Last Minute Queries – Rd4

Written by Schwarzwalder on April 13 2018

Questions?  Questionables?  Questionability?  Quizzes? Quizzing?  Quizzed?  Quandaries?  Queries?  Queried?  Quagmires?  Q & A?  FAQs? Quick  answers!!

Who to play at M8?  Heard of a late withdrawal somewhere?  Got a tip for VC?  Who will have a big one this week?  Last chance to answer before the Rolling Lockout starts…….

2
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

77 thoughts on “Last Minute Queries – Rd4”

    1. Vice Captains duties this week?

      T/U Dusty v Lions.

      T/D Buddy v Dogs.

      Big shout out to D.Barry for getting dropped and giving me a nice Sunday loophole. 🙂

      5

      2
  1. Will Esava Ratugelea’s performance last week be enough for Chris Scott to stop playing musical rucks and give ER some decent price rises over the next 3-5 weeks?

    Will Josh Kelly be back to 100% next week?

    If you can answer either of those, give me the lotto numbers too because you are physic! 🙂

    5

    2
        1. Bluey, you answer a riddle with a riddle.

          How long is a piece of string? Twice as long as half it’s length! 🙂

          6

          0
          1. Or just confuse:

            This visage, no mere veneer of vanity, is a vestige of the vox populi now vacant, vanished. However, this valorous visitation of a bygone vexation stands vivified, and has vowed to vanquish these venal and virulent vermin, vanguarding vice and vouchsafing the violently vicious and voracious violation of volition

            😉

            10

            1
    1. wait a minute FN.. you’re down to 25 trades already.. hold Zorko for the love of whatever or whoever, you need to distance yourself from that Red T mate..

      26

      0
      1. Haha made some bad life choices unselected rookies, cox, hibbo. Should probably think about my team 5min before the start of the season…

        2

        0
      1. Think Taylor will be 2-3 weeks away with Henderson could be anywhere from 3-10. Chris Scott said that he was wrong to say he turned the corner and will be a few weeks away. – AFL website

        5

        0
        1. Thanks for that. I just wanted to make sure I am making the right decision as I don’t want to be caught up with a rookie that only plays 5 games and I am having to waste a potential 50k for picking the wrong rookie

          1

          0
          1. I’m in the same boat but have convinced myself to go Henry with better scoring and hopefully better JS, especially having Banfield and Brayshaw already from Freo in the mids adds to that.

            6

            1
            1. This is helpful for me also. I was concerned Henderson would be back I the next week or so. Was going to get Richards but will now consider Henry. Maybe both?

              2

              0
  2. Smashed by injuries this week (Kelly, Marchbank, Ryan & Murphy), so considering the following options:

    Marchbank & Ryan (WCE) to either

    TU: Richards & Hogan

    TD: Ryan (FRE) & Henry

    5

    22
  3. Took a chance at the start of the year with Daniher, but has probably been a poorer decision than the correction of the Melbourne Star.

    TU – Trade
    TD – Hold

    Have money to upgrade, who are peoples opinions ? Thanks in advance !

    26

    6
    1. M8 you have to hold now, he is a key position forward so he will have his ups and downs. You just ridden is lows so is surely set for big one soon…

      3

      7
    1. I still think hes worth it in the ruck 4 a few more weeks gives him 70ish not to bad 4 a fwd and then plan to move to backup ruck

      0

      1
  4. With Kelly sidelined, who do I play at M8?

    T/u Banfield and save trade
    T/d Downgrade Graham for Richards (via DPP) and field Finlayson

    Cheers Coaches

    22

    6
  5. Replacement for Ryan,

    TU: Henry (will play on field)

    TD: Richards (via sicily meaning Murray gets field time)

    5

    11
  6. Do i start with fogarty or stephenson for my F6 spot
    (Heeney, Billings, Smith, Fritsch(omitted), Garlett, Henry) Stephenson, fogarty

    1

    0
  7. Coming 170 odd overall, 30 trades left, $245k bank.

    Have Josh Kelly and Liam Ryan.

    Will be trading Ryan to Henry.

    Do I trade:
    T/U: Brayshaw to McLean, (Garlett DPP) spend Bank
    T/D: Kelly to MacRae, save bank

    15

    7
  8. Trading Ryan out

    T/U to Richards via Sicily and playing Murray on field
    T/D to Henry and playing Henry on field

    6

    2
    1. Homer Jay.

      Check the “Trade or Hold” feed.

      Zac Merret has been voted on already.

      Personally I would probably hold if I didn’t own Cogs.

      2

      0
  9. Hi Guys,

    T/U: Ryan > Richards (via Sicily TPP)
    T/D: Ryan & Brayshaw > Henry & Coniglio

    Not enough money to do both Richards and Coniglio (5k short)

    Thanks Guys!

    1

    8
  10. Too much money unused and an underperforming rookie on the bench. So:

    TU: LDU to Greene
    TD: LDU to Gray
    Comment: Walters

    5

    4
  11. I am rethinking trade two and would appreciate your opinion. Liam Ryan out but who comes in?

    Up – Richards via dpp
    Dn – Henry

    1

    7
    1. You asked this yesterday;

      Which rookie is best, keeping in mind I put a high value on js.

      Up – Ed Richards (11 votes)
      Dn – Henry (30 votes)

      If you can’t decide you may have to flip a coin

      5

      4
  12. Missed the Armitage to Cogs trade last week so that is trade #1. Asking for a little help with the second trade
    MID – Danger, Titch, Dusty, J Kelly, Fyfe, Cogs, Holman, T Kelly (Brayshaw, Banfield, Garlett)
    TU: Ryan to Henry (F6 or F7) Banfield to cover Kelly
    TD: Kelly’s gone – trade to premo leaving Ryan and ZGL on FWD bench

    8

    1
  13. Last minute quirey that ive thought about all week!!!

    Etihad Stadium, indoor stadium with retractable roof
    7 games in 2018 for a total of 171 goals & 192 behinds?

    MCG, open stadium
    8 games in 2018 for a total of 231 goals & 174 behinds!

    Does anyone else think this is strange, or is there a strange breeze at Etihad when the roof is open?

    Cheers Catta

    4

    0
    1. Isn’t Etihad oriented very poorly with the sun? Could be that. Slight dimension differences have an impact too.

      0

      0
  14. Late dilemma

    Trade one : Ryan to Henry

    Trade two
    TU: armitage to Richards via finlayson (play Murray and bank the cash)
    TD : armitage to Seedsman
    Comment: leave armitage

    9

    0
  15. Definitely trading Ryan to Henry (or Richards though swinging Sicily around).

    Now that Barry is an out I’m contemplating trading him out, swinging Garlett into the mids, swinging Sicily fwd and getting Richards too.

    Used two trades for the season as an FYI.

    TU – do the double rookie trade
    TD – play conservative and only trade the LTI rookie out (Ryan)

    4

    4
  16. already doing Ryan to Henry trade this week but with Dom Barry out, should I use my second trade to trade him out?
    TU: trade to Richards via Finlayson DPP, field Murray instead
    TD: hold and hope he comes back next week

    0

    4
    1. Number of us are in the same possie. If he’s been dropped from a team that’s 3-0 surely that spells trouble for the next few weeks at least. I’m leaning towards pulling the trigger. At least it doesn’t need to be done tonight.

      3

      0
  17. Sorry if this question is elsewhere but Ryan to:
    T/u – Fog
    T/d – Crowden?

    Comment: someone else (actually have the cash to get Petracca but will leave $4k in the bank… Figure Ryan trade out is for a cash cow only at this point.

    1

    1
    1. Noona

      Henry from the Cats is worth a look.

      Crowden is a pressure player and probably wont make cash fast.
      His DPP does make him more attractive. + FURL factor.

      Henry scored 93 last week. He should see a few nice price rises andd he is Cheap $117K

      4

      0
  18. Channel 7 has won the broadcast rights to the cricket.

    TU: Fine by me.
    TD: Not happy about this.

    Comment: Please tell me BT won’t be commentating…

    5

    3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *