How we trading this week? Have a luxury trade to move on an underperforming premium? Locking in your final upgrade? Using a set aside injury trade?
2
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Trade Talk Rd17
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Got 3 left and 78 K to spend.Probably use 2 this round, but not sure for who. Would Simpkin be a definite out? Maybe something along the lines of
Simpkin Wicks out for
TU Petracca ,Greaves in
TD Macrae Greaves in
Would love to plan a fancy upgrade, but with Doc, Williams and Simpkin to deal with it’s more likely I’ll be swapping players instead. Again!
Hopefully 2 of Williams , Simpkin and Docherty play as I need to trade J Martin as well
Hey Chillo, any injury issue with Doc or just his scoring??
Calf strain. Not on the official injury list so I guess it’s not too bad, but I imagine he’ll have to get through some sort of test to play this week.
Thanks!
TU: Neale
TD: Macrae
BOTH!!!!
I’ve got trades but what’s the point given the rubbish I keep getting from so-called premiums…
go with form players
TU:
Rivers —> Greaves
Wicks —> Selwood
TD:
Rivers —> Greaves
Wicks —> Acres
1 trade left – so do i get rid of
T/u Jack Martin
T/D Docherty
???
What’s wrong with doc?
TU: Boak
TU M. Crouch
Whoops can’t afford Macrae
TU Petracca
TD Dunkley
Tu; Toby Greene
Td; Charlie Dixon
Leaning towards Dixon, plays the dons this week
Dons give up the third most points of any team. If you’re playing for League and need a sure fire this week, I think Dixon is the way to go.
It’d be your call on how he goes in Rd 18.
TU Lachie Hunter
TD Taylor adams
also will docherty and simpkin play?
Hi All,
In preliminary finals for both my leagues and need one last upgrade for my defender spot.
TU Ryan
TD Haynes
Comment: Anyone else.
Have Lloyd,Laird,Ridley,Stewart,Docherty.
Thank you everyone. Ryan it is
So this for last mid then full premo
TU: Draper,Wicks > J.Dunkley, M.Lynch
TD: Draper,Wicks > S.Menegola ,M.Lynch
Comments other players
Need to burn by last 2 trades this week, I’m taking the punt that Williams is more of chance to play over Simpkin.
TU
Draper -> Olivr/Steele/Danger/Boak/Crouch/Merrett/Adams (via B.Williams DPP)
Simpkin -> Coleman (Will have to emergency loop between him and Riccardi)
Just not sure which premo mid has the best schedule/form running home.
Forgot to do a TD lol
TD
Other option is to take the punt and assume both of Williams/Simpkin play
Draper -> Mcluggage (via DPP)
Riccardi -> Coleman
Best Fwd to get for Simpkin ? Already have Martin , Greenwood , Smith , petracca
Cheers
Brayshaw’s pretty cheap. Whit will dominate Melb. If you have no cash and need a straight swap, Greene will also destroy Melb.
Probably need to trade Zilliams out if he doesnt get up.
TD: Daniels (no cash left over)
TU: Rich (use the extra money for hopefully 2 luxury upgrade next week)
Comments: Short or others around similar coin
What are the SCT Community’s thoughts on the Crows’ Elliott Himmelberg? Genuinely found his spot and form, or just the best two games he’ll ever have?
T/D: A cheap POD
T/D: Stay away, hes covering for someone/(other tangible reason)/etc
Hi Community,
Rankine to
TU: Wingard (More mid time with Worpal out)
TD: Rozee (+30k, and over his heel injury)
Hi BB,
I’ve run with Rozee, started the season amazingly and then I guess was hampered by his heel injury. Looks as though he’s coming along nicely and at his current price makes a great F7.
Very hard to ignore the price Joestar
J Kelly
TU: Upgrade him to Neale
TD: Bite the bullet and back him to pull up fit?
Last 2 trades…
Trading out Jack Martin & Draper
TU
Bring in Blake Acres & Wingard/LDU…
Best of what I can afford…
TD Bring in rookie, leave riccardi @ F6 & tom hawkins/Dusty
Best mid under $500,000?
TU – Parker
TD – Viney
Selwood worth a cheeky trade at $375,000?
TU – better options available
TD – yep worth a roll of the dice
Is Steele too exxy now to get in?
Need R2 have $519k
T/U: ROB + no cash to use with last trade
T/D: English + $80k odd to use with my last trade next week
Filling out my last 2 fwds
TU: Greenwood + Wingard
TD: Whitfield/Hawkins +102Ker (Keep Riccardi / Coleman Loop at F6)
If taking TD I’d the upgrade F6 next week
Playing purely for leagues..
I have to play one of wicks/Schoenberg in mids,or Close in fwd line..
So TU wicks /sch to Neale
Td Close to Andy Brayshaw or another fwd under 550k
side is full premo** – have Z Williams
TU –> Williams to Laird
TD –> Rivers to Daniel (loophole Z Williams in my backline)
How many trades have you got left after making this? Also any other issues with your squad?
i will have 1 trade after this
Cripps is my worst mid
Simpkin my worst fwd
Going Rivers/Wicks to Greaves/Coleman for cash and backup as I already have $102K players in D8 & F8. No playing rookies in M10/M11
Assuming Simpkin is out, need a replacement FWD
TU: Greenwood
TD: R Gray
Comment: Brayshaw
Who to trade for Neale?
Current midfield Bont, Macrae,Oliver, Mitchell, Kelly, Fyfe, Duncan, Cripps
Trade out:
T/U Cripps
T/D Duncan
Have got 4 trades and $378k. Sitting around 2,000th but focused on winning league now. Main targets are Neale (traded him out for danger when he had his bye), petracca and greenwood. I’m $3k short of being able to go Simpkin and rankine for neale and greenwood (F$#K!). So my options are:
T/U – Greenwood and petracca in
T/D – neale in, downgrade Draper to a $102k ruckman…cross my fingers and load up for next week
Cheers!
TU Daniel Rich
TD Nick Coffield
Thanks Coaches
I’m full premo except for Rankine. Worried about Docherty under an injury cloud, only backline coverage is Cottrell at D7.
TU – Rankine to Hawkins – go hard or go home!
TD – Wait til Sunday teams named, if Doc plays then Rankine to Greenwood, if Doc misses then Doc to Daniel
Draper > Conroy
Gives me $269k and 2 trades left
Who do I upgrade?
Tu: Simpkin/D Smith > Premo mid (133k to upgrade next week)
Td: Nicnat > Gawn (189k left to upgrade next week)
Just thinking grand final at this stage. Final 2 trades…
T/U – McGrath/Close > Greenwood/Josh J Kennedy
T/D – McGrath/Wicks > Sloane or JP Kennedy/O. McInerney
Copped the Simpkin, Docherty & Williams issues. Should I pull the trigger on Doc to Duggan early, or wait for news?
T/U – Doc to Duggan
T/D – Pass, and wait for news
What is the issue with Doc?
1 Trade left will hold for the week unless Williams, Simpkin is out
$9k ITB, 3 trades left, 2 rookies on field (mosquito and riccardi). Have made peace with the fact I won’t be getting to full premo, and I have zero forward bench coverage.
definite outs are Draper and Mosquito, and one in is Conroy, which leaves me with 457k to play with.
Who’s going to be the best forward to bring in at that price? Options I’m looking at include Dixon, Powell-Pepper, Walters, D Smith, and Balta.
I have Z. Williams, H.Andrews, S.Docherty J.Kelly, J.Simpkin… who is not gonna play out of these?? Fml
Andrews definitely out, the rest not sure yet
Who’s the best forward under $430k?
TU – Danger
TD – Boak
Comment – Adams
I feel like Boak has the best run home
I don’t mind Adams
I actually had him prior to his bye, great POD, but am cautious about him copping some attention unless Treloar makes a comeback
3 trades left, playing for league 330k. No injuries
Upgrading D Smith to Brayshaw – locked in.
Second trade option:
Doch/Crisp to Haynes or Ryan -likely Haynes as it leaves cash to do Cog to Oliver in the GF week.
Opponent has Haynes, no one in Prelims has Ryan.
TU: Crisp or Doch out and Haynes In (crisp unique). have cash to do Oliver following week.
TD: Bring in Ryan (unique) and miss out on Cogs to Oliver (could do crippa or duncan instead)
Any comments appreciated. Thanks legends
Can anyone confirm why Doc is in doubt?
Fake news not on Cartlon’s injury list. Jack Martin has cooked Calf
Thanks Nateo!
Couldn’t find anything either.
Saw on Twitter he underwent scans on his calf. Low Grade calf injury – not ruled out, test later in the week..
who will do better the next 2 games
TU: Cripps
TD: Parker
TU: Greenwood
TD: Dunkley
Last mid;
TU: Hunter
TD: Lyons
If I had the bank to do Nic Nat to Gawn in one move I would, but it’ll take me two moves and I think my two biggest problems are Simpkin and Rankine (maybe Doc? ugggghhh). I have bench coverage in Mids and Def, none in the Fwds unless Skinner or Foot get named again (possible?). Not quite enough in the bank to do a worthwhile trade in one move so leaning to T/U for the upside.
T/U – Simpkin and Wicks to Adams/Lyons/Boak
T/D – Rankine and Wicks to Parker/Gray/Wingard
Hi all, preliminary final week lets go!!, Almost full premo
Last rounds trades were Nic Nat, Close and Cameron > Gawn, Coleman and Conroy
Thinking of downgrading Riccardi and Upgrading wicks, and bringing Hamish Brayshaw and bring in a Premo mid (as i have $733,700 to spend) although this does mean I will field Coleman. But happy for other suggestions!!
DEF: Lloyd, Stewart, Haynes, Ridley, Doc, Daniel (Rivers, Sholl)
MID: Bont, Oliver, Neale, Merrett, Mitchell, JKelly, Cripps, Wicks (Foot, O’halloran, Robertson (lions))
RUC: Gawn, Grundy (Conroy)
FWD: Whitfield, Petracca, Dusty, A.Brayshaw (Freo), Bailey Smith, Riccardi (Coleman, Skinner)
6 trades left, $325,000 in the bank.
Cheers!! and good luck in your prelims
Hey JJ,
Seems like you could go Wicks to someone in the Lyons/Adams/Boak or Riccardi to Greenwood range straight up, then save the second trade to address potential outs for Kelly or Doc.
Good luck!
I could go If I bring in Hamish Brayshaw that would be cover for Jkelly and have Sholl and River covering if Doc should miss.
Yeah go for it, Dunkley or Boak are my two picks. Happy with Coleman at F6, could do a lot worse… then just cash out your last couple of cows in the last two rounds and try to upgrade that F6!
Fos, I believe I may have a problem next week upgrading my F6 as my last bulked cash cows are rivers and sholl.
Amid a gazillion other holes in my team (doubts over Simpkin & Docherty, Witherden on the outer at Lions, poor games by Rankine/Riccardi) I need a replacement tonight for Dom Sheed for my league prelim final (no cover on the bench unless Ruscoe gets a recall). Have a total of $466,700 to spend.
Recommendations?
T/U: Andrew Brayshaw
T/D: Mitch Duncan
Cheers
TU: Brayshaw
TD: Dunkley
I have three trades left, not much money in the kitty and three players I want to upgrade.
Which player do I keep for the rest of the year
TU: Wingard
TD: DBJ
Comment: Jack Martin
TU: Brayshaw
TD: Greenwood
Best Mid or Forward under $560k?
Thinking of Lyons, Duncan or Dunkley but open to any suggestion
Have $516k to spend on final midfielder
TU = Robbie Gray
TD = Touk Miller
Hi all,
In Prelim so it’s do or die. F6 to reach full premo, but only have $460 max. to spend. Who would you select? Any feedback greatly appreciated. Cheers and good luck for this round!
TU: Haynes
TD: Ryan
Cash in on
T/U: Riccardi
T/D: Wicks
Cheers
is Clayton Oliver likely to get tagged by De Boer
Injuries killed me last week, thought i was set and had to trade out McGrath, Williams and Jelly- however I won so now i have a dilemma. 1 trade left, Brad Close on the field. If he plays i might hold but if he gets dropped do I go
TU: Bailey Fritsch
TD: Luke Dalhouse
Funds are limited to 369k as you can probably guess
TU: luke Ryan
TD: Rory laird
Which one is the better option?
TU: J.Lyons
TD: J.Dunkley
Shuey to:
TU: McCluggage
TD: J. Berry
Comment: any other sub $530k MID
Josh Dunkley*
Nice! Consider it Done-kly
😉
$509K to spend on a defender if Williams is out (and Simpkin plays)
TU: Maynard
TD: Daniel
Comment: Crisp (opponent has him, tempted to match)
$470K to spend on Mid/Fwd if Simpkin is out (and Williams plays)
TU: JPK
TD: Lukosius
Comment: Walters (again, opponent has him)
Thanks team!
Wicks to Coleman will have leave me $103K
TU: Simpkin to Gray/Brayshaw/Greenwood and looping Close/Riccardi in F6
TD: Keep Simpkin and trade Riccardi to J Cameron (leftfield)
Looking like Coniglio will be getting dropped according to rumours. Who to get in for him? Can afford anyone
TU: Macrae (opponent has him)
TD: Dunkley/Crouch/Lyons (opponent has neither, will have more cash itb for next week)
Comment: other
Need to make a big move since my opponent had Tim Kelly last night so I am on the back foot already.
Dunkley to his Macrae 😉
Dunkley does seem to hold strong form once he hits it, basing off last year. Is it worth taking a punt on him?
Need to upgrade DSmith or Simpkin
T/U Petracca
T/D Hawkins
Treloar back in this week, looking like a very juicy POD for final 2 games
Need to upgrade Riccardi…will have 605k (just shy of Hawkins). Playing for overall and finals.
TU Dustin Martin
TD Robbie Gray
Comment Bailey Smith or Walters
FWD Line is: Whitfield, Petracca, Greenwood, Brayshaw, D. Smith.
Thanks team!
TU Bailey Smith
TD Walters
TU: Treloar
TD: Dunkley
Comment: Crouch
Playing in prelim
Riccardi is managed and ive got no cover in the forward line
Do i
TU – Riccardi to Acres
TD – Mosquito to Rozee and hope Riccardi comes back next week and i can loophole the two
Trading out Cogs for
TU Viney
TD Walters
Who to trade for cogs (max $570k)
T/U: Petracca
T/D: Lachie Hunter
Comment: other dunkley, Adams
Already have Lyons, Duncan, Gaff
Need some last minute advice:
TU – Bailey Smith
TD – Caleb Daniel