Ideally yes but lost so much value you need to use two trades to get anything good. Got Q Clash and tigers before the bye. If he cant score against those teams he never will and you cull on the bye
Two injuries in the first round of the byes means I’ll probably spend the rest of the byes trying to keep my head above water instead of upgrading my team.
Confused as to why TU is heavily in favour thus far. Baz and Heeney let’s say is a 50/50 (I do think Smith out averaging him for the rest of the year), however Trac as a fwd is a must have and is off the bye. TD easily.
Problem is you have 5 midfielders not playing none of them with DPP so you can’t swap in some of your DPP forwards. Plenty of trades though. If you have a boost I would do 4.
Trade out Derksen put back Holmes (Def finished).
Trade out Burton
Trade out Flanders to rook. bring Murdock on field.
Find 2 DPP mids 1 rook 1 premo.
Then you might do something with Lindsay if you want to.
Lindsay’s breakeven is so high, he’ll almost definitely lose cash this week. Rookies are in the team to make money so Lindsay absolutely has to go in my mind
Trade out Lindsay. Move Holmes to defense and get either LDU or Anderson in Mids. Trade out Retchko and get Any playing rookie mid. Trade out Flanders for any premium that has had bye either miller or jhf.
TU: Flanders, Lindsay, Retschko to Gawn, LDU and 99k rookie
TD: Flanders, Lindsay, Mcluggage to Heeney, LDU and B Macdonald
Both these trades leave me with no cash itb.
Comment: Flanders and Lindsay to Heeney and B Macdonald (242k itb)
Is it worth using 2 extra trades to do the following? Already missing 6 premiums on the last bye but Wilkie is such amazing value and is a top 6 defender if you take away his injury game.
got 48,700 in the bank just had a really good round 1936 top 1% looking to get rid of at least 2 if not all 3 of retschko, angry, and jaques which players should i target was considering rowell but looks like im going to need to get both cameron nairn and bailey mcdonald and i dont know how long they stay in the team for please reply with some targets
Oof here we go again with the sideways/injury trades.
Current plan pending teams announcements
Flanders -> Petracca
J.Lindsay -> 99k DEF rookie
Will try to bank some more cash and sit longer on rookies like Retschko, Cumming and Angry Anderson as I may have traded out a few too early this year already eg Jagga, Pou etc
Very torn here only due to the awful bye.
Would much prefer him over anyone else around his price. Take out the injury affected game and it’s a 108 average, looking every bit of a top 6 defender. Ideally I prefer someone coming off the bye, however I think this value might be too good to pass up.
Weighing him up against a Touk for example. There are a number of forwards who can deliver the same output for the same price, where as I don’t think we will get the same value down back.
Wilkie still a play if he is your 7th premo out on that last bye?
I’ve been weighing up Wilkie or Sanders this week and going with Wilkie for reasons you mention. Note on Sanders, since his first 2 low games he’s averaged 106, similar logic to Wilkie so he’s a solid pick too. Same bye unfortunately though!
Just want to say that I feel it’s important to acknowledge the contributors for their work and articles. I know everyone wants to figure out the best next move but a read and thanks (or thumbs up) for those doing the work never goes astray. It’s community of people who love footy! Carry on….
Brought in Sanders last week and he did exactly what I wanted. think he’s a cut above, role there, and a 105 player. Reckon Touk and JHF are similar, 95ish. JHF throwing in the 70’s and 120’s Touk closer to 85’s and 110’s. Touk with the bye behind for me.
Is it worth trading retscho for a player like Rowell? Retscho probably has a bit of cash to make but would leave me with 2 rookies
TU – trade retscho, has the bye anyways & get Rowell in while he’s cheap
TD – hold retscho
Lindsay was totally shafted by CD 13 kicks (11 effective), 6 handballs (6 effective), 6 hball receives, 5 marks, 2 spoils and 300 metres gained for only 59 WTF!
The numbers also change depending on when he gets the stats so you can’t just look at the final stas and expect a certain result. It’s a big part of the charm of supercoach cause it means that defenders can end up scoring well by doing team things without having stellar stat lines
But if you look at the official points scoring data published on the site they are the amount of points a player scores for those actions. You can’t say “A player will score X for an effective kick” and then give him Y for an effective kick, if there is a range between -10 and +20 for an effective kick that’s what the official game rules should say. Based on the published game rules for scoring somebody is cheating.
Another example is Cripps’ mark and goal to win the game, in other games the same actions have scored as much as 30 when done by a Bontempelli or daicos but Crippa only got 11.
That’s not ‘charm of the game’ that’s evidence that it’s pure luck based on an unknown stats persons love or hate of a particular team/player
First trade required little thought, Flanders to Trac. Done.
Second trade, somehow Carroll is still in my team but with a BE 80 time to go. Been weighing up Wilkie or Sanders but going for Wilkie. Each of the last 3 years he’s shown he can bring massive scores but this year he’s brought consistency. Sanders might complete my team post bye if he keeps his form.
Still have 286k in the bank so could bring in a JHF or Bailey this week also but I’m tempted to wait until next week either for Xerri (BE 188) or Finn (cheap as he’ll get).
TU: Bring in JHF or Bailey
TD: Wait a week for one of the others (Xerri will probably need an extra downgrade)
We’re definitely involving him more in ball movement this year which has boosted lots of those numbers plus Silvagni being able to lock onto someone frees Wilkie up to roam a little more
Crows mid-season draftee Hugo Hall-Kahan is set to make a surprising debut in Thursday’s Cats clash. Isaac Cumming’s fresh hamstring concern has opened the door for the 22yo, who has made an instant impression with his speed and line-breaking from defence
Can anyone give some insight into Luke Parker as of recent? Hasn’t been scoring the best but still respectable numbers and comes off his bye at a juicy price. Role hasn’t changed from what I can gather.
TU: Parker (Off his bye)
TD: Wilkie (Bye is a killer)
I’d look at the 3 who’ve had the bye but it’s really dealer’s choice who you go for there. Rowell is cheapest, LDU has been best this year, Dawson has been best historically. I don’t think you can really go wrong
I think I’ve changed my mind now on holding Retschko lol
Flanders -> Petracca
J.Lindsay -> 99k DEF rookie eg Hugo Hall-Kahan who has been named
Retschko -> LDU
Thinking out loud, if I hold Retschko it means no points in rd 13, a rookie score against Brissy while wait for cash gen rd 14 and then maybe he makes an extra 10k before I upgrade in rd15?
If I upgrade him now it means both extra points in rd 13 and 14 which helps a lot, one less rookie upgrade to worry about later, all the INs have had a bye already and i avoid cancelling out any cash gen by LDU/other going up in price in rd 13 and 14 before I can upgrade in rd 15. i am left with 62k in the bank and then 10 trades to upgrade 3 remaining on-field rookies. Feels like a decent plan?
TU: go for it, getting near a completed team
TD: hold off and stick with just 2 trades, let the rookies cook a few more weeks
Both great picks – I’m hoping one of these boys will be my last premo trade. For my team, I slightly favour Heeney because of his R15 bye (I have too many players with Smith’s R16 bye).
Burton Derksen Flanders > HHK Lake Tracc
Still have 14 trades after the above. Hamilton gives me Fwd/Mid swings as have Murdock & Poo still
TU Yes Do it
TD no it’s a waste
Not sure who to get as my second trade, already getting Rowell. I also already have Anderson and petraca so I feel like I can’t really get touk aswell.. should I get Wilkie even though he still has the bye? I was thinking of getting horne Francis but him and touk just seem so inconsistent and Wilkie has been putting up good numbers
TU – get Wilkie ( seems like a proven premium at this point and great value )
TD – horne Francis/touk (off the bye but scoring isn’t as good)
Thinking going either of these two options
TU – Retschko & Flanders to Heeney & LDU ($38,100 ITB)
TD – Retschko & Flanders to Sanders & LDU ($126,300 ITB)
Can we start again? 2 more casualties this round at the moment….Flanders and Coleman…looks like Murdock is here to stay.
Flanders replacement (looking at similar price and off bye)
Tu: Touk
Td: JHF
Was about to ask the same question. Touk for me
i was going to get both this week
if you had to choose one, JHF is a bit cheaper, and if that cash saved can help you get someone else, then get JHF
Looking for some money makers this week while the byes are happening
thinking of getting flanders looks good at half back, one bad game dosent matter
jamie elliot seems to be very reliable down forward as well
tu: good trades
td:think again
Get Steven Wright. He can tell an original and funny joke.
Lindsay’s done a great job but time to go. Whose better trade in:
Tu: Rowell
Td: LDU
is mccluggage a trade out
tu:yes
td:no
Ideally yes but lost so much value you need to use two trades to get anything good. Got Q Clash and tigers before the bye. If he cant score against those teams he never will and you cull on the bye
Two injuries in the first round of the byes means I’ll probably spend the rest of the byes trying to keep my head above water instead of upgrading my team.
Better rookie?
T/u – Bailey MacDonald
T/d – Tom Anastasopolous
Be careful trusting a hawks rookie. They never stay in team for long
Can’t get both because of the R16 bye, which one?
T/u – Cal Wilkie
T/d – Ryley Sanders
Thinking of going Flanders, Retschko and Angry -> Touk, LDU and a 99k rookie.
Want LDU because of North’s upcoming run
T/u – Rowell
T/d – Richards
Rowell has already had his bye
TU – Flanders -> Touk / JHF
TD – Lindsay & Retschko -> LDU & B. Mcdonald
TU: JHF
TD: Bailey
TU: Wilkie (little bit cheaper)
TD: Worrell (no more bye)
Out: Lindsay, Edwards, Retschko and Flanders
In: B McDonald, msd mid that gets selected, Rowell and Wilkie.
tu: ryley sanders
td: ed richards
Looking for a defender off the bye. Milera worth the cash?
TU: Yep good average and can keep it up.
TD: Too pricey, look elsewhere.
TU – LDU
TD – Heeney
With Flanders out, I have taken this opportunity to delete my team. See you all next year!
on a serious note though, this game bites the big one
on a more serious note,
Flanders AAnderson Lindsay OUT
Petracca Wilkie Anastasopoulos IN
TU: LDU & Heeney
or
TD: Baz & Trac
Confused as to why TU is heavily in favour thus far. Baz and Heeney let’s say is a 50/50 (I do think Smith out averaging him for the rest of the year), however Trac as a fwd is a must have and is off the bye. TD easily.
Have you considered LDU and Tracca.
Hey boys, would you please help a girl out? $53,900 ITB 17 trades. Playing for leagues only. What should I do this week?
Def: Sinc Whitfield Ash Wilkie Clark Lindsday (Derk Edwards)
Mid: Butters Nandos Holmes Clarry Callaghan Walsh Luggage Ison (Retsch Cumming Burton)
Ruck: Gawn Jackson (ZZ)
Fwd: Sheezel Flanders JHF McInerney Bailey Poo (Murdock Banfiend)
Flex: McAndrew
Missing 4 this week – Whitfield Ash Clarry Finn
Problem is you have 5 midfielders not playing none of them with DPP so you can’t swap in some of your DPP forwards. Plenty of trades though. If you have a boost I would do 4.
Trade out Derksen put back Holmes (Def finished).
Trade out Burton
Trade out Flanders to rook. bring Murdock on field.
Find 2 DPP mids 1 rook 1 premo.
Then you might do something with Lindsay if you want to.
Derksen doesn’t have enough money to do a trade. Just do Lindsay out and swing Holmes back that way
Would you do Lindsay to HHK over Derksen? Was thinking Derksen just to get one more score from Lindsay
Lindsay’s breakeven is so high, he’ll almost definitely lose cash this week. Rookies are in the team to make money so Lindsay absolutely has to go in my mind
How about Derksen + Burton + Flanders to HHK Hamilton (Mid/Fwd/) swing + Tracc + $89k? Fixes up any dead rookies and gets me the right swinga
McLuggage, Flanders Phillipou >> LDU, Petracca, Anastastopolous
Anastastopolous on Bench, Murdoch on field.
Trade out Lindsay. Move Holmes to defense and get either LDU or Anderson in Mids. Trade out Retchko and get Any playing rookie mid. Trade out Flanders for any premium that has had bye either miller or jhf.
This is the way to go. I would say try to bring in Petracca as the forward if you can afford him over the other two
Thanks – who would you trade Lindsay too? Already have Anderson and JHF
Can you get Petracca? Lindsay, Retschko & Flanders to Tracc, Rowell & a rookie?
Who’s the better duo to trade in?
TU – LDU & Touk (Both off their bye and LDU great run coming up)
TD – Heeney & Z.Bailey (Bye still to come for both and I have a feeling Lions might consider increasing Bailey’s mid minutes)
TIA!
TU: Flanders, Lindsay, Retschko to Gawn, LDU and 99k rookie
TD: Flanders, Lindsay, Mcluggage to Heeney, LDU and B Macdonald
Both these trades leave me with no cash itb.
Comment: Flanders and Lindsay to Heeney and B Macdonald (242k itb)
Can you do Flanders, Lindsay and Clug to Heeney, Gawn and someone?
I can do Heeney, Gawn and BMac if he is named, is Clug worth getting rid of though?
Hasn’t been great this year but is Chad Warner worth a look given Sydney’s insane run home?
does harry kyle have job security
Flanders > Rowell basically locked in.
Is it worth using 2 extra trades to do the following? Already missing 6 premiums on the last bye but Wilkie is such amazing value and is a top 6 defender if you take away his injury game.
Edwards > Rookie
Philipou > Wilkie
TU: Go for it
TD: Just use the one trade
Flanders and Washcroft > Dawson and Heeney
T/U Good do it
T/D Wait until after byes
trading out washcroft not the play unless ur team is fully finished
Better trade out this week, retschko or lindsay?
Restchko on bye but possibly still some cash to make, compared to lindsay who probably will start leaking cash.
In Warner and Anderson
Out Flanders and Reshtko
Tu: yes
TD: no
Rankine Keep or Trade
TU: Keep
TD: Trade
Mcclugage Keep or Trade
TU: Keep
TD: Trade
Flanders replacement
TU Treacy
TD Touk
483k ready for trades this week
Flanders to JHF
Coleman to LDU via Holmes
Lindsay to Wilkie
Still leaves me with 231k
got 48,700 in the bank just had a really good round 1936 top 1% looking to get rid of at least 2 if not all 3 of retschko, angry, and jaques which players should i target was considering rowell but looks like im going to need to get both cameron nairn and bailey mcdonald and i dont know how long they stay in the team for please reply with some targets
Hugo Hall-Kahan will suit up for the Crows this weekend…if ya fancy a punt on a 99K rookie, at least we know he’s gonna play one game!
TU: Lindsay retschko and Flanders out for petracca LDU and B MacDonald
TD: Lindsay Rachelle Flanders for Bontempelli petracca and Nairn
Would love suggestions for my team – 101k ITB, 18 trades 1 boost remaining.
DEF: Sinclair, Holmes, Ash, Clark, Daicos, Lindsay (W.Edwards, Derskson)
MID: Butters, Bont, Merrett, Sheezel, Daicos, Richards, Tsatas, Ison (Retschko, Cumming, Anderson)
RUC: Grundy, Jackson (ZZ)
FWD: Trac, Pickett, Jmac, Murdock, Phillipou, Lombard (T.Edwards, Banfield)
FLX: Flanders’s
Thinking Lindsay, Flanders > Wilkie, Bailey.
Any other suggestions to improve?
This might be a bit crazy and outrageous.
Lindsay, Flanders, Tsatas OUT
swing ZZ to defence
K.White, Darcy Cameron (flex) and Baz/Heeney IN
Flanders, Lindsay and Lombard to whoever suits your byes.
Might even look at Phillipou out before Lombard now who has a lower breakeven
I would looking at players from Crows, Port, Suns or North this week for your upgrades
TU: Lindsay Retsch Flanders for Bont Trac and mid season rook
TD: Lindsay retsch and Flanders out for petracca LDU and B MacDonald
Like Parker’s run home and the fact that he is already past his bye, so shading him over Wilkie.
Like JHF’s run home more than Miller’s too.
Flanders, Pou & Marshall for JHF, Parker & a selected rookie.
TU
TD
TU: Wilkie
TD: Touk Miller
anyone know the extend of kidie coleman and justin Mcienerny injuries?
thanks
Coleman 5-6 weeks
McInerney nothing official yet but I suspect he will be a test this week
Oof here we go again with the sideways/injury trades.
Current plan pending teams announcements
Flanders -> Petracca
J.Lindsay -> 99k DEF rookie
Will try to bank some more cash and sit longer on rookies like Retschko, Cumming and Angry Anderson as I may have traded out a few too early this year already eg Jagga, Pou etc
TU: Bailey Smith
TD: Heeney
Comment: LDU
TU: Petracca
TD: Rowell
TU: JHF
TD: CHAD W
TU – Lindsay, Flanders > Wilkie, Bailey
TD – Lindsay, Flanders > Wilkie, JHF
Comment other
Wilkie at 457k?
Very torn here only due to the awful bye.
Would much prefer him over anyone else around his price. Take out the injury affected game and it’s a 108 average, looking every bit of a top 6 defender. Ideally I prefer someone coming off the bye, however I think this value might be too good to pass up.
Weighing him up against a Touk for example. There are a number of forwards who can deliver the same output for the same price, where as I don’t think we will get the same value down back.
Wilkie still a play if he is your 7th premo out on that last bye?
Thoughts really appreciated community!
I’ve been weighing up Wilkie or Sanders this week and going with Wilkie for reasons you mention. Note on Sanders, since his first 2 low games he’s averaged 106, similar logic to Wilkie so he’s a solid pick too. Same bye unfortunately though!
Best trade in:
TU – Heeney
TD – Smith
TU: Lindsay Retsch Flanders for Bont Trac and mid season rook
TD: Lindsay retsch Flanders for Trac Wilkie MacDonald
TU – Petracca
TD – Rowell
Just want to say that I feel it’s important to acknowledge the contributors for their work and articles. I know everyone wants to figure out the best next move but a read and thanks (or thumbs up) for those doing the work never goes astray. It’s community of people who love footy! Carry on….
is there a risk brining in issac heeny give errol is back soon or i shouldn’t be worried about it?
Heeney’s goal scoring/big play ability should protect against the midfield minutes Gulden may soak up
for flanders replacement who should i bring in? currently think of one of either Sanders, Touk Miller or Horne Francis.
Thoughts on which one?
Brought in Sanders last week and he did exactly what I wanted. think he’s a cut above, role there, and a 105 player. Reckon Touk and JHF are similar, 95ish. JHF throwing in the 70’s and 120’s Touk closer to 85’s and 110’s. Touk with the bye behind for me.
Touk for me personally
TU – Dawson
TD – LDU
Currently own Xerri & Sheezel. With zero Adelaide players
Is it worth trading retscho for a player like Rowell? Retscho probably has a bit of cash to make but would leave me with 2 rookies
TU – trade retscho, has the bye anyways & get Rowell in while he’s cheap
TD – hold retscho
TU: Trac
TD: LDU3
Trading for this week
Flanders phillipou A.Anderson for Trac, Mid-Season Rook, and ……
TU: Touk Miller
TD: Another Premium?
My forward line looks like Sheezel, trac, mccinerney, Tkelly, Mcckerher
TU – Bailey
TD – Warner
Surprised no one has asked this – but Rowell (value) vs Anderson (form) to bring in as last mid?
TU – Rowell
TD – Anderson
Rowell’s value is to good to ignore. I’m hoping his hand is ok.
Lindsay was totally shafted by CD 13 kicks (11 effective), 6 handballs (6 effective), 6 hball receives, 5 marks, 2 spoils and 300 metres gained for only 59 WTF!
11 effective kicks =44 – 2 clangers =Total kicks 36
6 effective hballs = 9
6 hball receives = 9
5 marks UC = 10
2 spoils = 4
1 harball get =4.5
2 looseball gets = 9
1FA = -4
Total = 77.5
In a winning team
He started on bench and came on about the 20 min mark.
The numbers also change depending on when he gets the stats so you can’t just look at the final stas and expect a certain result. It’s a big part of the charm of supercoach cause it means that defenders can end up scoring well by doing team things without having stellar stat lines
But if you look at the official points scoring data published on the site they are the amount of points a player scores for those actions. You can’t say “A player will score X for an effective kick” and then give him Y for an effective kick, if there is a range between -10 and +20 for an effective kick that’s what the official game rules should say. Based on the published game rules for scoring somebody is cheating.
Another example is Cripps’ mark and goal to win the game, in other games the same actions have scored as much as 30 when done by a Bontempelli or daicos but Crippa only got 11.
That’s not ‘charm of the game’ that’s evidence that it’s pure luck based on an unknown stats persons love or hate of a particular team/player
Is Luke Parker likely to get rested ????
If Kangas stay in finals contention, less likely. Maybe 1 week along the way
I am wondering myself if he is a viable trade in, would love to get peoples thoughts
First trade required little thought, Flanders to Trac. Done.
Second trade, somehow Carroll is still in my team but with a BE 80 time to go. Been weighing up Wilkie or Sanders but going for Wilkie. Each of the last 3 years he’s shown he can bring massive scores but this year he’s brought consistency. Sanders might complete my team post bye if he keeps his form.
Still have 286k in the bank so could bring in a JHF or Bailey this week also but I’m tempted to wait until next week either for Xerri (BE 188) or Finn (cheap as he’ll get).
TU: Bring in JHF or Bailey
TD: Wait a week for one of the others (Xerri will probably need an extra downgrade)
Wilkie is puzzling me. What has changed? What has made him go from a solid 95 ave to elite 110? And will it continue?
I always worry when a player starts the season well, better than he should, only to have normality resume mid-season.
I have 1 defender to fill and will wait for NAS
I’ve looked at the number of marks and possessions. 178 marks in 2024, 194 last year, but he’s already on 121 after 12 games.
Last year 429 possessions but already up to 280.
So he’s smashing previous numbers. Yes, the big question is whether he can sustain it. I hope so!
could be saints style of play?
We’re definitely involving him more in ball movement this year which has boosted lots of those numbers plus Silvagni being able to lock onto someone frees Wilkie up to roam a little more
IN: LDU, Tracc and named rookie
OUT: Flanders, Poo and Retschko
TU – LDU
TD – Rowell
TU – LDU, Anderson, Miller.
TD – Players like Bont, Wilkie, Gawn…
Who’s better as a def, cab get in anyone really
TU: A. Roberts
TD: W. Milera
Comment other eg. Parker/Blakey
Have: Holmes, Whitfield, Sinclair, Clark currently
Or fk the byes
TU: Dale
TD: NAS/Wilkie
i like Bowey personally..
Flanders replacement:
TU: Touk Miller
TD: Jake Bowey (Mckercher swing fwd)
Depends on your team’s needs. Bowey for reliability and consistency, Miller for a higher ceiling but higher score variation
not to happy with the score let me know about my trades
out:
mcirnerney,linsday and steene
in:
sanders,mccarthey,smith
tu im cookin
td im loosing
bro is not me btw
Flanders replacement.
Tu:Sanders
TD: Miller
Comment: Hall or Bailey
for me personally, Bailey at his current price is pretty irresistable
Crows mid-season draftee Hugo Hall-Kahan is set to make a surprising debut in Thursday’s Cats clash. Isaac Cumming’s fresh hamstring concern has opened the door for the 22yo, who has made an instant impression with his speed and line-breaking from defence
That’s very handy, DPP too
Worth going early on him for the cash injection?
Hey everyone.
Two options this week:
TU: 1 trade – Flanders to Bailey Smith
TD: 2 trades – Flanders to LDU / Lindsay to Wilkie
Tu – Zac Bailey
Td – touk
Playing for league,
I like Zac Bailey but brains saying touk
Lindsay flanders mcclugage –> touk Wayne milera rowell
Tu good
Td bad
TU: Bailey Smith
TD: LDU
Coleman replacement and looking at defenders coming off the bye
TU: Wayne Milera
TD: Worrell
TU: Lindsay to Wilkie and avoid Lindsay losing more cash
TD: Phillipou to Rowell to get a player with no upcoming bye
Can anyone give some insight into Luke Parker as of recent? Hasn’t been scoring the best but still respectable numbers and comes off his bye at a juicy price. Role hasn’t changed from what I can gather.
TU: Parker (Off his bye)
TD: Wilkie (Bye is a killer)
Which rookie to trade this week, both score around the same BE around the same.
T/U Anderson JS fair to medium
T/D Retschko JS medium
Would you use Rachele to trade into LDU, or just use my two rooks to grab JHF?
LDU (No Rache)
jHF (Keep Rache)
which combo of premos should i trade in (best 2 to trade in)
Baz, Heeney, LDU, Rowell, Dawson
Cant do baz and heeney* too expensive
I’d look at the 3 who’ve had the bye but it’s really dealer’s choice who you go for there. Rowell is cheapest, LDU has been best this year, Dawson has been best historically. I don’t think you can really go wrong
If Jmac does not play this week is it worth trading him out as they have their bye coming up too?
TU – Yes
TD – No
TU Wilke
TD LDU
I think I’ve changed my mind now on holding Retschko lol
Flanders -> Petracca
J.Lindsay -> 99k DEF rookie eg Hugo Hall-Kahan who has been named
Retschko -> LDU
Thinking out loud, if I hold Retschko it means no points in rd 13, a rookie score against Brissy while wait for cash gen rd 14 and then maybe he makes an extra 10k before I upgrade in rd15?
If I upgrade him now it means both extra points in rd 13 and 14 which helps a lot, one less rookie upgrade to worry about later, all the INs have had a bye already and i avoid cancelling out any cash gen by LDU/other going up in price in rd 13 and 14 before I can upgrade in rd 15. i am left with 62k in the bank and then 10 trades to upgrade 3 remaining on-field rookies. Feels like a decent plan?
TU: go for it, getting near a completed team
TD: hold off and stick with just 2 trades, let the rookies cook a few more weeks
TU: Wilkie
TD: Parker
Comment: Milera
TU: Touk this week
TD: Play Poo on field and grab Pickett after his bye
Would complete my forward line
Others are Sheezel Tracc JHF Bailey Juzzy
Upgrade Lindsey to Roberts? Even though his BE is 150? I just don’t trust any other def premos
Only other premo i’ll have out is Heeney.
Who else do you have on your defensive line? Think there’s better options than Roberts at this point – Dale, Wilkie, Ash and Blakey comes to mind.
Am I crazy considering bringing in McCluggage at 394k with two enticing matchups before his bye …. would give me the extra $$ to bring in Rowell.
T/U: Jump on board – Rowell and McCluggage in
T/D: Stay away – JHF and Miller/Bailey instead.
Form is temporary…..class is permanent.
Most of the time !!!!
And yes, I have luggage
Help me out guys!
TU: Rowell (+ save $70k)
TD: Anderson
William Edwards BE is now 55
TU – Hold
TD – Downgrade to Hugo Hall-Kahan
Comment for another rookie downgrade option if better
Who is the best Mid/Fwd $99k rookie loop if I need one? Considering games etc
having a look I think there are only 5 players who meet that criteria and none of them have played a single game yet. not sure if that helps 🙂
Campbell Lake is probably a chance to get a game at some stage but I have no idea about the others
Lake has been named for Sunday
Flanders Poo Clugg > Tracc LDU Anastopolous
TU Good Trades
TD Bad Trades
Tu Parker + 50k
Td wayne milera
Any reason to hold mcclugage or do i straight trade up to Rowell
Tu yes need to trade
Td might as well hold him
TU: Sinclair
TD: Save 120k and go Wilke
TU: Bont
TD: Rowell
And bring in Bont following round 16
TU: Dawson
TD: LDU
Who to trade out:
TU: Phillopou
TD: A. Anderson
TU:
Retschko –> Smith
Flanders –> Pickett
Lombard –> Bailey
TD:
Retschko –> Smith
Flanders –> LDU
I can’t split the two.
Wilkie or Rowell.
Which ever I pick finishes off that position.
Rowell doesn’t have a bye so if you’re stuck between the two, go for him. I’m personally going Wilkie but that’s only cause I need a defender
Both
TU Touk
TD Pickett
TU: Flanders, Bruhn to LDU, Touk – 13k ITB
TD: Flanders, Bruhn, Lindsay to LDU, Heeney, Hall-Kahan – 154k ITB
Hall-Kahan yet to play a game charlie edwards on the bubble and dpp only an extra 20K
TU Touk
TD Rowell
Can get either baz or heeney
Which is better and who will average more for the rest of the season taking into account their venue they play at, draw etc
Both great picks – I’m hoping one of these boys will be my last premo trade. For my team, I slightly favour Heeney because of his R15 bye (I have too many players with Smith’s R16 bye).
Thanks baz
Who is best to trade in:
TU: Nairn
TD: Anastasopoulos
Comment any other fwd rookie
Thanks.
Also best option moving forward?
Out of:
Defs: Wilkie, Lizard, Dale, Roberts
Fwds: Touk, Sanders etc
This is my backline which I don’t love:
– Sinclair, Holmes, Ash, Clark, Daicos
Would appreciate any comments.
TU- Trade DShort>DWilmot
TD- Hold Fire
Sorry..J Short (old man fingers typo)
TU: Baz this week & Heeney next week
Or
TD: Heeney & LDU this week
Burton Derksen Flanders > HHK Lake Tracc
Still have 14 trades after the above. Hamilton gives me Fwd/Mid swings as have Murdock & Poo still
TU Yes Do it
TD no it’s a waste
is jack steele a trade out?
Not sure who to get as my second trade, already getting Rowell. I also already have Anderson and petraca so I feel like I can’t really get touk aswell.. should I get Wilkie even though he still has the bye? I was thinking of getting horne Francis but him and touk just seem so inconsistent and Wilkie has been putting up good numbers
TU – get Wilkie ( seems like a proven premium at this point and great value )
TD – horne Francis/touk (off the bye but scoring isn’t as good)
Doing Flanders & Lindsay OUT for Hall-Kahan & Rowell IN. Leaves me with $340K.
Tempted to use a 3rd trade for Retschko to LDU?
TU : Go for it – one premo closer to a completed team
TD : Hold off on 3rd trade, have 22 players this round without doing it.
Tu mcclugage to Rowell
Td philipou to jhf
Lindsay flanders philipou –> touk Wayne milera JHF
Tu good trades
Td bad trades
Out: Flanders, Lindsay, Retschko
In: Miller, Heeney, Hall-Kahan
TU or TD
To start on field
Tu wade derksen
Td bodhie ryan
Is Clug a trade out now? I had Retschko going out for Rowell but now I’m thinking Clug out
Carnage: Out Flanders fwd and Busslinger def
TU. in Sinclair and red dot fwd/mid — best player in comp
TD. In Bowey and red dot fwd/mid — 50-90k dollars bank credit for last mid in two weeks time
R16 remains the same + one week delay in picking up flex 1. Xerri bonus high B.E. will make less expensive, or 2. Nankervis ~70k dollars bank credit
TU Oliver
TD Walsh
Ignoring the bye
Which is the better trade to get?
TU Nguyen-Joyce. Flanders-JHF. Retschko-LDU. Left with 9k ITB
TD Nguyen-Joyce. Flanders-Touk. Retschko-Rowell. Left with 33k ITB
TU: Bowey
TD: Wilmot
Last week’s trades were
Cook, T.Marshall & Dovaston > Banfield, Wilkie & Ison
Already done Lindsay down to HHK
Def – Sinclair, Holmes, Whitfield, Wilkie, McCarthy, Houston (Derksen, W.Edwards)
Mid – Butters, Bont, Merrett, Daicos, Callaghan, W.Duursma, Retschko (S.Cumming, HHK , Burton)
Ruc – Gawn, Jackson (McAndrew)
Fwd – Sheezel, Trac, Flanders, Kozzy, JHF, Smith (Lombard, Banfield)
Flex – Murdock
$442,000 ITB, 15 trades left, 1 boost
Thinking going either of these two options
TU – Retschko & Flanders to Heeney & LDU ($38,100 ITB)
TD – Retschko & Flanders to Sanders & LDU ($126,300 ITB)
any feedback/suggestions appreciated!
With McCluggage out…
Strongly considering cutting my losses and trading to JHF?
TU or TD?
Out: Flanders, Retschko
In: Miller, Rowell
TU or TD
Would you trade Murphy Reid to Pickett whilst they are the same price?
TU – Yes
YD – No
TU: Trac
TD: Zac Bailey
I’m stuck
Keen on bringing Zac Bailey in with possibly more midfield time with clug out.
Touk feels safer tho
Tu – touk
Td – Bailey