My proposed trades for round 3.
Out – Leake Boxshall (or FOS if Boxshall plays) Gawn
In – NOD Lindsay and Rankin.
I am holding Sanders this week as he has a very achievable BE
I still have Perryman (who won’t lose value this week) and will probably become Bice if he is named for round 4.
I have also changed my philosophy on the flex position.
Better to have an extra consistent rookie scoring 80’s earlier in the season to enhance $ generation.
Later in the season better to have someone one like Flynn who gives ruck cover when you are running low on trades.
I’m very worried about Rankine’s hammy “awareness” when he was subbed on the weekend. I’m avoiding him now for that reason but not a lot of options for premium forwards. Hopefully with DPP in a few weeks, there maybe better variety.
I’m a bit surprised the majority have said FOS. I know He has shown a wore scoring potential but Tsatas is guatanteed to not make money for 2 weeks and then isnt even a lock to return with Parish available by then. What am I missing?
As a Richmond fan the role he used to have isn’t there anymore which is a worry. Not taking kick-ins getting minimal on the run handballs. It says a lot when you have Ben Miller taking kick-ins over him. Ive started him in my team the last 3 years and it’s always been a trap. Could I see him scoring well this weekend, yes but not consistently moving forward.
Was planning on trading WAshcroft to Callaghan this week. Haven’t been impressed at all with Will, especially up until 3qtr time on the weekend. But a massive last qtr and a bit of a bake from Llordo might get him going. I am a little concerned about some attention Callaghan may get in the future too, but he’s so smooth.
Anyway, should I trade WAshcroft -> Calaghan?
TU – Yes, trade WAshcroft -> Callaghan
TD – No, too sideways, back WAshcroft in a little longer.
That’s the key isn’t it?
If Ashcroft is viewed as a stepping stone then a sideways to Callaghan might get you to Uber faster but if you were thinking that Ashcroft might be M8 then its probably a hold.
Is Sheezel a worry for you? He’s getting plenty of possessions but about half are handballs. Is it because he’s in heavy traffic or copping a tag ? Plus I wonder is he getting enough CBA’s as last season? Can’t help but think the inclusion of Parker and Daniel along with some improvements from Simpkin and Powell affecting him around the ground. Thoughts?
Currently ranked 37k after a terrible Round 2 which saw me tumble 31k spots… needless to say I’m giving my team a serious look this week for ways to improve not only this week but through the entire season.
1. My premium picks haven’t fired (Sheezel, Gawn, and JHF)
2. The mid-price picks are duds (Perryman, Peatling, Sanders, and Flynn), and
3. I don’t have Levi Ashcroft who I think is a must have rookie.
So this week…
OUT: Sheezel, Gawn, JHF
IN: Sinclair, Rozee, Ashcroft
Move Flynn from Flex to R2 through the early byes; if he plays great, if not it’s best-18
Next week…
OUT: Perryman, Peatling, Paton
IN: Whitfield, Dawson, Bice
Following week…
OUT: Flynn, Sanders, Rookie TBC any line
IN: Xerri/RoMa/Briggs, Rookie TBC any line
Coaches Verdict…
Tu: Don’t do that, you’ve lost the plot
Td: Give it a whirl, you can always start planning for next year early
I had considered bringing in 3 premos for outgoing underperformers. I really didn’t want to hamstring my cash generation over the course of the season, hence the Levi inclusion this week. Plus, felt that I might be able to get away without a fully fielded team over the next 2 rounds given it’s Best-18.
however, you have given me food for thought that maybe I should consider Xerri as a direct replacement over Sinclair or Rozee in this round… so, thanks for that!
Will be doing 3 trades –
1. Perryman to either Whitfield or B Dale
2. Tsatas to L Ashcroft
3rd trade is either
TU : FOS to Henderson
TD : Paton to C O’Sullivan
I did 2 corrective trades last week, so maybe i don’t need to use the boost for a 3rd trade this week when its best 18? But I think with rookies increasing in price, its the right time to cull ones I’m not happy with.
Petracca hold??? Only have 3 Premo mids he’s one them. Other is Neal and Dawson.
Do I pull trigger on One of Dunkley / Anderson / Libba or leave as is.
I like all three trades, but I think Dale may be a better option for 65k cheaper. I think they will score similar for the year and having the extra cash now could get you a quick upgrade if you already have a stepping stone in your side. Congrats on the hot start!
first year playing this game, recently acquired my dads laptop and he said to maintain his SC team whilst he working offshore….current rank 30k so not doing him justice!
What I need help with is price increases, Herald Sun offer a ‘free’ game but then charge to view breakevens. Unsure how you can be competitive without paying for SC Plus.
Any recommendations for a website that gives you the breakevens, without the $29.95 or $59.95!(Codesports) charges…thank you in advance.
Hi Michelle – Good luck with your Dad’s team.
The coaches on this site are usually positive with any queries, including you asking what break evens and estimated price increases/deceases are, so feel free to throw any players you need to know on here.
Also break evens appear on https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/supercoach_breakevens
Not sure why the T/D, you’re just asking a question, but if you go to Footy Wire, select the player you want to check out, then select SuperCoach on the options, will come up with breakevens and projections for the next couple of rounds, enjoy SC mate, and good luck.
As a port fan I desperately want him to breakout ! He’s been touted forever. Has a good kick but lacking everywhere else and think he wouldn’t be in if it weren’t for injuries and lack of depth in ports list.
He has JS and not a bad run of opponents so could be making good $. He is injury prone though, a reason he hasn’t had continuity as well.
Yeah. Was between Freijah and Perryman and I picked Perryman. Then last round it was between SDK and Freijah and I picked SDK. But this week he comes in! Major restructure but he’s in. Better not spit out a 60!
Is it worth wasting a trade Tsatas while it’s still best 18 for the next two weeks (which is how long he should be out for)? I’ve got Lindsay and Camporeale as well on the bench, and I’ve already made two trades this week (Perryman and Day to Clark and Callaghan). Not sure if I want to use a boost to do that.
Hey coaches, I have a bit of a dilemma with my first trades. Here’s my current team:
Sheezel / Houston / Holmes / Roberts / O’Sullivan / Z. Reid // Trainor / Prior
Daicos / Neale / Dawson / Oliver / Cerra / NOD / M. Reid / Knevitt // Camporeale / Tsatas / FOS
TDK / Flynn // Boyd
JHF / Rankine / Macrae / B. Smith / Davidson / Stone // Kako / Paton
Flex is C. Daniel.
The good: I grabbed most of the good rookies and most of my mid-pricers and premos have been solid.
The bad: Ruck – I thought Flynn would play and be good for quick cash generation and as a stepping stone to a slightly fallen premium ruck. Also, my D1 (Sheezel) and F1 (JHF) are under-performing.
I can *just* afford an aggressive move, or I could play it safe. I’m currently ranked around 12,000 (320 points off the leader) and have about $25k in the bank. I’m curious about people’s thoughts on the following two options:
TU: Sheezel / FOS / Trainor –> Freijah / Callaghan / X. Lindsay.
– This adds two potential keepers (or at least two stepping stones / late season upgrades). The downside is I’ll probably want to get Sheezel back in at some point. Given that I hit on most of my rookies and premos and haven’t used any of my 40 trades, I’m not worried about using three of them now.
TD: FOS / Trainor –> Lindsay (or L.Ashcroft) / Henderson.
– Gives me an extra rookie for cash generation. I could also go FOS / Paton if I wanted to get Lindsay AND L. Ashcroft (and skip Henderson).
The plan after this week is 2-3 more rookies (e.g., Hamling, Clohesy, Bice) and then fix R2 with K. Briggs after his price dips ahead of round 5 (I’m okay carrying Flynn and Boyd over the two best-18 rounds).
Hoping to get some opinions for the SC Talk community! I will be grabbing baz next week and need to make sure I have a plan to ensure he comes in without much difficulty. Which looks better?
TU: Bring Freijah in this week, leaving me with 300k to turn any non playing rookie into Baz easily
TD: Grab a premo defender this week, and lock in Short down to Bice next week regardless of what Short scores, which will give me the money to fund Baz
FYI by doing TD i’d have to run 2 defender rookies!
Reckon this is a classic case of Father Dougal’s reverting to the mean theory he discussed earlier in the week. Salem historically has good stretches of games then has quieter stretches of games. Also, May returns this week too which will impact Salem’s game.
T/u short to dale and sanders to Bailey smith
Supposed to be some wet weather footy at the Gabba so does that affect smiths score and as we already know he is going to rested every now and then so they can manage him through the season
T/d short to freijah sanders to rankine
Is freijah really worth trading in. Seems to playing midfield with the big outs they have but that won’t last
TU FOS Tsatas Hastie > Henderson Lash Lindsay + $80k
Probably Perryman to Bice next week or can upgrade Perryman
TD FOS Perryman Tsatas > O Sullivan Lash Lindsay + $240k
Can also get Bice next week for Prior if needed or upgrade Flynn or Short with the $240k
The O Sullivan in TD refers to COS!
Hi everyone – just wondering best combo to bring in?
T/U Dunkley and Dale (with $14 200 itb) or
T/D Callaghan and Zorko (with $107 900 itb)
My proposed trades for round 3.
Out – Leake Boxshall (or FOS if Boxshall plays) Gawn
In – NOD Lindsay and Rankin.
I am holding Sanders this week as he has a very achievable BE
I still have Perryman (who won’t lose value this week) and will probably become Bice if he is named for round 4.
I have also changed my philosophy on the flex position.
Better to have an extra consistent rookie scoring 80’s earlier in the season to enhance $ generation.
Later in the season better to have someone one like Flynn who gives ruck cover when you are running low on trades.
Who are you running at R2 with Gawn going out?
I had Gawn as my flex.
My rucks are Xerri and TDK
I’m very worried about Rankine’s hammy “awareness” when he was subbed on the weekend. I’m avoiding him now for that reason but not a lot of options for premium forwards. Hopefully with DPP in a few weeks, there maybe better variety.
No love for Simpkin ?
On the watch list Wighty.
Just a lot of players to fit into Norths midfield.
Let’s not forget Wardlaw will return within a month
Crom website says it was about “managing his loads”. Thought I read elsewhere it was a hip issue…
Anyone got solid intel on this?
Who to prioritise trading out first
Tu: Tsatas
Td: FOS
I’m a bit surprised the majority have said FOS. I know He has shown a wore scoring potential but Tsatas is guatanteed to not make money for 2 weeks and then isnt even a lock to return with Parish available by then. What am I missing?
Asked this in the previous one, still can’t make a decision.
Jayden Short:
TU – get rid of him
TD – one more week
Any insight from those who watched him would be handy.
As a Richmond fan the role he used to have isn’t there anymore which is a worry. Not taking kick-ins getting minimal on the run handballs. It says a lot when you have Ben Miller taking kick-ins over him. Ive started him in my team the last 3 years and it’s always been a trap. Could I see him scoring well this weekend, yes but not consistently moving forward.
reid – osullivan
tsatas – lindsay
currently ranked 4k
already have nod bice and all other good cows
Thoughts maybe hold tsatas but cant loop him this week as essendon play first
Who goes first for Lindsay?
TU FOS
TD Tsatas
JHF > Rankine
Hastie > Lindsay
FOS > O’driscall
Allows me to get JHF discounted for Sanders when Treloar / Bont return
TU or TD
Trading out JHF with the plan to get him back in, for a player with hamstring history who was subbed last week for “injury awareness”?
TU: Salem
or
TD: Bowey
TU: FOS Hastie Tsatas > Lashcroft Lindsay Henderson + $81k
TD: Perryman FOS/Tsatas Hastie > COS Lashcroft Lindsay +$230k
Trade: Garcia, Tsatas and Paton
Bring in: Callaghan, Lindsay, Henderson
TU – Yes
TD – No
Short>Dale
Day>Callaghan
Sanders>Salem via DPP
TU: Yes
TD: No
Yall reckon will day to fin
sideways trade tu
good trade td
Is it worth bringing in Connor O’Sullivan?
Concerned slightly with Kolodjashnij 1 week away and Stewart a test this week.
Tu or Td
FOS a hold now over Tsatas?
Fos only needs one spike score to get his cash gen moving, also likely to gain DPP and should be safe job security wise in that side.
Tsatas on reduced minutes as it is, with Parish set to return shortly, becomes a bit of a job security risk.
Who goes out this week:
Tu: Fos
Td: Tsatas
Who to target
Fin
Dale
TU – Zorko
TD – Dale
If you want to boot one, which one would it be
TU FoS
TD Kako
Comment neither, instead do paton and hanily
kako
TU – Dale/Zorko (Bice next week)
TD – O’Sullivan (Any premo next week)
Want to boot one
TU- Short
TD- JHF
neither,short doesnt ton up against saints then trade
jhf is a keeper
Then JHF needs to start scoring like he is.
Tom Stewart a test this week. I’ll likely hold if he’s given the green light. Should I trade if not?
TU: Trade him before he drops in price.
TD: Hold, he’s a premo, injury sounds minor.
Really struggling with this decision…
Was planning on trading WAshcroft to Callaghan this week. Haven’t been impressed at all with Will, especially up until 3qtr time on the weekend. But a massive last qtr and a bit of a bake from Llordo might get him going. I am a little concerned about some attention Callaghan may get in the future too, but he’s so smooth.
