Questions? Questionables? Questionability? Quizzes? Quizzing? Quizzed? Quandaries? Queries? Queried? Quagmires? Q & A? FAQs? Quick answers!!
Will Hately finally get a game? How many players did you get on-field this week? Did you VC O’Brien last night? Is Cunnington a must-have? Whatever your query is, get it into the comments below and our Coaches will help out where they can………
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
46 thoughts on “Last Minute Queries – Rd13”
Hey community, wondering if it’s smarter to go to Caleb Daniel this week as he is cheap and get Boak later on or just bring in Boak now and worry about F6 later?
T/u – Bring in Boak now
T/d – Daniel this week, Boak later
That’s deliberate, Free kick Collingwood!!!!!
Currently my forward line is complete BUT im considering the following for a big saving and value…
Atkins OUT swinging TKelly into my midfield (finishing the year there at M7/8) and bringing in either daniel/boak as there much better value in there position than a merrett in the midfield?
TU : good move save the 80k and lock in a top 6 fwd with cash bein so scarce kelly is good enough to finish in ya mids.
TD : spend the 80k get merrett he is better than boak/daniel.
Looking at the current averages:
With Kelly in your MIDs, your F6 is unlikely to ave. 95+.
With Kelly FWD your M8 should still ave. a min. 110, 120 if you don’t have the top4 already.
That’s a min. 15pts/week or 165pts over the final 11 rounds (max 25/wk or 275 total)..
Massive dilemma on what to do with Hore – trade or hold???
TU (trade Hore):
TD (hold Hore):
Is Sicily/Bont a big enough upgrade on JJ/RGray to make it worth it?
If Hore is going to be your D6 then I’d hold.
Hore, JJ and Gray is better than Sicily, Lockhart(?) And Bont imo
It would be Duursma at D6.
So JJ/Hore/Gray vs Sicily/Duursma/Bont.
Do you have an extra 15000 to grab Sicily over JJ?
Nah, just short.
I’d keep Hore, double down to Bewley and Clarke and get yourself THE BEST this week. The other next week!
Do I trade Answerth to Clarke for a quick 80K?
T/U – Dunkley
T/D – Sicily
Has anyone heard how Steele’s scans went this morning? If his only 1-3 weeks might hold,if his 4 + then will trade for Dunkley.
According to Dr Google a dislocated patella is a minimu 6wks, likely longer for elite athletes (no jokes please 😉 )
He did in fact dislocate it, so you’d think 4+ min. However bad. Scans on STK website will be ‘in the next few days’. I’ve traded him already 🙁
Learned with Williams, Whitfield and Rocky to not hold on anymore and this is far more significant. Sad. But true.
Coaches, if Hately is named, is he a better downgrade option than Bewley?
Worried about both of their JS at the moment.
T/U – Hately better trade
T/D – Bewley better trade
Only 13 players on field
In: Clarke/ Boak/ Hind
Tu: Good Trades
Td: Think again!
Very tempted by Robbie Gray this week at just over $400k. I can only do one upgrade this week so it’ll have to be Gray or Dunkley. Decision is doing my head in at the moment:
Gray will likely score ok this week playing in the guts, but if when Rocky and/or Wines are back.
You’d THINK Dunkley is the better long-term solution.
Good luck whatever you decide!
13 trades left.. 15 playing this week before trades
1 fwd and 1 defender to complete team.. Should I:
TU: Out> Answerth, Scott and Corbett
In> Sicily, Clarke and Gardner
TD: Hold trades
Dursma and clark to bewley and boak TU
Ainsworth and clark to bewley and gray TD
Whitfield, Hayes, Scrimshaw
Sicily, Bewley, Blakely
T/U – Yes
T/D – No
Yep. If you have 16+ trades BEFORE this round.
Is Scott to Bewley worth the trade for 50k if it saves a donut this round?
Out Hore/ Atkins
In Boak/ Clarke
Tu: Good trades
TD: bad trades
Got Lobb who was a great second ruck. Now with him out do I sideway trade to McEvoy who was great before he was injured or hold off a week and upgrade to Gawn but will cost me all my spare cash and will leave me struggling to upgrade other spots.
TU Go to McEvoy and leave McEvoy and Grundy for the rest of the season
TD Hold and upgrade to gawn and downgrade other rookies and use that to upgrade other positions. This might be a problem with lack of good downgrade options.
That’s very unlucky. Lobb was looking great.
It was a shame i jumped him when McEvoy went down and he was fantastic and looked like a real keeper. Oh well ill hold and try to get to gawn somehow
Ryan and Gray
Fyfe and Bewley
I reckon it depends on your trades and how close to FULL you are Chillo.
Bewley will make cash and you likely want Fyfe. But if you don’t have the trades or cash-generators sitting around, you probably wanna go the other way as it’s gonna give you more and immediate onfield pts.
I’m actually more worried about getting the right cows.
Bewley is going to take a spot that could go to Clarke next week, or Naish the week after. Is that the right way to go? I might sleep on it and make the call tomorrow…
Good idea. Will you not have room for Clarke next week if you go Bewley this? You’re in a very strong position if not!
I got Bewley this week and will likely go for Clarke next. Having held his spot this week with ESS’s big INs, you’d think his JS is pretty good.
If I could only take one, it’d probably definitely maybe be Clarke!
18 trades prior to this potential trade.
TU: Clark/Answerth/Westhoff to Boak/Sicily/Hind – 16 players & $18K left
TD: Clark/Answerth/Stocker to Sicily/Hind/Clarke – 17 players & $237K left
Hind would be cash generation.
DEF: Laird, Lloyd, Williams, Smith, Hore, Clarke, (Burgess, Gardner)
MID: Jelly, Macrae, Fyfe, Neale, Cripps, BCrouch, OBaker, Bewley, (Answerth, Stocker, Scott)
RUC: Gawn, Grundy (Pines)
FWD: Dunkley, Danger, Heeney, TKelly, Westhoff, Baker (Setters, Young)
Next rd – Clarke or Naish via DPP
You have so many trades left. Keep the cash generating and enjoy spending it in the best! Big TD from me!
can I have some of your trades please???
Merrett or the bont?
bont averages 130 this season at marvel and guess where doggies next 8 out of 10 games are… yup marvel! but merrett loves to rack up the pill and pts also.
Bont! his 25k cheaper too.
Wrong PieMan. My bad
Bont if you want pts and a highlights reel. Zerrett if you just want the pts 😉
Seriously? Don’t know. Both good choices you’d think?
Good luck with it!
Bont has been moved forward a lot more lately with Doggies inability to kick a decent bag and also coinciding with Dunkley going back into he mids … I’m willing to bet that Merrett (with some better love from CD) will outscore Bont from now on IF Bont stays more forward as he has of late … but possibly cant go wrong with either??
TU: Caleb Daniel
TD: Rowan Marshall
Yeah, I’m beginning to think I should have jumped on Daniel earlier now too … he hasn’t looked like dropping off in good scoring at all … very consistent …
Yep. Might be my final upgrade. DEFs score better than FWDs, on recent years’ averages. He’s pretty good at his role too!