most of the rookies that everyone has left (should have) and on field are actually outscoring Butters … I’m looking at him as a rookie that has made heaps of cash and is an upgrade – Martin, Daicos, Hayes, Preuss even NOD and definitely McCartin and SDK are all worth holding over Butters … he has no heart and plays like a petulant child when not being allowed to play on ball …
Does have the eagles this week, whether that means he’ll see no ball at all or push up and take intercept possies when eagles are kicking outta their back 50.. could go either way haha
Also a ROB owner, along with with about half a dozen other so called premiums who I thought would be serviceable or better.
Well, I’m languishing with my worst ever start to a season, ranked 50K and going nowhere.
And it’s not the rookies/cash cows that are at fault; they’ve all been good to brilliant.
Comes a time when you just have to acknowledge you made a bad call (or 7) and ditch them.
As CT rightly points out, it’s an upgrade, not sideways.
yep – while you’ve got good cows like Martin, Daicos, now Hayes and even possibly Preuss and to lesser extents JHF and NOD (and maybe likely one incoming in Clark) … then you can actually “switch your thinking” and think of the likes of Butters and Gresham as “cows” who have made great cash to an upgrade or downgrade and upgrade etc …
Butters has, for me at least, been meh all year … his attitude on field, unless playing the role he apparently want to play (ie on ball) seems to be one of not giving a s — … he’s definitely got to go I reckon.
Gresham and even more recently Sinclair looks to have had their roles change … so they are potentially of concern …
And as for ROB – I have no idea what went wrong with him … perhaps he doesn’t have a serviceable midfield to tap to?
Definitely some meaningful polls in there … and dare I say it also something for the good Father to get his teeth (and pumpkin seeds!) into …
FWD –
DUNKLEY, HEENEY, BRODIE, BUTTERS, COGS, MARTIN (SDK, MACDONALD)
My general thoughts are that obviously my ruckline is very weak but they’re scoring alright for the time being. I believe that it is time to move odriscoll, JHF and Hinge.
Will probably look to come closer to completing my backline and wait to see who drops to finish my midfield. Will also see what Gawn/Darcy/English come down to and work from there
Double downgrade to Cooper Hamilton and Jack Carroll this week I reckon. Clark missing was a nice bonus, he can wait another week. Got a few candidates to make way – Bowey, Gibcus, Daicos, Dylan Stephens (will we ever see him again…?) or Hugh Dixon (how the hell do you get dropped for a state league fill-in?!).
Leaning towards Dixon for Hamilton to open up the DPP with Martin, and maybe Stephens for Carroll to maximise the number of scoring players on the bench – subject to breakevens, in case someone needs to go to avoid losing money.
I was all set and excited to turn Daicos and Rosas into Macrae and best cheap Mid rookie but man Gresham and Butters are killing me, The age old problem of what I want (Macrae) verses what I need (2 forward keepers who can average 90 ) and not stink it up when they don’t
He’s a viable option until Grundy gets back but that’s still 10ish weeks where you’ll have a 100ish averaging forward for less than 400k. Just keep a trade in the bank for then
Was thinking the same thing mate. Goldstein in similar position, he also has a negative break even. Both due to grundy and Xerri going down. With grundy being gone for another 10 or so weeks and Xerri probably 2 away I would suggest Cameron could be a great grab considering we actually need more time to decide who is gone be F4-6. With butters and cogs not looking like keepers. Sorry for the rant aha
I’d suggest whichever one services your bye structure best is the one you should keep. All scoring around the same anyway. JHF with the R14 bye would be my choice
Yeah, after I put this up I was revising my byes and think JHF will stay just cause the first two rounds I’m only just scraping through with 18 each week
Not that good of a player and won’t want him anywhere near your field but he should stick around. Suns backline looked the most balanced it has in years; ample mix of accountability, dash and height.
yeah think i’ll go with thompson. history suggests that he’ll average around 50 ( maybe in the 40s this season) if he can stay in the team, which i’m happy with considering i really just want him for cover in the byes
Butters has to go. The guy has had scores of 58, 57, 57, and 52 in his last 6. I have multiple rookies putting up better numbers. Rosas is going to join him I think.
Bringing in Clarry and Greg Clark for Butters and Rosas via Brodie and Martin DPP
T/U – Good trades, go for it
T/D – Get rookies off.
is my onfield rookies will be Clark, Daicos, McCartin, Martin and De Koning, who are all going well, with mccartin coming of a ninety, martin and daicos obviously good, de koning with his two best games yet, and clark looks very good
Fck Butters off 4 scores of 50 in his last 6 he’s not a premo and never had a history of premo scoring, I think at worst Greg Clark can match him for remainder of season.
I was going to ask the same question but Docherty leaves me with only 17 in round 12 while Dawson gets me 18 so if people think he’s the better buy anyway then I’ll stick with him
Feel like I’ll use my last trade boost. I want to get etither Gawn/Darcy this week but I have other plans. S Hayes can continue at R2 for another week.
So my current likely trade plans are:
NOD to SICILY
BERRY to RIOLI JR
BUTTERS to HEENEY
Other current plans include ROWELL (M8) to TOUK but he is currently solid and still expected to increase in price next week from an achievable breakeven.
I’d suggest that it may be better to just hold off on bringing in Clark. He’s still only played one game, so he’s not gonna increase in price. Save that Boost for later in the season in case of emergency. Either hold Stephens as a loophole, or in case he gets another game – or hold one of MacDonald or Ward, neither have astronomical breakevens and could potentially make a cheeky $10-20k.
Tossed up Boak, Green and Mills. Boak doesnt work well with my bye, green either (and lowkey think he may falter later in the season) and Mills could be poachable in a few weeks.
After much yelling, I’ve calmed down a bit and decided to give Butters one. more. chance. He plays North this week and his price has fallen so far that his BE is somewhat manageable. It’s only Rd 9, got to stay the course!
Doubling down:
Dixon and McDonald OUT
Rioli Jnr and Carroll IN
Anybody watch the Eagles game and know much about Florenca? Will he be added to the list, how did he look and what did he look like longer term.
Or is he just a one game player who happened to blue moon and never seen again.
The talk is about Sydney change of game plan not Lloyd’s role. “They” say he doesn’t fit this new style.
I am not convinced by this analysis and still believe he is an relevant defender.
At $488k he is a fallen premium. He may not return to his outstanding high scores but as a D5 or D6 makes him useful.
Got 23 trades left after already doing NOD down too rioli. Is it worth it to go butters to petracca this week cause he works better with my byes or hold the trade and 208k for next week
TU: Pull the trigger
TD: Hold the trade and the money
Is it worth going to Buku early if it means avoiding a price decrease from Bowey? Just thought with Weightman and Vandermeer injury if his J/S would be good as I can’t afford a premo defender just yet
I have a ruck problem I think, I have R1 ROB, R2 Witts and R3 Preuss. Should I trade one out now or hold until after byes, a lot of $$ sitting on the bench.
T/U Trade one of them for Hayes at R3
T/D Hold until after byes and get a rookie then
Forwards and rucks fine, need to work on getting rookies out of defence & mainly your mids.
I’ve used a boost this week and bought in Rioli & Clark(know I should wait a week) and upgraded ruck to Witts. I’d suggest using trades to fix the mids- lots of choices this week- pity most are first week of buys!
Oh no, it finally happened, there’s another one of me. I made a mistake when choosing my site moniker I see.
Reckon that midfield needs a bolster but also wondering who your other defender is cause there aren’t enough listed there. Probably Daicos, MacDonald and Dixon out to Hamilton, Rioli and really take your pick out of Cripps, Oliver, Parish, Laird, Boak, Keays, Green and Merrett. Oliver is probably best for byes but go for who you like.
22 trades left: Thinking of going
Hinge > Darcy Cameron via DPP
NOD > Rioli jnr
120k itb
Leaves me with Daicos, rioli, Hayes and martin as on-field rookies
Reckon you’d be happy to have him in the fwd line atm, after all he is the 3rd ranked Fwd in the league (averaging 102, known high ceiling also) – but if you didn’t have him then may not be the biggest loss.
The way i see it atm is that a lot of the high ranking forwards are dropping below 100 pretty consistently, so you might as well have one with a big ceiling.
If Hewitt misses again, thats two of the next four given his r12 bye. I’m fortunate to have both SDK and P McCartin on my def bench, and with Hewitt playing late this week, can loop and/or wait trill Hewitt’s late game to trade him to a number of options that improve my bye structure.
So, its not really a t/u or t/d at this point, just like to hear some thoughts.
I’m sold on Cumming so I’m bringing him this week regardless but I’m wondering if you guys think it’s worth using my boost, I’ll have two boosts left and 23 trades with Rioli being the only true rookie on the field (Brodie and Daicos the others). I’m ranked 6,100 overall and I reckon these are good trades for two premos that or moderately cheap.
Dunkley, Parker, Treloar, Cogs, Nic Martin, Rioli (Curtis, Lohmann)
That will be my lineup post trades and with Hayes, Daicos, SDK, Ward and Mccomb I should be able to get Steele and Brayshaw in when they bottom out next couple of weeks.
If English is available and Gawn is unavailable with his knee I am thinking trading Butters to English. Otherwise I am probably going to cop a donut with Hayes as R2 and Dixon as my R3
Numerous rookies are still making money (Ward, JHF, McDonald, Dixon etc), albeit slowly & still appear to have reachable BE’s. Is it time to move some of them on now or wait until they make a bit more cash?
All 4 of those are unlikely to make significantly more, with the slight exception of Dixon if West Coast give him a game to ruck but the other 3 would have some value to trade out to other rookies on the bubble who will make more cash from here such as Rioli or Hamilton. Carroll too, just super worried about his job security when Hewett is in the side.
He’s been a real leader down-back for us and has matured significantly. No silly FA’s or 50m penalties (especially in the current climate of everything being a 50m….)
Trading out rookie deadwood this week. Stephens & Dixon to Rioli and Carroll.
Very tempted to hit the boost button as Butters is giving me the deadset sh#ts stinking up my forward line. English is my preferred upgrade. Any word on his comeback?
Stephens out for me as well this week, Dixon went last week – double downgrade looks good and I’m leaning towards Rioli and Carroll as well (I don’t trust Leon Cameron to continue playing rookies).
I was thinking of boosting but I think I need to keep a couple in the back pocket for the byes / later rounds, plus Butters gets WCE and my other potential out would be Luke Jackson (with Gawn likely missing, he may score well this week).
Trying to work out who to upgrade too, I like Dawson a lot more and he’s cheaper but I think Sicily having the last bye could be really helpful for me so please help:
TU: NOD and Ward > Clark and Sicily (end up with 5 DEF and 6 MID premos)
TD: Ward and Daicos > Rioli and Boak (end up with 4 DEF premos and 7 mid premo).
Don’t want to use another trade boost yet, because I’ve got two left.
Trading in either Clark or Rioli for Ward works with either TU or TD, but which of the two would be more ideal to get in this round? (Sorry if this one’s already been asked)
Need a defender have currently got Crisp, Hewett, Chapman, Vlastuin, Gibcus, Diacos, (SDK) will trade a rookie out.
Looking at Doc or Sicily, Doc is prone to injury, Sicily likes getting suspended.
T/U Docherty
T/D Sicily
Solid side. Not fielding any dicey rookies, nicely done.
You could do a simple one down (JHF, NOD or Daicos), one up (DEF or MID).
If you’d prefer to hang onto Daicos, you could probably boost out Stephens and Ward for Rioli and Carroll/Clark/Hamilton and then put that cash on top of McCartin or JHF.
Culling Butters also something many of us are considering.
Cameron looks good on paper, and could well be a shrewd pick (last bye, will get ruck status etc.), however one poor score at his price, and it kills his cash gen.
Take Bowey for example. Started at a lower price (so easier to make cash), had one poor score in round 4, and his cash gen stalled. Came back with two good scores to get his cash moving, followed by another poor game, and it stopped dead again. In the five weeks since his first poor game, he’s only made an extra $21k, due to random bad scores.
Cameron has a better role and higher ceiling, but his higher starting price makes it much harder to make money. May be a decent pick, but a lot needs to go right.
If you had the right combo of ‘must trades’ – Berry, Gresham & Dixon for example – and couldn’t get up to 2 premos, then he’s probably a decent option.
Hearing on Twitter that Max went for scans purely as a precaution.
This was Gawn on Nova100 radio this morning..
Max ” I hurt myself in the second quarter, so it’s not that bad, I managed to play out the game. I did sit forward a lot, Luke Jackson did most of the ruck work in the second half, but I think I’m ok. ”
Thanks to all the contributors to this forum especially to Gunboat Diplomacy and Chaos Theory as they really have their fingers on the AFL pulse.I have never messaged this forum before and wanted to show my appreciation of all the time and effort put in by all.
If English is back in this week, is he a must trade in if I’m not using him as a ruck? My rucks are Witts, Preuss & S. Hayes. I have Dixon at F8, and was going to hold him so that if I trade in English as a FWD, I can trade out Hayes at some stage (byes?) and move Dixon to R3. That opens up DPP with Dixon & English.
TU: English a good trade in, whether it be ruck or forward. Keep Dixon in case English needed as a Ruck at some stage.
TD: Look elsewhere and don’t worry about not having a DPP R/F and trade out Dixon also.
Hi everyone – trying to decide between Boak, Brayshaw and Petracca – was leaning towards Boak but chat seems to suggest he’s not that popular – could I get some feedback as to which of these 3 would be best and why ? Please
I would personally recommend Petracca over the other two, followed by Brayshaw then Boak (purely for explosiveness, and I think both him and the Dees can still improve).
Only reason I’m not making the same trade this week is I can stretch the budget to Touk.
FYI, Petracca BE 89 priced at $559k, Boak’s BE 107 at $587k, and Brayshaw’s BE is 122 at $570k.
Rioli, Carroll and Hamilton all on the button this week….am I the only one concerned about js and that they all have the R12 bye ?? Think I’ll wait for Clark and sit tight…currently only got 16 warm bodies r12.
Any love for Mitch Duncan? Played a much more SuperCoach friendly role on the weekend and scored well. $442k seems like his absolute floor price and could be a handy F6
Harley Geelong went back to their old game style last weekend, slower & more methodical, which suited Duncan’s scoring. But you would think they would go back to how they were playing before the weekend, so I would be hesitant to risk bringing him in. A lot of forwards do have question marks though
$11,100 ITB, 24 Trades Left (3 Boosts), Rank 4757.
DEF: J. Sicily, J. Crisp, J. Short, J. Sinclair, G. Hewett, H. Chapman (P. McCartin, S. De Koning)
MID: L. Neale, C. Oliver, J. Steele, J. Macrae, T. Miller, P. Cripps, N. Daicos, J. Berry, (J. Horne-Francis, J. Ward, R. McComb)
RUCK: J. Witts, B. Preuss (S. Hayes)
FWD: J. Dunkley, W. Brodie, S. Coniglio, Z. Butters, N. Martin, H. Dixon (M. Rosas, J. McEntee)
Not really sure how I am meant to approach or prepare for the bye rounds, this is only my second year playing.
Butters and Berry scoring low. Probably hold Butters, last chance against North. Don’t have a lock for my F6 spot, but struggling to choose a decent forward, considering 3 trades. Think I should be trading out J. Berry (maybe), J. Ward, H. Dixon, J. McEntee, M. Rosas but who goes first? Cheers.
Dixon out – swing SDK/McCartin forward, Daicos down back, bring in Clark/Carroll. Also downgrade Rosas to Rioli (or Ward to the other of Clark/Carroll), then upgrade Berry
Hey Muzza,
Well done with the team for just your second year. Reckon the mids and forwards are probably where you should focus upgrading the next couple of weeks. Berry and Ward would net you Heeney and Hamilton or Taranto and Rioli. If you wanted to boost the midfield instead, you could boost and do Dixon out so you pick up both Rioli and Hamilton then really any midfielder you like the look of. Brayshaw, Petracca, Boak, Keays, Green, Merrett are all good choices, with the first two having the last bye which can be helpful.
As for preparing for byes, I’d always been really bad at it until using Macca’s bye planner the last two years which is an excellent tool. If you want to do it more simplistically though, just write down the list of players in your team that you think will play each work and make sure you have at least 18 each week. JHF and Daicos can be useful to hold onto till their bye as it will get you more players on the field in the first two weeks and then you can trade both out for players with round 13 byes for example but there’s definitely people on this site that are better at explaining bye tactics than I can.
Hopefully English to come back
Bowey Gresham Dixon out
Touk Rioli Strnadica in +305 k to turn Nod into a prem next week. If not Strnadica who ?
Rookie line is NOD , NWM Fin M .Hobbs , Dica(ruck) , Curtis Rioli
Already traded rosas too rioli.
Dixon is stuck at R3 for me so is it worth it to go dixon > strnadica to free up 255k for an upgrade like Hinge and NOD > Clark and Oliver next week
Or should i just hold dixon and go Hinge and NOD > to clark and someone like petracca or english next week
This leaves me $135k in the bank with Daicos D6, Butters Caldwell and Martin M5-8 and Darcy Cameron F6 with a bit of flexibility through DPP for the byes
Still gotta field a rookie at M8, got mccomb and Hamilton already, so it’s either trade in Rioli this week and field 1 of the 3 or instead get Clark early and field him
Last week traded out NOD & Rachele > L.Parker & McComb
Thinking of going Bowey & Dixon > Hamiltion & any premo on any line
My current team before trades:
DEF: Sicily, Crisp, Hewett, Ridley, Bowey, Gibcus (McCartin, Sinn)
MID: Neale, Oliver, Steele, Macrae, Crippa, Brodie, N.Daicos, JHF, (Ward, McComb, Hollands)
RUC: Gawn, Preuss (S.Hayes)
FWD: Dunkley, Parker, Cogs, Butters, N.Martin, Durdin (C.MacDonald, H.Dixon)
$151,600 in the bank, 27 trades left, three trade boosts left
Any feedback/advice is greatly appreciated
Hi JJ.
With those trades I reckon switch Daicos to def and bring in either Touk, Parish, Brayshaw or Tracca into your midfield. I have Touk so am going Parish this week.
Good luck with whatever you decide with your trades !
I woud do Dixon to Rioli, he has better job security than Hamilton.
Then upgrade Bowey to a premium def or mid via Daicos.
If you really like Hamilton i would consider trade boosting for another downgrade, JHF, Ward, Gibcus could all go down to him. Would free up some cash and you could bring in Greg Clark and any premo you want next week.
Thanks Finn byes aren’t an issue though. Just wondering when Fyfe returns Brayshaw’s scoring may be affected as they are saying Fyfe wants more midfield time .
A bigger priority would be getting rookies of the field but if your fine with that and have an almost all premo lineup then that wouldn’t be the worst idea
Bringing in Miller, Rioli, and Carroll this week
Trading out JHF and Ward
Who else goes:
TU
NOD – breakeven 55
$266,300 cash itb
TD
Rosas – breakeven 50
$168,300 cash itb
Comment: Save boost (only got 2 left)
26 Trades (3 Boosts)
193k ITB
DEF: Sicily, Crisp, Short, Hewett, Daicos, Gibcus, (PMac, SDK)
MID: Neale, Oliver, Steele, Macrae, Cripps, Brayshaw, Brodie, JHF, (Ward, Stephens, Uwland)
RUC: Gawn, Preuss, (SHayes)
FWD: Dunkley, Heeney, Cogs, Butters, Martin, Curtis, (Dixon, Rosas)
Want at least 2 of Carrol, Rioli, Hamilton, but not sure how I’ll get there. Want to hold JHF and Daicos until byes, I could just get Ward/Stephens/Dixon/Rosas out of the way for them. Not sure what’s happening with Gawn, even less idea on what I’m going to do this week. Please give suggestions or even better just tell me what to do: I have very little experience with this point in the season (and the rest of the season in fact).
Thanks so much
That’s a lot of cash in the bank. Think you’ve actually got enough to go straight from Gibcus to Dawson as an option. Wouldn’t worry about Gawn too much, looks like he’ll play and worst case scenario you run with Hayes who outscored him last week anyway.
With that much cash, I’d probably consider using a boost and double downgrading to Rioli and either Hamilton or Carroll (I lean Hamilton cause I’m not sure how Carroll goes with Hewett back and the dpp means he’ll be easier to hide). If you trade any 3 of the 4 you named, the double down will let you pick up anyone up to about 600k where I’d personally target Miller with that. However, you could afford any of Petracca/ Boak/ Keays/ Green/ Walsh and really should just pick your favourite out of them. A defender could work in Dawson or the highest scoring SuperCoach defender in Docherty but his bye sucks. A wild choice could even be Bontempelli who might somehow be getting fwd status before round 12 and he’s just fun to have in the team.
A lot of options there but the 2 down and 1 up to Touk would be where I’d go. I’m trading Gibcus out this week rather than a Stephens or Dixon but I definitely understand the frustration with those.
Was thinking of bringing Sicily in, that almost completes my backline, but now I’m thinking a rare gem in Cummings,who to score more for the rest of the season,( note a bit worried of Sicily’s inability to see out a year?)
TU Sicily
TD Cummings
I’m 6,100 overall and not sure if I should trade Hewett this week to get a better premo than Parker in, here are my options and I’m seriously stuck. I’ve got 25 trades left so a Hewett trade isn’t the worst but I’m not sure whether it’s worth holding butters who I was going to trade before I realised Hewett was out.
TU Butters, Dixon, Mccartin > Cumming, Parker, Rioli 17k left
TD Hewett, Dixon, Mccartin > Cumming, Boak, Rioli 80k left
I’m only considering this as Port play north, Boak and Butters might go huge but I’ll be having to bring Hewett back in a week later.
Reilly ROB Obrien seems all but dropped this week. I have Pruess R2, Sam Hayes R3.
So..what to do?
TU: Play Hayes R2 and keep ROB at R3 until Gawn comes down, then upgrade.
TD: Trade ROB to Strnadica, take that sweet sweet 400k and go on a spending spree. (4 rook upgrades to go)
Bowey – J Lloyd
J Berry – M Riolli
Butters – Goldy
Going for $450K players with a POD as not a lot of money in the bank.
Lloyd may be a keeper and Goldy set to make some money and has loop.
Would prefer this than 1 up and 2 down.
Yep thanks GD I picked Dean as a loophole and have Ridley who doesn’t sound too positive so if he is out again it will be a donut, hands will be tied to move him on unfortunately and swing McCartin back and bring in Touk.
Are these 3 trades a good idea or not . Butters,JHF and Coniglio to Bont,Petracca and Hamilton T/U Leaves 20 trades and 3 boosts. Other option is JHF,Ward and Rosas to Rioli ,Petracca and Hamilton T/d. Thanks
With news that o’drizzy is out should i trade him or trade rosas instead and use o’drizzy as a loophole. Either way im trading the other one next week to get to a premo
TU: Trade rosas with a risk of going down in cash and use O’drizzy as loophole
TD: Trade O’drizzy and hope rosas goes up this week for trading next week
I’d go Rowell & Berry to prem & Rookie- whichever suits your byes for both, Daicos as Def 6 not bad.
Just worry about Darcy longer term and injury wise.
Thanks. I’ve practically almost completed my team so I feel that I have enough trades currently for the rest of the season. So I don’t mind risking it with Darcy for the higher ceiling. I was thinking of trading Rowell next week to Clark and Durdin to English.
Lads, am in desperate need of some Trade suggestions as I’ve lost all direction with my Team. With Xerri out, doubts on Ridley, Gawn & JHF set for a stint on the sidelines and a few “DNPs” on the Bench, I’m at a Crossroads.
DEF:
Sicily Docherty Lloyd
Ridley Bowey De Konig
(J.Boyd Uwland)
MID:
Neale Oliver Macrae Miller
Green Rowell Daicos Horne-Francis
(McComb Hough Soligo)
RUCK:
Gawn Witts (H.Dixon)
FWD:
Dunkley Brodie Coniglio
Butters Martin Rioli
(Xerri Durdin)
$207,500 in the Bank
21 Trades and 2 Boosts
Hit me with some ideas Lads, even some elaborate 3 Week 8 Trade type Plans.
Trade out Xerri…too much cash doing nothing. With DPP of SDK bring in a premo def such as Pendles, Dawson, etc.
Also could trade Bowey before he drops more cash, move Daicos back and bring in a mid rookie on the bubble (Carroll, Hamilton) or go early on Clark.
So this idiot was going Zeibell to Stewart (I know Stewart bombed) but reversed and copped another price drop ♂️♂️ anyways rage trading him for sure freed up bulk cash so just wondering, 23 trades left
TU- use trade boost and get 2 cheapies out and Zeibell to Hewett for example
TD save the boost and just zeibell and NOD out and bank the cash for next week
Thanks legends
TU Trade odriscoll first
TD Trade Bowey first (high BE).
Have coverage with SDK (but no emg cover).
Would swing Mccartin to backline so wouldn’t be upgrading anyone. I am leaning towards Bowey and then odriscoll next week
I should say, the thumbs up option gets me to just 2 rookies on field (De Koning or McCartin at D6 and Nick Martin at M8 with Clark to come in next week)
Sc’ers double downgraded last week and took an L in my main league… Falling behind the 8-ball here. thought I would have the cash for Oliver but I’m about 50k short.
Wondering weather using a boost to get him is the way to go. Or is there anything I can do this week for a point injection. Doesn’t feel like the team is bad but I keep losing so it’s to sct for the W!!!!! 23 trades and 3. Boosts remaining.315k itb
Team as follows:
Backs: crisp, Hewett,short, Sicily,daicos, gibcus, Martin, dekoning.
Hi all
Does anyone know if we can use the Trade Boosts during the Supercoach Finals or just during the Supercoach Head to Head season?
I’ve used 3 and itching to use another, though don’t want to waste them if they can be used during League finals
Round 12 bye for Hewett is ok. Wanting a D/M . Don’t trust Zorko’s body, been burnt before. Thought about Pendles but he’s a lot of money for an older player that I think will be rested at some stage. Missed the boat on Hewett earlier this season – is it too late to get him now or am I better off with the POD, being that he is in so many teams?
With stradinica not playing should I trade Dixon too begg or Jamieson instead or are they not worth it
TU: Go instead to begg/jamieson
TD: Save the trade their not worth it
Rory Thompson probably has the best security and has already played a game. Also Buku Khamis but hard to ever be confident in bulldogs rookies continually getting games
Might help up forward- just really confused with who’s gunna be top 6-10 with the forwards.
In the past players like Hawkins have finished years well and come out top 6, but if you’re right on those numbers I can see Smith & Bont getting a gig in my side come finals- and might be just ahead of players such as Taranto.
Might be good upgrades on Coniglio, Martin, etc.
Got Carroll last week, already traded NOD to rioli and have 21 trades left
Is it worth it to downgrade macdonald too hamilton with 310k itb
This would let me do something like hinge and rosas > Clark and a premo like oliver next week
Otherwise i’d have to go to someone like dawson or pendelbury next week
TU: Yes do it
TD: Save the trade no need to have rioli, carroll and hamilton
Is it worth me boosting this week to get Hamilton into the side. Would leave me with 21 trades and 2 boosts.
T/U – Save trade and boost – Ward, Gibcus > M.Rioli, Parker
T/D – Use boost – Ward, Gibcus, Rosas > M.Rioli, Parker, Hamilton + 100k
I think him being out this week makes it an easy decision. If he achieves his average for the next 5/6 rounds he’ll only make 10k. I’m happy to move him on and get another rookie off the field.
Was originally gonna go Gibcus and Macdonald to Caroll and Dawson, but now I’m considering brining in Big Sean Darcy for Preuss
TU – Send it cos Darcy wont be under 600k again
TD – stick with original trades
Zak Butters
TU- Hold
TD- Trade
Rather get rookies off the field first.
With 4 scores of 50 in his last 6 games his scoring worse than majority of rookies is the issue!
most of the rookies that everyone has left (should have) and on field are actually outscoring Butters … I’m looking at him as a rookie that has made heaps of cash and is an upgrade – Martin, Daicos, Hayes, Preuss even NOD and definitely McCartin and SDK are all worth holding over Butters … he has no heart and plays like a petulant child when not being allowed to play on ball …
Butters is playing North this week – maybe loophole him?
Butters and o’driscoll are out I think
Think I’m done with Bowey. His purpose seems to have been served.
Will be either him or Durdin, to get my last forward rookie off field
Does have the eagles this week, whether that means he’ll see no ball at all or push up and take intercept possies when eagles are kicking outta their back 50.. could go either way haha
I know the name of the game rn is to race to full premo, but I’m almost tempted to pause and do some sideways-ing.
ROB -> Darcy is very appealing.
Had ROB pencilled is as a serviceable 105-110 ruck but a 60 v a non-ruck is a problem.
Still need 2x DEFs and a 1x FWD for full premo but Darcy going to put away ROB by a huge amount – same with English over Butters tbh.
Might get a poll up on people’s general thoughts on sideways-ing at this stage of the season.
That is not a sideways trade, that is definetly a upgrade.
Take it from another owner of ROB.
Good luck GD.
Absolutely with you there GD.
Also a ROB owner, along with with about half a dozen other so called premiums who I thought would be serviceable or better.
Well, I’m languishing with my worst ever start to a season, ranked 50K and going nowhere.
And it’s not the rookies/cash cows that are at fault; they’ve all been good to brilliant.
Comes a time when you just have to acknowledge you made a bad call (or 7) and ditch them.
As CT rightly points out, it’s an upgrade, not sideways.
Lol, look at us SLOB owners. Need a support group.
Yeah, thinking he goes to Darcy. Clear net gain on points.
yep – while you’ve got good cows like Martin, Daicos, now Hayes and even possibly Preuss and to lesser extents JHF and NOD (and maybe likely one incoming in Clark) … then you can actually “switch your thinking” and think of the likes of Butters and Gresham as “cows” who have made great cash to an upgrade or downgrade and upgrade etc …
Butters has, for me at least, been meh all year … his attitude on field, unless playing the role he apparently want to play (ie on ball) seems to be one of not giving a s — … he’s definitely got to go I reckon.
Gresham and even more recently Sinclair looks to have had their roles change … so they are potentially of concern …
And as for ROB – I have no idea what went wrong with him … perhaps he doesn’t have a serviceable midfield to tap to?
Definitely some meaningful polls in there … and dare I say it also something for the good Father to get his teeth (and pumpkin seeds!) into …
VERY well said, Macca.
Exact way to look at it. Always love your take.
Gunboat proceed with caution. Darcy is made of glass and will breakdown again
If you had to trade one out, who would you trade?
T/U – Butters
T/D – Gresham
Burn them both …
G’day lads, gonna ask for a general consensus on what the moves need to be looking like going forward.
DEF –
WITHERDEN, CRISP, HEWETT, SHORT, DAICOS, MCCARTIN (HINGE, WILMOT)
MID –
STEELE, MACRAE, NEALE, OLIVER, MILLER, TRAC, CRIPPS, JHF (ODRISCOLL, STEPHENS, MCCOMB)
RUCK –
PREUSS, HAYES (DIXON)
FWD –
DUNKLEY, HEENEY, BRODIE, BUTTERS, COGS, MARTIN (SDK, MACDONALD)
My general thoughts are that obviously my ruckline is very weak but they’re scoring alright for the time being. I believe that it is time to move odriscoll, JHF and Hinge.
Will probably look to come closer to completing my backline and wait to see who drops to finish my midfield. Will also see what Gawn/Darcy/English come down to and work from there
1) O’Driscoll to Rioli (Rich)
2) JHF to Brayshaw (Freo)
Obviously agree with your ruck line, but still serviceable while fattening up.
If you’re okay with running that ruck set up for a bit longer then you can go:
NOD -> Hamilton
Stephens -> Rioli Jr
And then either:
Hinge -> 550k DEF premo (Cumming, Dale, Zorko, Dawson)
OR
JHF -> 590k MID premo (Keays, Brayshaw)
Calculations made with no cash ITB.
Double downgrade to Cooper Hamilton and Jack Carroll this week I reckon. Clark missing was a nice bonus, he can wait another week. Got a few candidates to make way – Bowey, Gibcus, Daicos, Dylan Stephens (will we ever see him again…?) or Hugh Dixon (how the hell do you get dropped for a state league fill-in?!).
DEF: Short, Crisp, Hewett, Bowey, Chapman, McCartin (De Koning, Gibcus)
MID: Macrae, Oliver, Cripps, Neale, Miller, Brayshaw, Keays, Nic Martin (Daicos, Stephens, McComb)
RUC: Witts, Preuss (Hayes)
FWD: Dunkley, Heeney, Moore, Brodie, Butters Cogs (Dixon, Rosas)
Leaning towards Dixon for Hamilton to open up the DPP with Martin, and maybe Stephens for Carroll to maximise the number of scoring players on the bench – subject to breakevens, in case someone needs to go to avoid losing money.
Actually, Rioli looks the better downgrade than Hamilton. Make $20k less bank, but hopefully better job security and scoring.
I was thinking the same about Dixon, turns out he’s one of the nightclub seven
I was all set and excited to turn Daicos and Rosas into Macrae and best cheap Mid rookie but man Gresham and Butters are killing me, The age old problem of what I want (Macrae) verses what I need (2 forward keepers who can average 90 ) and not stink it up when they don’t
Thoughts on Darcy Cameron, is he a viable option as a fwd?
Tu or Td
He’s a viable option until Grundy gets back but that’s still 10ish weeks where you’ll have a 100ish averaging forward for less than 400k. Just keep a trade in the bank for then
Was thinking the same thing mate. Goldstein in similar position, he also has a negative break even. Both due to grundy and Xerri going down. With grundy being gone for another 10 or so weeks and Xerri probably 2 away I would suggest Cameron could be a great grab considering we actually need more time to decide who is gone be F4-6. With butters and cogs not looking like keepers. Sorry for the rant aha
TU: carroll
TD: hamilton
TU: Dixon, stephens – D Cameron, hamilton/carroll
TD: Dixon, O’dris – Dawson, hamilton/carroll
Probably going to double down and grab both this week but if you could only pick one
TU: Hamilton
TD Rioli
ok so my last 3 onfield rookies are daicos, gibcus and martin.
Do i trade daicos and gibcus to get in doch?
this will mean i’ll have to field either mccartin or sdk for 1-2 weeks
Yeah. That’s fine, Wokkas.
SDK/McCartin both serviceable on field, np.
Who to bring in:
TU: Jordan Dawson
TD: James Lloyd
Hahaha I’d bring in Dawson mate given you don’t even know Lloyds first name
That was easy lol.
I’m keeping one of these 3 so who would you hold onto
TU: Gibcus
TD: NOD
Comment: JHF
TU: JHF
And just a reminder, this is who to keep, not who to trade
I’d suggest whichever one services your bye structure best is the one you should keep. All scoring around the same anyway. JHF with the R14 bye would be my choice
Yeah, after I put this up I was revising my byes and think JHF will stay just cause the first two rounds I’m only just scraping through with 18 each week
TU
Bowey to Howard
Rachele to Riolo
TD
Bowey to Zorko
Rachele to Rioli
TU: Keep Luke Jackson
TD: Trade
I would wait until later on in the week as Gawn is going for scans
Time to think about Boak?
Not sure who needs to hear this, but Whitfield has had his first price rise for the year.
Dead cat bounce?
Lol… had to Google this.
Jake Lloyd at $488k? I know his average points are down but 116 in a losing side. Good time to get on if don’t have him already.
New game plan does not really suit him.
I’d look elsewhere.
Boy, if he was not out in R1 I would be further down the pooper than I already am
Thinking about going .
Ward> Rioli Jr
Nod>Dawson or Zorko
This week;
O’driscoll > Rioli (via dpp)
Ward > Clark
This allows me to do the following next week;
Gibcus > Defensive rookie (hopefully)
MacDonald > Steele (will be roughly 610k!!)
Feel as though I will sacrifice upgrading this week in order to be prepared for a cherry rope priced Steele next week.
Thoughts appreciated!!
Tu or Td
Have to bring in a defensive rookie this week. does anyone know one that is close to debuting or something?
no real options honestly. Best bet would be Zach Reid or trying to make something happen through DPP
There’s Thompson (123k DEF) from the Suns.
Not that good of a player and won’t want him anywhere near your field but he should stick around. Suns backline looked the most balanced it has in years; ample mix of accountability, dash and height.
yeah think i’ll go with thompson. history suggests that he’ll average around 50 ( maybe in the 40s this season) if he can stay in the team, which i’m happy with considering i really just want him for cover in the byes
Butters has to go. The guy has had scores of 58, 57, 57, and 52 in his last 6. I have multiple rookies putting up better numbers. Rosas is going to join him I think.
Bringing in Clarry and Greg Clark for Butters and Rosas via Brodie and Martin DPP
T/U – Good trades, go for it
T/D – Get rookies off.
is my onfield rookies will be Clark, Daicos, McCartin, Martin and De Koning, who are all going well, with mccartin coming of a ninety, martin and daicos obviously good, de koning with his two best games yet, and clark looks very good
TU – Rioli Jr
TD – Hamilton
T/U- Maurice Rioli Jnr
T/D- Jack Carroll
Who scores more for rest of season….?
T/U – A. Brayshaw
T/D – Petracca
Thanks guys
Who to upgrade to Miller?
Whitfield
Cogs
Gresham
Or Taranto?
Ended up
Dixon> Rioli
Gresham> Brayshaw
Fck Butters off 4 scores of 50 in his last 6 he’s not a premo and never had a history of premo scoring, I think at worst Greg Clark can match him for remainder of season.
Option 1 = T/U:
Bowey > Petracca
Butters > Brayshaw (Freo)
JHF > Clark
Option 2 = T/D:
Bowey > Dawson
Butters > Petracca / Brayshaw (Freo)
NOD > Clark
Who to sack first?
Fatt Rowell (BE 68) T/U
Zak Slutters (BE 100) T/D
I’m holding Zak Spudders one more week
Time to offload Ridley.
TU: Tom Stewart
TD: Jordan Dawson
If it’s this week, Dawson for sure. Stewart will be primed in a couple of weeks.
If it’s for you last defender spot – Stewart. Hope this helps
Docherty – t/u
Dawson – t/d
I was going to ask the same question but Docherty leaves me with only 17 in round 12 while Dawson gets me 18 so if people think he’s the better buy anyway then I’ll stick with him
Feel like I’ll use my last trade boost. I want to get etither Gawn/Darcy this week but I have other plans. S Hayes can continue at R2 for another week.
So my current likely trade plans are:
NOD to SICILY
BERRY to RIOLI JR
BUTTERS to HEENEY
Other current plans include ROWELL (M8) to TOUK but he is currently solid and still expected to increase in price next week from an achievable breakeven.
Any suggestions?
Better buy this week:
T/u – Parker (535k)
T/d – Sicily (570k)
Am I stupid for considering this
Trading 3 rookies for 3 rookies and building my bank
Out – Ward – McDonald & Stephens
In – Clark – Rioli – Hamilton
Will give me 500k bank to really push for upgrades over next 2-4 rounds
Thoughts ?
I’d suggest that it may be better to just hold off on bringing in Clark. He’s still only played one game, so he’s not gonna increase in price. Save that Boost for later in the season in case of emergency. Either hold Stephens as a loophole, or in case he gets another game – or hold one of MacDonald or Ward, neither have astronomical breakevens and could potentially make a cheeky $10-20k.
TU – Brayshaw
TD – Petracca
Melbourne play WCE and North in their next two….
In Carroll Rioli and Touk
Out Ward McDonald Stephens
25 trades remaining after this
T/U – JHF to Carrol, Naish to Rioli, Dixon to Gawn
T/D – Keep Running with Preuss + Hayes combo and either upgrade Naish to a premo MID/FWD
Thinking of going:
Butters, Berry > Rioli JR, Brayshaw (freo) via Parker DPP. Leaves 136k ITB.
Tossed up Boak, Green and Mills. Boak doesnt work well with my bye, green either (and lowkey think he may falter later in the season) and Mills could be poachable in a few weeks.
Open to any other suggestions of course!
Thoughts on Dusty in the FWD at $503K
Thinking Butters/Xerri to Dusty
TU: Worth a punt
TD: Not yet
After much yelling, I’ve calmed down a bit and decided to give Butters one. more. chance. He plays North this week and his price has fallen so far that his BE is somewhat manageable. It’s only Rd 9, got to stay the course!
Doubling down:
Dixon and McDonald OUT
Rioli Jnr and Carroll IN
I’m in the same boat Chillo,
Same ins, however Hinge and NOD out for me.
Holding Butters this week but he’s on thin ice
Is Touk a top 8 mid from here on in?
TU: Yes
TD: No
Mitch Duncan back into form and worth a punt at a discounted price? At worst a decent F5-6 come the end of the year?
I’m considering sideways-ing Butters to him. Feel I’ll be disappointed far less with Duncan…
Anybody watch the Eagles game and know much about Florenca? Will he be added to the list, how did he look and what did he look like longer term.
Or is he just a one game player who happened to blue moon and never seen again.
Jake Florenca is an Eagle’s WAFL Covid Contingency Listed player.
He only gets a game when the team is Covid compromised so very poor job security.
Showed a bit with 19 possessions in his debut match.
If i’m trading out butters i can get any forward apart from the ones I already have in dunkley, brodie, coniglio
Suggestions for who would be best
What is the role change that I keep hearing about for Lloyd?
Is he no longer taking kick ins?
Is he no longer seagulling?
Thanks coaches
Lloyd took 9 kick ins and played on all 9.
The talk is about Sydney change of game plan not Lloyd’s role. “They” say he doesn’t fit this new style.
I am not convinced by this analysis and still believe he is an relevant defender.
At $488k he is a fallen premium. He may not return to his outstanding high scores but as a D5 or D6 makes him useful.
Thanks CT.
Got 23 trades left after already doing NOD down too rioli. Is it worth it to go butters to petracca this week cause he works better with my byes or hold the trade and 208k for next week
TU: Pull the trigger
TD: Hold the trade and the money
Nevermind i actually have 21 trades after doing the rioli one
JHF, L. Jackson > M. Rioli, Parish
My side with these trades:
DEF: Sicily, Crisp, Short, Hewett, Dawson, P. McCartin (O’Driscoll, De Koning)
MID: Neale, Steele, Macrae, Parish, Miller, Cripps, N. Daicos, M. Rioli (Ward, D. Stephens, McComb)
RUCK: Gawn, Preuss (S. Hayes)
FWD: Dunkley, Heeney, Brodie, Coniglio Butters, N. Martin (H. Dixon, MacDonald)
20 trades left, any suggestions?
Is it worth going to Buku early if it means avoiding a price decrease from Bowey? Just thought with Weightman and Vandermeer injury if his J/S would be good as I can’t afford a premo defender just yet
T/U yes
T/D no
I have a ruck problem I think, I have R1 ROB, R2 Witts and R3 Preuss. Should I trade one out now or hold until after byes, a lot of $$ sitting on the bench.
T/U Trade one of them for Hayes at R3
T/D Hold until after byes and get a rookie then
ROB appears the weakest link.
Wasting Preuss’s centuries sitting on the bench.
Use the cash from ROB to strengthen another line.
All the best.
Need help this week lads
Def: Stewart, Lloyd, Ridley, Whitfield, gib is (SDK, Kelly)
MID: Neale, Steele, macrae, Miller, Brayshaw, Daicos, MacDonald, McComb, (owens, Clark, long)
Ruck, gawn, preuss (Hayes)
Fwd: Dunkley, Moore, Brodie, coniglio, butters, Martin. (Dixon and rosas)
Currently have 104k with 3 boosts remaining
Comment options
Forwards and rucks fine, need to work on getting rookies out of defence & mainly your mids.
I’ve used a boost this week and bought in Rioli & Clark(know I should wait a week) and upgraded ruck to Witts. I’d suggest using trades to fix the mids- lots of choices this week- pity most are first week of buys!
Oh no, it finally happened, there’s another one of me. I made a mistake when choosing my site moniker I see.
Reckon that midfield needs a bolster but also wondering who your other defender is cause there aren’t enough listed there. Probably Daicos, MacDonald and Dixon out to Hamilton, Rioli and really take your pick out of Cripps, Oliver, Parish, Laird, Boak, Keays, Green and Merrett. Oliver is probably best for byes but go for who you like.
Oh shit yeah I’ve got short as other defender
Yeah, defence is fine then, definitely upgrade the midfield
To trade out:
TU: Lohmann and Butters
TD: Gibcus and NOD
Been quite busy so only had a quick look. What do we think lads.
TU) Gibcus & JHF -> Jordy Dawson & Rioli Jr
(Daicos D7 as cover, McComb looped with Rioli Jr on-field. – 20 trades & 2 boosts)
Td) Gibcus, MacDonald & JHF -> Rory Thompson, Andy Brayshaw & Rioli Jr
(Daicos on-field – 19 trades & 1 boost left)
TU – Dawson
TD – Zorko
Ridley and Butters are really starting to give me the shits, if i can only sack one of them this week who goes first?
TU: Ridley to Dawson
TD Butters to Darcy Cameron
Butters to Darcy Cameron WTF??
Trading one problem for a new problem once Grundy returns.. Will ultimately cost you another trade when you have to trade Cameron on Grundy return..
I wouldn’t be surprised if Butters outscores Cameron for the rest of the season..
22 trades left: Thinking of going
Hinge > Darcy Cameron via DPP
NOD > Rioli jnr
120k itb
Leaves me with Daicos, rioli, Hayes and martin as on-field rookies
TU: Good trade
TD: Bad trade
Is Luke Parker still a must have down forward?
Really seems inconsistent at the moment
Reckon you’d be happy to have him in the fwd line atm, after all he is the 3rd ranked Fwd in the league (averaging 102, known high ceiling also) – but if you didn’t have him then may not be the biggest loss.
The way i see it atm is that a lot of the high ranking forwards are dropping below 100 pretty consistently, so you might as well have one with a big ceiling.
If Hewitt misses again, thats two of the next four given his r12 bye. I’m fortunate to have both SDK and P McCartin on my def bench, and with Hewitt playing late this week, can loop and/or wait trill Hewitt’s late game to trade him to a number of options that improve my bye structure.
So, its not really a t/u or t/d at this point, just like to hear some thoughts.
Looks like he will be playing this week, he made it through training yesterday and only needs to do so again tomorrow to play
Butters, McCartin, Dixon > Cumming, Parker, Rioli
I’m sold on Cumming so I’m bringing him this week regardless but I’m wondering if you guys think it’s worth using my boost, I’ll have two boosts left and 23 trades with Rioli being the only true rookie on the field (Brodie and Daicos the others). I’m ranked 6,100 overall and I reckon these are good trades for two premos that or moderately cheap.
Sicily, Crisp, Short, Cumming, Hewett, Dawson (SDK, Uwland)
Neale, Oliver, Macrae, Miller, Cripps, T Green, Brodie, Daicos (Ward, MacDonald, McComb)
Gawn, Preuss (S Hayes)
Dunkley, Parker, Treloar, Cogs, Nic Martin, Rioli (Curtis, Lohmann)
That will be my lineup post trades and with Hayes, Daicos, SDK, Ward and Mccomb I should be able to get Steele and Brayshaw in when they bottom out next couple of weeks.
TU Do it
TD Go one up one down this week
Still think you should hold Hewett under than scenario – with such good DEF cover.
Hewett is averaging 117.3 points per game – which is pretty tough to replace.
Reckon only Docherty, Short & Stewart will end up around that sort of average.
And Carlton are looking pretty good this year – so he should continue to score well 🙂
And use Hewett to loop SDK and McCartin in the meantime – should still get at least 65 points from one of them
If English is available and Gawn is unavailable with his knee I am thinking trading Butters to English. Otherwise I am probably going to cop a donut with Hayes as R2 and Dixon as my R3
TU: Yes
TD: No
Looks like they will both be available
Gawn yes. English out with the Flu.
Berry down to Clark (if he’s back)
Butters to Oliver
Brought in Titchell which I’m really regretting now, did he get tagged on the weekend?
I can do a third trade to go Titchell to Brayshaw, but want to save trades so if I think Titchell can be a serviceable M8 I will hold
T/U – Hold Titchell, he’ll bounce back
T/D – Get rid of him
Trade Rosas to Rioli:
T/u – Do it, Rioli will make coin and Rosas is dead
T/d – Not worth it
Worried about Rioli Jnr and Carroll’s JS, thinking of downgrading to Greg Clark a week early. Getting rid of Ward and upgrading Butters.
TU Clark early
TD Rioli
Comment Carroll
Go Rioli. You can get Clark next week, but you can’t get Rioli next week
Thoughts?
Daicos/ JHF > MRioli/ Parish via SDK ddp
Went early on Clark he will be M8 sending Brodie fwd so Rioli mid bench
Mids will be:
McCrae, Cripps, Miller, Steele, Oliver, Parish, Neale, Clark( McComb, MRioli, Hough)
Fwds:
Dunkley, Cogs, Parker, Treloar, Brodie, Martin( McDonald, Curtis)
Numerous rookies are still making money (Ward, JHF, McDonald, Dixon etc), albeit slowly & still appear to have reachable BE’s. Is it time to move some of them on now or wait until they make a bit more cash?
All 4 of those are unlikely to make significantly more, with the slight exception of Dixon if West Coast give him a game to ruck but the other 3 would have some value to trade out to other rookies on the bubble who will make more cash from here such as Rioli or Hamilton. Carroll too, just super worried about his job security when Hewett is in the side.
Thanks Johnno
Need Help
TU: Ridley > Stewart
TD: Ridley > Short (save $49,000)
Thanks everyone.
Thoughts
TU
Horne Francis – clark
O’Driscoll – Petracca
TD
Horne Francis – clark
O’Driscoll – Parker
Parker does strengthen my forward line quite a bit but I do feel like Petracca is the better player
– if I get clark he will be on my bench unless I go with Parker
So it’s also who I’d rather playing as a rookie, Hamilton or clark
T/U – Crisp
T/D – Lloyd and $75k cash
Bigger priority to bring in:
TU: Touk Miller (gives me 3 def + 6 mid premos)
TD: James Sicily (gives me 4 def + 5 mid premos)
Sic is destined to miss some games sooner or later
Off of what basis?
He’s been a real leader down-back for us and has matured significantly. No silly FA’s or 50m penalties (especially in the current climate of everything being a 50m….)
I think sic is an absolute jet! But in his career he has missed a significant amount of games and only played one full season.
Seeking advice. A run of injuries and shitty choices has me at:
DEF: Daicos, Lloyd, Hewett, Crisp, SDK, NOD (Hinge, Skinner)
MID: Neale, Oliver, Macrae, Steele, Miller, Green, JHF (McComb, Hough, Tsitas)
FWD: Dunkley, Brodie, Coniglio, Gresham, Butters, Martin (Curtis, J Williams).
22 trades and 2 boosts remaining, $363,8000 in the bank.
A sorry tale. Any ideas? Don’t feel I can afford to be ‘sidewaysing’ Butters, Lloyd et al ATM…
No wonder you are struggling, you only have onfield 7 mids and no ruckmen!
Ha! Cripps in MID, Gawn, Preuss, S Hayes in Ruck…
Mids are performing but getting screwed front and back, as they say.
Downgrade Butters to Cameron
Upgrade Hinge to a Premo defender
T/U – Grab Carrol with Rioli/Rosas as my F6
T/D – Rory Thompson as bench cover allowing me to have SDK/Mccartin as my F6
Thoughts on bringing in Darcy cameron
Trading out rookie deadwood this week. Stephens & Dixon to Rioli and Carroll.
Very tempted to hit the boost button as Butters is giving me the deadset sh#ts stinking up my forward line. English is my preferred upgrade. Any word on his comeback?
Pretty sure english is a lock this week
English to miss with the flu.
His hamstring is fine so should return R10
Stephens out for me as well this week, Dixon went last week – double downgrade looks good and I’m leaning towards Rioli and Carroll as well (I don’t trust Leon Cameron to continue playing rookies).
I was thinking of boosting but I think I need to keep a couple in the back pocket for the byes / later rounds, plus Butters gets WCE and my other potential out would be Luke Jackson (with Gawn likely missing, he may score well this week).
Weighing up some options legends.
TU – D. Stephens > Clark
Coniglio > English
TD – D. Stephens > Clark
Durdin > Rioli
O’Driscoll > Dawson
Trying to work out who to upgrade too, I like Dawson a lot more and he’s cheaper but I think Sicily having the last bye could be really helpful for me so please help:
TU: Dawson
TD: Sicily
NOD – Brayshaw (Mids Complete)
J. Hayes – Rioli
Ward – Hamilton (Short 2k on Caroll sigh)
Probably better to go early on Clark if your short 2k on your 2nd mid rookie and find another next week
Clark is coming next week.
TU: NOD and Ward > Clark and Sicily (end up with 5 DEF and 6 MID premos)
TD: Ward and Daicos > Rioli and Boak (end up with 4 DEF premos and 7 mid premo).
Don’t want to use another trade boost yet, because I’ve got two left.
Trading in either Clark or Rioli for Ward works with either TU or TD, but which of the two would be more ideal to get in this round? (Sorry if this one’s already been asked)
TU: Clark
TD: Rioli
Rioli is on the bubble, Clark has another week due to his covid out
Everyone jumping off Butters….I’m holding…..obviously gonna ton up with all the angst !!
Now that I have traded him he will absolutely ton up, but if I trade him back in, he’s going to get 50
BOWEY > PETRACCA
BUTTERS > DARCY CAMERON
Thoughts?
Need a defender have currently got Crisp, Hewett, Chapman, Vlastuin, Gibcus, Diacos, (SDK) will trade a rookie out.
Looking at Doc or Sicily, Doc is prone to injury, Sicily likes getting suspended.
T/U Docherty
T/D Sicily
Dawson? At his current price and BE – will be at his cheapest price for remainder of season @ 519k
NOD > Carroll
Ward > Goldstein
Call me crazy but I think old Goldy is worth a shout in a FWD line crying for options. This leaves me with about $13K ITB.
is it worth bringing in someone like pendles or zorko instead of docherty due to bye structure?
Definitely, both looking pretty reliable
Need advice guys, do I make any trades? If so who should go? Or do I stay with what I have this week?
22 trades & 3 boosts left with the following side:
DEF: Sicily, Crisp, Short, Hewett, Dawson, P. McCartin (O’Driscoll, De Koning)
MID: Neale, Steele, Macrae, Miller, Cripps, Coniglio, N. Daicos, Horne-Francis (Ward, D. Stephens, McComb)
RUCK: Gawn, Preuss (S. Hayes)
FWD: Dunkley, Heeney, Brodie, Butters, L. Jackson, N. Martin (H. Dixon, MacDonald)
Hey, Simon.
Solid side. Not fielding any dicey rookies, nicely done.
You could do a simple one down (JHF, NOD or Daicos), one up (DEF or MID).
If you’d prefer to hang onto Daicos, you could probably boost out Stephens and Ward for Rioli and Carroll/Clark/Hamilton and then put that cash on top of McCartin or JHF.
Culling Butters also something many of us are considering.
Good luck.
Thanks mate, sound advice! I’m worried about Luke Jackson, is he a must trade?
Would you avoid bringing in a forward premo at the moment? It seems like they are all a bit up and down
See if Gawn is out this week, if Gawn is out keep Jackson – will play majority of the game in ruck
CT or Chillo
Could we please get a price prediction rise for Darcy Cameron based on him scoring 100 per week?
It currently has his predicted for 70’s and 80’s which I feel isn’t very realistic based on his current role.
Would be much appreciated. Cheers
Darcy Cameron.
Rd 8 Score 108
Rd 8 :$330k->$369k ( $38k)
Rd 9 BE -9
Projected Score 100
Rd9->$417k ($48k) New BE 35
Rd10->$446k ($29k) New BE 61
Rd11->$463k ($17k) New BE 72
Rd12->$476k ($12k) New BE 80
Legend, thanks mate helps a lot!
Cameron looks good on paper, and could well be a shrewd pick (last bye, will get ruck status etc.), however one poor score at his price, and it kills his cash gen.
Take Bowey for example. Started at a lower price (so easier to make cash), had one poor score in round 4, and his cash gen stalled. Came back with two good scores to get his cash moving, followed by another poor game, and it stopped dead again. In the five weeks since his first poor game, he’s only made an extra $21k, due to random bad scores.
Cameron has a better role and higher ceiling, but his higher starting price makes it much harder to make money. May be a decent pick, but a lot needs to go right.
Only problem with Cameron is you’re forcing yourself into a late trade.
As soon as Grundy is back, he’ll have to go.
Great until then though.
Ten weeks tho. Reckon either Cameron or Goldy might be worth it
Xerri only 3 weeks away. No guarantee to be straight back in, but he’ll be hovering.
If you had the right combo of ‘must trades’ – Berry, Gresham & Dixon for example – and couldn’t get up to 2 premos, then he’s probably a decent option.
Not sure I’d base my trades around him though.
Word is that Gawn may miss due to his knee soreness and easy games coming up.
Nothing is finalised as yet.
He is to have a scan for verification. He could miss the WCE game but nothing has been decided as yet.
Please do not post rumours without a quoted source. Thank you.
Sure. Quoted source is AFL.com.au
https://www.afl.com.au/news/758231/dees-skipper-sent-for-scans-on-knee-in-doubt-to-face-eagles
Hearing on Twitter that Max went for scans purely as a precaution.
This was Gawn on Nova100 radio this morning..
Max ” I hurt myself in the second quarter, so it’s not that bad, I managed to play out the game. I did sit forward a lot, Luke Jackson did most of the ruck work in the second half, but I think I’m ok. ”
Sound like he’s right to play to me.
Yep. Good grab, FT.
He also said he didn’t want to get the scan but the club doctors insisted lol.
Don’t personally own Maxxy but wouldn’t be worrying if I did.
“Gawny was just a little bit sore, so gave the opportunity for Jacko (Luke Jackson) to take up some more ruck time.”
Simon Goodwin on Max Gawn
FT, Goodwin backing up Gawn’s comment.
Sounds like an excuse to rest him this week with an easy game against west coast
Confirmed Max plays this week.
Thanks to all the contributors to this forum especially to Gunboat Diplomacy and Chaos Theory as they really have their fingers on the AFL pulse.I have never messaged this forum before and wanted to show my appreciation of all the time and effort put in by all.
Well said Dragon.
Both those guys do a mountain of work for this site.
Glad you enjoy the content.
Ah. Thanks, Dragons.
Appreciate it but it’s our pleasure.
Great group, just happy to be involved.
Thank you, Dragons.
I could not have said it any better than GD just did.
Fully agree.
Thoughts
TU Horne Francais Butters to Rioli and M7 Parish (Rioli on field )
TD keep JHF and bring in Cameron
Can you hold JHF? He’s breakeven is manageable again now that 30 is out of his cycle, and he has a handy bye.
Only if there’s a good cheap rookie defender option but that’s not looking likely
Buku Khamis
Nick Daicos (382K) plays Dogs this week.
3 rd ave: 75 breakeven: 68
TU: hold
TD: trade
there’s no right answer- depends on the status of your team
which option is best
TU: daicos – crisp
TD: o’driscoll – dawson
Out Dixon Ward & McDonald
In Rioli Hamilton & Petracca
T/U – Use third boost to get Gawn
T/D – Only use two trades and grab Darcy/Witts
Gawn in doubt for this week. If he does play he will probably spend significant time forward with Jackson rucking more. Re-evaluate next week.
Looks like Gawn is ok to continue as normal, false alarm.
If English is back in this week, is he a must trade in if I’m not using him as a ruck? My rucks are Witts, Preuss & S. Hayes. I have Dixon at F8, and was going to hold him so that if I trade in English as a FWD, I can trade out Hayes at some stage (byes?) and move Dixon to R3. That opens up DPP with Dixon & English.
TU: English a good trade in, whether it be ruck or forward. Keep Dixon in case English needed as a Ruck at some stage.
TD: Look elsewhere and don’t worry about not having a DPP R/F and trade out Dixon also.
English has a 120 avg and is by far the number 1 forward. He’s looking like a must have
TU: Parish
TD: Boak
Comment: Laird
Tu: Parish
Td: Petracca
Parish has the R12 bye, are you ok with that?
Looking to offload NOD, J.Ward and JHF and bring in Touk Miller, M.Rioli & Strnadica, leaving me with a team of:
DEF: Sicily, Short, Sinclair, Hewett, Daicos, McCartin (Gibcus, Hinge)
MID: Neale, Oliver, Steele, Macrae, Parish, Miller, Cripps, N.Martin (Stephens, McComb, M.Rioli)
RUCK: Preuss, Hayes (Strnadica)
FWD: Dunkley, English, Treloar, Brodie, Coniglio, Butters (S.DeKoning, Rosas).
$328k and 21 trades remaining.
Appreciate any comments, particularly on any rookies who I should sell ahead of the three chosen.
Who to keep?
TU: JHF (BE 59 vs North)
TD: Hinge (BE 71 vs Bris)
Hi everyone – trying to decide between Boak, Brayshaw and Petracca – was leaning towards Boak but chat seems to suggest he’s not that popular – could I get some feedback as to which of these 3 would be best and why ? Please
I would personally recommend Petracca over the other two, followed by Brayshaw then Boak (purely for explosiveness, and I think both him and the Dees can still improve).
Only reason I’m not making the same trade this week is I can stretch the budget to Touk.
FYI, Petracca BE 89 priced at $559k, Boak’s BE 107 at $587k, and Brayshaw’s BE is 122 at $570k.
Petracca has 2 juicy games the next 2 weeks that he could go huge in. That’s who I’m bringing in
Also would it be better to bring rookies in this week and get Steele instead the following week? Thoughts please
T/U – Brayshaw
T/D – Parish
Thanks guys 🙂
Brayshaw yet to have his turn with covid.
Rioli, Carroll and Hamilton all on the button this week….am I the only one concerned about js and that they all have the R12 bye ?? Think I’ll wait for Clark and sit tight…currently only got 16 warm bodies r12.
Trade out:
TU: Butters
TD: L. Jackson
Comment: Neither
Depending on Gawn knee, Jackson could get more ruck time
Any love for Mitch Duncan? Played a much more SuperCoach friendly role on the weekend and scored well. $442k seems like his absolute floor price and could be a handy F6
Harley Geelong went back to their old game style last weekend, slower & more methodical, which suited Duncan’s scoring. But you would think they would go back to how they were playing before the weekend, so I would be hesitant to risk bringing him in. A lot of forwards do have question marks though
Duncan played HB on the weekend he wasn’t in the fwd line
That’s where he plays his best footy, when he can roam around and use his skills off the half backline. The more he has ball in hand, the better.
TU: Use trade to get carrol for NOD
TD: Save trade
Would have 19 left with first, is it worth using trade for cash gen,
I guess Hugh Dixon won’t be playing now with the incident that happen so trade him out
TU: YES
TD: NO
I’m not sure WC can afford to drop players based on that incident.
Naish was there and played on the weekend.
I would wait for teams to be named before trading Dixon at this stage.
$11,100 ITB, 24 Trades Left (3 Boosts), Rank 4757.
DEF: J. Sicily, J. Crisp, J. Short, J. Sinclair, G. Hewett, H. Chapman (P. McCartin, S. De Koning)
MID: L. Neale, C. Oliver, J. Steele, J. Macrae, T. Miller, P. Cripps, N. Daicos, J. Berry, (J. Horne-Francis, J. Ward, R. McComb)
RUCK: J. Witts, B. Preuss (S. Hayes)
FWD: J. Dunkley, W. Brodie, S. Coniglio, Z. Butters, N. Martin, H. Dixon (M. Rosas, J. McEntee)
Not really sure how I am meant to approach or prepare for the bye rounds, this is only my second year playing.
Butters and Berry scoring low. Probably hold Butters, last chance against North. Don’t have a lock for my F6 spot, but struggling to choose a decent forward, considering 3 trades. Think I should be trading out J. Berry (maybe), J. Ward, H. Dixon, J. McEntee, M. Rosas but who goes first? Cheers.
Dixon out – swing SDK/McCartin forward, Daicos down back, bring in Clark/Carroll. Also downgrade Rosas to Rioli (or Ward to the other of Clark/Carroll), then upgrade Berry
Have no DPP in forward to swing either. Could do Dixon > S. Skinner then DPP Skinner & McCartin, Rosas > Rioli and Berry to Brayshaw?
Hey Muzza,
Well done with the team for just your second year. Reckon the mids and forwards are probably where you should focus upgrading the next couple of weeks. Berry and Ward would net you Heeney and Hamilton or Taranto and Rioli. If you wanted to boost the midfield instead, you could boost and do Dixon out so you pick up both Rioli and Hamilton then really any midfielder you like the look of. Brayshaw, Petracca, Boak, Keays, Green, Merrett are all good choices, with the first two having the last bye which can be helpful.
As for preparing for byes, I’d always been really bad at it until using Macca’s bye planner the last two years which is an excellent tool. If you want to do it more simplistically though, just write down the list of players in your team that you think will play each work and make sure you have at least 18 each week. JHF and Daicos can be useful to hold onto till their bye as it will get you more players on the field in the first two weeks and then you can trade both out for players with round 13 byes for example but there’s definitely people on this site that are better at explaining bye tactics than I can.
Thanks Johnno,
How can I find “maccas bye planner”?
Cheers
Done by a contributor for the site and is so helpful. Here’s the link
http://supercoachtalk.com/maccas-updated-bye-planner-2/
Hopefully English to come back
Bowey Gresham Dixon out
Touk Rioli Strnadica in +305 k to turn Nod into a prem next week. If not Strnadica who ?
Rookie line is NOD , NWM Fin M .Hobbs , Dica(ruck) , Curtis Rioli
Hiya coaches,
Is it time for Ryan to go?
TU Yes, different role means his scoring will continue to be affected
TD Nah, he’ll come good.
Just needs a team to get 60 I50’s unlike norf
In need of a real ruckman, only got Preuss, Dixon and Hayes (yep, traded Gawn early!)
Butters & Dixon
to
Rioli & Darcy
And stop this ruck merry-go-round!
Works beautifully for my byes!
Yes/No
Thanks!
Also, who needs to go first:
TU Butters
TD Cogs
Or bandaid effect, just do both now… or then again, should I keep them both?
Cheers.
tu- sicily
td – docherty
below- zorko
Zorko
Trade T. Mitchell to A. Brayshaw.
Yes/No
TU: Crisp
TD: Doc
Comment: Zorko
Dawson (TU) v Zorko (TD)
Comment for Cumming
T/U: Dixon/Ward and Bowey > Zorko and Rioli
T/D: JHF and Bowey > Touk and Hamilton
T/U -Option 1
Bowey > Dawson
NOD > Petracca
Butters > Rioli
T/D – Option 2
Bowey > Dawson
Will get Clark next week
Thanks team 🙂
T/U – Naish to Rioli + Ward to Duncan/D Cameron
T/D – JHF to Carrol, Naish to Rioli, Dixon to Darcy
TU – Pendles
TD – Sicily
TU: Taranto
TD: Duncan
TU – Carroll
TD – Hamilton
TU: Witherden
TD: Doc
Comment: Dawson
Assuming both play, who should I trade?
T/U: Ward
T/D: Dixon
TU – Complete the back 6 full premo (when hewett returns) by trading NOD to Short/docherty/dawson/zorko and hold butters
TD – Trade Butters to Brayshaw (freo) and field NOD and Daicos in backline
Already traded rosas too rioli.
Dixon is stuck at R3 for me so is it worth it to go dixon > strnadica to free up 255k for an upgrade like Hinge and NOD > Clark and Oliver next week
Or should i just hold dixon and go Hinge and NOD > to clark and someone like petracca or english next week
TU: Go to Strnadica this week
TD: Hold the trade
I’m pondering a similar dilemna Finn but not sure of what sort of job security Strnadica has.
Yeh same but with Nic Nat out for 7 weeks I think I’m willing to take that gamble
What’s everyone’s thoughts on Tim Taranto ?
TU
TD
It will interesting to see what happens to Taranto now Cameron has gone.
If he moves back into the midfield I will be all over him at that price.
He does have that early bye like Cogs and Butters so I’m inclined to wait until after that.
Gibcus, naish, butters to goldy, cumming, Rioli….yay or nay
who to trade out this week?
TU: Horne-Francis
TD: O’Driscoll
J Berry > Rioli
H Dixon > Darcy Cameron
Titchell > Petracca
This leaves me $135k in the bank with Daicos D6, Butters Caldwell and Martin M5-8 and Darcy Cameron F6 with a bit of flexibility through DPP for the byes
T/U – T/D?
Ward, MacDonald, Rosas to Rioli, Hamilton & Carroll?
Leaves me with $368 inb, 24 trades (3 bonuses) & capacity to trade hard through the bye rounds.
TU: Yes
TD: No
I wouldn’t waste a boost I’d just do the two downgrades too rioli and Hamilton or carroll
Still gotta field a rookie at M8, got mccomb and Hamilton already, so it’s either trade in Rioli this week and field 1 of the 3 or instead get Clark early and field him
Tu – get Rioli and field 1/3
Td – get Clark early, no Rioli
Last week traded out NOD & Rachele > L.Parker & McComb
Thinking of going Bowey & Dixon > Hamiltion & any premo on any line
My current team before trades:
DEF: Sicily, Crisp, Hewett, Ridley, Bowey, Gibcus (McCartin, Sinn)
MID: Neale, Oliver, Steele, Macrae, Crippa, Brodie, N.Daicos, JHF, (Ward, McComb, Hollands)
RUC: Gawn, Preuss (S.Hayes)
FWD: Dunkley, Parker, Cogs, Butters, N.Martin, Durdin (C.MacDonald, H.Dixon)
$151,600 in the bank, 27 trades left, three trade boosts left
Any feedback/advice is greatly appreciated
Hi JJ.
With those trades I reckon switch Daicos to def and bring in either Touk, Parish, Brayshaw or Tracca into your midfield. I have Touk so am going Parish this week.
Good luck with whatever you decide with your trades !
I woud do Dixon to Rioli, he has better job security than Hamilton.
Then upgrade Bowey to a premium def or mid via Daicos.
If you really like Hamilton i would consider trade boosting for another downgrade, JHF, Ward, Gibcus could all go down to him. Would free up some cash and you could bring in Greg Clark and any premo you want next week.
Time to trade Ridley?
TU Yes
TD No
TU: Parish
TD: Brayshaw Freo
Whoever suits ur byes better
Thanks Finn byes aren’t an issue though. Just wondering when Fyfe returns Brayshaw’s scoring may be affected as they are saying Fyfe wants more midfield time .
Luke Ryan (FRE) – Decided to hold last week and am now asking myself why.
T/U – Trade
T/D – Hold
A bigger priority would be getting rookies of the field but if your fine with that and have an almost all premo lineup then that wouldn’t be the worst idea
Bringing in Miller, Rioli, and Carroll this week
Trading out JHF and Ward
Who else goes:
TU
NOD – breakeven 55
$266,300 cash itb
TD
Rosas – breakeven 50
$168,300 cash itb
Comment: Save boost (only got 2 left)
Who to choose in FWD’s
T/U – Goldstein
T/D – Taranto
With Xerri and Hopper to come back maybe look elsewhere
Sicily and Dawson as upgrades leaving daicos D6
Or
Sicily and Stewart as upgrades trading out daicos leaving Paddy mac or drizzy as D6
I m not sure where to post this question.
Am I in bad shape if I have on 1 trade boost left (22 trades remaining)?
Just to clarify –
TU = 1 boost & 22 trades remaining is bad shape
TD = 1 boost & 22 trades is not in bad shape
26 Trades (3 Boosts)
193k ITB
DEF: Sicily, Crisp, Short, Hewett, Daicos, Gibcus, (PMac, SDK)
MID: Neale, Oliver, Steele, Macrae, Cripps, Brayshaw, Brodie, JHF, (Ward, Stephens, Uwland)
RUC: Gawn, Preuss, (SHayes)
FWD: Dunkley, Heeney, Cogs, Butters, Martin, Curtis, (Dixon, Rosas)
Want at least 2 of Carrol, Rioli, Hamilton, but not sure how I’ll get there. Want to hold JHF and Daicos until byes, I could just get Ward/Stephens/Dixon/Rosas out of the way for them. Not sure what’s happening with Gawn, even less idea on what I’m going to do this week. Please give suggestions or even better just tell me what to do: I have very little experience with this point in the season (and the rest of the season in fact).
Thanks so much
That’s a lot of cash in the bank. Think you’ve actually got enough to go straight from Gibcus to Dawson as an option. Wouldn’t worry about Gawn too much, looks like he’ll play and worst case scenario you run with Hayes who outscored him last week anyway.
With that much cash, I’d probably consider using a boost and double downgrading to Rioli and either Hamilton or Carroll (I lean Hamilton cause I’m not sure how Carroll goes with Hewett back and the dpp means he’ll be easier to hide). If you trade any 3 of the 4 you named, the double down will let you pick up anyone up to about 600k where I’d personally target Miller with that. However, you could afford any of Petracca/ Boak/ Keays/ Green/ Walsh and really should just pick your favourite out of them. A defender could work in Dawson or the highest scoring SuperCoach defender in Docherty but his bye sucks. A wild choice could even be Bontempelli who might somehow be getting fwd status before round 12 and he’s just fun to have in the team.
A lot of options there but the 2 down and 1 up to Touk would be where I’d go. I’m trading Gibcus out this week rather than a Stephens or Dixon but I definitely understand the frustration with those.
Who to field this week?
TU: Naish
TD: M.Rioli
Who’s a better selection for Defence? Will be my last spot before Stewart.
Current premos are Sicily, Short, Crisp, Hewett.
Bye doesent matter
T/U – Docherty
T/D – Dawson
Cheers everyone
Which rookie to bring in:
T/U – Hamilton
T/D – Carroll
Best trade in option
Boak
Or Dawson or Sicily
Was thinking of bringing Sicily in, that almost completes my backline, but now I’m thinking a rare gem in Cummings,who to score more for the rest of the season,( note a bit worried of Sicily’s inability to see out a year?)
TU Sicily
TD Cummings
Who has better job security
T/U – Carroll
T/D – Hamilton
Tagging on sorry…
Who has better Job Security?
TU: either of the above
TD: M. Rioli
Jhf > Brayshaw
Dixon > M Rioli
MacDonald > Hamilton
Thoughts on these? Don’t see much value left in Dixon and Cmac
Bowie > Petracca
MaCdonald > Any Rookie
T/U – Field Hayes at R2 vs North which allows me to finish my MIDS with Brayshaw/Laird and grab a premo RUC next week.
T/D – Just get Gawn/Darcy this week and end the RUC scoring risks
Leon Cameron has quit as GWS head coach.
I want to give a million TU
I’m 6,100 overall and not sure if I should trade Hewett this week to get a better premo than Parker in, here are my options and I’m seriously stuck. I’ve got 25 trades left so a Hewett trade isn’t the worst but I’m not sure whether it’s worth holding butters who I was going to trade before I realised Hewett was out.
TU Butters, Dixon, Mccartin > Cumming, Parker, Rioli 17k left
TD Hewett, Dixon, Mccartin > Cumming, Boak, Rioli 80k left
I’m only considering this as Port play north, Boak and Butters might go huge but I’ll be having to bring Hewett back in a week later.
Reilly ROB Obrien seems all but dropped this week. I have Pruess R2, Sam Hayes R3.
So..what to do?
TU: Play Hayes R2 and keep ROB at R3 until Gawn comes down, then upgrade.
TD: Trade ROB to Strnadica, take that sweet sweet 400k and go on a spending spree. (4 rook upgrades to go)
As a fellow SLOB owner, Alex, now is the perfect time to get him to Darcy.
Any way you can make that happen?
Darcy is so injury prone and a rollercoaster, he scares me GD.
Next few weeks include GC, Coll, Melb, Bris. Not the easiest month.
Bowey – J Lloyd
J Berry – M Riolli
Butters – Goldy
Going for $450K players with a POD as not a lot of money in the bank.
Lloyd may be a keeper and Goldy set to make some money and has loop.
Would prefer this than 1 up and 2 down.
Gibcus OUT per Gabelich with H&S
TU Trade
TD Hold
Hold if you can, I guess. Decent on field and can still make a little more coin.
Only trade if you have to in order to avoid a donut. Gibcus -> any premo DEF a solid move anyway.
Yep thanks GD I picked Dean as a loophole and have Ridley who doesn’t sound too positive so if he is out again it will be a donut, hands will be tied to move him on unfortunately and swing McCartin back and bring in Touk.
Yay or nay ?
OUT: bowey, JHF & Dixon
IN: Dawson/dale, Rioli & Darcy
Bank: $10k
FYI: Preuss and Hayes are currently my R1 &R2
TU: Dixon too Darcy this week but puts Steele on the backburner gets pts onfield getting Hayes offield.
TD: Dixon too strnadica will be able too get Steele in a week or two keep playing Hayes R2 til byes.
After a defender with R13 bye.
TU : dale
TD : dawson
Are these 3 trades a good idea or not . Butters,JHF and Coniglio to Bont,Petracca and Hamilton T/U Leaves 20 trades and 3 boosts. Other option is JHF,Ward and Rosas to Rioli ,Petracca and Hamilton T/d. Thanks
Definitely don’t do the first one.
Too much sideways-ing, Bont returning from injury, Petracca not Top 8 and get to full premo before touching Cogs.
TU: Dixon too Darcy this week but puts Steele on the backburner but pts onfield getting Hayes offield.
TD: Dixon too strnadica will be able too get Steele in a week or two keep playing Hayes R2 til byes
tu- do trades over the next few weeks and reach full premo before byes (however won’t have 18 in each bye round)
td- wait it out and reach full premo at the last bye round (fielding at least 18 in each bye round)
T/U – Gawn
T/D – Darcy
Harley you will probably want both if you’re not running Witts.
Darcy is the best buy this week as he is cheaper and Max dropped a poor score last week and will most likely drop a bit of cash in the next few weeks.
I would go Darcy.
Nathan O’Driscoll out for six weeks due to a foot injury.
With news that o’drizzy is out should i trade him or trade rosas instead and use o’drizzy as a loophole. Either way im trading the other one next week to get to a premo
TU: Trade rosas with a risk of going down in cash and use O’drizzy as loophole
TD: Trade O’drizzy and hope rosas goes up this week for trading next week
NOD Bowey Gresham out
A Brayshaw D Cameron Rioli jnr in
tu/td
What would you do with this side this week? Have 19 trades left with 137K ITB
D: Docherty, Short, Sinclair, Crisp, Hewitt, Daicos (Dekoning, NOD)
M: Neale, Macrae, Steele, Cripps, Brayshaw, Green, Oliver, Rowell ( Berry, McComb, Owen)
R: Preuss, Hayes (Hayes)
F: Parker, Dunkley, Cognelio, Brodie, Butters, Martin(Durdin,Curtis)
Was thinking Berry to Rioli and NOD to Dawson or Hayes to Darcy or Witts.
go the ruck option – Darcy .Higher ceiling , cover , thus peventing a doughnut and more likely to get more pts over the Dawson option imo
I’d go Rowell & Berry to prem & Rookie- whichever suits your byes for both, Daicos as Def 6 not bad.
Just worry about Darcy longer term and injury wise.
Thanks. I’ve practically almost completed my team so I feel that I have enough trades currently for the rest of the season. So I don’t mind risking it with Darcy for the higher ceiling. I was thinking of trading Rowell next week to Clark and Durdin to English.
Lads, am in desperate need of some Trade suggestions as I’ve lost all direction with my Team. With Xerri out, doubts on Ridley, Gawn & JHF set for a stint on the sidelines and a few “DNPs” on the Bench, I’m at a Crossroads.
DEF:
Sicily Docherty Lloyd
Ridley Bowey De Konig
(J.Boyd Uwland)
MID:
Neale Oliver Macrae Miller
Green Rowell Daicos Horne-Francis
(McComb Hough Soligo)
RUCK:
Gawn Witts (H.Dixon)
FWD:
Dunkley Brodie Coniglio
Butters Martin Rioli
(Xerri Durdin)
$207,500 in the Bank
21 Trades and 2 Boosts
Hit me with some ideas Lads, even some elaborate 3 Week 8 Trade type Plans.
Cheers in Advance
horne Francis to a premium, probably will be out this week so not a bad time to trade him
Is that Dan Rioli or Maurice Rioli in your forwards? I was going to say Xerri to M Rioli and JHF to Cripps
Maurice Rioli
Trade out Xerri…too much cash doing nothing. With DPP of SDK bring in a premo def such as Pendles, Dawson, etc.
Also could trade Bowey before he drops more cash, move Daicos back and bring in a mid rookie on the bubble (Carroll, Hamilton) or go early on Clark.
any advice would be very much appreciated.
25 trades (2 boosts) left, $7k itb
DEF: Short, Sicily, Crisp, Sinclair, Hewett, SDK (McCartin, Gibcus)
MID: Neale, Oliver, Macrae, Miller, Cripps, Smith, Daicos, Berry (JHF, Ward, Stephens)
RUC: Preuss, Hayes (English)
FOR: Dunkley, Heeney, Brodie, Cogs, Butters, N Martin (Rioli, Curtis)
What do I do?
JHF to Bubble playing Rookie or Clark
Berry to a Super Premo
Who is more important to get at this stage?
T/up – Brayshaw (Freo)
T/down – Crisp
G Clark T/U or M Rioli T/D
Go Rioli.
Clark ( coming off Covid ) can come in next week as he’s only played one game.
TU: Dawson ($519,900)
TD: Lloyd ($488,200)
So this idiot was going Zeibell to Stewart (I know Stewart bombed) but reversed and copped another price drop ♂️♂️ anyways rage trading him for sure freed up bulk cash so just wondering, 23 trades left
TU- use trade boost and get 2 cheapies out and Zeibell to Hewett for example
TD save the boost and just zeibell and NOD out and bank the cash for next week
Thanks legends
Bont T/U Petracca T/D Thanks
TU Trade odriscoll first
TD Trade Bowey first (high BE).
Have coverage with SDK (but no emg cover).
Would swing Mccartin to backline so wouldn’t be upgrading anyone. I am leaning towards Bowey and then odriscoll next week
Running Gawn, S hayes and J hayes at ruck was going to downgrade to strnadica this week but that’s out so thinking
TU
Odriscol ward J hayes out
shrek Rioli and Hamilton in
TD
hold the boost and just do odriscol ward to Rioli and Hamilton/carrol
And bank 350k
So I’m doing NOD and Gibcus out for Rioli and Dawson. For the trade boost though:
TU: JHF to Darcy Cameron
TD: MacDonald/Stephens to Hamilton
I should say, the thumbs up option gets me to just 2 rookies on field (De Koning or McCartin at D6 and Nick Martin at M8 with Clark to come in next week)
TU: Dawson
TD: Zorko
In:
Boak, M rioli
Out:
Naish, dixon
I know it’s been done but this is so bloody hard. Really rate everyone’s opinions in here.
TU – Christian Petracca
TD – Andrew Brayshaw
Much love to everyone 🙂
I’d lean towards Trac based on fixture, price and he’s less likely to be tagged than Brayshaw.
Butters out for
TU: Laird
TD: Brayshaw
TU
Bowey > Trac
NOD > Dawson
Butters > Rioli/carrol / Hamilton
TD
Bowey -trac
MacDonald – Rioli/carrol/Hamilton
Will be my last trade boost
Alternatively I had a three way trade option also.
In: Lloyd, Moore, rioli
Out: bowey, naish, dixon
NOD-Zorko
JHF- Oliver
Butters- Rioli
TU: Dawson
v
TD: Cumming
Sc’ers double downgraded last week and took an L in my main league… Falling behind the 8-ball here. thought I would have the cash for Oliver but I’m about 50k short.
Wondering weather using a boost to get him is the way to go. Or is there anything I can do this week for a point injection. Doesn’t feel like the team is bad but I keep losing so it’s to sct for the W!!!!! 23 trades and 3. Boosts remaining.315k itb
Team as follows:
Backs: crisp, Hewett,short, Sicily,daicos, gibcus, Martin, dekoning.
Mids: touk, cripps,Neale, McRae, parish, Steele, butters, Carroll. McDonald, solido, Owens.
Rucks: gawn. Preuess. Hayes.
Fwds: Dunkley, cog, broadie,Martin, parker. Hamilton, durdin. Rosas.
Could bring in Brayshaw or Keays instead?
Hi all
Does anyone know if we can use the Trade Boosts during the Supercoach Finals or just during the Supercoach Head to Head season?
I’ve used 3 and itching to use another, though don’t want to waste them if they can be used during League finals
Zak Butters to Darcy Cameron
Banking 50k, I believe Cameron will average more points. Thoughts legends??
T/U – Go for it
T/D – Hold tight Butters will come good.
You’ll trade Cameron later. I see it as 2 wasted trades.
Double downgrade for me this week;
Odriscoll > Rioli (via dpp)
Ward > Clark
Over 300k banked for next week!
Worth using a boost to get in Rioli?
TU = Dawson
TD= Hewett
Round 12 bye for Hewett is ok. Wanting a D/M . Don’t trust Zorko’s body, been burnt before. Thought about Pendles but he’s a lot of money for an older player that I think will be rested at some stage. Missed the boat on Hewett earlier this season – is it too late to get him now or am I better off with the POD, being that he is in so many teams?
With stradinica not playing should I trade Dixon too begg or Jamieson instead or are they not worth it
TU: Go instead to begg/jamieson
TD: Save the trade their not worth it
Any DEF rookies? Im forced to get one if I dont want a donut. Should I risk it with Cleary?
Rory Thompson probably has the best security and has already played a game. Also Buku Khamis but hard to ever be confident in bulldogs rookies continually getting games
Worth using a boost for Hamilton or Carroll? Will leave me with 2 boosts for the season.
TU: Do it
TD: Rioli is good enough and get Clark + upcoming rookies in following weeks
Bring in Darcy Cameron to F6?
Probably move on O’Driscoll and swing Nic Martin to M8 getting McComb/Hamilton offield..
Already done o’driscoll to rioli
Dixon stuck at R3 so thoughts on swapping him to aiden begg for cash gen?
Do I:
TU – NOD/Ward to Hamilton/Cameron
TD – use a boost to do Hinge to Rioli
Currently have 3 TBs left.
NOD and Ward to Rioli and Cameron?
Wasn’t sure where else to put this, but might be worth considering…
Bearing in mind that 35% is the threshold to gain DPP status, here are the status of some notable players so far this year:
Bontempelli 37% forward
Gawn 28% forward
Marshall 27% forward
McComb 52% forward
Short 23% mid
DCameron 39% ruck
Bailey Smith 37% forward
Is it R12 that DPP status is granted again?
Might help up forward- just really confused with who’s gunna be top 6-10 with the forwards.
In the past players like Hawkins have finished years well and come out top 6, but if you’re right on those numbers I can see Smith & Bont getting a gig in my side come finals- and might be just ahead of players such as Taranto.
Might be good upgrades on Coniglio, Martin, etc.
T/up – Laird
T/down – Crisp
Got Carroll last week, already traded NOD to rioli and have 21 trades left
Is it worth it to downgrade macdonald too hamilton with 310k itb
This would let me do something like hinge and rosas > Clark and a premo like oliver next week
Otherwise i’d have to go to someone like dawson or pendelbury next week
TU: Yes do it
TD: Save the trade no need to have rioli, carroll and hamilton
Those three all have the R12 bye.
Is MacDonald going to be playing in round 12 tho? Cos if he isn’t then I may aswell just have hamilton
NOD and Daicos to Rioli and Brayshaw?
Is it worth me boosting this week to get Hamilton into the side. Would leave me with 21 trades and 2 boosts.
T/U – Save trade and boost – Ward, Gibcus > M.Rioli, Parker
T/D – Use boost – Ward, Gibcus, Rosas > M.Rioli, Parker, Hamilton + 100k
I wouldnt trade out gibcus unless i was gonna cop a donut if I was you he’s still got cash to make when he comes back in
I think him being out this week makes it an easy decision. If he achieves his average for the next 5/6 rounds he’ll only make 10k. I’m happy to move him on and get another rookie off the field.
Worth a boost?
T/U – JHF to Carroll
T/D – Berry to D.Cameron
TD is sideways but could put $100-$150k on by R14 bye
Was originally gonna go Gibcus and Macdonald to Caroll and Dawson, but now I’m considering brining in Big Sean Darcy for Preuss
TU – Send it cos Darcy wont be under 600k again
TD – stick with original trades
Needing help with suggestions for a KEEPER with$516.0K to spend.
I already have Heeney, W.Brodie, Cogniglio, Rowell as some of the possible choices.
I was leaning toward Cerra or maybe Vlaustin….
Your ideas very much appreciated.
Wines? Port look to be doing much better
TU: Boak
TD: Parish
Hi all. Think I phrased this badly earlier, so…….What is the rule RE: the 5 x Trade Boosts
TU: Can be used during the Supercoach Finals or
TD: Can only be used during the Supercoach Head to Head home and away season?
Best mid to bring in have 656k already have Neale,Oliver,Cripps,Macrae,BRodie,Cogs and Rowell . All other lines complete
I’d look at turning Rowell into Steele after Steele’s bye (and as Rowell is going to have his).
And therefore Laird / Brayshaw right now depending on bye’s and if the saved funds allows a potential upgrade soon.
Thanks
TU: trade in Boak
TD: trade in Parish
thanks people
oops sorry didnt see it was just asked a few up… sorry.