Game Chat – The Grand Final

Written by Motts on September 28 2019


Not many people tipped this as the Grand Final match-up at the start of the year, and even fewer thought it would happen mid-season when both clubs were beset by injuries. Richmond dropped as low as ninth before the bye, but has won an astonishing 11 consecutive games, the second-best streak in club history. Greater Western Sydney has done it the hard way to qualify for the Grand Final, finishing sixth and defeating the Western Bulldogs, Brisbane and Collingwood on the way to the decider. Both sides play high-pressure games with fierce tackling a feature, meaning composure will be the key to premiership glory.

WHERE AND WHEN: MCG, Saturday, September 28, 2.30pm AEST


Round 17: Richmond 13.16 (94) d GWS 9.13 (67) at the MCG

Richmond was the closest it had been to full-strength to that point of the season, while GWS lost important playmaker Stephen Coniglio to a knee injury. The Tigers got off to a hot start, keeping the Giants to just two points in the first term while kicking four goals of their own, and were never headed.

Round 3: GWS 19.11 (125) d Richmond 10.16 (76) at Giants Stadium

It was the Jeremy show as Cameron and Finlayson combined for a whopping 12 goals against an undermanned Richmond defence. The Giants kicked six goals to two in the second term to break the game apart. Matt De Boer comfortably nullified Dustin Martin, while Kane Lambert and Dion Prestia battled hard.


Rd 17, 2019, Richmond 13.16 (94) d GWS 9.13 (67) at the MCG
Rd 3, 2019, GWS 19.11 (125) d Richmond 10.16 (76) at Giants Stadium
Rd 17, 2018, GWS 11.13 (79) d Richmond 10.17 (77) at Giants Stadium
2PF, 2017, Richmond 15.13 (103) d GWS 9.13 (67) at the MCG
Rd 18, 2017, Richmond 9.10 (64) d GWS 6.9 (45) at the MCG



1. The influence of the classy Shane Edwards (16th overall in AFL Player Ratings) in crucial moments. He is often thrown in the middle when the game needs a spark. Watch his hands closely, he has a tendency to set up teammates in space with clever flicks and handballs.

2. Richmond’s forward-line set-up is a changing beast, with one of Tom Lynch, Jack Riewoldt or Dustin Martin as the deepest forward. The constant movement can often catch opposition defences off-guard and force mismatches.

3. The Tigers are statistically the worst clearance side, averaging 34 a match, while the Giants are the best with 42. Richmond is used to playing this way, backing its strong defence to rebound and set up attacking forays.

Greater Western Sydney

1. Richmond may pride itself on its strong defensive unit, but the Giants’ is potentially even better. Phil Davis, Nick Haynes, Sam Taylor and Heath Shaw are all strong intercept markers and work well as a unit to cover each other’s players.

2. Jeremy Cameron (58th overall in the AFL Player Ratings) has had a strong recent record against Richmond, booting 10 goals from 49 disposals in two matches this year. He missed the 2017 preliminary final between these two sides with a hamstring complaint.

3. The Giants are one of the best running sides in the competition, and have good depth in the area too, as evidenced by Zac Williams’ successful stint on the wing in the preliminary final. Lachie Whitfield is also poised to return from appendix surgery.


Dustin Martin v Matt De Boer

Martin was rattled in round three, lashing out and striking Adam Kennedy while being held to just 15 disposals by De Boer. The Giant was sidelined with a collarbone injury the last time the two sides met, with Martin jumping to 25 touches.


Jack Riewoldt (Richmond)

An uncharacteristically quiet prelim from the Tigers spearhead, missing two late goals with poor set shots, but he did set up several majors for teammates. Riewoldt will be champing at the bit to get on the scoreboard in the biggest game of all.

Toby Greene (GWS)

All eyes are on Toby (pun intended) on his return from a contentious one-week suspension. When Greene is at his best, he is one of the most damaging players in the competition, but he also has a self-destructive streak.


Bachar Houli was unlucky to miss the 2017 Norm Smith and is currently in red-hot form, cherry ripe for a best-on-ground performance.

MOTTSY’s TIP: Richmond by 20 points


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

18 thoughts on “Game Chat – The Grand Final”

    1. I’m actually enjoying the pre game entertainment…normally hate it.

      The Cat Empire were good in 2017.

      Phil Davis past his fitness test pre game.

      Can’t wait for the cheer when Pickett comes off the bench.


  1. Coniglio ruling himself out has interested me all week.

    You’d think they’d have just named him in case, plus even at limited minutes he would have had an impact.

    That said, those limited minutes would have compromised rotations; tiring out the others.

    We’ll see.

    Good luck btw, GP!


    1. Thanks. Pretty nervous.

      Not sure what to make of the giants fade out in the last qtr against the pies.

      looked out on their feet.


    1. Tigers second half is definitely the stronger and Giants have two mids injured

      Pickett is a certain starting rookie for supercoach next year.


  2. Razor Ray for Norm Smith? Richmond are better team but umpires definitely swaying the contest. Absolutely disappointed with what has been produced.


      1. I left the screen once i saw it go past 40 difference. Have to go to work soon and i was really tentative on it all week that i was going to miss a great final few minutes. Happy to have worked all day if i knew it was going to be a performance like that!


      2. Hi GD. I also gave up at half time and switched to the races to cheer my SuperCoach racing stable. Far more entertaining for me.

        Congratulations to Richmond for a resounding victory. Far too good. All their supporters would have loved every minute of the game. Embrace and enjoy the special moment of a Grand Final win.


  3. Yep, many congrats to all Tigers out there. Especially our super host Schwarz!
    Gotta be a happy camper and can look forward to 2020 for another crack at it!
    Way too good. The kid Pickett goes alright. Should be the first rookie on everyone’s list next year.


  4. Don’t think it changes result but gws shouldn’t have played davis or whitfield, two of their most important players but not fit to play afl grand final. Tigers made hard calls , gws went with sentiment in hope!



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *