Trade Talk R19, 2012

Written by Motts on July 30 2012

Righto, here we are. Last round before finals. Will you be burning a couple to make the 8 or like me are you firmly ensconced and playing a nuffy this week?

If the former, who’s in your sights to come and go?

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

113 thoughts on “Trade Talk R19, 2012”

  1. Got all premiums except for Lake, Porps and Giles

    Thinking this is the week to turn Giles into Jacobs

    Still leaves me with $175k in the bank, could upgrade Lake to Scotland or Porps to Fyfe, I have 4 trades, sitting on top, think I’ll wait and see

    0

    0
  2. 2627 for the Burblers’ this week, so I’m in a bit of a “holding pattern” until the finals start

    0

    0
  3. Trying to resist trading until finals but Callan Ward to Marc Murphy seems a good move and if i don’t do it soon then it may not be achievable.

    Also, thinking forward, i’m hoping i can engineer a SC prelim final trade where i get in a North player like Goldy, Boomer, Drew or Wellsy who have got Freo and GWS in the final two rounds. Think it could be a smart sideways trade if i have trades left come that point.

    0

    0
  4. 2 trades left and low cash. Entrenched in the 8 so I thought i’d hold fire and save the trades even though the Stanton to Murph trade was giving me an itchy trigger finger.
    In hindsight, I’m pretty shattered I didnt do it. I need him gone but after his woeful performance and Murphy’s blitz, I now cant afford it without doubletrading (leaving me zero trades). Hurts.

    0

    0
  5. Will Roughy go????

    T/U – No Stanton didnt hit his head it will save him

    T/D- Yes at least one week for the action

    0

    0
  6. Trade down MIke Pyke or David Hale to a no-name who doesn’t need to play, to make some extra cash? Pyke seems to be in great form and Hale was a late withdrawal.
    T/U Hale
    T/D Pyke
    Thanks

    0

    0
  7. Upgrading Patton, but not sure who to.
    T/U Danger (really good run home, 3 round average of 1270
    T/D Fyfe (dirt cheap, proven premium)
    THanks

    0

    0
  8. Considering a double this week.
    Can afford going
    Rocky and Dickson to
    T/U Stevie J and Murphy
    T/D fyfe and Watson
    Rocky will cost me games come finals and I don’t trust him to produce

    0

    0
  9. It’s time for Stanton to go. I’ve got $214k in the bank so I can get anyone. I’ve got 5 trades left and a win will guarantee me top spot in my league. What would you do?

    T/U get in Watson
    T/D get Murphy and use the cash elsewhere

    0

    0
  10. Won’t be until next week but my final trade will for a premium ruck.

    My midfield bench is Barlow and Gibson. I want to get a mid/fwd so I can swap if needed (have Sylvia on my fwd bench)

    I have 2 options:
    T/U: Trade Barlow>Couch, Stephenson>Cox/Jacobs/Nic Nat, (Gibson mid cover and able to switch sylvia into mid, Giles Ruck cover)
    T/D: Trade Gibson>Couch, Giles>Cox/Jacobs/Nic Nat, (Barlow mid cover, Campbell ruck cover if he plays)

    0

    0
  11. 1710 on the weekend so my team is on the gear at the moment. Only non premium in my side is Morris. 4 trades left. Already have Deledio, Goddard, Scotland, Carrazzo, H Shaw and Broughton

    T/U Waters
    T/D Enright

    Comment other

    0

    0
  12. Not sure where to place this, so here is as good a place as any.I am wondering, how many people actually pay for and use Supercoach gold ?
    I personally dont have it and havent had the opportunity to use it during the season, do the people who use it find it valuable or are sites like SC Talk and Too Serious enough to work your magic.
    T/U I have Supercoach gold
    T/D i get all my information and stats that i need from the Free sites

    0

    0
  13. Bit of topic but seeing as we are getting to the end of the SC season, I thought I’d throw up who I think deserves a All Australian Supercoach Jumper.

    DEF H Shaw, Waters, Birchell

    DPP DEF/MID Goddard, Deledio, Scotland

    MID Watson, Pendleburry, Mitchell

    DPP MID/FWD Beams, Pavlich, Sidebottom

    FWD Rioli, Franklin, Roughead

    RUCK Cox, Ablett (C), Swan(VC)

    BENCH I Maric, J Kennedy, Priddis

    SUB Carrazzo

    EMG Cotchin, Petrie, OKeefe

    For the record if Petrie and OKeefe came in for Franklin and Sidebum, the score would be 2885 for the round.

    0

    0
  14. T/U: keep 3 trades for finals
    T/D: Upgrade cloke – fyfe or
    malceski – rance or
    ryder – any ruckman

    0

    0
  15. have 4 trades left and 309k in the bank. sitting 1st in all my leagues. need to get rid of scott selwood cause he will cost me finals im feeling. want to bring in Murphy to replace him.
    other mids are, GAJ, JpK, Pendles, Priddis, J Selwood (masten, pfiffer on the bench)
    Thumbs up: make the trade now
    Thumbs down: wait until finals / someone other than murphy

    0

    0
  16. My team is really bad, so I need some improvement please!
    Here it is:
    B: Deledio, Houli, Rance, Bugg, S.Shaw, Logan, Hawksley (Tunbridge, Wilson)
    M: Swan, GAJ, Cotchin, Sloane, Gibson, Miles (Jetta, Papertalk)
    R: McEvoy, Pyke (Campbell, Pattison)
    F: Beams, Sidebum, Roughie, Cloke, Zorko, Goodes, Elliott (Couch, Walsh)
    Thanks

    0

    0
  17. Just want thoughts on my team, don’t want to get hate.

    DEF: Deledio, Scotland, Lake, Mackie, Davis, Carrazzo, Morris (Ellis, Wilkes)
    MID: Watson, Gaz, Thompson, Boyd, S. Selwood, Pendles (Miles, Crozier)
    RUC: Cox, Giles (Campbell, Hall)
    FWD: Dangerfield, Beams, Sidebottom, Buddy, McGlynn, Zorko, Adams (Pfeiffer, Kennedy)

    One trade left with 60k in the bank. Not doing any trades until the grand final so don’t bother suggesting trades

    Cheers 😀

    0

    0
  18. stuck with dempsey, cloke and zorko still to upgrade and dont know who should go first! got 180k and 5 trades. thinking zorko-swan to sure up midfield.
    suggestions?

    0

    0
  19. B: Deledio, Goddard, Birchall, Shaw, Lake, Broughton, Ellis (S.Shaw, Darley)
    M: Watson, GAJ, Boyd, Priddis, Pendles, Barlow (Horsley, Gibson)
    R: Nic Nat, Jacobs (Redden, Big O)
    F: Danger, Beams, Sidey, ROK, Martin, Zorko, Goodes (Pfeiffer, Cameron)
    2 Trades
    $102,300 in the bank.
    In my main league i am 5th and a win this week may get me in the top 4.
    I’m thinking maybe Ellis (335K, BE 62) to Suckling to complete my team going into finals with 1 trade.
    Hopefully Broughton comes back soon and i will have a complete team, except for Barlow who i am pretty confident about seeing he plays Melbourne at home in the SC grand final. Maybe i am better off trading Broughton instead of Ellis?
    Would love some feedback/thoughts on what you think i should do from here…
    Thanks 🙂

    0

    0
  20. need to upgrade morris for a D7…. thoughts on fisher- his price is great for a former premo defender…..

    0

    0
  21. Looking to upgrade Stanton to premium midfielder under 500k

    Current Mid: Watson, Ablett, Mitchell, Selwood, Stanton, Murphy

    T.u Rockliff
    Td. Nick Dal Santo

    0

    0
  22. Poll has spoken. Waters gets the nod. 2 trades left for finals and team is just about done. Broughton could possibly be the only other one to go.
    Here is my team.

    Back: Deledio, Goddard, H Shaw, Scotland, Carrazzo, Waters, Broughton
    (Baguley, Wilkes)

    Mids: Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, J Selwood, Hayes, Priddis
    (Couch, Crozier)

    Ruck: Cox, Nic Nat
    (Redden, Campbell)

    Fwds: Franklin, Dangerfield, Sidebottom, Chapman, Goodes, Martin, Zorko
    (Cloke, Smedts)

    0

    0
  23. DEF: Lids, Carrazzo, Scotland, Goddard, Enright, Birchall, Lake
    MID: Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, Murphy, Priddas, Dal Santo
    RUCK: Nic Nat, Goldstein
    FOR: Franklin, Pavlich, Dangerfield, Sidebottom, Chapman, Martin, Zorko

    1 Trade left & 126,000 left.

    Thinking of Lake to Heath Shaw as my last trade. Any Advice?

    0

    0
  24. My team $240000 CASH
    And I have 5 trades
    I’m on top of my league

    Def: Goddard, Deledio, Carrazzo, Shaw, Lake, Scotland, broughton – Spurr, Guthrie

    Mid: Ablett, Pendlebury, Thompson, Mitchell, Selwood, Priddis – Gibson, Baguley

    Ruck:Cox, Kreuzer, -Redden, Campbell

    Fwd: Dangerfield, Pavlich, Goodes, martin, Zorko, Franklin, Smedts – Milera, Hall

    Thumbs Up: 2 trades- Broughton to Waters and Kreuzer to Naitanui (I have Cox)

    Thumbs Down: 1 trade Milera to Fwd under 510000 (comment who)

    0

    0
  25. Dunno what to do with Goodes… doing my head in. Iv had him all year, just waiting for him to churn the big scores out.
    5 trades, only $20k, Thinkin Sam Shaw> Tom Bell, then Goodes> Murphy? Then use cash to make final trade in finals, maybe Lake> Prem def or Zorko> prem fwd?

    0

    0
  26. Thinking again of double trade after holding off the last two weeks. Backline still my biggest issue. Sitting top 4 in all leagues and ~5500 overall

    Lake and Broughton have massive breakevens so thinking its time for them to be sent on their way. With the cash in the bank, I can upgrade them to H.Shaw and Suckling.

    Final team will then be

    Delidio, Goddard, Scotland, Carrazzo, H.Shaw, Suckling, Yarran (Dempsey/S.Shaw)

    Ablett, JPKennedy, JSellwood, Priddis, Hayes, SThompson (Gibson/Couch)

    Goldstein, Giles (Stephenson, Redden)

    Franklin, NReiwoldt, DMartin, Chapman, Harvey, Goodes, Zorko (Cloke, Porplyzia)

    2 trades in the bank for any sideways trades required for injuries/suspensions. Figure it gives me decent bench cover except for the rucks.

    TU: do it.. just make the damn trades
    TD: patience boy.. save dem trades

    0

    0
  27. Waiting for Gibson to hit his peak, then BANG -> Cheapest Fwd/Rck DPP player (to swap with Hale for cover)

    Then Darley/S.Shaw will be changed into a premium for my last trade.

    Then I will have a full team with this as my cover:
    Back: Lake and Darley/S.Shaw
    Mid: Baguley (Def/Mid) and A.Kennedy (Mid/Fwd)
    Ruck: Hale (Rck/Fwd) and Campbell
    Fwd: Zorko (Mid/Fwd) and Smedts (Def/Fwd)

    0

    0
  28. Best FWD I can get for under 511k? I’m upgrading one of my GWS players.
    Already have Hale, Mayne. Blair, Zorko.
    Thanks

    0

    0
  29. Hey guys,not sure what I should do this week. Team is looking like:

    Backs: Deledio, Carrazzo…

    …oh, no trades left. I’ll just stand in the corner, shall I?

    Seriously, though, having come off a half season last year (only joined up Round 11-12ish), this season has been an absolute headache for planning. Hopefully everything I’ve learned this year will put me in good stead next time round. I’ve got a full premo team (+ Zorko, but he counts I reckon), bar one or two who are returning some sub-par scores these last two weeks. It’s certainly taught me the value of picking up those fallen premiums when possible – one trade instead of two is nothing to sniff at.

    A huge thank you to anyone who has offered advice or feedback to me during the season – and a general tip of the hat to anyone who has offered any advice to anyone on this site, as even when I don’t post questions myself, I can usually find the information I’m looking for in someone else’s discussion.

    Kudos, SCT!

    0

    0
  30. Geez broughtons nearly stuffed it up for me.
    Thinking about Pfiefer to Couch and then Broughton to Fisher.
    Leaving me with 300k, 2 trades and hopefully only Morris to upgrade

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *