186 thoughts on “Last Minute Queries – Round 1”

    • i think his JS is ok, there could be some management of his TOG. As a Tigers defender he should see plenty of the ball, and should be ok scorer.

      3
      1
      Reply

    • Unlimited trades for the remainder of the week, however players will be locked in/out of your team and in position once their teams game gas started.

      8
      0
      Reply

    • i can’t un-see Coleman’s price of $233k. he is basically an expensive rookie price. at that price it doesn’t matter if he plays 50/50 defence and forward, as long as his TOG isn’t managed to much, he had 74% TOG r0 and started the game at half-back. He is back in my team.

      9
      2
      Reply

    • Same thoughts but after some consideration it’s Coleman for me . Price plus think he’ll gradually get better with more games under his belt and playing in a top side. Windsor looked great but was blowing hard against a weak Tigers outfit. Don’t think he has the tank to sustain a full game in the midfield but will definitely improve.

      3
      2
      Reply

  11. Tell me you love the squad, all feedback welcome. Tear it apart

    DEF: Sinclair, Rozee, Clark, McKercher, Grlj, Jacques (Lindsay, Serong)
    MID: Butters, Anderson, Dawson, Richards, Walsh, Parish, Bruhn, Smith (Carroll, Macrae, Blamires)
    RCK: Jackson, McAndrew (Reidy)
    FWD: Sheezel, Petracca, Flanders, Phillipou, Marshall, Dovaston (Murray, Robertson)
    FLX: Lombard

    4
    3
    Reply

  13. All Feedback Welcomed.

    Have been tossing up Sinclair vs another premo defender and R1 selection

    DEF: Sinclair, Rozee, Clark, McKercher, Grlj, Jacques (Lindsay, Serong)
    MID: Butters, Anderson, Dawson, Richards, Walsh, Parish, Bruhn, Smith (Carroll, Macrae, Blamires)
    RCK: Jackson, McAndrew (Reidy)
    FWD: Sheezel, Petracca, Flanders, Phillipou, Marshall, Dovaston (Murray, Robertson)
    FLX: Lombard

    1
    3
    Reply

    • would have loved to see both play in round 0 to have a better look at them

      Windsor we only saw half a AAMI game from him, but he had some good match-sim prior to that. I have liked him as a footballer the last couple of years and this might be his big moment. He had a bad run with injury last year, even spent some time in hospital, had a foot problem and did a hammy late in the year. Even without a midfield role, i would have been interested in him.

      I’m not sure Blakiston is up to being the sole ruck against the big boys. He had one good quarter in the AAMI that made his score look better than it should have been. There was a game last year, i belive Round 21 against Sydney where he played the first ruck and scored 53 from 90% TOG (against Grundy). He should get at least 5 rounds as ruck, and after that should hold is place in the team as a defender.

      5
      2
      Reply

  18. Put this in the other thread, but might get buried now…

    TU: 3rd Premo Defender (Clark)
    TD: 2nd Premo Ruck (English/Gawn/Jackson/Grundy/Anyone, McAndrew Flex)

    7
    10
    Reply

  19. who are people thinking are the lock rookies at this point?
    Based on team whispers ive rejigged the rookies on my team to be:

    Grlj, Jacques, Sellwood, Serong, Lindsay
    Smith, Sharp, Carroll, Blamires
    McAndrew, ZZ
    Phillipou, Robertson, Marshall, Lombard

    any big ones Im missing? Im not sold Lindsay/Sellwood/Carroll but cant think of any guys Id prefer over them TBH.
    Based on my experience small forwards like Rosa/Dovaston wont score well, and Im thinking Gibcus as a key back is not as good as the other def options. The port mid rookies have less JS than Carroll in my opinion.

    4
    0
    Reply

  20. Just wondering what coaches are doing around the captains loophole.

    Are coaches picking a player that they know won’t play or are you picking 31 players that are all expected to play and foregoing the loophole.

    Thumbs up – non playing player
    Thumbs down – foregoing loophole option.

    10
    38
    Reply

    • I don’t mind it Daz.

      No early Bye, and if it doesn’t work, you can trade to someone coming off an early Bye.

      I like him the most of the low $500K guys, like Oliver and Steele.

      3
      1
      Reply

      • i like his price alot, but his round 12 bye is a killer.

        if Young doesn’t play, i’m looking at finding the extra cash to get to LDU, like Freo said, he is the best of that $500k price bracket

        0
        1
        Reply

  35. Best Colby McKercher replacement?

    TU: Serong/Gulden & Watkins (Port)
    (Forced to downgrade sharp for $$)

    TD: Take a punt on someone 540k or less & hold Dyson Sharp

    2
    2
    Reply

  38. Not sure on midfield set up yet.

    Could you run 3 premos and 4 mid prices
    Young, parish, coniglio and bruhn

    T.u – could work
    T.d – stupid move

    10
    7
    Reply

    • Any way to have both Budarick and Flanders up forward? Haven’t heard anything about Powell all pre-season so could be a masterclass or a disaster, don’t know enough to pass opinion

      2
      0
      Reply

  45. T/U Windsor + Parish
    T/D Sinclair/Whitfield + Grlj DPP to mid, replace with Lindsay/Jaques/Serong onfield and bring in another bench rookie

    1
    7
    Reply

  47. Daniel Annable has been named to debut for Brisbane. The word is that this kid is a jet. 181K MID and was drafted 6 in the 2024 draft. Should we try and start him and save a possible trade? Or wait and watch him this week?

    1
    2
    Reply

  48. Sinclair Clark Windsor Grilj Serong Jaques (Gibcus Lindsay)
    Butters Anderson Brayshaw Dawson Richards Rozee Bruhn Jagga (Brodie Carroll Blamires)
    Grundy McAndrew (ZZ)
    Sheezel Trac Budarick Phillipou Lombard Robertson (Marshall Draper)
    Flanders

    Thoughts?

    0
    0
    Reply

  53. Need some help on last spot – my M4

    TU: Walsh (has two byes and injury profile)
    TD: LDU (no early bye but I have Sheez/McKerch already too)

    7
    2
    Reply

  74. T/U – Dawson + Walsh

    T/D – Merrett + Gulden

    In an ideal world it’s Dawson and Walsh but some cash has to give for Dyson Sharp

    8
    5
    Reply

  85. If I was only to choose one of these players, both with injury concerns, and assuming both play this round, who do I pick?

    TU: C McKercher
    TD: H Young

    6
    10
    Reply

    • Named in the start group not the interchange, I put him in at $99K, if I can get four or five games make a few dollars. If it doesn’t workout them a cheap C loophole.

      1
      0
      Reply

      • I think he is derek. $99k could be worth the swing. That he’s mature age feels encouraging. Don’t love small forward rookies. 35k saving over Dovaston.

        0
        0
        Reply

  112. As it stands
    DEF: sinclair, Rozee, J.Clark. grjl, serong, Jacques (Lindsay sellwood)

    TU: McKerch + Coleman ( clark and sellwoof out)
    TD: J.Clark + sellwood (keep as is)

    4
    6
    Reply

  113. Still got a few leagues to fill:

    Rock the Casboult (463151)

    Game of Sloanes (702041)

    Kysaiah’s Messiahs (263519)

    Vlastuin Space (609309)

    What a Steele (272272)

    If it ain’t Boak (195955)

    Right in De Goey (554577)

    Barbeques Treloar (741669)

    3
    0
    Reply

    • some (very few) leagues start round 1, it depends on how they were set up, but most get cracking in round 2, so you have another week to get it sorted.

      0
      0
      Reply

  132. Last min tinker – which combo is better

    TU: H. Young + Dovaston
    TD: Bruhn + Marshall

    (Can’t afford Young and Marshall)

    2
    2
    Reply

  137. I am concerned about Hayden Young’s injury risk. What is the probability he is a late out, (10%?) or what is the probability he breaks down during todays match? (20%?) Perhaps it is smarter not to start him and wait and see how he goes. Coniglio named at half back….He could be a tasty replacement for Young? Thoughts? Cheers TH

    2
    1
    Reply

Leave a Reply to Big C Cancel reply

/** Infolinks