Anyway, should I trade WAshcroft -> Calaghan?
TU – Yes, trade WAshcroft -> Callaghan
TD – No, too sideways, back WAshcroft in a little longer.
Thanks
Callaghan probably make you some cash to upgrade to a uberpremo faster
That’s the key isn’t it?
If Ashcroft is viewed as a stepping stone then a sideways to Callaghan might get you to Uber faster but if you were thinking that Ashcroft might be M8 then its probably a hold.
Last trade
T/u short to dale
T/d sanders to rankine
Should max gawn go?
T.u no just leave him for year and cop money loss
T.d yes trade and go down to tdk or Witts
T/U = Anderson
T/D = Liberatore
T/U = Sinclair
T/D = Whitfield
Who to get rid of first
TU – Tsatas
TS – Hastie
Perryman replacement
TU : Zorko
TD : Whitfield / Sinclair
Who to bring in for Tsatas?
TU: Campo
TD: Henderson
Who to get for Perryman?
TU – Freijah
TD – De Koning
Thanks
Is Sheezel a worry for you? He’s getting plenty of possessions but about half are handballs. Is it because he’s in heavy traffic or copping a tag ? Plus I wonder is he getting enough CBA’s as last season? Can’t help but think the inclusion of Parker and Daniel along with some improvements from Simpkin and Powell affecting him around the ground. Thoughts?
Sheezel losing money and JHF losing money.
Is this an issue for Supercoachers?
TU: Tsatas -> Lindsay
FOS -> Henderson
Perryman -> Dale
O’Sullivan and Bice next week
TD: Tsatas -> Lindsay
Paton -> O’Sulivan
Perryman -> Freijah
Henderson and Bice next week
TD
Garcia to Lindsay
Perryman to Dale
Pattern to Bice
TD
Garcia to Lindsay
Perryman to Dale
FOS/tsatas to COS
(Leaves Ried/prior/trainer down back to trade in bice)
COS this week, Bice next week
Appreciate feedback on this thought bubble.
Currently ranked 37k after a terrible Round 2 which saw me tumble 31k spots… needless to say I’m giving my team a serious look this week for ways to improve not only this week but through the entire season.
1. My premium picks haven’t fired (Sheezel, Gawn, and JHF)
2. The mid-price picks are duds (Perryman, Peatling, Sanders, and Flynn), and
3. I don’t have Levi Ashcroft who I think is a must have rookie.
So this week…
OUT: Sheezel, Gawn, JHF
IN: Sinclair, Rozee, Ashcroft
Move Flynn from Flex to R2 through the early byes; if he plays great, if not it’s best-18
Next week…
OUT: Perryman, Peatling, Paton
IN: Whitfield, Dawson, Bice
Following week…
OUT: Flynn, Sanders, Rookie TBC any line
IN: Xerri/RoMa/Briggs, Rookie TBC any line
Coaches Verdict…
Tu: Don’t do that, you’ve lost the plot
Td: Give it a whirl, you can always start planning for next year early
Magic, did you consider – Sheezel Gawn Perryman >> Dale Xerri Rossi
hey FJW – It’s a great prompt…
I had considered bringing in 3 premos for outgoing underperformers. I really didn’t want to hamstring my cash generation over the course of the season, hence the Levi inclusion this week. Plus, felt that I might be able to get away without a fully fielded team over the next 2 rounds given it’s Best-18.
however, you have given me food for thought that maybe I should consider Xerri as a direct replacement over Sinclair or Rozee in this round… so, thanks for that!
That’s a lot of trades / boosts so early in the year as you’ll still have to navigate the real bye rounds.
Hypothetically if I was trading my Petracca (Pending upon rookie selections). Who to bring in
T/U: Dunkley (Monster R1, May be too hard to get in future, super consistent)
T/D: Dawson (started on fire but crows have been dominant, goes up forward to avoid the tag, but is 50k cheaper)
Comment: Someone cheaper Callaghan/Cerra/Rozee etc
Luke Ryan
T/u – Hold
T/d – Trade to a Dale/Clark
Hi all
Tu trade in l Ashcroft
Tad too late
Thanks
Trade out which one
TU : Kako
TD : FOS
Trading in which one would you prefer (as Perryman replacement)
TU : B Dale
TD : Whitfield or Sinclair
Thinking Dale as he is due to increase by the most this week, and then if Short sucks again, he can be traded up next week to Whitfield or Sinclair?
If you can only bring in one:
Tu: O’Sullivan
Td: Henderson
Have already done:
1. FOS to Ashcroft
2. Flynn to Linsday via Flex
Do I boost to trade Paton to Connor O’Sullivan before the price increase?
TU: Make the trade
TD: Not worth a boost
JHF
TU: Trade (to Rankine).
TD: Hold
Trade out short
TU Sinclair
TD Whitfield
Who to trade out:
TU – Tsatas (out for few weeks but lower B/E)
TD – FOS (poor scoring but high JS)
TU:
Out -Perryman, Hastie, Paton
In – O’Sullivan, Frejiah, Lindsay
TD:
Out- Perryman, Hastie, F O’Sullivan
In- O’Sullivan, Callaghan, Lindsay
SDK BAllen Berry
to
Dale Henderson Edwards
Why are people recommending COS over Henderson? I don’t get it – COS JS looks very shaky
TU FoS to Lashcroft – will be playing the next 5 games and grow better
TD Hold dont use the boost its fine you doing well
Comment FoS to Henderson Do it, go with your guts. net 80k and enroute henderson to forward when he gets dpp (fingers crossed)
Out: Lalor, Lachie Ash and Flynn
In: COS, Marshall and O’Driscoll
TU: go for it
TD: save that boost
Don’t have Short and need to go down on someone to go up on Flynn (Flex)
Why get rid of Ash?
Average of 101 breakdown of 54
Thanks mate. It was just to free up some cash generation
Why not just go Flynn down to o’driscoll in flex?
Short to Dale
JHF to Callahan
Tsatas to Henderson
Will be doing 3 trades –
1. Perryman to either Whitfield or B Dale
2. Tsatas to L Ashcroft
3rd trade is either
TU : FOS to Henderson
TD : Paton to C O’Sullivan
I did 2 corrective trades last week, so maybe i don’t need to use the boost for a 3rd trade this week when its best 18? But I think with rookies increasing in price, its the right time to cull ones I’m not happy with.
Out goes
Gawn, tsatas and Garcia
In come tdk/witts, lindsey and any Fwd under 400k
T.u good moves
T.d no way
T/U – Option 1:
W. Ashcroft -> X. Lindsay
S. Powell-Pepper -> I. Rankine
T/D – Option 2:
H. Perryman -> R. Bice
A. Hastie -> X. Lindsay
S. Lalor -> I. Rankine
Appreciate everyone’s votes
Is it worth using a boost for the following?
Paton > O’Sullivan
Tu or Td
Tsatas > NOD
Dolan>Henderson (via dpp)
(Been following this page for a while now, absolutely love it)
TU (Do it for $ Gen)
TD >(not worth it)
Tsatas > Lindsay
FOS > Lash
TU: Good Trades
TD: Bad Trades
Is Hastie > Henderson worth a boost?
TU: Yes
TD: No
Short to
TU: Zorko (one less rookie on field in defence)
TD: Callaghan
Comment: Libba
TU: Flynn > Marshall
TD: Tsatas > Callaghan
TU:
Out – Perryman, Paton, Tsatas
In – B. Dale, COS, Henderson
$13,900 cash – Dale for points
TD:
Out – Perryman, Paton, Tsatas
In- Freijah, COS, Henderson
$171,600 cash – Freijah for cash generation
Already trading Perryman and Short to Dale and Freijah.
Who to trade out to bring in Lindsay?
TU: Flynn (via Flex)
TD: F.O’Sullivan
Am I mad to trade Gawn to Xerri?
TU – Yes
TD – No
TU Petracca out for Dawson
TD Keep Petracca
Petracca hold??? Only have 3 Premo mids he’s one them. Other is Neal and Dawson.
Do I pull trigger on One of Dunkley / Anderson / Libba or leave as is.
TU – Leave
TD – Grab one of those 3
Dont tempt the SC Gods re rule 101.
If a sideway premo trade is not recommended. Would a trade which makes cash please the SC gods?
That being Petracca>Callaghan
TU Petracca> Callaghan
TD Hold Petracca
Pulled trigger on Dunkley. Let’s see what the gods say after this round
TU Short to Dale $28600 itb
TD Petracca to Dawson $120300 itb
Really want to get Callaghan. Two ways to do it.
1. FOS/B Campo/Roberts to Callaghan/Sinn/Lindsay and $18k
2 Tsatas/FOS/Cory Warner to Callaghan/Henderson/Edwards and $2k
Lindsay and Henderson both have similar BE and cash generation this week.
T/u 1
T/d 2
Comment….both mad ideas. Yes…B Campo !!!!
Thats Roberts from sydney.
The 475k defender who’s averaging 111 for the year?
And you’re thinking of trading him out? That’s just silly.
Rank 85th. Looking to sure up cash gen. I’m passing on COS.
Paton – Henderson
Day – Lindsay
Perryman – Sinclair
Leaves me 200k. Could go Dale for another 50k banked. 36 trades 4 boost.
TU – Yay
TD – Nay
Just look at the advice from Sledgers players and do the opposite !!!!
I like all three trades, but I think Dale may be a better option for 65k cheaper. I think they will score similar for the year and having the extra cash now could get you a quick upgrade if you already have a stepping stone in your side. Congrats on the hot start!
Went only Sanders > Lashcroft last week.
Def – Sheezel, Holmes, Roberts, Short, Perryman, Trainor (Leake, Reid)
Mid – Neale, Rozee, Oliver, W.Ashcroft, FOS, NOD, L Ashcroft, Knevitt (Kako, Hastie, L.Camporeale)
Ruc – Xerri, TDK (Boyd)
Fwd – JHF, Rankine, Macrae, Daniel, Hewett, Stone (H.Garcia, Davidson)
Flex – Tsatas
$194,100 ITB
Thinking Perryman & H.Garcia to Dale & Lindsey (+$160,700 ITB) . It moves Tsatas to MID bench and FOS to Flex.
Thoughts would be greatly appreciated!!!
Also is it worth using a boost to go Hastie to Henderson (+$181,500 ITB)?
TU – Yes
TD – Hold the boost
Those who T/D may I ask why? I am interested in your thoughts?
TU:
Out – Perryman, Paton, Tsatas
In – B. Dale, COS, Henderson
$13,900 ITB
TD:
Out – Perryman, Short, Tsatas
In- Whitfield, Freijah, Henderson
$31,100 ITB
Appreciate the advice!
Perryman, Short, Day –> Dale, Freijah, Callaghan
Whilst missing out on O’Sullivan, Lindsay, LAshcroft
Couple of decent rookies to get next week it seems gives me comfort
Probably too much points chasing here John. Make sure you’ve got the right rookies first, then fix your premiums if you can
Agree. Get CG in order.
You can’t pass on Lindsay and Ash.
Trading in X. Lindsay
T/U trade O’Sullivan
T/D trade Tsatas
FOS > COS
JHF > Xerri
Via Paton loophole
TU: Perryman -> Dale
TD: Perryman -> Freijah
Haven’t used any trades yet
Perryman, FOS, TSATAS -> Dale, Lindsay, Henderson
Leaves me without Laschroft, COS (Geel) and Freijah
T/U: Good Trades
T/D: Reassess
Max > Xerri
JHF > NOD
Leaves $370 itb as we move forward for upgrades
OUT: SDEK & Hastie (if not named)
IN: NOD & Lashcroft
Looking at 2 different options
Option 1
Out – lalor, FOS, and Garcia
In – Lindsay, Henderson, forward under 400k
Option 2
Out – gawn, Garcia, Fos
In – tdk/witts, Lindsay and forward under 400k
T/U – Option 1
T/D – Option 2
first year playing this game, recently acquired my dads laptop and he said to maintain his SC team whilst he working offshore….current rank 30k so not doing him justice!
What I need help with is price increases, Herald Sun offer a ‘free’ game but then charge to view breakevens. Unsure how you can be competitive without paying for SC Plus.
Any recommendations for a website that gives you the breakevens, without the $29.95 or $59.95!(Codesports) charges…thank you in advance.
Hi Michelle – Good luck with your Dad’s team.
The coaches on this site are usually positive with any queries, including you asking what break evens and estimated price increases/deceases are, so feel free to throw any players you need to know on here.
Also break evens appear on https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/supercoach_breakevens
Not sure why the T/D, you’re just asking a question, but if you go to Footy Wire, select the player you want to check out, then select SuperCoach on the options, will come up with breakevens and projections for the next couple of rounds, enjoy SC mate, and good luck.
Thank you for your reply BW and for the website recommendation.
Another place to grab break evens is tooserious.net (the stats tab at the top of the page).
TU: Hold Short & Save boost
TD: Trade him out for Salem for some cash and a possible keeper?
Who should I trade to Dale?
TU Short
TD Perryman
Play on field this week. Will loop the other
TU Reid
TD Prior
Better trade:
Tu: Tsatas > Henderson
Td: Paton > O’Sullivan
If I do the first option I will move Paton to Bice next week. Thoughts appreciated!
Which do you think is the better option:
TU: Sinclair / Pepper Powell (price proj +43k)
TD: Darcy / Freij (price proj +56k)
What’s the consensus on Tsatas considering the likes of FOS and Perryman need to be addressed
T/U: Hold (only misses 1 game plus bye)
T/D: Trade (there’s better mid rookies and misses 2 weeks of cash gen, could lose his spot too)
Better set of trades this week
TU: Tsatas FOS Hastie > Lindsay Lash Henderson
TD: Tsatas/FOS Flynn Perryman > Lindsay Lash Dale
Was keen on Sinn preseason and baulked at him. I’m now strongly considering him as an option down back.
Talk me off the ledge!
TU – Do it!
TD – Crazy move!
As a port fan I desperately want him to breakout ! He’s been touted forever. Has a good kick but lacking everywhere else and think he wouldn’t be in if it weren’t for injuries and lack of depth in ports list.
He has JS and not a bad run of opponents so could be making good $. He is injury prone though, a reason he hasn’t had continuity as well.
Enjoy
Have enough $$$ for Tsatas and FOS to Callaghan and Henderson, but then will miss out on Lindsay.
T/u – Tsatas and FOS to Callaghan and Henderson
T/d – FOS to Lindsay + maybe Tsatas to Henderson (not sure if the second trade is worth it)
How good do I feel having picked Freijah as my POD and now watching everyone jump on him after two rounds. Not too bloody good at all.
You’d rather he spudded it up and forced you out of a trade after two rounds instead?
Yeah. Was between Freijah and Perryman and I picked Perryman. Then last round it was between SDK and Freijah and I picked SDK. But this week he comes in! Major restructure but he’s in. Better not spit out a 60!
Trading JHF to free up some cash for Daicos next week:
R.Thilthorpe
S.Darcy
Thoughts appreciated.
My thoughts are…no.
Is it worth wasting a trade Tsatas while it’s still best 18 for the next two weeks (which is how long he should be out for)? I’ve got Lindsay and Camporeale as well on the bench, and I’ve already made two trades this week (Perryman and Day to Clark and Callaghan). Not sure if I want to use a boost to do that.
To out Tsatas that is, my grammar is terrible today
Hope she gets better soon WW.
Didn’t know he was in the closet 🙂
Boom, Tish!
LOL XD
TU: Henderson
TD: Hewitt
TU
FoS > Lashroft
Hanily > Lindsay
Use the boost and Paton > CoSullivan
Do it 100% worth correcting and having the 3 best rookies, have good firing power for the best 18
TD
Save the boost
Camporeale omitted..
Tsatas injured (2weeks)
Who goes out for Henderson?
Tu: Camporeale
Td: Tsatas
JHF -> Rankine with a boost
TU: Send it
TD: Hold
With Camp dropped i have adjusted my trades! Which option is better:
1 – FOS / Camporeale / Perryman > J Clark / Henderson / M Reid
2 – FOS / Camporeale / Perryman > Dale / Henderson / Lindsay
While Option 2 feels better value / BE wise, it absoloutely cooks my already busy R12 bye so am very torn.
Who to bring in?
TU – Rozee
TD – Rankine
Ones a keeper and top of his line, the other probably isn’t..
Rankine all day
Yeah my exact thought process mate, much better for my team structure too.
I think I’m leaning towards holding but if I trade Tom Stewart do I bring in
TU: Dale
TD: Sinclair
Paton > O’Sullivan. Worth a boost?
If I pull the trigger I will be most likely be moving Prior to Bice next week.
Tu: Go for it
Td: Hold the boost
And a follow up. I’m bringing in Lindsay and Henderson for Tsatas and Camporeale so is it even worth using a boost to get rid of Stewart?
TU: yes, he’ll plummet in price
TD: hold, everyone will try to grab him after the drop so may as well save the trade and boost to bring him back
thoughts on trading in bowey?? First 2 rounds and practice game have shown he can rack up the touches…
Trades done already this week
Perryman to Dale
Tsapas to L Ashcroft.
Wanting to use a boost so I can get the best rookies in before price rises, so which is better option –
TU : Paton to Cos (still leaves me either Z Reid or Trainor to trade to Bice next week if I decide to)
TD : Camporeale to Henderson
Who to field (for Draft)
TU – Cerra
TD – Serong
One more sorry, if you could only do one of these trades
TU: Stewart to Dale/Sinclair
TD: Camporeale to Henderson
Have Flynn at R2, no cover
Is he a must trade out this week?
I was considering trading Prior next week to bring in Bice, however he looked decent tonight and scored 77.
My only dead rookie down back is Paton.
Tu: Boost this week and trade him to COS
Td: Hold of for Bice next week and hold Prior now completely
Tom stewart to
TU: bowey
TD: Freijah
Have to trade one of these two…
Both have been named first emergency..
Who should I trade?
TU – Hastie
TD – Camporale
TU: Salem
TD: Freijah + $61,000
Hey coaches, I have a bit of a dilemma with my first trades. Here’s my current team:
Sheezel / Houston / Holmes / Roberts / O’Sullivan / Z. Reid // Trainor / Prior
Daicos / Neale / Dawson / Oliver / Cerra / NOD / M. Reid / Knevitt // Camporeale / Tsatas / FOS
TDK / Flynn // Boyd
JHF / Rankine / Macrae / B. Smith / Davidson / Stone // Kako / Paton
Flex is C. Daniel.
The good: I grabbed most of the good rookies and most of my mid-pricers and premos have been solid.
The bad: Ruck – I thought Flynn would play and be good for quick cash generation and as a stepping stone to a slightly fallen premium ruck. Also, my D1 (Sheezel) and F1 (JHF) are under-performing.
I can *just* afford an aggressive move, or I could play it safe. I’m currently ranked around 12,000 (320 points off the leader) and have about $25k in the bank. I’m curious about people’s thoughts on the following two options:
TU: Sheezel / FOS / Trainor –> Freijah / Callaghan / X. Lindsay.
– This adds two potential keepers (or at least two stepping stones / late season upgrades). The downside is I’ll probably want to get Sheezel back in at some point. Given that I hit on most of my rookies and premos and haven’t used any of my 40 trades, I’m not worried about using three of them now.
TD: FOS / Trainor –> Lindsay (or L.Ashcroft) / Henderson.
– Gives me an extra rookie for cash generation. I could also go FOS / Paton if I wanted to get Lindsay AND L. Ashcroft (and skip Henderson).
The plan after this week is 2-3 more rookies (e.g., Hamling, Clohesy, Bice) and then fix R2 with K. Briggs after his price dips ahead of round 5 (I’m okay carrying Flynn and Boyd over the two best-18 rounds).
Thanks in advance for your input everyone!
TU – OUT Camporeale IN Henderson (for bench) or pass on Henderson and go
TU – OUT Flynn as flex to Callaghan
Is Flynn still a trade?
TU Yes
TD No
I think if he is named then keep, if out then trade
Hoping to get some opinions for the SC Talk community! I will be grabbing baz next week and need to make sure I have a plan to ensure he comes in without much difficulty. Which looks better?
TU: Bring Freijah in this week, leaving me with 300k to turn any non playing rookie into Baz easily
TD: Grab a premo defender this week, and lock in Short down to Bice next week regardless of what Short scores, which will give me the money to fund Baz
FYI by doing TD i’d have to run 2 defender rookies!
Cheers!
TU: Dale (+70k)
TD: Zorko
Want to trade in Henderson for better cash generation
Tu- trade out Camporeale
OR
Td- trade out FOS
thoughts on salem?
average over 100 first 2 games
looks to be the main cover for melbourne
gaining 30+k
tu or td
I was looking at this option aswell but steven may is back and he will take majority of the kick ins so he’s prob a watch for this week
Reckon this is a classic case of Father Dougal’s reverting to the mean theory he discussed earlier in the week. Salem historically has good stretches of games then has quieter stretches of games. Also, May returns this week too which will impact Salem’s game.
T/u short to dale and sanders to Bailey smith
Supposed to be some wet weather footy at the Gabba so does that affect smiths score and as we already know he is going to rested every now and then so they can manage him through the season
T/d short to freijah sanders to rankine
Is freijah really worth trading in. Seems to playing midfield with the big outs they have but that won’t last
Perryman, Short, Flynn > Dale, Marshall, Lindsay
Thinking of changing tack from my original moves and keeping Gawn instead of swapping to TDK.
TU: Gawn > TDK (+120k for a premo upgrade next week)
TD: Campo > Henderson for Cash Gen and take the Gawn price drop hit(s)
worth to bring in frejiah for bo allen with 100k in bank
Hey- Love some late advice
TU- Flynn to Simpkin (dual position)
TD- Flynn to Tom Powell (looks to finally have a good role)
Cheers