Trade Talk R19

Written by Schwarzwalder on July 23 2017

No more mucking around with only one week to go before Finals. Who is your final upgrade target?

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

112 thoughts on “Trade Talk R19”

    1. Tagged Gibbs out of the game today but did bugger all himself (in SC terms). If you can, move him on…..

      16

      0
  1. Probably just Greene for me , was going to do a straight trade for Josh Kennedy but geez if you kick 6 and still don’t ton up, then you’re hardly a friend of CD!

    20

    0
  2. i wont be trading Strnadica……..Need i say more, my best trade of the year…Been my captain more times than danger..

    40

    0
  3. Rocky is being used as a tagger atm .Doing his job for the team but fast becoming S C irrelevant. It was the turning point of my season when i bought him in instead of Zorko after their bye .

    12

    0
  4. Really wanting to trade out T Lynch – 6 trades left…..it’s a toss up between him & Nank, but will hold Nank because of his DPP with Strnadica.

    TU: See ya Lynch
    TD: Can hold him and keep him on the bench & continue to use Greenwood

    5

    35
    1. Who would you trade him to? And is there any way you could afford Ryder? If so, you could get rid of Nankervis instead.

      7

      1
  5. Only 4 trades left but im sick of my average scores from “premos” such as Rance, Lynch and Nank (although ive never really seen nank as premo id say a “keeper” but his time is running low in my team)

    Considering trading 1 Ryan down to a non player putting witherden in the backline to loophole with Rance and then upgrade Nank to maybe franklin? This maybe a rage trade however but unsure at the moment.

    8

    0
      1. Yea i think im gonna pull the trigger! Question is Nank to Buddy or Ryder. Ryder gives ruck cover and it very tempting however is about 60k more expensive…

        7

        0
  6. Pretty simple for me this week
    Out – Newman
    In – Docherty

    Leaves me with 2 trades

    Looking like making finals in 7 out of 7 leagues but do need > win in a couple to ensure this so no holding back now.

    24

    0
  7. I think it is time for Parsons to go so I can open up each position.
    Parsons out
    Glass in

    So Greenwood goes into the fwd line and then Witherden can now switch between def and mid. Stuck with 2 trades after this and have Greene out for 1-2 weeks.

    10

    0
  8. Rocky is going but who to bring in with $605k left?
    i can’t go Titchell or Zorko so my options are either:
    Dusty, Kelly, Neale or Sloane??

    3

    1
      1. My only concern with Dusty is he is so close to being rubbed out for a week, with his points as they are. One tiny indiscretion and he’s out for a week. And Slaone and his concussions makes me wary too. I’d go Neale or Kelly or either of the other 2 if you’re feeling brave.

        3

        3
  9. If Pendles is ruled out for a couple more, who do you think ?

    TU: Heeney
    TD: Wallis

    I only have 9.2k and 4 trades and would prefer extra DPP’s and money

    30

    4
  10. Rocky out for Dusty is trade number 1 (great job negating gibbs but also great at negating my bench cover)
    2nd trade will be a def for Lewis Young, but who.

    T/U Newman: Leaves me more cash after (about $170k) but only Ryan as def cover and who really knows with FURL and these kids in the west liking to drink whether he will be named anytime soon.

    T/D: Ryan: For the above mentioned reasons but leaves me with only $40k but better def cover (I think haha)

    Leaning towards the Ryan trade provided Newman is named which leaves me with 5 trades going forward.

    13

    5
  11. Young is a forward. You may be doing a DPP trade.
    I picked up Wingard this week, as I thought he’d have several big games at home (4 out of 5 to come). That has gone down the toilet as word tonight is it looks like 2 weeks possibly 3 out.
    Have top 4 sealed so I may hold to see where he’s at prior to first final as I only have 4 trades left. Going Parsons to Young as I have absolutely zilch in the bank. Hoping strongly that Young gets another go this week.

    6

    1
  12. Both causing me headaches. Who do I ditch?

    T/U : Harbrow ( trade to Laird )
    T/D : Nank ( trade to Ryder )

    23

    5
  13. IN: Watson and Joelwood (Don’t ask…)
    OUT: Mountford and Cox.

    Rocky to M9, Withers D7, Nank/Greenwood F7

    12

    3
  14. Nank to Gawn via Ryder. Fwd line: (Yeo, Macrae, Dahl, Buddy, Heeney, Ryder)

    TU Great trade
    TD there’s a better fwd option over Gawn

    23

    1
  15. I am guessing I will need to trade Shiel this week after his shoulder injury yesterday. I have two options:
    TU: straight swap for either Titch or Dusty.
    TD: Use it to sure up other areas by trading Shiel & nank for Kreuzer & Beams

    Currently have 4 trades left.

    19

    1
  16. OUT: Rockliff and Parsons
    IN: Z.Merrett and Glass

    DPP open on all lines and I can move Greenwood forward to loophole with Lynch/Nank.

    11

    0
  17. Got the Rocky dilemma like some.

    TU – keep him and loophole with Greenwood at M8/9 in case he comes good
    TD – get rid of him all together and replace with a super premium eg. Dusty

    3

    12
  18. L Ryan to Glass , need the cash so jumping early and also add def/link
    Nank the tank of late to Ryder

    Witherden and Greenwood can patrol the def/mid and fwd line to cover premium under achievers like bloody Lynch

    9

    1
  19. Who would you say would be better bench cover in the run home, trading out Shai Bolton for:

    TU: Tom J Lynch
    TD: Isaac Smith

    10

    1
  20. 2 parts to my question.
    Pt 1. What do coaches rate as best option?
    T/U Titch/Nank/Petracca
    T/D Rocky/Ryder/Yeo

    4

    15
  21. Fwd line
    Yeo, Dahl, Greene, Heeney,Wallis,Greenwood,
    Lynch + Nank
    I have 5 trades left with 5 weeks left!
    220k in the bank.
    Greene is out
    Nank is either out or R3
    Lynch is F7. Greenwood floating M9/F7.
    Thinking Ryder and Macrae/ JJK/Buddy
    Who’s the best fwd from here on in that you would get?

    4

    0
  22. 3 trades left, durdin and bolton fwd coverage. other lines covered. pendles out for maybe 3 weeks.

    TU: pendles to jelwood, 2 trades left, $79,300 in the bank for injuries and maybe luxury upgrade.
    TD: pendles to jelwood, bolton to mids, d.lloyd out and young brought in down forward, 1 trade left, $149,600 in the bank for one luxury upgrade.

    will finish top 2 in my leagues so have second chance week to choose luxury upgrade player.

    7

    1
  23. Sadly Pendles has to go

    Parsons to Glass
    Pendlebury to Beams

    Leaves me with 2 trades and 320K in the bank. Team is a mess with Witherden at D6, Nankervis at R2 and Greenwood at F6, but hopefully that cash is enough for a double upgrade. My only focus at this stage is trying to salvage my ranking, so we’ll see how we go.

    5

    1
  24. 4 trades left, $212k in the bank – looking to get rid of Parsons this week and bring in a good FWD.
    Currently have: Macrae/Dalhaus/Franklin/Nank/Lynch/Greenwood (Parsons)

    By trading Parsons I can shift Nank/Lynch to F7 – with a budget of $497 should I bring in:

    TU: Heeney – best available but leaves me with $0
    TD: Wallis – POD, DPP and will have $51k left over over for luxury/injury upgrade during finals

    Thanks!

    14

    1
  25. What DEF should I trade Newman out for? Knowing that I have the consensus top 5 in Doch, Adams, Laird, Hurley and Hibberd:

    T/U: Roberton

    T/D: McDonald

    Comment: Lloyd

    15

    2
    1. I would also consider these guys for $520K

      L.Parker. Swans on fire and good for 100+ every week.

      Steele Sidebum. Should play more midfield with Pendles out .

      He doesn’t burn the ball like Trelore either!

      5

      1
  26. After hearing that Pendles needed more surgery on his hand, I will now move him on (I only have 15k itb)

    Should I?

    TU: Trade Pendlebury and Rockliff out for Sloane and Beams?

    TD: Trade Pendlebury and SPP for T.Mitchell plus rookie?

    5

    12
  27. with only 4 trades left Pendles and Wingard are out for me.
    I’m gonna go Pendles to Heeney via DPP
    However, Wingard is out for 2-4 weeks, should I:

    TU: Hold and wait two weeks to see if he’s back, playing Greenwood forward temporarily.
    TD: Move Nank Forward and bring in Mummy/Grundy (would already have Paddy, Yeo, Dahl, Macrae and Heeney Fwd)

    Also I play to win the league with my mates, not to get a high overall score.

    8

    2
  28. Greene has to go.

    Current forward line is:
    Greene, Heeney, Dahl, Macrae, Nank, Lynch (Greenwood, Eddy)

    Already have Ryder in the ruck

    TU: Yeo
    TD: Buddy

    Am open to any suggestions!

    12

    3
  29. Final defence move and need a hand!
    Can on make one trade this round

    TU – Simpson to Docherty
    TD – Shaw to Hurley/Hibbert

    6

    12
  30. Okay I can only make one trade this round and have 150k in the bank

    Should I balance team out or get the Doch of all trades and keep shaw?!

    TU – simpson to docherty
    TD – Shaw to Hibbert/Hurley

    4

    6
  31. Need to win this week. 2 trades left. I don’t have enough cash to bring in 2 premiums. But I have space for improvement at D6 and F6.

    Option 1
    Newman > Hurn
    Preuss > Wallis
    Nank stays at R2

    Option 2
    Fisher > Glass
    Preuss > Kreuzer
    Witherden at D6
    Nank/Greenwood at F6

    TU: Hurn & Wallis
    TD: Kreuzer

    4

    14
    1. Another option you could consider (and I’m guessing you should have the funds to do so) is the following:

      Preuss –> Mumford
      Nank –> Wallis

      This will give you 2 premiums of great value and maybe also provide you with a couple of nice PODs for your matchup this week.

      Best of luck with your decision!

      5

      2
  32. only have 3 trades left and have to deal with Walters.
    I do have cover for him as I traded parsons to Heeney last week which meant I could loophole lynch / nank.
    my other forwards are buddy, dahl, yeo, greenwood / bolton.
    I cant afford a direct swap for macrae so I am thinking of:

    T/U trading walters to beams / sloane / gray so I have a premo at M9 to loophole with Hanners / Fyfe.
    T/D holding walters on bench for a bit longer and hope macrae drops in price or another forward puts their hand up (JJK, greene, cameron, billings etc)

    in either scenario I will need to play two of greenwood, nank. lynch on field in the short term

    0

    4
    1. I should add I am top of ladder in all three of my leagues so not desparate to make the trade this week. Its more about ranking as I have dropped from being in the 300’s after rd 15 to being in the 700’s this week. I probably should show more discipline lol

      2

      0
  33. Only have 3 trades left but Rocky and Newman have been stinking it up on field.

    TU: Both of them gone Dusty and Roberton in with 63k left for my last trade to cover in finals.
    TD: Slow down maybe just Rocky out.

    4

    8
  34. Currently i have Lynch and Greenwood at F6/F7 and Parson at F8.

    Going to get rid of Parsons and I was thinking Young. What are peoples thoughts on a non playing rookie instead so that I can loophole?

    Or is the playing rookie always better incase of injuries. Bit torn.

    1

    3
    1. I’d personally go basement price DPP rookie to loophole Greenwood/Lynch. Bayok (WCE) in the best option here.

      2

      1
  35. 8 trades left 27 900 in the bank and set for the top 4.

    Suddenly I have Wingard, Pendles out and Nank to move out as well. Team below and want one ruck, mid and two forwards. Who to take with not much cash?

    D Doc Adams Simpsons Roberton Laird Lloyd (Ryan Hibberd)
    M Danger Selwood Fyfe Bont Hannaberry S Mitchell Treloar Witherdon (Pickett Myers Pendles)
    R Grundy Nank (Strandica)
    F McRae Dal Buddy Ryder Wingard Butler Eddy Greenwood

    I was thinking of who is the biggest bargain in the forwards or mids as I cant afford who I would like (Kruezer, Dusty, Yeo, Heeney) So… for my next four trades in order (breakevens considered).

    Thumbs up Gunston M Wallis Sloane Gawn in and Greenwood, Wingard, Pendles, Nank out.

    Thumbs Down Keep Greenwood for first final as F6, Gunston, Mummy and Beams in and Wingard, Pendles and Nank in.

    Any thoughts greatly appreciated!

    1

    1
    1. Dave2008.

      Priority 1. Pendles and Wingard need to go.

      Wingard to Gawn frees up $45K. + $28K bank = $73K

      Pendles $497 + $73 = $570k to spend on premo Mid.

      Eg: Z Merritt $570.300.

      Next week you could downgrade Ryan to Conor Glass.

      Freeing up $ to finish your forward line.

      2

      0
      1. Thanks. I don’t need to win this week as I am playing for league and secure in top 4. So i can trade in order of break evens. Gawns calf a concern. Krueżer is a pod in my league and I don’t have Dusty. So what about Wingard and Butler for Young and Gunton this week then Pendles and nank for Krueżer and Dusty next week ?

        0

        1
  36. Stuck with roughhead or greenwood in the forward line and can only upgrade one.
    Who gets upgraded?

    TU roughead
    TD greenwood

    15

    0
  37. Hey guys I need help
    TU – Priddis to Dusty
    TD – Greenwood to Macrae

    Can only choose one for this week.

    16

    1
  38. Hurn has scored 165 and 149 the past two weeks. Is this an anomaly or has he hit late-season form?

    Already have Doch, Laird, Adams, Hibberd, Lloyd.

    TU: the tons will continue, trade Hurn in
    TD: not worth the risk

    1

    13
  39. 4 trades left. $158K in the bank. Rank 8067. Playing for PB and will make finals in 8/9 leagues (Miss out on SCT2)

    Def: Doc, Adams, Laird, Lloyd, Howe, Shaw: Ryan Junker
    MID: Danger, Selwood, TMitch, Zorko, Bont, Kennedy, Hanners, Treloar: Witherdon, Florent, Bolton
    Ruck: Ryder, Grundy: Strnadica
    Fwd: Macrae, Dahl, Yeo, Nank, Heeney, Greenwood: Parsons, Brown

    I have enough DPP to play around with.

    I am looking for a Player who will allow better cover fwd and mid. I will have enough funds to look at Kennedy, Brown, Gunston, De Goey and Douglas if I do a single trade – Parsons to one of these.

    Im not too concerned with Nank, trading him out will just leave another gap to fill and he will provide Ruck coverage.
    With two trades (Parsons and Florent) I could get another mid eg Neale and a rookie.

    Or I could do no trades.

    I have spent too much time thinking about this and would like a fresh set of eyes to provide some thoughts.

    Cheers Brian.

    1

    0
    1. Trade out Parsons for sure as you fwd line is clearly the weakest part of your team.

      Kennedy could go big next three weeks but Eagles have GWS and Adelaide in last two week. Gunston was super impressive last week. It’s been a tough call all year trying to find consistent forwards.

      2

      0
  40. Brian.

    Have you considered trading Parsons for another Ruck?

    You could then move Ryder forward and loophole Nank and Greenwood at F6/F7

    Greenwood would also be free to cover M9 if needed.

    5

    0
    1. If you need funds to get Kreuzer or Gawn you could downgrade Ryan to Conor Glass.

      This would also allow you to swing Witherden back to D7 to loophole with Shaw or Lloyd.

      4

      0
  41. Am trading out Rocky (as I am fed up with his output) and Greene (and cannot afford him on the pine for 2 weeks and don’t trust him when he comes back) this week and have 1,117k to spend.
    I am contemplating between getting one of Martin/Merrett and Ryder. I am leaning towards Martin for his higher ceiling, but than am a bit lost on who to get in the forward line as I have Macrae, Yeo, Heeney, Dahlhaus and Greenwood (who I am planning on upgrading next week). Any help with who to get in would be awesome – 547,200 to spend.

    0

    0
  42. Does anyone think Kruezer is worth the extra money over Gawn? Im going to trade out Wingard Pendles Nank and Butler over the next two weeks for either.

    Thumns Up Gunston Young Martin and Kreuzer
    or
    Thumbs Down Yeo Young Martin and Gawn

    8 trades left 27 900 in the bank and set for the top 4.

    D Doc Adams Simpsons Roberton Laird Lloyd (Ryan Hibberd)
    M Danger Selwood Fyfe Bont Hannaberry S Mitchell Treloar Witherdon (Pickett Myers Pendles)
    R Grundy Nank (Strandica)
    F McRae Dal Buddy Ryder Wingard Butler Eddy Greenwood

    Thoughts please ?

    0

    7
  43. Nank to JJK?
    Not using nank for cover anymore got darcy there.
    4 trades, already using 1 for pendles to dusty. Must win for finals in main cash league. JJK to kick a bag against the bears?
    TU: do it
    TD: save the trade and take your chances the matchup looks pretty even. With jroo out nank could kick a bag himself!

    1

    2
  44. Playing for League, in second place and have 6 trades with about 20k in bank

    Still have Pendles but am 4k off Neale. Thoughts on who to get or leave it (Greenwood/Witherden cover)

    T/U – Parker
    T/D – Sloane/Anyone else

    Comment – Hold trades or use another trade to get a premium

    1

    1
    1. Harry

      With 6 trades you could probably afford a downgrade.

      If you want to only use 1 trade then….

      As a POD left field option for Pendels, I would look at Steele Sidebottom.$520K

      Should play plenty more midfield and uses the ball well. He also likes to sneak forward for a goal.

      Parker is probably the safest option. Sydneys form speaks for itself.

      Sloane can go huge but he has also gone 6 weeks straight this year under 100.

      Best of luck with what ever you do.

      1

      0
      1. Freo Tragic

        Thanks very much, i think i might wait a week because i will finish either second or third on the ladder, and might downgrade scharenberg and upgrade Pendles to possibly Kelly or someone

        What do you think? Better plan?

        1

        0
  45. A bit stuck on what to do this week. I am in the top 700 overall, top of the league is guaranteed and everyone on my best 22 in named to play. I should win this round comfortably. I only have 4 trades left and $120k in the bank.

    What is throwing me is I don’t have Titch or Dusty and am currently playing with Nank, Greenwood and Lynch covering F5,6 & 7.

    Do I:
    TU: Trade Newman (D7) & Lynch (F7) for Titch & C.Glass. Leaving 2 trades and $180k remaining for upgrades.
    TD: trade a playing premo like Shiel for Titch and then upgrade Nank to Kennedy. 2 trades left and $10k
    Comment: Do nothing. hold the trade to cover off injuries over the finals weeks.

    2

    0
  46. hi there

    thumbs up-Berry trade to hibbered (melbourne)
    or
    thumbs down Bontempelli (under performing) trade Tom Mitchell

    cheers

    4

    1
  47. Is Goldy done for the year ? Only have two trades left and need to win this week
    or out of finals. Can cover him , by using DPP , or do I move him on ?
    T/U move him on.

    T/D Ride your luck and save a trade

    3

    3
  48. Trade 1 – Ryan to Glass

    Trade 2 Who goes next?
    TU: Nank R2 (to Ryder) with Martin R1/Darcy R3
    TD: Steele (to Dusty/Zerrett/Neale) with Greenwood F7/M9, Witherden M10/D7

    0

    1
  49. At an absolute loss what to do this week?

    Team:

    Doc, Laird, jj, shaw,Lloyd,Adams
    Ryan/Shaz

    Danger, Sloane, Bont, jpk, Jelwood,
    Rockliff ,Pendels, Murphy.
    Withers/Greenwood/ cuz

    Wits, Gawn. Strad.

    Dahl, Mccrae, Greene, franklin,
    Nank, Yeo. Parsons/Eddy.

    5 Trades left 18k.

    Obviously Pendels needs to go & thinking two trades to get Dusty or Mitchell. Not sure whether to trade parsons to Young for that to happen or switch greenwood forward & trade Greene to Dusty/ Mitch & parsons to young? Then trade Pendels to hopefully Mitch /Dusty next week?

    Or are there any other thoughts?

    Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated! Thanks guys

    1

    0
  50. 8 trades left 27 900 in the bank and set for the top 4.

    D Doc Adams Simpsons Roberton Laird Lloyd (Ryan Hibberd)
    M Danger Selwood Fyfe Bont Hannaberry S Mitchell Treloar Witherdon (Pickett Myers Pendles)
    R Grundy Nank (Strandica)
    F McRae Dal Buddy Ryder Wingard Butler Eddy Greenwood

    As a POD which we all need to win league finals or go up in rank who would you trade in for Wingard? Other trade this week Young in for Pendles.

    Thumbs Up McLean
    Thumbs Down Gunston

    1

    0
  51. Billy.

    Personally I would look at trading Parsons to a M/F rookie. This way you could play Greenwood at F6 and bench Greene.

    This would fee up cash to turn Pendles into anyone you like.

    1

    0
  52. 6 Trades, 81k – Thinking Parsons to Bayok or should I go SPP for Bayok or even Young?
    Or should I be keeping SPP for a bit of cover. Need help for this week please?
    Adams, Shaw, Hibberd (melb), Doch, Newman, Tuohy (Hibberd – Nth, Ryan)
    Jelwood, Danger, JPK, Neale, Merrett, Fyfe, Bont, Greenwood (Pepper, Witherden, Cousins)
    Gawn, Martin (Strnadica)
    Dahl, Nank, Macrae, Buddy, Lynch, Ryder (Eddy, Parsons)

    0

    1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *