if needed R13. No way to know what to do exactly in the future until I see how hosed I am by the events of R11.

    TU = sounds good
    TD = does not sound good. (please say why below)

    7

    0
      1. Oh darn. Thanks for pointing that out. Meant Hampton! No Otten stays for now. Too late to edit. ๐Ÿ™

        Hampton โ€“> Scharenberg (bye on R13, but only decent downgrade, and good long term it looks like, nice to have him R11 and R12. Must do to afford the other trades.)
        Eddy โ€“> S. Selwood (bye on R12, and even if he tags should score ok and make money)
        Sandi โ€“> Ryder (plays all three bye rounds, and in form. )

        6

        0
  31. Hey guys,
    Trading Fisher out this week to get 19 on the field (15 trades left),
    I jumped the gun on Greenwood last week (no Ragrets),
    and I’m trading Eddy for Bolton if he’s not named.
    Should I trade Fisher for
    T/U Scott Selwood
    T/D James Cousins

    4

    3
  32. Do people really think that Harbrow will keep his current level of scoring up? He’s nearly 29, and his best average prior to this year is 85.5.

    TU: Yes โ€“ it will be different this time.
    TD: It’s a trap!

    1

    15
  33. Will Mitchell Hibberd (NM) play again this year?

    TU: Yes, he’s been playing really well in the VFL.
    TD: No, Brad Scott hates him.

    4

    4
  34. Is it wise to trade out Stef Martin now seeing that a: He has a bye &
    b: Archie Smith looks like ruining him

    I think trading him out now for a fwd, swinging the Nank into the ruck for a week and then bringing in Kruezer after his bye?
    It’s a straight swap, and if I don’t do it I’ll have to trade either Hannan or Barrett out who still have 50k or so to make, or SPP who has his bye already out the way.
    So who should go? Martin, Hannan, Barrett or SPP?

    1

    1
  35. OUT: Balic and WHE
    IN: Greenwood and Sloane
    Leaves with 15k. Then next week is Newman to Lloyd (or Docherty if SPP can go up 15k which I’m doubting) and SPP to Scharenberg.

    3

    0
  36. Ok, I know I’ve already made a comment beforehand. But now I’m struggling to figure out what trades I should make this week.

    Before I talk about trades, here’s my team below as it stands (without any trades made or moving much players around), so you can have a rough understanding of my situation

    DEF: T. Adams, R. Laird, Z. Tuohy, J. Lloyd (BYE), N. Newman (BYE), C. Marchbank (BYE) – T. Stewart, M. Scharenberg

    MID: P. Dangerfield, M. Murphy (BYE), C. Oliver (BYE), T. Cotchin, JPK (BYE), N. Fyfe, D. Beams (BYE), SPP – J. Barrett (BYE), Z. Fisher (BYE), S. Bolton

    RUC: A. Sandilands, J. Witts – D. Cameron (BYE)

    FWD: E. Yeo, L. Dahlhaus (BYE), JJK (Injured), I. Heeney (BYE), T. Nankervis, T. Taranto – J. Parsons, S. Durdin

    So my main struggle is that this week is my hardest hit out of the byes. I don’t know if it would be better for me to trade people in to get the 18 I need, or if I should cop some zeros.
    Also, I’m still at a crossroads of whether to keep JJK or not. I’ve seen a fair few people here saying to keep him, but I don’t know if I can trust a player coming back from a calf injury. Don’t want to have him in and be either out of form or carrying some small niggles from the injury.

    So here’s a couple of lists I made up of who I’ve at least thought of trading out or trading in.

    OUTS – JJK, J. Parsons, Z. Fisher, J. Barrett, S. Durdin, D. Cameron, SPP, T. Taranto

    INS – H. Greenwood, S. Selwood, J. Cameron, J. Cousins, P. Ryder, O. Wines, S. Pendelbury

    Marchbank would’ve been in there too, but I’m wanting to trade him out for Hibberd NEXT week.

    If any of you have taken the time to look at my current team, and my trade options below. What trades do you think I should be making? Are there any other players I should be looking at to trade in?

    Please don’t be shy to give me your opinions on what you think I should be doing. Don’t know if I can reply back, because of comment limits and such.

    Any opinions are greatly appreciated! ๐Ÿ˜€

    0

    0
  37. Was always planning to get Sloanedog in this week, but wasn’t expecting him to make his 155 breakeven, so now I’ll have to pay out the nose for him.
    This weeks trades are looking to be:
    Balic, Fisher & Newman OUT
    Greenwood, Sloane and Scharenberg IN

    This leaves $7.7k in the bank, with two upgrades left. I’m tentative to go early on Scharenberg, but the only other option is to trade out Barrett, but he’s got another $40k-ish to make.

    TU: Good stuff
    TD: Nah

    7

    0
  38. TU: In = Greenwood, Strndica (Nank Fwd), McNiece/Scharenberg
    Out = Hampton, Butler, Eddy
    330k in the bank to chase Doc next week

    TD: In = Laird, Greenwood, Strndica (Nank Fwd)
    Out = Marchbank, Butler, Eddy
    Nothing in the bank

    Both options have 18 players playing (teams pending :/)

    0

    4
  39. Is Ryder the real deal? He would provide cover in the rucks during the byes, getting swapped forward afterwards… however not sure on his consistency or scoring ability, when you take out his only two scores over 100 he’s been pretty low.

    TU: Real deal trade him in
    TD: No good, not showing consistency

    0

    5
  40. Defenders T Stewart & Otten are both playing this week, and I’m short of R11 players, but I want to trade out a defender to bring in T Adams. My other option is Newman who isn’t playing. I could bring T Adams in as a MID but want my 2nd trade for Fisher to Greenwood.

    TU: T Stewart or Otten to T Adams
    TD: Newman to T Adams

    1

    10
  41. TU: Cousins vs TD: Bolton?
    I think cousins is more likely to score higher but worried about his job security

    0

    0
  42. hey guys, to he honest I don’t what to to do, have 18 playing this weekend, opponents have 16 and 13 with 3 trades if they trade, I could upgrade but cows are still munching, but I think is better to sit until next week, have 14 trades and 50k in the bank and I see no real viable options really this round, think I’ll sit

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *