Trade Talk R11 – PART TWO

Written by Schwarzwalder on May 31 2017

Plenty happening in the lead-up to the Bye Rounds. What changes are you making to your team?

1
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

92 thoughts on “Trade Talk R11 – PART TWO”

    1. Me personally would be only trading if i need the bodies on the field. If you need the extra player for round 11 then go for it but, if you can field 18 or 19 in both Rd 11 and 13 then i say wait on Kennedy

      6

      0
  1. Bringing in a mid premo, was set on sloane but only got 16 players in R13 which is making me lean towards Dusty

    TU Sloane
    TD Dusty

    6

    34
        1. Already got Pendles! Seems like its pretty conclusive to get dusty…hopefully missing out on sloane doesn’t burn me

          1

          1
  2. Greenwood and Strdnica in, Nank into my forward line.
    Got 538k left, 17 trades.
    Ottens or Newman out for Docherty next week…
    T/U to trade Ottens
    T/D to trade Newman

    8

    34
  3. Who to take out for Cousins

    Currently can field 20 (includes trade ins of Scharenberg and Bolton)

    TU: SPP (700,000 remaining in salary)
    TD: Z Fisher (587,400 remaining in salary and can field 21 this week)

    2

    34
    1. Adam – I would wait a week on Cousins if you are already fielding 20 this week.

      I would also be a little concerned about Boltons JS (if Butler is named this week, he may lose his spot), and a little concerned about Scharenbergs injury history (maybe wait until he is named for his third game)?

      I know that seriously upsets your trades for this week, but all three of your trade ins this week may not be in their respective sides next week (for varying reasons).

      Scharenberg probably has the best JS out of the 3.

      13

      2
  4. Gonna have to move on JJK to get through the byes I think…looking at these two options to provide max bye coverage at discount prices, but who is more likely to be a keeper?

    TU: Lynch (GC) – high BE this week but very cheap
    TD: Wines – also cheap but can he score enough from here to be worth keeping?

    5

    26
  5. I have had enough of Heater Shaw stinking it up.

    This week Fisher , Pickett , Shaw out with Greenwood , Bolton if named , Taylor Adams in.

    T -U Shaw just has to go as his best SC days are behind him.

    T- D Unlikely but , somehow Shaw will turn it around

    12

    31
    1. TDA – As an “owner” I watched Shaw pretty closely on the weekend, and although his SC score didn’t reflect it, he actually looked fit (and played really well).

      Wilson and Williams are obviously affecting his scores, but he still has speed, and he was working right up the ground.

      Couldn’t believe that he scored in the 70’s again when I checked the scores after the game.

      Having said that, I might have been looking through” wishful thinking glasses”!!!

      12

      0
  6. any hawks fans out there reckon t.miles will get a game when he comes back from injury- still have him on sitting not he pine…….

    2

    4
    1. I still have him too but hope to trade him to Bolton this week. Chances of him getting a game later in the year would be pretty slim, with Birchall due back soon and other youngsters like Hardwick performing well.

      2

      0
  7. 80k to trade z.fisher to scott selwood-have 19 trades left
    T/U no brainer do it
    T/D not worth the trade, s.selwood’s a trap

    24

    14
  8. Hey guys,
    Trading Fisher out this week to get 19 on the field (15 trades left),
    I jumped the gun on Greenwood last week (no Ragrets),
    and Iโ€™m trading Eddy for Bolton if heโ€™s not named.
    Should I trade Fisher for
    T/U Scott Selwood
    T/D James Cousins

    16

    4
    1. Selwood has the better job security and the better bye so you would be making more out of him compared to Cousins as i don’t see him playing too many games and then you could possible keep Selwood in M9.

      Plus going early on a basement rookie is not the best of idea’s

      7

      1
    2. I can confirm Eddy has not been named. Hinkley reported in his presser today that at this stage they will go in Unchanged.
      Hinkley even announced his Emergencies at this stage as Palner , Toumpas and , Monfries.

      3

      1
  9. Is everyone going to keep Steele until the end?

    Completed my fwd line early but have realised I will probably need Yeo.

    I can trade Steele or N Riewoldt to him now if I want and will still only have 2 non premos playing. (It will also help me field 18 for my bye this week)

    7

    2
  10. For those looking to bring in Scott Selwood, Jelwood said today that there is a chance that Scott will play a run with role on Sloane this week.

    9

    0
  11. Current Mids…. Dangerfield / Selwood / Kennedy / Fyfe / Trelaor / Beams / Kelly…

    T/U – Sloane
    T/D – Pendles

    Both work well with my byes. Really torn who to get!

    7

    19
    1. Pendles handles a tag – Sloane doesn’t.
      Sloane goes bigger, but Pendles is more consistent.
      Pendles for me.

      13

      1
  12. Tell me I’m an idiot. Been thinking all week to trade Ablett out for pendles or dusty. I bank $60k. Worried about the little mans shoulder and his desire to last out the season with a basket case. It’s obvious his hearts not there and can’t win brownlow. Thoughts

    20

    1
  13. As it stands, I have 15 on field players for this round. My options both involve using 3 trades, are –

    TU: Trade out Hibberd – Roos (non playing), Fisher & J Atley (non playing) for Scharenberg, Greenwood & Cousins – giving me 18 bodies on the field but trading out 3 rookies for 3 rookies
    OR
    TD: Trade out Hibberd – Roos (non playing), Fisher & WHE for Scharenberg, Greenwood & T Lynch – leaving me still a player short but hoping that Lynch’s score would be double that of Cousins. And he’s had his bye.

    6

    11
    1. You are also relying on the fact he gets more games after, this could just turn him into another non playing rookie and just plugged a hole for a week and almost a wasted trade.

      Therefore 2 looks better to me

      2

      1
  14. Looking at my last – hopefully MID spot, and its out of
    TU : Sloane / T Mitchell – both with R13 bye, or
    TD: D Martin R12 – bye is probably better

    8

    9
    1. If you can easily field a team of 18 to round 13 then take sloane/titch. If you are going to be struggling for a full team Martin will be better for that week.

      Without byes in mind I would be taking sloane/titch

      7

      0
  15. Have the opportunity to get Sloane into my team for the final mid premo spot and I really want him before his price skyrockets again. However it would require a 3-way trade of:

    Out: Newman, Fisher, Myers
    In: Scharenberg, Cousins, Sloane

    Completed midfield would then be Danger, Pendles, Jellwood, Kennedy, Bont, Fyfe, Treloar, Sloane. No concern for coverage on the Rd 13 bye. Would leave me with only $15k in the bank and 12 trades. Obviously concerned about bringing in 2 rookies after their second game but is it worth it for bench players anyway?

    8

    1
    1. Cousins is the main concern as his job security is something that could ruin this trade. How many games will he get after his bye??? If you are happy with him doing nothing on the pine, then i say go for it.

      Other minor issue is Myers, he is still making decent money so trading him could be a loss of a fair bit of money, but Sloane can hopefully make up for that with his scoring

      0

      1
      1. Thanks Nato. Just realised I have another option. Could trade:

        Out: Newman, Powell-Pepper, Fisher
        In: Scharenberg, Bolton, Sloane

        Would also bank me $113 and have a dual position player in my mids. Again, Bolton’s job security might also be an issue but all i lose is SPP’s coverage through the byes which shouldn’t be a problem. No Cousins in and no Myers out.

        TU/TD?

        8

        1
  16. It truly is moving week isn’t it. Not sure who to cull at this stage and am thinking of pulling the trigger a little early on some under-ripe cows in order to get some more scoring players for this week as I am severely undermanned.

    Out:Berry, Fisher, Eddy
    In: Scharenberg, S Selwood, Greenwood

    4

    1
  17. Some of you might remember i posted a Team a couple weeks ago that my Brother has set up hoping for a Top 5 overall result for the Round 11 Bye.

    Anyway here is the Team he is running with.

    Backs – Adams , Laird , Z.Williams , Shaw , Mackie , Otten.

    Mids – Danger C , Mitchell VC , Sloane , Pendles , Martin , Josh Kelly , Wines , R.Gray

    Rucks – Mumford , Witts

    Fwds – Yeo , Waite , Nankervis , J.Cameron , Higgins , Walters.

    Once again out of interest

    T – U He has a big show to get a Top 5 overall finish for the Round 11 Bye

    T – D He is Dreaming

    6

    3
  18. Tossing up between 2 trades this week, not sure which to do:

    T/U: Fisher, Balic, Butler OUT
    Sloane, Cousins/bolton, greenwood IN (114/100k in the bank)

    T/D: Newman, Balic, Butler OUT
    Adams, S.Selwood. Greenwood IN (177k in the bank)

    11

    2
    1. or, i can do
      Newman, Barrett, WHE OUT
      Adams, Sloane, Greenwood IN (hopefully butler is named so i can do this)

      Like this comment if you think this is better

      13

      0
  19. Thoughts on these trades?

    OUT: JJK, Barrett, Berry
    IN: Lynch (GC), Wines, Scharenberg

    TU – do it
    TD – don’t do it

    4

    13
  20. Currently planning this trade:

    Out: Eddy, Powell-Pepper & Berry
    In: Greenwood, Martin & Scharenberg

    By doing this I have the following coverage for the byes:

    Rd11: 19(playing)/30
    Rd12: 25/30
    Rd13: 19/30

    T/U – Do It
    T/D – Don’t Do It

    6

    0
  21. Balic, Berry & Fisher > Greenwood,Bolton & Scott Selwood.
    means I can go Marchbank > Doc next week

    T/U – Go for it
    T/D – Nah

    8

    1
  22. Is anyone else struggling to field a backline for r13? If I trade Newman to Scharenberg I’m left with 1 starter. Doc in for Otten will make it 2. Thinking I’ll have to sideways Shaw to Lloyd just to get another starter. Are there any rookies with a non r13 bye I’m not seeing?

    3

    1
        1. Hmmm…. Defender rookies have been hard to come by this year at certain times. I am in a similar position to you but already have Doc Hibberd and still have Stewart. I have been looking to upgrade my rookies as I have found no option to downgrade them to.

          So maybe you might need to downgrade elsewhere to upgrade the defenders?

          0

          0
  23. This weeks trades:

    Newman ->Adams
    Fisher -> Scott Selwood
    WHE – > Greenwood

    Gives me 200k for next week.

    Tu good
    TD bad

    18

    0
  24. With Archie Smith now featuring the Brisbane squad this may bring down S. Martin scoring. With Stef Martin only getting 62 on the weekend and having the bye now should we consider trading him out?

    TU: Martin will drop heavily with Archie Smith trade him out for Mumford/ Goldstein
    TD: Martin will bounce back and average 100 with Archie Smith in the team

    3

    7
    1. Last year they played Archie because Martin got KOed and needed the help.

      I reckon playign Archie might just have been a way to get him a 2 week rest and he’ll be going mostly solo til the end of the season.

      0

      0
  25. I’ve traded out Parsons, Fisher and Myers for Strdnica, S Selwood and Greenwood. Its left me with 450k and 16 trades.
    I need 1 premo in backs, it’ll be Newman or Ottens to Docherty.
    1 premo in mids, Selwood to ?
    Got Sandi and witts in the rucks atm.
    2 premos in fwds, Roughy, Petracca and rookies to whoever takes my fancy

    3

    0
    1. For you last mid spot you should be looking at whichever of the following you don’t already have IMO:
      – Bontempelli/Dangerfield/Sloane/Pendlebury
      I would say these are definite top 8 mids you should have by season’s end.

      1

      0
  26. tu pickett and Fisher for Bolton and s selwood (leaves me with 13 trades)
    TD hold
    I should win league game but thinking selwood will be good

    7

    0
  27. Can anyone shed some light on Jack Bowes? He’s in my team and I’m not sure what’s happened to him… If he’s unlikely to play again anytime soon, he probably needs to go.

    1

    0
    1. Was withdrawn last week due to illness. My guess is due to now having the two weeks off (bye + sick), given his age, he may need to have a run in the NEAFL to get match fitness back up.

      2

      0
  28. So both Bolton and Butler have been named. What does that mean for Bolton’s job security? His playing R13 would be grand if he actually plays, and beyond. Love to hear the thoughts of those more aware of the situation in Tigerland.

    Other option is Cousins, who does not seem to be that solid either…..

    1

    1
    1. Father – g’day!!

      I would also love to hear from some Tigers supporters on your query (and on Emma’s query below).

      I am tossing up between the much cheaper Bolton ($117K MID / FWD), and Scooter Selwood ($281K / MID).

      The extra money saved by bringing in Bolton would be lovely for some upgrades (Bont / J Lloyd / Docherty), but Bolton would need to play at least Rounds 13 and 14 to make it worth the trade IMO.

      Who else do Richmond have to take his place?

      0

      0
      1. Smart move this week by Richmond. 1 tall and 5 smalls. If you look at the North Defenders, other than Williams(?) none are particularly quick so they will be hoping the ball will come to ground or get it in quick so the smalls can do the damage.

        Don’t see Richmond continuing with that set up so one would have to make way.

        5

        0
  29. TU – Barrett, Berry, Balic – Perryman, S Selwood, Greenwood
    TD – Barrett, JJK, Balic – Greenwood, S Selwood, Lynch

    0

    6
  30. Already committed to Eddy-> Greenwood
    Am thinking of doubling down
    Pickett–> Bolton
    WHE –> Yeo

    I have 18 playing this week, and 19 for R13. This gives me 2 extra players in R13, will be left with 16 trades and $300k in the bank.

    TU – pull the trigger
    TD – hold fire

    4

    0
  31. Juswt going for leagues lads so byes are not an issue
    Newman – adams
    Barret – greenwood
    Balic – s selwood
    leaves with 12 trades
    or
    barret – greenwood
    toranto – sloan
    leaves 13 trades
    what do we think of these trades guys, torn on selwood or not..

    4

    4
  32. Balic Newman Williamson for J Selwood S Selwood Greenwood Thumbs up
    (Means I have to switch both my D/Ms Berry and Hibbert to defense and down to 18 trades. Sitting in top 4 in league 7-1. Need to make these trades to be an even chance to win my league game )

    Thymns down hold and just bring in Greenwood.

    4

    0
  33. Should I trade Bowes out for Brodie?? Bowes has made me some money but it doesn’t look like he is getting any games.

    0

    0
  34. TU – JJK, Barrett, Balic to Lynch, S Sellwood, Greenwood
    TD – JJK, Balic, Strnadica to J Selwood, Greenwood, Bolton

    1

    2

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *