Rate My MAR Team 3

Written by Schwarzwalder on March 14 2018

We’ve had such an overwhelming response to the RMT threads all pre-season.  With just eight days before The Big Dance, all Coaches are in a rush to get their teams sorted.

Enter your team into the comments below and our Coaches will give you a thorough check-up.  Don’t be afraid to (constructively!) critique your fellow Coaches either………..

5
1


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

170 thoughts on “Rate My MAR Team 3”

  1. Defenders
    Laird Simpson Savage
    Coffield Doedee Finlayson
    (Muarry,Mirra)

    Mids
    Martin,Titch,Kelly, Fyfe,Parker
    Coniglio,Brayshaw (Freo) Brodie
    (Kelly,Barry,Holman)

    Rucks
    Jacobs,Gawn
    (Olango)

    Forwards
    Heeney,Billings,Smith,Petracca
    Giles-Langdon,Fritsch
    (Garlett,Ryan)

    All Feedback welcome
    I have 30k left over
    Hibberd over Simpson ?
    Cripps or Parker ?

    24

    -3
    1. – I’d change Brayshaw / Brodie to Banfield
      – Mirra probably has to go

      Hibberd > Simpson
      Parker > Cripps (if you want the POD)

      6

      1
    2. Nice team, I really like it.
      I have both Cripps and Parker in my team so I can’t really help you there. 🙂 they are both just such good value and good point scorers

      If you can get Hibberd over Simpson then I reckon you do it.
      I noticed in the midfield you have Brodie, who I reckon will be a good pick and make money. However, you already have Brayshaw as an expensive rookie. Maybe you could downgrade one of them to say Banfield who would get you more profit over time since he is cheaper. This way you could use the extra cash from the downgrade to put maybe Savage up to Hibberd or Petracca to Mclean or maybe Jacobs up to Ryder
      I’m going with Ryder now because hopefully come round 10 there will be some miracle ruckmen who plays and takes his place for the round, if not I’m willing to cop the donut that round

      Anyway that’s my feedback, good team and go with your gut

      2

      0
  2. Smash me to bits everyone!!! Wooooo we are soooo damn close!!

    Backs: Laird, Hibberd, H Shaw, Coffield, Naughton, S Murray (Doedee, Finlayson)

    Mids: Danger, Dusty, T Mitchell, Fyfe, Cripps, A Brayshaw, Davis-Uniacke, T Kelly (Banfield,Barry,Holman)

    Rucks: Ryder, Gawn (Olango)

    Forwards: Heeney, Billings, T Mclean, D Smith, Fritsch, L Ryan ( Fogarty, L Keefe)

    3

    4
        1. Grade 1 hamstring strain 3 weeks=21 days
          D-Day:Sunday,March 11
          Round 1:Sunday,March 25 v Melb (MCG) D+14
          Round 2:Monday,April 2 v Hawthorn (MCG) D+22
          Round 3:Sunday,April 8 v West Coast (OS) D+28
          What’s the chance his first game back is round 4 v St Kilda at home?

          3

          1
    1. And you might want to consider, Lloyd, Touhy, Savage or Sicily at around the same price instead of Shaw,
      Go with your gut but I personally have them over Shaw

      4

      2
      1. yeh heata was deffs a 50 50 for me, i think ill change him to a LLoyd who i had last year and he was pretty consistent…Im still not sold on savage and sicily who everyone seems to have jumped on board!

        2

        0
      2. Brandon Ellis and Jeremy McGovern can also be had for a similar price. Both are durable, have good recent scoring history, and are surprisingly unpopular. McGovern also has a handy round 12 bye.

        1

        1
  3. Nathan’s Gunz v????

    Thoughts lads?

    Laird, Hibberd, Simpson, Coffield , Doedee, Murray, (Finalyson, Murphy)

    Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, Conigilio, Brayshaw, Kelly (Banfield , Barry, Holman)

    Jacobs, Gawn (Olango)

    Heeney, Billings, Mclean, Sicily, Fogarty, Fritsch (Garlett, Ryan)

    Conerns i have are Fogarty does he get a spot once Tex comes back so i guess he’s just a place holder for now & Jacobs/Simmo not really setting the JLT games on fire. Not to mention 1.5k banked

    1

    4
  4. My team seemed to change after every JLT game but now I am fairly happy with it
    Only a few premo picks I’m unsure so I would like some feedback on that

    DEFS- Laird, Touhy (maybe Lloyd), Sicily, Naughton, Murray, Finlayson (Doedee, Mirra)

    MIDS- Danger, Mitchell, Kelly, Fyfe, Parker, Cripps, Brayshaw, Banfield (Kelly, Barry, Holman

    RUCKS- Ryder, Gawn (Olango) probably will become Cameron just in case

    FWDS- Heeney, Mclean, Smith, Petracca, Keeffe, Fritsch (Ryan, Rioli)

    I’m fairly like I said just need some feedback on a few premiums like Tuohy, my forward picks, Ryder and obviously Dangerman

    I honestly reckon if Danger misses the week I’m gonna pull a Motts Maneuver (I think that’s the right context) and put him on the bench for the week and take a rookie score. I’m only going for league wins not the overally ranking so this will work as we don’t vs anyone in the first two weeks. this saves me trades and the hassle of getting him back. Unless of course the injury is 3+ weeks if this is the case I will go down to Coniglio or Merrett.

    With Ryder I’m just going to cop the 0 in round 10. I’m just hoping that come round 10 some miracle rookie ruckmen (Cameron??) will come out and play, much like Sean Darcy at the backend of last year

    Finally Tuohy or Lloyd.
    I’m going to put it simply Lloyd can’t score with McVeigh, Newman and Rampe around him which is a shame. That’s why I’m leaning towards Touhy but if there is a chance to trade Lloyd in later on I will

    Any feedback would be greatly appreciated

    3

    3
      1. Rioli?
        Yeah more of a place holder until round 1 rookies come out seriously considering putting him up to Fogarty again depending on team selections

        2

        0
  5. Hey guys made a few changes still a guns and rookie setup

    DEF: Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Naughton, Murray, Dodee (Mira, Finlayson)

    MID: Dusty, Twitch, Kelly, Sloane, Fyfe, Hall, Kelly, Barry (Holman, Brodie, Uniacke)

    RUC: Jacobs, Gawn (Cameron)

    FWD: Franklin, Billings, McClean, Fritsch, Ryan, Keefe (Rioli, Waterman)

    $250k in the bank to go Hall, who I believe will strive without Gazza, straight to danger

    6

    1
    1. Take out a mid premo and put in another fwd premo, need to account for what position rookies will be playing in!

      2

      0
  6. B: Laird, Hibberd, Simpson, Coffield, Naughton, Doedee (Murray, Murphy)
    M: Danger, TMitch, MCrouch, Fyfe, Cripps, Brayshaw, Kelly, Finlayson (Banfield, Barry, Holman)
    R: Gawn, Jacobs (Olango)
    F: Buddy, Heeney, Billings, Dahl, Keefe, Miers (Fritsch, Ryan)

    1

    2
    1. Save Franklin for an upgrade target (they play the hardest teams in before the bye, will most likely go down in price)

      5

      0
  7. DEF; Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Coffield, Naughton, Doedee (Murray, Finlayson)

    MID; Dusty, Kelly, Fyfe, Bont, Parker, Jaegar, Brayshaw, Brodie (Kelly, Shipley, Holman)

    RUCK; Gawn, Nic Nat (Olango)

    FWD; Heeney, Walters, Smith, Trac, Bell, Keeffe (Fristch, Ryan)

    $64.9k
    Savage and Sicily have been in and out,
    Bont could become any of the other mids as I am the least sold on him.
    Jaegar or Bell will become a rookie if Nic Nat isn’t good to go

    Pull it apart please.

    2

    0
    1. I don’t think you can justify having Jaeger, Brayshaw and Brodie in your midfield. Perhaps downgrade Brayshaw or Brodie (Banfield / Barry)

      Don’t mind the Bell pick, but depends what you are expecting from him, he will most likely average 70-85 but i suppose that’s the risk you are taking!

      1

      0
  8. DEF: Laird, Hibberd, B.Ellis, Naughton, Murray, Doedee, (Finlayson, Keefe)

    MID: Dusty, Titch, Zorko, Fyfe, Cripps, J.Graham, Brayshaw, Banfield, (T.Kelly, Barry, Holman)

    RUCK: Gawn, Nank (Cameron)

    FWD: Billings, Lambert, McLean, Smith, Fogarty, Fritsh, (Garlett, Ryan)

    245.6k in the bank.

    Rookies due to change of course.
    Not sure on some players such as Ellis, Nank and Graham (clear Tigers fan), but not sure who are sensible replacements.
    Thoughts and Suggestions are appreciated, thanks.

    1

    4
  9. Dunno about the Def and leaving out Dangerfield
    Def – Laird, Hibberd, Sicily, Coffield, O’Shea, Murray (Doedee, Mirra)

    Mid – Martin, Tich, Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, A Brayshaw, T Kelly, Berry (Finlayson, Ahern, Holman)

    Ruck – Ryder & Gawn (Cameron)

    Foward – Heeney, Billings, Walters, Smith, Petracca, Garlett (Fritsch, L Ryan)

    1

    0
    1. If O’Shea doesn’t play because of only 1 quarter in the whole JLT you can get Naughton at the exact same price

      1

      0
  10. DEF:
    Laird, Hibberd, McGovern
    Coffield, Naughton, Finlayson
    (Finlayson, Doedee)
    MID:
    Mitchell, Zorko, Neale, Fyfe
    Parker, Coniglio, Brodie, Barry
    (Kelly, Holman, Banfield)
    RUCK:
    Gawn, Nankervis
    FWD:
    Heeney, Billings, Mclean
    Smith, Fritsch, Giles-Langdon
    (Ryan, Rose)

    3

    2
  11. DEF
    R.Laird, M.Hibberd, J.Sicily, A.Naughton, T.Doedee, J.Finlayson
    (S.Murray, L.Murphy)

    MID
    D.Martin, T.Mitchell, J.Kelly, N.Fyfe, P.Cripps, S.Coniglio, A.Brayshaw, T.Kelly
    (B.Banfield, D.Barry, N.Holman)

    RUC
    S.Jacobs, M.Gawn
    (D.Cameron)

    FWD
    I.Heeney, J.Billings, D.Smith, C.Curnow, A.Christensen, B.Fritsch
    (J.Garlett, L.Ryan)

    $9,800 in the bank.

    4

    0
  12. Def: Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Naughton, Murray, Doedee (Finlayson, Mirra)
    Mid: Martin, Mitchell, Fyfe, Cripps, Sidebottom, Liberatore, Armitage, Brayshaw (freo) (Banfield, Kelly, Holman)
    Ruck: Jacobs, Gawn (Olango)
    Fwd: Heeney, Mclean, Smith, Petracca, Garlett, Fritsch (Venables, Ryan)

    $38k left

    Thoughts?

    0

    4
  13. DEFFENDERS –
    R.Laird, M.Hibberd, J.Howe, N.Coffield, A.Naughton, S.Murray.
    (J.Finlayson, T.Doedee)

    MIDFIELDERS –
    D.Martin, T.Mitchell, J.Kelly, Z.Merrett, P.Cripps, T.Liberatore, A.Brayshaw(Feo), T.Kelly.
    (B.Banfield, D.Barry, N.Holman)

    RUCKS –
    M.Gawn, T.Nankervis.
    (D.Cameron)

    FORWARDS –
    J.Billings, T.McLean, D.Smith, T.Bell, D.Fogarty, L.Keefe.
    (L.Ryan, B.Fritsch)

    $173.8K in the bank.

    Would love any feedback.
    Think I’m pretty happy with this. One thing I’m thinking is maybe Howe to Sicily but not sure if it’s worth it just for a couple more $. or even McLean to Franklin, but once again I’m pretty torn atm.

    3

    0
  14. Hurley, Laird, Hibberd, O’Shea, Doedee, Mirra (Murray, Cumming)

    Mitchell, Kelly, M.Crouch, Merrett, Fyfe, Brayshaw, Brodie, Finlayson (Banfield, Kelly, Holman)

    Jacobs, Gawn (Cameron)

    Heeney, Billings, Dahlhaus, Smith, Keeffe, Fritsch (Ryan, Venables)

    $138,800 left
    Unsure on who to use at F3?
    Did have Danger until the weekend

    3

    0
  15. Awaiting the Danger results but in the meantime….

    Def: Laird, Hibberd, Sicily, Coffield, Doedee, Murray (Naughton, Finlayson)

    Mid: Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Zerrett, Fyfe, Cripps, Brayshaw (fre0), Holman (Banfield, Kelly, Barry)

    Ruck: Martin, Gawn (Cameron)

    Fwd: Heeney, Billings, Smith, Taberner, Keefe, Fritsch (Garlett, Ryan)

    Thoughts?

    Tossing up between Bell and Taberner, also whether to go Sandilands instead of Martin or otherwise Cox or Lycett to upgrade elsewhere?

    1

    3
  16. All input is appreciated.
    I have $337K in the bank and I really don’t know where to spend it as I previously had danger but traded him for armo!
    Def: Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, Doedee, Naughton, Keefe (Murray, Finlayson)

    Mid: Martin, Mitchell, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Armo, Brayshaw, Kelly (Banfield, Worpel, Holman)

    Ruc: Goldstein, Gawn (Olongo)

    Fwd: Heeney, Billings, McLean, Smith, Garlett, Fritisch (Ahearn, Ryan)

    1

    2
  17. Any suggestions to make my team better?

    Def – laird,hibberd,tuohy
    Naughton,murray,doedee
    (mihocek,murphy)

    Mid – dusty,mitchell,kelly,merrett,fyfe
    parker,brayshaw,finlayson
    (T.kelly,banfield,holman)

    Ruck – Martin,gawn
    (orlango)

    For – Franklin,billings,Smith
    Bell,keefe,fritsch
    (giles-langdon,ryan)

    3

    1
  18. Right here it is, just read that Danger has suffered a slight hamstring strain and has not been ruled out for Round 1 as of yet, positive signs. What does everyone think of this team?
    DEF: Laird, Simpson, Ellis, Saad, Coffield, Doedee (Murray, Finlayson)

    MID: Danger, Titch, Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, Libba, Dow, T Kelly (Starcevich, Fogarty GEE, Holman)

    RUC: Gawn, Lycett (Cameron)

    FOR: Heeney, Walters, Mclean, Bundy, Ahern, Fritsch (Garlett, Ryan)

    $96,200 in the bank

    What do we think??

    2

    4
  19. Catta’s Clan … mk6

    Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, Naughton, Doedee, Finlayson ( emg Murray & Mirra )

    Martin, Mitchell, J Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Brayshaw, Banfield
    ( emg Barry, T Kelly, Holman )

    Gawn, Jacobs ( emg Cameron )

    Heeney, Billings, McLean, D Smith, Keeffe, Fritsch ( emg Garlett & Ryan )

    $14k in the bank & Mirra as my VC loophole

    Cheers Catta

    8

    0
  20. Any suggestions?

    Def: Roberton, Laird, Shaw, Coffield, Finlayson, Murray (Naughton, Doedee)

    Mid: Mitchell, Sloane, Fyfe, Ross, Cripps, Coniglio, Brayshaw, Kelly (Banfield, Barry, Holman)

    Ruck: Grundy, Gawn

    Fwd: Dahlhaus, Heeney, Sicily, Petracca, Fogarty, Frisch (Keefe, Ryan)

    $160k In the Bank

    0

    3
  21. DEF – laird, hibberd, shaw, coffield, doedee, finlayson (murray, payne)

    MID – danger, martin, mitchell, j kelly, fyfe, coniglio, brayshaw, banfield (t kelly, barry, holman)

    RUCK – gawn, jacobs (cameron)

    FOR – heeney, billings, smith, christensen, keeffe, frisch (j garlett, l ryan)

    any ideas / suggestions would be great. thanks.

    1

    1
  22. Hi SCT Community,

    Happy to hear what you think.
    Have Danger but will wait to the last minute and if I need to change to Oliver as a straight swap. Also have Marley Williams NM. They’ll see a lot of the ball down back.

    Def: Laird, Hibberd, M Williams (NM), Naughton, Doedee, Murray (O’Shea, Finlayson)

    Mid: Danger, Mitchell, Zerrett, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Brayshaw (Freo), Holman (Banfield, Kelly, Barry)

    Ruck: Gawn, Sandilands then Ryder after his bye (Olango)

    Fwd: Heeney, Billings, Waltrers, Smith, Keefe, Fritsch (Giles-Langdon, Ryan)

    Thanks all.

    3

    0
  23. GangstaGuru’s V6 (and may be my final version before the season kicks off)

    DEF – R. Laird, M. Hibberd, J. Lloyd, N. Coffield, T. Doedee, J. Finlayson (S. Murray, L. Murphy)
    MID – D. Martin, T. Mitchell, D. Zorko, N. Fyfe, P. Cripps, S. Coniglio, A. Brayshaw, D. Fogarty (T. Kelly, D. Barry, N. Holman)
    RUC – M. Gawn, T. Nankervis (D. Cameron)
    FWD – I. Heeney, M. Walters, K. Lambert, D. Smith, B. Fritsch, L. Ryan (L. Keeffe, J. Garlett)

    $66.2K remaining

    With Lambert and Nank, I’m liking where both of these guys are heading. Nank looked on fire last week, and with another good pre-season he’ll probably last a fair bit longer this year than what he did in the previous season. Lambert averaged around 95-100 after he came back half way through last year, and looked very switched on in the two JLT games.

    3

    0
  24. I would appreciate any feedback on the following selections.

    B – Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, Naughton, Finlayson, Murray (Doedee, Coffield)

    C – Dangerfield, Martin, Mitchell, Crouch, Fyfe, Coniglio, Brayshaw, Banfield (Kelly, Barry, Holman)

    R – Martin, Gawn (Cameron)

    F – Billings, Mundy, D Smith, Fogarty, Keefe, Fritsch (Garlett, Ryan)

    Remaining Salary $100,700

    Pending the Danger factor of more than one week a trade to Kelly and a balance of $221,900 in the bank might be an option.

    All comments welcome.

    2

    0
    1. Nice well balanced team. Maybe think about switching out Coffield for Naughton, as there are alreaDy a few players who will perform a similar role.
      Also get rid of Dangerfield

      2

      2
  25. After crossing my whole team off and beginning again from scratch, this is what I’ve come up with:

    $130.8k left

    Def: Laird, Hibberd, Simpson, Naughton, Doedee, Murray (Finlayson, Murphy)

    Mid: Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Brayshaw, Banfield (Barry, Kelly, Holman)

    Ruc: Martin, Gawn (Cameron)

    Fwd: Heeney, Billings, Smith, Christensen, Fogarty, Fritsch (Keefe, Ryan)

    I think I can speak for most people when I say that Laird and Hibberd are going to be the 2 Mr Consistencies in the Defence this year. Kade Simpson has had an up and down start to the JLT series, but it’s just JLT right? I’m torn between Naughton and Coffield for my D4, and Doedee/Murray are the locks if the latter is named, along with Lachlan Murphy.

    Dusty is my downgrade from Danger, and I feel like this is going to be where the money is made, with Fyfe, Cripps and Coniglio starting underpriced.

    Lachlan Keefe will probably go once the round 1 teams are named, and I hope that Garlett will return to be a possible downgrade option.

    Please give some feedback

    8

    0
  26. Any feedback would be great, i have gone with 3 lock defenders, 5 lock mids, 2 lock rucks and 4 lock forwards who i believe will be in the best 6-8 of their position at seasons end.
    This team is minus Danger.

    Def: Laird, Hibberd, Howe, Naughton, Doedee, Murray (Coffield, Finlyason)

    Mids: Martin, T.Mitchell, J Kelly, M. Crouch, Fyfe, Brayshaw, Barry, Banfield (LDU, Kelly, Holman)

    Rucks: Ryder, Gawn (Olango)

    Forwards: Heeney, Billings, T.Mclean, D.Smith, Stephenson/Fogarty not sure yet, Fritsch (LRyan, (undecided on last rookie choice)

    51.4 k in the bank

    1

    0
  27. DEF: Laird, Hibbard, Savage, Coffield, Naughton, Murray (dodee, finlayson)

    Mid: Dusty, Titch, Fyfe, cripps, whitfield (think could be a good pod), Rayner, Brayshaw, Brodie (banfield, Kelly, holman)

    Ruck: Kruezer and Gawn (olando)

    FWD: Menegola, Greene, Billings, Smith, Fogarty, Fritch (Keefe, Ryan)

    60k

    2

    1
  28. Def – Laird, Hibberd, Rampe, Coffield, Finlayson, Naughton (Murray, Doedee)

    Mid – Fyfe, Menegola, Hannebery, Cripps, Coniglio, Liberatore, Petraccca, O’Meara (Barry, Fogarty)

    Ruck – Gawn, Naitanui (Cameron)

    Fwd – Heeney, Lynch, Sicily, Christensen, Fritsch, Ryan (Garlett, W.Rioli)

    Really struggling to cement a squad.
    Happy for some feedback.

    1

    6
    1. Few interesting PODs there…. not sure Menegola will have such a productive year this time around. Probably would need to add some midfield rookies for cash generation mate!

      3

      0
  29. Hi everyone, first of all I want to say thanks for all the hard work that goes into providing us all the valuable info to make us better SuperCoaches. Much appreciated!

    I’ve been tinkering with my team for a while now based on all the info posted on here. Here is what I think will be my final team to start with. I do understand that Dangerfield might be gone for a week or so and depending on what happens with him, I might keep him and use a rookie score or I’ll bring in Kelly (GWS) instead.

    Please feel free to rip into my team as all positive and negative feedback is always welcomed.

    Defenders
    R Laird, M Hibberd, J Lloyd, (S Murray)
    J Kelly, A Naughton, T Doedee, (L Keeffe)

    Mids
    Dangerfield, D Martin, T Mitchell, (J Finlayson)
    N Fyfe, P Cripps, A Brayshaw, (T Kelly)
    B Banfield, N Holman, (D Barry)

    Rucks
    S Jacobs, M Gawn, (T Olango)

    Forwards
    I Heeney, J Billings, T McLean, (J Garlett)
    J Caddy, Z Giles-Langdon, B Fritsch (L Ryan)

    $46k left in the bank.

    2

    1
  30. Hey lads, any feedback on HODLgang? I’ve got Danger in at the moment as I don’t feel he’ll miss much footy (if at all). And I’d love Rocky’s fragile body to hold up of course. Only got 38k in the bank. Cheers:)

    DEF:
    Roberton, Rance, Tuohy, Shaw, Naughton, Doedee. (O’Shea, Murray).

    MID:
    Dangerfield, Fyfe, Beams, Cripps, Rockliff, Brayshaw (FREO), Davies-Uniacke, Coffield. (T.Kelly, Barry, Holman)

    RUCK:
    Goldstein, Gawn. (Cameron)

    FWD:
    Heeney, Wingard, Petracca, Young, Christensen, Keeffe. (Fritsch, Ryan).

    1

    3
  31. Does anybody remember Linda Blair from the Exorcist movie and the scene where her head just spins round and round.
    That’s how I am feeling at the moment with a bit of information overload and trying to keep abreast of of the Supercoach news.
    My latest incarnation is as follows:

    Backs: Laird, Loyd, Savage, Brayshaw, Doedee & Murray (Naughton Finlayson)

    Mids: Martin, Mitchell, Cripps, Fyfe, Coniglio, Libba, Kelly, Barry (Ahern, Banfield, Holman)

    Rucks: Goldy & Gawn (Olango)

    Forwards: Heeney, Walters, Smith, Barlow, Christensen, Ryan (Venables Fritsch)

    Just over $48K in the bank

    Whilst not necessarily PODS picking Barlow, Goldy, Walters, Libba, Brayshaw & Venables gives me at least a bit of difference to other teams.

    Feedback appreciated – even thumbs up/down

    1

    4
  32. backs: hurley, touhy, shaw, A. brayshow (melb), doedee, murray (coll)
    bench: o’shae and mirra

    mids: titch, kelly, fyfe, bont, pendlebury, cripps, whitfield, dow
    bench: kelly (geelong), barry, holman,

    rucks: M. Gawn and naitanui
    bench d. cameron
    forwards: robbie gray, k. lambert, j. townsend, j. higgins, p. Ahern, b. fritsch
    bench: j. garlett and l. ryan

    i have $13,400 in the bank any feedback is welcome
    i know j garlett is injured aswell
    cheers

    0

    5
  33. Def:
    Laird, hibberd, sicily, naughton, finlayson, murray (coffield, doedee)

    Mid:
    Mitchell, zerret, neale, fyfe, cripps, coniglio, brodie, banfield (garlett, holman, t.kelly)

    Ruck:
    Ryder, gawn (cameron)

    For:
    Billings, mclean, smith, petracca, christensen, fritsch (keefe, ryan)

    3

    0
  34. Def- Laird, hibberd, sicily, naghton, finlayson, murray (doedee, murphy)
    Md- Mitchell, Kelly, Zorko, Fyfe, Parker, Cripps, Brayshaw, Barry (Banfield, Kelly, Holman)
    R- Martin, Gawn (Olango)
    Fd- Heeney, smith, petracca, caddy, bell, fritsch (miers, keefe)

    2

    1
  35. Def: M Hurley, R Laird, K Simpson, J McGovern, A Naughton, T Doedee, (S Murray, J Finlayson)
    Mid: D Martin, T Mitchell, J Kelly, M Crouch, N Fyfe, S Coniglio, A Brayshaw, W Brodie, (T Kelly, D Barry, N Holman)
    Ruck: M Gawn, S Lycett (D Cameron)
    Fwd: J Billings, D Smith, J Sicily, A Christensen, B Fritsch, W Rioli, (Z Giles-Langdon, D Venables)

    Remaining salary: 6,600

    D3,D4 and R2 are the main question marks. An alternative to my current selections is M Hibberd (D3), N Coffield (D4) and P Ryder (R2).

    TU: K Simpson (D3), J McGovern (D4), S Lycett (R2)
    TD: M Hibberd (D3), N Coffield (D4) and P Ryder (R2).

    1

    9
  36. Defenders
    Laird Hibberd, Brayshaw (Melb)
    Murray, Doedee Finlayson
    (Naughton, Murphy)

    Mids
    Martin,Mitchell, Merrett, Fyfe, Coniglio
    Armitage, Brayshaw (Freo) Brodie
    (Kelly, Banfield ,Holman)

    Rucks
    Ryder,Gawn
    (Cameron)

    Forwards
    Heeney,Billings,Smith,Petracca
    Fogarty,Fritsch
    Giles-Langdon,Ryan)

    With this team i have $307,000 remainding
    Please community be critical and give me feedback, still unsure about my forward rooks don’t have much confidence in any of them

    I know Brayshaw, Armo and Coniglio are all big risks but all will make significant cash but i can easily trade them down to a well performing premo at the round three mark or a well playing rook, and will get danger back into the side

    4

    0
  37. Hey guys here’s my team

    Def: M.hurley, E.Yeo, R. Laird, N Coffield, A.naughton, T. Doedee (Murray Finlayson)
    Mid: Martin, Mitchell, Merrett, Fyfe, Bont, Dow, LDU, Brodie (banfield, kelly, Holman
    Ruc: Gawn, Lycett (Cameron)
    FWD: Heeney, Billings, Smith, C.Curnow, Stephenson, fritsch (Higgins, Ryan)

    I’ve got 271.500k remaining. Should I upgrade someone or leave as is? Feedback would be great. Cheers.

    2

    3
    1. Danger may come back fast and kill it, so you better keep the cash otherwise you may need to use 2 trades.
      LDU is the only concern for me. You can get better value for the same cash. I watched him play and he doesnt seem to be a supercoach points maker. Then he is garanteed start R1

      1

      1
  38. Thumbs up or down appreciated

    Def: Laird, Hibberd, Sicily, Naughton, Doedee, Murray(Finlayson, Murphy)
    Mid: Danger, Titch, Kelly, Merrett, Fyfe, Brayshaw, Brodie, Kelly(Banfield, Barry, Holman)
    Ruck Gawn, Martin(Olango)
    Fwd: Heeney, Billings, McLean, D.Smith, Bell, Fritsch(Keeffe, Ryan)

    7

    -1
  39. Hey SCT community! Love hearing everyone’s feedback every year! Would love to have my team dissected. What are everyone’s thoughts on Parish this year? Not quite sold on the forward line with the 3 mid pricers. Thoughts?

    DEF: Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, Naughton, Doedee, Finlayson (Coffield, Murray)

    MID: D Martin, T Mitchell, J Kelly, Z Merrett, Coniglio, Brayshaw, Brodie, T Kelly (Banfield, Barry, Holman)

    RUCK: Martin, Gawn (Cameron)

    FWD: Heeney, Billings, D Smith, Petracca, Parish, Keeffe (Fritsh, Ryan)

    13.5k in the kitty

    3

    2
  40. Def: Laird, Hibberd, Simpson, Sicily, Doedee, Murray (Finlayson, Mirra)

    Mid: Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, Brayshaw, T.Kelly, Holman (Banfield, Worpel, Barry)

    Ruck: Martin, Gawn (Balta)

    Fwd: Franklin, Billings, Walters, McLean, Fritsch, Ryan (English, Garlett)

    1

    0
      1. Yeah pretty happy with it, started without Danger last year and ended up picking up at 550k. Hoping the same strategy works this year haha

        1

        0
  41. in need of some feedback surrounding my name
    laird, hibberd, savage, naughton, doedee, finlayson (mirra, murray)

    martin, mitchell, kelly, fyfe, cripps, libba, brayshaw, banfeild (kelly, holman, barry)

    martin, gawn

    heeney, billings, mclean, smith, keefee, fritsch (garlett, ryan)

    players that i have in mind:
    bont, parker, cognilio, walters

    4

    0
    1. Big punt on Libba, think I’d take Coniglio around the same price. Either way it’s a decent line-up……

      1

      0
  42. Defenders- E.Yeo, R. Laird, M.Hibberd, N.Coffield, A.Naughton, S.Murray (T.Doedee, J. Finlayson)

    Midfielders- D.Martin, J.Kelly, N.Fyfe, A.Treloar, P.Cripps, A.Brayshaw, W.Brodie, B.Banfield (P.Ahern, T.Kelly, N.Holman)

    Rucks- S.Jacobs, M.Gawn (T.English)

    Forwards- I.Heeney, T.Greene, J.Billings, L.Dalhaus, J.Stephenson, W.Rioli (B. Fritsch, L.Ryan)

    Thumbs up or down and comment any advice!

    Decided no midprice players this year

    2

    3
  43. Def:
    Hurley, Laird, Sicily, Doedee, Murray, Finlayson (Naughton, Murphy)

    Mid:
    Dusty, J Kelly, Zerrett, Fyfe, Cripps, Brayshaw, Brodie, T Kelly (Banfield, Barry, Holman)

    Ruck:
    Ryder, Gawn (Olango)

    Forward:
    Heeney, Billings, Walters, McLean, D Smith, Fritsch (Langdon, Ryan)

    17k in bank

    2

    0
    1. My strategy is essentially to use 5 keeper players from the 2013 draft and 4 keeper player from the 2009 draft to maximise scoring potential

      0

      1
  44. DEF: R. Laird, M. Hibberd, B. Ellis, Z. Tuohy, T. Doedee, S. Murray (J. Finlayson, L. Keeffe)

    MID: T. Mitchell, D. Zorko, N. Fyfe, P. Cripps, Andrew Brayshaw, W. Brodie, B. Banfield, D. Barry (T. Kelly, J. Garlett, N. Holman)

    RUC: M. Gawn, S. Jacobs (T. Olango)

    FWD: J. Gunston, T. McLean, D. Smith, C. Curnow, J. Sicily, R. Lobb (B. Fritsch, L. Ryan)

    3

    3
    1. Now that is a different team. Not quite what I would do but good luck. Great to see someone with a bit of variety in their format..

      0

      0
  45. Laird Lloyd savage naughton Coffield doedee (Murray finlayson)

    Martin Mitchell Kelly Zorko Fyfe Brayshaw Brodie Banfield ( Kelly Dow Holman)

    Martin Gawn (olango)

    Billings McLean smith Petracca caddy fritsch ( venables Ryan)

    Feel free to rip apart this is prob draft number 2000 haha

    0

    0
  46. First Dangerless team and I can’t help but really like it.

    Def: Hibberd Laird Sicily Naughton Doedee Murray (Finlayson, Murphy)

    Mid: Dusty, Titch, Kelly, Neale, Fyfe, Cripps, Brayshaw, Kelly (Banfield, Barry, Holman)

    Ruck: Goldy, Gawn (Olango)

    Fwds: Heeney, Billings, Smith, Petracca, Keefe, Fritsch (Garlett, Ryan)

    7.5k spare

    2

    0
  47. Hey guys need a bit of support with my structure regarding forwards and mids
    (DEF) Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, Naughton, Doedee, Murray (Keeffe, Finlayson)
    (MID) Dusty, Titch, Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Brayshaw, Kelly (Banfield, Holman, Barry)
    (RUCK) Ryder, Gawn (Cameron)
    (FWD) Heeney, Billings, Smith, Sicily, Fogarty, Fritsch (Giles-Langdon, Ryan)

    Should I go:
    Coniglio down to a rookie, Fogarty to McLean
    Or keep it as is, just not sure what Fogarty/Stephenson’s scoring potential is compared to Banfield
    Would love some help!!

    1

    0
  48. DEF: Howe, Savage, Hurley, Brayshaw, Naughton, Doedee, Murray, Finlayson
    MID: Martin, Fyf, Bont, Parker, Steven, Armitage, Brayshaw, Barry, Banfield, Holman, T. Kelly
    RUCK: Ryder, Gawn, Hayes
    FWD: Billings, Walters, Petracca, Smith, Christensen, Fritsch, Ryan, Waterman

    All rooks pending being named, got 65k in the bank so there’s some wiggle room.
    Laird > Hurley considering POD
    Coniglio, Libba?
    Rioli too much of a risk?
    Any advice/critiques will be appreciated.

    1

    0
  49. DEF:: laird, savage, mills, naughton, doedee, coffield (Murray, finlayson)
    Hibberd for me is overpriced can find the pill but I reckon I can find him cheaper through the season, savage lately season was a different player and showed in JLT his a great get and mills I feel has great upside will average 85+. The rookies naughton & coffield are pricey but u know they will play ALOT of games.

    MID:: danger, Mitchell, zerrett, Parker,Fyfe, Selwood, brayshaw,Brodie ( kelly banfield holman)
    Danger misses a week I’ll still start him! Selwood will play huge midfield minutes unlike danger and Ablett who will rotate forward a lot. The rest of premos pick them selves and again brayshaw and Brodie should play all season u can’t put price on JS.

    RUCK:: Gawn & nank (olango)
    Not a lot to say nank is a bull around the ground rd 11 I’ll by chasing Ryder

    FWD:: Lambert, McLean, smith, petracca, keeffe, fritsch (venables, Ryan)
    No player over 500k too pricey for the unknown and all but Greene with that rd 14 bye! I’m happy with my spread here though in my eyes will be top 8s. Rookies here scare me though. Am considering coffield > Murphy down back and venables > Stephenson for JS in fwd line.

    1

    1
  50. TEAM 1

    DEF:
    Laird, Lloyd, Salem, Coffield, Naughton, Murray
    (Doedee, Mirra)

    MID:
    Martin, Kelly, Crouch,Fyfe, Cripps, Brayshaw, Brodie, Kelly (Banfield,Worpel,Holman)

    RUCK:
    Martin, Gawn
    (Olango)

    FWD:
    Heeney, Wingard, Billings, Smith, Petracca, Ryan
    (Ahern, Fritsch)

    TEAM 2

    DEF:
    Laird, Lloyd, Hibbered, Coffield, Naughton, Murray
    (Doedee, Mirra)

    MID:
    Martin, Kelly, Crouch,Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Brodie, Fogarty (Banfield,Worpel,Holman)

    RUCK:
    Martin, Gawn
    (Cameron)

    FWD:
    Heeney, Billings, Smith, Petracca, Rioli, Ryan
    (Ahern, Fritsch)

    Which team do you think is best and would you suggest any changes to either team?

    1

    0
  51. Version 6203

    Def: Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Coffield, Naughton, Murray, Doedee, Finlayson
    Mids: Martin, Titch, Fyfe, Parker, Cripps, Coniglio, Brayshaw (Fre), Banfield, Kelly (Gee), Barry, Holman
    Rucks: Martin, Gawn, Cameron
    Fwds: Heeney, Billings, McLean, Smith, Keefe, Ryan, Giles-Langdon, Fritsch

    Cash: 14.2k

    2

    0
  52. Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, Coffield, Naughton, Murray (Finlayson, Doedee)

    Mid: Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Merrett, Fyfe, Brayshaw, Fogarty, Banfield (Kelly, Barry, Holman)

    Rucks: Jacobs, Gawn (Cameron)

    Fwds: Heeney, Billings, Daulhaus, Smith, Christenson, Fritsch (Ryan, Keefe)

    2

    1
  53. What’s everyone’s thoughts on running 4 on-field rookie mids? Would allow for greater cash gen and depending on the M8 (Holman, Kelly, Barry, Banfield) would only be losing 30-40 points (assuming they score 60-70 and a premo is scoring 90-110). It would also allow people to have greater depth up forward which seems to be the line giving everyone trouble. I’d really welcome some thoughts/opinions/feedback on this idea, cheers.

    6

    1
    1. I think it also looks like there are a few rookie or premium rooky pics in defence to help cover forward lack of rookies

      1

      0
      1. That’s exactly what I was thinking mate. You’ve got Coffield, Naughton, Mirra, Murray, Finlayson, Keeffe and Doedee all with good job security/money making potential and you have maybe Fritsch, Ryan and Garlett in the forward line) so that’s why I’m thinking 4 on-field mid rookies and 3 on-field defence as opposed to 3def, 3mid and 1fwd because that extra mid rookie will definitely(read – hopefully) score more than the forward rookie. Anyway that’s just what I think, cheers.

        0

        1
    2. That’s exactly what I’m doing at moment (see here: http://supercoachtalk.com/rate-my-mar-team-3/#comment-721274).

      My reasoning is similar to yours:

      – The midfield rookies are far stronger than those in other positions this year, so the short-term loss of points will be minimal.
      – You’ll make more cash, and make it faster.
      – It gives you greater depth on other lines (I have zero rookies on the field on the forward line, for example).
      – Because premium defenders and forwards are cheaper than premium mids, you get to start more keepers. This means going full-premium sooner, with fewer trades.
      – The weekly multiplier puts a real squeeze on premium prices as the season goes on, so by the middle of the year there will be very premium midfielders (averaging 110+) available in the mid-$500K range. Throw in the faster cash generation from your midfield rookies, and you’ll have 8 premium mids before you know it.

      2

      0
  54. Def: Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Naughton, Doedee, Murray (Finlayson, Murphy)

    Mid: Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, Brayshaw, Brodie, Kelly (Banfield, Holman, Barry)

    Ruck: Ryder, Gawn (Cameron)

    Fwd: Heeney, Billings, Petracca, Smith, Christensen, Fritsch (Ryan, Garlett)

    130k in the bank
    – In defence currently have the rookies and will most likely keep it as so due to more def rookies scoring better than other positions. Also not fully sold on Savage but defence prems have not been as solid as previously thought.
    – In mids I would preferably won’t to upgrade Brodie to Coniglio but short on cash and also considering dropping Martin to go to Zorko as a Pod choice that I feel he is being heavily slept on.
    – Rucks have been one headache of mine as have tossed between Ryder, Jacobs and Martin with all having their positives and negatives.
    – In the Fwd line I have tried to beef into up more as the rookies here do not have the scoring capacity as of other lines. Have a few breakout forwards but choosing the right ones have been difficult as two players left out in Walters and McLean could be the better choices rather than Petracca and Smith

    Any Feedback or Suggestions greatly appreciated, kinda went overboard on the detail haha 🙂

    2

    0
  55. First real attempt due to slackness and nightshift.
    B:laird,Rampe,Sicily,O’shea,Naughton,
    Doedee,(Finlayson,Ballenden)

    M:Martin,tmitch,Kelly,MCrouch,Fyfe,
    Bont,Banfield,Pohlke
    (Ahern,Worpel,Holman)

    R:McEvoy,Gawn

    F:Buddy,Greene,Mundy,Perracca,Keefe,
    Bayok,(Naish,Petruccelle)

    Rookies to swap out as required

    Happy for and criticism or pump up

    1

    1
  56. This is my final team so far. Thoughts will be appreciated?

    Def: Laird, Hibberd, Coffield, Naughton, Doedee, Murray, (Mirra, Finlayson)

    Mid: Dusty, Titch, Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, Brayshaw, Coniglio, Banfield (Kelly, Barry, Holman)

    Ruc: Gawn, Jacobs (Cameron)

    For: Heeney, McLean, Billings, Smith, Christensen, Fritsch (Keeffe, Ryan)

    2

    0
    1. I doubt you will ever get your defence to full strength with six rookies who are unlikely to be great cash generators.

      0

      0
  57. thoughts on my team appreciated.

    def – laird, hibberd, sicily, coffield, naughton, doedee (murray, finlayson)

    mid – danger, martin, titch, kelly, fyfe, cripps, brayshaw, kelly (barry, banfield, holman)

    rucks – gawn, kreuzer (olango)

    fowards – heeney, billings, d. smith, rioli, fristch, keeffe (garlett ryan)

    swapping sicily and keeffe in fwd and backline – leaving only 2 fwd rookies on and murray on.

    0

    2
  58. DEF – M.Hibberd, Lloyd, Savage, Sicily, Doedee, Murray, Keefe, Goddard
    MID – Martin, Mitchell, J.Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, O’Meara, A.Brayshaw, Dow, T.Kelly, Barry, Holman
    RUC – Martin, Gawn, Cameron
    FWD – Heeney, Billings, Petracca, Christensen, Fritsch, Ryan, Ahern, Ballenden

    Have $88k left in the bank

    0

    0
  59. Def: laird , hibberd , savage , Bonner , naughton , Murray

    Mid: Mitchell Kelly Fyfe Cripps coniglio
    Brayshaw brodie Kelly

    Rucks: Martin gawn

    Fwd: heeney Billings McLean smith Petracca fritsch

    Please provide some feedback , gone quite strong in the forwards due to lack of rookie options . Recently just traded Sicily and Christensen for Bonner and Petracca . Also would like another prem mid but don’t want to upgrade congilio because of the value on offer

    1

    1
    1. Pretty sure donuts are in play as it is not considered to be a SC bye round. That”s my understanding, as that was what occurs last season.

      6

      0
  60. Def – Laird, Hibberd, L McDonald, Sicily, Finlayson , Murray (Doedee, Murphy)

    Mid – Martin, Tich, M Couch, Fyfe, Cripps, A Brayshaw, T Kelly, W. Bodie (Barry, Banfield, Holman)

    Ruck – Ryder & Gawn (Cameron)

    Foward – Heeney, Billings, Walters, Smith, Venebles, Garlett (Fritsch, L Ryan)

    1

    1
  61. DEF – laird, hibberd, naughton, coffield, doedee, finlayson (murray, payne)

    MID – danger, martin, mitchell, j kelly, fyfe, coniglio, brayshaw, banfield (t kelly, barry, holman)

    RUCK – gawn, jacobs (cameron)

    FOR – heeney, billings, smith, t Greene, keeffe, frisch (j garlett, l ryan)

    any ideas / suggestions would be great. thanks. $37,300 left in the bank.

    1

    1
          1. Thanks for the feed back guys really appreciate it. I’m a bit worried about the back line to. The alternative is Shaw in the back line for naughton and Christensen in the forward line for Greene. I’m leaning towards keeping naughton and Greene but can be persuaded. Just not sure which way to go

            2

            0
  62. thoughts on my team appreciated.

    def – laird, hibberd, sicily, coffield, naughton, doedee (murray, finlayson)

    mid – danger, martin, titch, kelly, fyfe, cripps, brayshaw, kelly (barry, banfield, holman)

    rucks – gawn, kreuzer (olango)

    fowards – heeney, billings, d. smith, rioli, fristch, keeffe (garlett ryan)

    keep in mind that i dont care about overall score. winning my league is very important, starts in rd 2 so danger is a lock.

    0

    1
  63. Feedback would be appreciated!

    Def: Larid. Hibberd. Sicily. Naughton. O’Shea. Doedee. (Murry & Finlayson)

    Mid: Martin. Tich. Kelly. Fyfe. Cripps. J. Graham. Brayshaw. Berry. (Banfield. T. Kelly. Homman.)

    Ruck: Ryder & Gawn (Cameron)

    Forward: Heeney. Billings. Smith. Petracca. J. Garlett. L. Ryan. (Ahern & Frisch.)

    $207.800K in the bank. Not sure whether any upgrades are necessary, bit worried about the defense though. Hoping Jack Graham will continue his hot streak from the finals.

    2

    1
  64. hey guys
    would love to know your thoughts on my team.

    Def: Laird, hibberd, lloyd, o’shea, murray, doedee (naughton, finlayson

    Mids: martin, mitchell, crouch, fyfe, whitfeild, banfiel, barry, holman ( ahern, wigg, kelly)

    ruck: gawn, jacobs (olango)

    fwds: heeney, greene, dalhaus, petrreca, sicily, keefe ( ryan, fritsch)

    $69k left

    cheers

    0

    1
    1. May want to upgrade Whitfield to someone like a Bont or Cripps as i believe will just not get you over 100 every week

      2

      3
  65. Hello all nearing in on my final team so feedback is appreciated

    DEF-R. Laird, M. hibberd, S. Savage, N. Coffield, A. Naughton, T. Doedee ( S. Murray, L. Murphy)

    MID- P. Dangerfield, T. Mitchell, J. Kelly, N. Fyfe, P. Cripps, A. Brayshaw (FREO), J. Finlayson, T. Kelly (B. Banfield, D. Barry, N. Holman)

    RUCK- M. Gawn, T. Nankervis (T. Olango (loophole)

    FWD- I. Heeney, J. Billings, D. Smith, C. Petracca, J. Sicily, B. Fritsch ( J. Garlett, L. Ryan)

    i am also considering Cam O’Shea after he scores nearly 60 in 1 quarter
    If Danger is out then i will downgrade him to like a Marcus Bontempelli and then that will alow me to upgrade Sicily to a Toby McLean
    Then when danger comes back leave him a few weeks hopefully scores 90-100 drops in price then i will bring him back

    Cheers guys

    2

    0
      1. Thanks Doc
        I have chosen to go with depth in forward line this year simply just because of the lack of forward rookies.

        1

        0
  66. DEF: Hurley, Laird, Hibberd, Coffield, Naughton, Doedee (Murray, Finlayson)

    MID: Danger, Dusty, Titch, Fyfe, Cripps, Brayshaw, Barry, Holman (Fogarty, Banfield, Kelly)

    RUC: Sauce, Gawn (Olango)

    FWD: Heeney, Billings, Walters, Smith, Fritsch, Venables (Waterman, Garlett)

    If Danger looks no good I’ll swap him for Cogs and upgrade Venables to Petracca

    Rd 14 is a concern, but hopefully will have upgraded all affected rookies by then

    1

    0
  67. DEF: Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, Savage, Coffield, Naughton (Murray, Doedee)

    MID: Kelly, Fyfe, Parker, Cripps, Coniglio, A Brayshaw, Banfield, Barry (Finlayson, Kelly, Holman)

    RUC: Martin, Gawn

    FWD: Billings, Walters, McLean, Smith, Sicily, Fritsch (Waterman, Ryan)

    Any thoughts greatly appreciated!

    3

    0
  68. DEF: Laird, Hibberd, J.McGovern, Coffield, Naughton, Murray (Keeffe, Doedee)

    MID: Martin, Mitchell, Fyfe, Bontempelli, Cripps, A Brayshaw, Brodie, Stephenson (Finlayson, Barry, Holman)

    RUC: Gawn, Nankervis, (D.Cameron)

    FWD: Heeney, Greene, D.Smith, Sicily,Christensen, Rayner (Fritsch, Waterman)

    $29,500 leftover

    Set with my premiums. Rookies mainly set, awaiting the teams RD1.
    Not too many PODS, but tried to get as many DPP as possible.
    Thoughts much appreciated.

    0

    0
    1. Don’t think Stephenson and Rayner are good picks. Throw Banfield in the midfield and L.Ryan in the forward line. That’ll give you enough cash to upgrade some rookies down the line

      0

      0
  69. Hey world my name is Chelsea and i am a 15yo girl posting for the first time this year, Posted last year as it was my first year and i wanted to bet my dad who puts his team up on here often(Shaun Bart)

    Would love to know what you all think of this effort

    Defenders
    Laird, Hibberd, McGrath, Coffield, Naughton, Muarry
    (Doedee, Finlayson)

    Mids
    Martin,Mitchell,Kelly, Fyfe, Parker, Cripps, A.Brayshaw, Banfield
    (Kelly,Barry,Holman)

    Rucks
    Martin,Gawn
    (Olango)

    Forwards
    Heeney, Billings, Smith, Fogarty,Fritsch, Waterman
    (Rayner,Ryan)

    Still have $182k in the bank just to bring danger in when he is back

    Would love comments and ideas please but remember in only 15 and doing this for the second year

    Thankyou all and have a great season

    2

    0
    1. Good team! but i wouldn’t suggest having Fogarty. Fogarty may get a game early in the season due to Tex Walker being out, but other than that i wouldn’t recommend it. Also would downgrade Rayner to a cheaper rookie such as Garlett. That cash could be used on someone like Christensen who has much greater job security.

      0

      0
    2. Very solid team Chelsea. If anything I think it’s a tad light on in the FWDS.
      Consider dropping a midfielder to upgrade a FWD rookie or 2.

      0

      0
  70. I always rock up late to these so hopefully I can get some feedback on my team:

    DEF: R. Laird, M. Hibberd, S. Savage, N. Coffield, A. Naughton, S. Murray (T. Doedee, J. Finlayson)

    MID: P. Dangerfield, T. Mitchell, D. Zorko, N. Fyfe, P. Cripps, A. Brayshaw, W. Brodie, B. Banfield (T. Kelly, D. Barry, N. Holman)

    RUCK: M. Gawn, A. Sandilands (T. Olango)

    FWD: M. Walters, T. McLean, D. Smith, C. Petracca, J. Sicily, D. Fogarty (B. Fritsch, L. Ryan)

    23k in the bank.

    Some justification on a few picks:

    – First, the structure. I know 3 – 5 – 2 – 5 is a bit obscure, but I’ve set it up this way for optimal cash generation. The forward rookies are frankly absolute rubbish, which is why I’ve loaded all of my potential break-out players in the forward line and left room in the mids and defense for some rookies who will actually earn me some cash.

    – Speaking of the forward line, I feel confident every single break-out player will average at least 90, which is the lowest average I’d be happy with them making, and a high enough average to make them top 10-15 forwards. Hopefully, most of them will push their average to the high 90’s, possibly even past the 100 mark (I’m putting my bets on Walters and Sicily.)

    – I know Sandi is a light breeze away from being out for 6 rounds, but when he’s on the park, he’s still up there as one of the best scoring ruckman in the game. The plan is praying he lasts until Ryders’ bye, and then swapping him for good ol’ Paddy.

    – I know Savage will probably burn the hell out of me, but there’s not any players in that price range that I have any more faith in. Any suggestions in the 420-480k range let me know!

    – If Danger is said to be out for more than 2 rounds, he’s gone. I’ll use the funds to upgrade Cripps to either Kelly or Martin, and then Savage to a 500k+ defence premo.

    Other than that, I’d love to hear some feedback! Greatly appreciated 🙂

    2

    0
  71. Any feedback appreciated guys not sure if my balance is right and rookies subject to change with 42k itb

    Def: Laird, McGovern, Savage, Luke Ryan, Naughton, Doedee (Murray, finlayson)

    Mid: Dangerfield, Martin, Fyfe, Parker, Cripps, Brayshaw, T Kelly, Banfield (Barry, Garlett, Holman)

    Ruck: Gawn, Naitanui (Olango)

    Fwd: Billings, Smith, Petracca, Sicily, Lobb, Fritsch (Giles-Langdon, L ryan)

    Dangerfield, Naitanui and Lobb’s spot pending round 1 teams

    Thoughts?

    2

    0
    1. Great to see Luke Ryan as a POD.
      And McGovern might just fly this year (imminent free-agency) ✅
      Only concerns IMHO are Naitanui, Lobb and Sicily. Better value and consistency in Sandi, McLean and ANO.
      Love the DEF and MID set up.
      Good luck

      0

      0
      1. Thanks for the feedback, yeh still not sold on Sicily just good price and dpp improves him as an option but do they negate the flog factor… could you remind me who ANO is?

        0

        0
    2. Was really keen on Lobb as a POD in the pre season as his scores when played as a sole ruck (which he will be in 2018) are impressive but interrupted pre season has scared me off to be honest…Some fun POD’s there though…

      0

      0
      1. Hoping for some positive news in the giants v swans practice match this weekend on Lobb dominating the game as D.simpson cannot be the ruckman for gws. He would have to become a top 10 fwd at his price though which does concern me….

        0

        0
  72. Def: Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, McGrath, Naughton, Murray (Doedee, Finlayson)
    – Laird and Hibberd have been locked in, and I’m trying to toss up between Lloyd/McGrath. Currently have both at the expense of a 6th premium mid.

    Mid: Martin, Mitchell, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Brayshaw, Coffield, Barry (Banfield, Killy, Holman)
    – Love Coniglio’s upside, not the biggest fan of Dusty. Like Coffield and Finlayson’s DPP flexibility.

    Ruc: Gawn, Naitanui (Cameron)
    – If Nicnat is out for Rnd 1, will probably go for Ryder (Olango)

    Fwd: Heeney, Billings, Westhoff, Smith, Christensen, Fritsch (Garlett, Ryan)
    – Billings, Westhoff and Christensen are all up in the air. Really like Westhoff as a massive POD, not sure about the price Christensen

    I’ve been looking at stacking the forward line given the lack of quality rookies, but trying to find a way to fit in 6 mids as well has been difficult

    0

    1
  73. Always subject to change but let me know what you think!

    Def: Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, Naughton, Doedee, Murray, (Finlayson, Mirra)

    Mid: Dusty, Titchell, Crouch, Fyfe, Bont, Cripps, Ahern, Banfield, (Kelly, Barry, Holman)

    Ruck: Gawn, Lycett, (Olango)

    Fwd: Heeney, Greene, Billings, D Smith, Dunkley, Ryan, (Garlett, Fritsch)

    $23,100 left over!!!

    1

    0
  74. Wow! Does anyone out there not have Sicily or just me?
    For all the owners out there would you still pick him if he was just a Defender (or just a forward for that matter)

    1

    0
  75. Just made a comment in rookie review , where are all of our DPP’s this year?My mid/fwd are Heeney and McLean , both fwd then not many choices in Midfield!

    0

    0
  76. Probably should put my team up for review , first time ever!
    Def: Laird ,Hibberd,Langdon ,Coffield , Naughton, Finlayson , ( Doedee , Murray )
    Mid: Danger , Dusty , Titch , Fyfe , Cripps , Brayshaw , T Kelly , Holman , ( Banfield , Spargo , Barry )
    Ruck: Ryder , Gawn
    Fwd: Heeney , Greene , Billings , Mc Lean , Stephenson , Fritsch ,( Keefe , Ryan )

    2

    0
  77. Hey guys its getting late but I thought Id see if I can get some feedback on my team. I bloody change it everyday and it annoying me so cant wait for it to start and be done with it.
    Backs: Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Doedee, Murray, Finalyson (Coffield, Naughton)
    Mids: Martin, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Liberatore, Armitage, Graham, Banfield (Holman, Barry, Kelly)
    Rucks: Martin, Gawn (Olango)
    Forwards: Billings, Walters, Lynch (Adel), Smith, Caddy, Bell (Fritsch, Langdon)
    Gone for a strong forward line considering the lack of depth. My theory is theres no point having Barry, Holman, Banfiled and Kelly all on the bench if you aren’t going to use them because you have loaded up on the midfield.
    A few questions???
    Birchall in or out??
    Lycett or stay with Martin or get Goldy??
    Do I need another good defender or with I start a decent team with all of them in??
    And thoughts on Caddy and Lynch??
    Thanks guys and good luck to every1 with their teams!!!
    Thoughts appreciated

    2

    0
    1. Not a pro at this but ….
      I’d start Naughton on the field.
      Birchall undercooked and unlikely to play RD1
      Do you have the cash for Goldy?
      Lynch a great POD. Caddy to have a huge role this year I hear.
      Check DingDong’s (BRL) teamsheet. While it may not be a great indicator, I am concerned that despite his great JLT series he may get pushed out of the middle with both Dayne’s to come in. Has $$ potential regardless, just don’t be disappointed with low 60s ave should it be thus.

      0

      0
  78. Def: Laird, Hibberd, Lloyd, Finlayson, Doedee, Murray ( Mirra, Mihocek )

    Mid: Danger, Martin, Merrett, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Kelly, Holman ( Banfield, Garlett, Barry )

    Ruck: Gawn, Nic Nat (if he plays round one)
    ( Cameron )

    Fwd: Greene, Billings, McLean, Smith, Christensen, Fritsch ( Ryan, Giles-Langdon )

    Thoughts?

    0

    1
  79. Hi guys,

    Going with a guns & rookies structure but am toying with a 2/5/2/5 structure. Effectively playing Coffield as D3. All the rookies seem to be in Def & mid so have built a team around that.

    DEF: Laird, Hibb, Coffield, Naughton, O’Shea, Murray (Finlayson, Doedee)
    MID: Danger, Dusty, Titch, Fyfe, Coniglio, Armitage, Brayshaw, Banfield (Kelly, Barry, Holman)
    RUCK: Gawn, Goldy (Olonga)
    FWD: Heeney, Billings, Walters, Smith, McLean, Garlett (Fritsch, Giles-Langdon)
    $37k in the bank
    Thoughts?

    3

    0
    1. Looks great to me.
      Only thought would be:
      Cog and Armitage into Parker/Bont + ANO (rookie?)
      Pls ignore if you believe either of them will be M8 by season’s end. If Cog can stay fit, he just might be.

      2

      0
      1. Cheers allsaints. Cog seems great value and could easily end up M8. Armo is a genuine risk but has shown the capability in the past to average 90+. It is Cripps & Will Brodie vs Cog & Armo. Tough choice…

        0

        0
  80. Latest incarnation:

    DEF: Hurley, Hibberd, McGrath, Coffield, Doedee, Murray (Naughton, Finlayson)
    MID: Titch, M. Crouch, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Armitage, A. Brayshaw, Barry (Banfield, Kelly, Holman)
    RUCK: Ryder, Gawn (Olango)
    FWD: Heeney, Walters, McLean, Smith, Petracca, Fritsch (Ahern, Garlett)
    $86,600 ITB

    Keen to hear your thoughts.

    Should I go Shaw instead of Mcgrath down back? Or Walters up to Buddy? Keen to hear from the wisdom of the crowd

    1

    0
    1. Probably keep McGrath over Shaw but I may be biased against Shaw after burning me last year! Heeney and Buddy may be too may swans in fwd to start with. They have a tough draw to begin with and buddy will have a downswing at some point

      1

      0
  81. Def: Laird, Hibberd, Sicily, Naughton, Doedee, Murray (Finlayson , Mihocek )

    Mid: Martin, Titch, Merrett, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Kelly, Holman (Banfield, Garlett, Barry)

    Ruck: Gawn, Martin
    ( Cameron )

    Fwd: Greene, Billings, McLean, Smith, Christensen, Fritsch (Ryan, Keefe)

    What do you reckon boys?

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *