Polling Station – Rd17

Written by Schwarzwalder on July 9 2018

Time again for the Polling Station, where you determine what is posted here at supercoachtalk dot com!

You want a poll on cheap defenders?  This is the place to ask.  You need to know about replacements for your last forward upgrade?  This is the place to ask.

Let us know if there are any polls / discussion threads you want to see ahead of Rd17 and we’ll do our best to get them into the schedule.

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

31 thoughts on “Polling Station – Rd17”

    1. I don’t often gloat about my trade selections but ………. 90K ago he was a cracking good trade. At his current price? Hmm, still probably worth considering with a favourable draw for Port. Definitely worth a poll.

      9

      0
  1. I am unsure about Lloyd now that McVeigh is out with a broken collarbone. Last year McVeigh held back Lloyd. Now, Lloyd has scored well with Mcveigh in the team, so with Mcveigh out, will this mean Lloyd does better or will he drop off?
    Or will Lloyd just stay the same?

    3

    2
  2. How many good substitutes do you have or aiming for in anticipation of injuries etc? I mean guys like Shuey, Petracca, Boak (not Giro, Ahern, Mihocek)

    8

    0
    1. In a similar vein (not that I can afford to trade them now) but if you still have them, are those good rookies like Doedee, Kelly and Fritsch (maybe Ahern too) keepers til the bitter end?!
      Have to say, I am so thankful to still have two of them.

      4

      0
  3. For those of us with f’ all trades left, can we do a poll on the Brownlow, excluding the unbackable Titch.
    eg my one-eyed Pie mate reckons Rusty’s a chance!?
    I need something to spend my winnings on once Belgium have won the World Cup 😉

    4

    0
  4. The gap between Grundy/Gawn and 3rd best (Martin) is over 20 points when looking at averages. If you’re serious about winning league or overall, do you now do whatever it takes to get grundy in?

    7

    0
    1. Good question. I have Martin and Gawn as things stnad with 5 trades and not quite enough to go directly Martin>>Grundy. Do I make 2 trades to bring Grundy in? Both Martin and Grundy have low breakevens so both skyrocketing over the next few weeks….

      4

      0
      1. Martin’s up against the ruckless Hawks next week. Grundy faces NicNat. You can probably afford to wait a week or two as the price gap should narrow in your favour.
        Think the Poll is a good idea in any case.

        7

        1
  5. I wanna know the best MID/FWD bench covers under 530k for the back half of the season.

    Keen to hear the dodgy picks

    2

    1
  6. Will CD be reviewing ruck scoring this year?
    Seems to me that they are massively over compensated for what they do – making the elite ruckman a higher scorer than an elite mid? Jumping up in the air at 8 feet tall to tip a ball 3 yards seems to be over rated 🙂

    Seems to be a bit random as well as you can see some great tap work unrewarded if his mids are not getting the ball

    0

    0
    1. Not really. There are only 2 rucks averaging over 105. They are getting 20+ touches, 3+ tackles, 40+ hitouts, not to mentions goals and clearances each game.
      Compare Grundy to Bont. Same possessions, more contested, more clearances, higher efficiency, more tackles, not to mention the 40+ hitouts per game. Should definitely be scoring 30 more points per game, if not more

      2

      0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *