Trade Or Hold Rd10 #2

Written by Schwarzwalder on May 22 2018

We’re here to help out our very own Father Dougal who is currently #6 overall.  He has Lids sitting on his bench for the past few weeks.  News coming through is that Lids will miss again this week.  What would you do in Father Dougal’s shoes?  Trade or hold?

 

What to do with Brett Deledio (GWS)?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

10 thoughts on “Trade Or Hold Rd10 #2”

  1. Tough decision, hold for one more week as he only cost you 340 consider him a non playing rookie about to bottom out.
    Hes upside is elite and even when he comes back this or next week he will make you money no matter what and then make your decision.
    I have him and that is my take, only you are on the crust of immortality.
    Good luck .

    8

    1
    1. if you are still in top 10, clearly everything else is working, so only burn a trade if you can improve, or you have an in jury. gonna watch you over the byes..that will sort out many people.

      1

      0
      1. Oh yeah, I am hoping to come out ahead after the byes, but really who knows! I have at last been planning for them.

        1

        0
    2. Actually he cast me $413,600, but that doesn’t change your thinking.

      I don’t see trading him out as being worth a trade. There is a lot of season left and I expect him to play well when he does play.

      3

      1
  2. If you’ve held him this long, wait another week. But being ranked #6 obviously makes that decision harder. Spargo, Ronke, Guelfi & Fritsch starting up forward could burn

    1

    0
    1. With Gray out for R10 I have Fischer, Fritsch, Ronke, and Guelfi. I’ve been upgrading in the back since that is where I can make the most improvement and the cows are ripe. With Gray and no Lids R11 I only play Fritsch and Ronke on the pitch, and when lids gets back I’d end up benching Ronke.

      R12 and R14 are when I really need Lids back.

      0

      0
  3. Depending on cover of course, can FD loophole a player from one of the first 3 games?

    If so & can get a 70-75 may be worth holding another week. Otherwise, time to move him on as he’s struggled for continuity for a quite a while due to an aging body!

    1

    0
    1. Not this week, since I also have Robbie Gray. I have used him as my captain’s loophole several times though.

      1

      0
  4. T/U Kelly to Macrae because he’s a gun and a great VC as he plays early over the next few rounds
    T/D Macrae is too expensive and would be chasing points

    4

    1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *