Cincotta will come in but the real question is who goes out.
Thumbs up Bowes
Thumbs down Roberts
I still have Chesser who I think is about a month away. Constable who u don’t see playing again unless an injury occurs. Cowan who has probably lost his spot to Cincotta. Davey and Phillips who each will hopefully return for round 8
I’ll be watching once more. Looked great but with a BE of 126, even if he does hit it, still shouldn’t go up by too much and still affordable next week. 1 more week of data!
Thanks FT appreciate it. I was leaning towards Sinclair due to the better bye as you mentioned but the only reason I am tempted by Sicily is the possibilty of forward tags on Sinclair
Currently have 24 trades left. Not sure if this is a good number at this stage but Im getting nervous. So
TU – Phillipou > Angwin as a bench warmer and hold the extra trade
TD Phillipou and Setterfield > Angwin and Walsh
I would love to trade in Tom Stewart but don’t have the necessary funds. What are the thoughts on Wil Powell at $482K? Played 5 games for 3 tons, including a last game of 143. 3 round average of 111.7 and a BE of just 7. Favourable bye as well. The floor bothers me (scores of 71 and 67 this season) but I do like a value pick.
TU – welcome Wil Powell
TD – find another way to bring in a genuine premo defender
Anyone considering Cunnington after his 110 against Melbourne on the weekend? Could perhaps make a little cash and be a solid stopgap if he runs into some form.
I was super peeved with my crap team other night after I had way too many drinks and deleted my team..
In the morning, sober, I realised I over reacted & emailed HS to asked them if it was possible to reinstate my crap team..they did so within 1 hour..the bonus is now I again have Supercoach Premium after it had previously expired after the trial ended..result. Unsure if its another trial but..
Thanks HS.
Could I please ask the SCT community which trade is more appealing. Byes are not a problem, Thank you.
Fallen in a massive hole, lost 26,000 places in the last 2 weeks.
Everything I touch is turning to mud at the moment.
Looks like a good side but keeps getting smashed.
I warn anyone against bringing in Oliver this week because this is what I am doing.
Setterfield >> Oliver
Ginbey >> Cincotta
Phillipou >> Simpson
Angwin and Simpson no guarantee not to be Red dots in a few weeks anyway.
I would rather wait to correct rookies at the Byes when we need green dots.
Cowan to Cincotta makes sense. I would hold Greene if you can’t afford to upgrade him. He should go well V my mob Freo. He wont lose too much cash with a 57 BE.
Thanks FT. After more thought, I’m keen to get Steele in this week instead despite his BE. I thought he looked back to his best last week and should go big against the Roos.
Greene is actually my first option to trade out this week – the return of Mitch Lewis has completely changed his role and they hardly kicked it to him at all last week. Not to mention that he looked pretty sore after running full pelt into the goal post!
I got him in pre round 6 as I liked his DE and his Bye. Cincotta is a must have.
The other Rookies are pretty risky this week so I would tend to wait for Weddle next week. We had him in our sites preseason, so If he gets a decent run he should start scoring ok.
bringing in one cheap m8 this week but can’t split the two, steele is tried and tested however green has had an uninterrupted year and is on the rise to a top 8 mid
TU Steele
TD Green
Apart from Cincotta on the bubble, not many others jumping out apart from Kemp & Atkins. And I don’t like their starting prices around $200k
Think most of us have some rookies who are spent and about to bleed cash- eg Phillipou, Gibney, etc, but those lucky enough to pick Chandler and Buckley are saving a few trades for them
>>> Is himmleberg playing back now? Worth picking up ?
I picked him up last week hoping he would play back. Unfortunately, he was playing FWD the whole time and taking some ruck contests – he was on like 20 SC at half time, and then picked up a few goals and goal assists to get a respectable score. But I am regretting my decision to add him.
Hi Billioux,
We should have more clarity tomorrow, when clubs release updated injury lists.
Then we will know the timeframe for Miller’s return to play.
So check out the “Injuries Rd 8” post on Tuesday (shameless plug) for the injury news!
As a Cats fan I think he is safe until Stengle returns in 3-4 weeks. Thats providing he keeps up the pressure acts and snags a goal or two. Scott likes him and wants to give him a go.
It’s worth remembering that 2 years ago he played in a prelim for the Cats and got badly injured. He then suffered a bad concussion last year.
In my eyes, the name of the game right now is reading the CG landscape. There’s just no way we’re filling out our sides with every 600k+ option we love. Honestly, even consecutive moves north of 550k will put a strain on most teams.
Maybe it’s my team in particular given I don’t have Bont, Dawson or Stewart and missed Chandler but I see a cold wind coming.
We were thin on rookies to begin with and there’s really not much coming through rn besides Cincotta. Wagner, Roberts, Constable, Cowan, Davey and now maybe Mitchell all dead.
Just don’t see how anyone’s getting to full premo popping 600k players in every week.
My recent trades ins have been all sub 500k:
– Day
– Heeney (had Hawkins until 10 mins before game)
Got eyes on Hewett, Stringer and Steele currently. Plan is to race to full premium, finding a balance between value and viability and then use remaining CG on that last spot for a Bont/Dawson that I don’t own. Would be too much of a strain, I think, to be balling out for them now and risk not having the funds to finish a side.
After replacing Setters and getting a sub 500k premo this week, my remaining non-premo spots will be:
– D6: McKenna
– M6-8: Hopper, Ash & Hollands/Cinc
– CG: 200k from Cowan & Young, 70k from Mitchell assuming he’s dead, only Cinc live
Will definitely need a rookie refresher set of trades soon but the plan, on paper, is:
– R9: Ash and Hollands into Steele
– R10: Probably bank Cowan & Young
– R11: McKenna to whichever DEF premo
By that point it’ll be Hopper M7 and Cinc M8, full premo everywhere else, jump on any good rookies and then throw everything to get Hopper to Bont/Dawson if I can at the byes.
Anyway, maybe my team’s just cooked or I’m a fool but totally think a) reading the CG landscape is the play rn and b) it’s helpful to look at your team this way.
Thought I’d start my day despairing at my team lol. Have a good day, all. Ttyl.
I think you are slightly better off than you think you are with only 3 rookies plus Hopper to upgrade. But your dead-ish bench will be a problem, as it is for many sides. I think the dead bench will also cause problems in the bye rounds.
I have 5 rookies on field plus Hopper. (should be only 4 but I gambled and traded Sheezel last week. Was always genius or madness, and madness it proved to be). Now gives me one more hole to fill. I think this fills 4 X 500k premos. So I think Hopper stays and need some luck to fill the last spot. I can see a Hail Mary on a Wines at 400k or something similar.
The only redeeming feature for me is 10 live rookies plus Mitchell (who may or may not be alive). I have kept Chesser and Roberts. I think Chesser will get back. Roberts is a maybe.
I think one big outcome for me was not starting with a loophole rookie. I started Rat at R3. As you well said – cash gen is the game, and rookies started thin and got thinner. We get dead rookies quick enough. Definitely note to self for next year.
Starting choice regrets – Brayshaw and Docherty. Started Sheed instead of Day, but that gave me Dawson instead of Steele, so no complaints.
Trading regrets so far – trading Darcy to Cameron, and trading out Sheezel. Wish I had bought Ryan from Richmond (probably instead of DVR). Would be allowing me to cash in Rat now. Now my choices for Rat are Teakle this week, or wait for D Cam to come back as F6.
Thinking of going Setters, L Jones, Grundy > Fiorini, Cincotta, S. Darcy
This banks me 250k and will allow me to go up to Steele in 1 trade next week (via Baker/Greene). Think this is ideal because there are no rookies on the horizon so I would hate to 1-down 1-up next week. Fiorini also has the R12 bye which is nice. Somewhat concerned that Fiorini is a trap but he had a massive tear at the end of 2021 so here’s hoping he can replicate that.
Value is the name of the game with no rookies on the horizon. Even if Fiorini only earns 100-150k and I dump him I think that is fine – it would take at least 2 trades to get a rookie up to a premo anyway. Been hunting value all season and it has caught me up since I missed Daicos – Haynes/Tomahawk/Day all coming good. Was also looking at Chayce Jones so anyone with him would be happy.
I guess for every Tomahawk there is a Redman though 🙂 🙂 🙂
Caleb Daniel was used at 44.4% of team centre bounces in Round 7 (Round 6: 6.5%).
Expect a decline when Tom Liberatore returns.
I am not completely adverse to the Daniels selection ( I have had him on my radar) but the Liberatore factor is a worry. Maybe watch this week with both of them playing.
Best of luck to you Le Savage with whatever you decide.
Where do you blokes go to get your BE stats etc.?
I find the SC site not very user-friendly.
Too Serious is good but slow to update… any better options?
Traded Phillipou out for Cincotta and have $236,500 in the bank
Do I
TU – Setterfield > Cripps
TD – Use boost, downgrade Phillips (FWD) > Angwin and then upgrade F.Greene (unsure who to go to from there but will have $666,800 in the bank)
My FWD line is basically non existent currently with Taranto, Dunkley, Rozee, Sheezel, F.Greene, D.Williams, Roberts, Phillips
I think the issue is that there is not really any great answers to your problem. You gave Cincotta already, so there is not really any other great rookie selections to be had.
Whilst ideally you would want to be shedding Philippou, Ginbey and Greene they are at least playing, if their cash gen is possibly dead. And your dead rookies are difficult to shift because they have made no money.
A total left field suggestion therefore is to trade a premo and a dead rookie for two mid pricers. Far from ideal, but maybe a solution. Especially since your premos are all performing. But at a pinch it would be Macrae and Davey for Wines /Clark/ JHF/ Bailey / Rampe if he’s back / Sheed/ Rachele combo.
Either that you go early on Weddle. But we know going early on rookies rarely works out. Or you are going to have to sit on these rookies and wait for others to emerge.
None of these are great answers. I hope other members of the community have a better suggestion. But that’s all I got.
I’d be seeing who plays out of Davey and Phillipou and trading 1 of them to Simpson (if he plays) to try and build up the cash. Stay away from using another boost.
You might have a stab at Fiorini due to his low cost.
At least McKenna, Wilmot and Baker are playing. No value in trading any of the other rookies.
Ideally, you neeed to get to focus on getting the worst on field rookies off the ground.
In order, I would be targetting Wilmot,Ginbey and Green. Our issue is the lack of rookies on the other side of that trade. On the positive side, they are all playing.
Hi guys.
Question ??
Do you think Rory Atkins will hold his spot as
he would be good cover and good for the byes
TU will hold his spot
TD flash in the pan
Comment please
Like other rookie-pricers, good idea to wait until there’s two games under the belt. Plus for his current price it would be agony if he fell out of the team now or next week. I have my eye firmly on The Rat for the reasons you’ve named
Went TU because I love aiming for high-ceilings in draft leagues; we all saw what Mills did last year. If Horse moves the magnets in the right way, that’s an easy trade win. On the other hand if the rest of your team is already looking a bit shaky, getting the consistency of Titch would really help out. Rankine > Dusty if you really can’t decide
Love the trade though, great options on either side, kudos
Thanks for your detailed response. I’m currently last on the ladder with Mills and Rankine. Mills bas been disappointing given his potential. Titch will add the consistency i need. Who knows when Horse will move the magnets around. I’m losing patience.
Re Rankine v Dusty: Dusty has the eagles this week, so I’m optimistic. Rankine certainly more consistent this year.
Genuinely a tricky decision, one i need to nail to climb up the draft ladder!
I know it’s a while off but anyone else worried how SuperCoach will work when the Tassie side joins and I assume there’s a team having a bye every week??
I need to get rid of Liam Jones asap.. There’s a spike in Wil Powell’s Kick-ins over last 2 weeks following Touk’s injury- Suggesting Weller is playing higher up the field and thus, Weller’s kick-ins have dropped.
TU: Powell- risk it for high ceiling + low BE and cash
TD: Ziebell- injury cloud but reliable scorer.
Comment: Titch in mids.
Freo’s ins this week. Fyfe for Johnson , even for 30% Gametime. Young to midfield for clearance and distribution. Wilson for run off halfback. Wrong forum, right moves.
Unfortunately I’m a Grundy owner.. for me it’s bank 75k and grab gawn or straight swap to a witts who before the injury everyone predicted would finish top 2-3 in the ruckline.
TU: gawn
TD: witts
Eventually I want Darcy Cameron at F6 and could probably swing max and DCam between lines when they both have DPP for injury cover.
TU: Grundy, Cowan, Davey > Teakle, Cincotta, Oliver
TD: Grundy, Cowan, Greene > Soldo, Cincotta, Oliver
Not sure between Teakle and soldo to get soldo have to offload Greene rather than Davey who isn’t rly getting game but I think Greene may have reached his end anyway?
With de koning out with concussion for 12 days that gives pittonet another 2 weeks gauranteed at least hopefully. Or are soldo and Teakle still the better options
I’m trying to figure out downgrade targets for Phillipou & Cowan but nothing seems clear.
I’m hoping that Constable gets another run or Dylan Williams starts in the backline again for Port and not a sub or Sam Simpson becomes a valid option.
Simpson is the only viable rookie trade-in option this week (I went early on Cincotta last week!!).. Question is who to trade out for him?
TU: Phillipou
TD: Greene
Greene, Setterfield and Hopper for Oliver, Cincotta and Day locked in for me right now.
Tossing up whether to use my third boost and get Hopper up to Day and swing him into defence later, or hold Hopper for another weak with Weagles coming up.
Also I know Oliver is a must at seasons end, but should I be looking for more value now in someone like Steele instead..? Although Oliver probably won’t get much cheaper.
Havent loved the idea of grundy to soldo but if Dcam is back in 3-4 weeks and soldo can get to 380-400k it would only be a simple rookie downgrade of 100k to make that move
Means i can get grundy to oliver this week and then essentially hopefully trade soldo to Dcam as my R2 in a few weeks. Good or bad idea?
Prioritise which option?
TU- do 1 down 1 up and a sideways trade going Grundy to gawn or witts asap
TD – do 2 down 1 up and focus on cash generation & get simpson in
I just want to get rid of all rookies first, Setters will drop price a bit for now but should climb back up, and his ceiling is much better than the rookies
Going against the grain this week but I think I gotta.
Ranked 1.7k, 22 trades left after these.
OUT: Setterfield, Roberts
IN: Fiorini, Cincotta
Bank 150k with these trades. Leaves me with 260k. Fiorini solid scorer when given the chance in the MIDS. Has a BE of 12 and with Miller out, I fully expect him to score 80+ most weeks and rise to hopefully 450k odd.
Next week will be Steele in for sure. Close eye on both Hopper and George Hewett this week, in a potential trade swap.
Have got a few trades on hand so I’m happy burning through some if it means I can generate cash and some stepping stones.
TU: Get rid of Phillipou and only be able to bring in Steele
TD: Get rid of Ginbey (but be stuck with Phillipou) and bring in Taranto
Ginbey is a lot less likely to lose a lot of money and is a rookie that’s getting games. Phillipou is going to potentially end up back where he started, but I feel like this might be one of the last chances for Taranto. Not keen on using boost to do both.
Help needed please: am i better off to trade out cash cows who seem to have peaked but are at least getting a gig (the likes of F Greene, Phillipou, Ginbey) or to trade out cows who aren’t playing but who MAY return to the paddock (the likes of Roberts, Phillips, Constable)
Obviously points on field and the strength of your team is the first thing, so 100% trade the necessary rookies to finance upgrades. All the ones you mentioned have, yes, peaked and are good to cull.
That said, if you can make the same upgrade happen by getting rid of a dead rookie over a live one then absolutely do that.
Out – Bowes- Cowan – Roberts
IN – Steele – Cincotta – Drury
Yes I am going early on Drury for a number of reasons. The kid is a ‘goer’ and gets involved. I reckon he has greater job security than Angwin as well.
These trades ( and any future ones) are also made with an eye to the byes and trying to make sure I have enough ‘warm bodies’ to get me thru.
Setterfield>Walsh
Ginbey>Cincotta
Cincotta will come in but the real question is who goes out.
Thumbs up Bowes
Thumbs down Roberts
I still have Chesser who I think is about a month away. Constable who u don’t see playing again unless an injury occurs. Cowan who has probably lost his spot to Cincotta. Davey and Phillips who each will hopefully return for round 8
Best bubble boys to bring in this week?
Looking to upgrade but need to free up funds.
Already have Cincotta..
Phillipou > Cincotta
I’ll need to wait for teams on Thursday to see if I can also finalise:
Cowan > Simpson
Setterfield > Laird
Food for thought, how did Laird look? Do I need to worry about his injury niggles.
TU: Laird, do it.
TD: Walsh, POD it.
I’d put that one down to bye structure, Jov.
Both great.
Wise words as always, thanks GD.
Two trades basically locked in at the moment.
Jones > Cincotta
Greene > Steele
TU: leave it at that
TD: use 4th boost and trade Grundy>Walsh
Is it just me or do the rookies completely run out after this weekend?
Yep, it’s the year of the midpricer!
Weddle the only decent prospect next week if the hawks give him a decent run.
Who’s the bigger priority to bring in this week?
TU: Sicily
TD: Taranto
Decided the 3 trades in necessary.
Phillipou to Cincotta
Setterfield to Laird
Ridley to Ryan.
Only trade I was tempted to save the boost for was Ridley, but the man has to go!
TU: James Sicily
TD: Luke Ryan
Out: Phillipou, Comben, JVR
In: Cincotta, Simpson, Cogs
TU: Good trades
TD: Rethink
I didn’t catch the saints game. Was Steele back to his best??
537k and playing North he’s every chance to reach his BE if 126 if so.
Appreciate any feedback.
T/u – Yes, he’s back!
T/d – No
Thanks everyone
I’ll be watching once more. Looked great but with a BE of 126, even if he does hit it, still shouldn’t go up by too much and still affordable next week. 1 more week of data!
Who is the better choice
TU Sicily
TD Sinclair
If you vote feel free to comment why you think this.
Sinclair plays for a better side, Great run coming up and a better Bye.
Sicily will be good, but needs to play “Tall” some games, this tends to lower his ceiling at times.
Thanks FT appreciate it. I was leaning towards Sinclair due to the better bye as you mentioned but the only reason I am tempted by Sicily is the possibilty of forward tags on Sinclair
Out Ridley Setterfield Ginbey
In Sicily Steele Cincotta
TU Good Trades
TD Bad Trades
TU – P Cripps
TD – W Day + 100k
Can only bring in 1 this week,
TU Steele (the Jack kind not the Sidebottom kind)
TD Sicily
Cheers all.
Hey FBS
Getting in a Mid for sub $550K with a favourable bye is just too tempting in my book.
Tu Stewart
TD Sicily to save some cash
Duncan
TU: keep
TD: trade
TU Out Ridley Setterfield Greene
In Sicily Steele Cincotta
Using a Boost
TD Out Greene Setterfield
In Cincotta Clarry
No Boost
Both good, just go with what you think helps in the back end- so maybe no boost:)
Why not Greene + Setterfield for Steele + Cincotta + $$$$
Out: Phillipou, Greene, Wilmot
In: Steele, Cincotta, Angwin
TU: Yes
TD: No
In: Cogs, day, cincotta
Out: Phillopou, baker, Bowes
Tu- good trades
Td- Adjust
Grundy has to go
TU: English (gonna drop cash but maybe not too much if he returns to the 130s)
TD: Darcy
Grundy to cheap prem0. Make some $$$
Rookie downgrade to Teakle.
Next week: double upgrade
T/U – Phillipou, Setterfield, Ridley OUT > Cincotta, Steele, Cogs IN
T/D – Greene, Setterfield, Ridley OUT > Cincotta, Steele, Sicily IN
Currently have 24 trades left. Not sure if this is a good number at this stage but Im getting nervous. So
TU – Phillipou > Angwin as a bench warmer and hold the extra trade
TD Phillipou and Setterfield > Angwin and Walsh
What should my biggest trade priority be this week?
Tu: move out Grundy
Td: replace my dead rookie emergencies (Roberts, Comben)
Awesome
Whats the best option under $575k
Tu: Marshall
Td: Gawn or Blicavs
Comment: anyone else
TU: Oliver and use my 3rd boost
TD: Sicily, no boost
or
TU: Dawson, using 3rd boost
TD: Stewart, no boost
Get Oliver Haz. That what the Boosts are for.
I would love to trade in Tom Stewart but don’t have the necessary funds. What are the thoughts on Wil Powell at $482K? Played 5 games for 3 tons, including a last game of 143. 3 round average of 111.7 and a BE of just 7. Favourable bye as well. The floor bothers me (scores of 71 and 67 this season) but I do like a value pick.
TU – welcome Wil Powell
TD – find another way to bring in a genuine premo defender
Anyone considering Cunnington after his 110 against Melbourne on the weekend? Could perhaps make a little cash and be a solid stopgap if he runs into some form.
mcvee phillips greene>crippa andwin and cincotta
yes no
Wait on teams before confirming. Not 100% sure angwin holds his spot
T/U – Setterfield & Phillipou to Walsh & Cincotta
T/D – Setterfield, Phillipou & Greene to Oliver, Cincotta & Simpson/Angwin
or Option 3
T/U – Setterfield & Greene to Oliver & Cincotta
Only downside is Phillipou projected to leak cash
Hey Mamba.
Pou may get a rest next week anyway. He looks like he needs it.
Is it worth doing a boost just to do F.Greene to someone on the bubble??
TU for Y
TD for N
Cincotta the only “must have”rookie this week.
Thumbs Up: Oliver
Thumbs Down: Stewart
FYI.
I was super peeved with my crap team other night after I had way too many drinks and deleted my team..
In the morning, sober, I realised I over reacted & emailed HS to asked them if it was possible to reinstate my crap team..they did so within 1 hour..the bonus is now I again have Supercoach Premium after it had previously expired after the trial ended..result. Unsure if its another trial but..
Thanks HS.
Could I please ask the SCT community which trade is more appealing. Byes are not a problem, Thank you.
TU Steele
TD Serong
Ranked in the top 1%
Looking to upgrade this week, already have Cincotta from last week.
Thinking;
OUT: Wilmont, Philipou & Greene
IN: Angwin, Simpson & Steele
TU or TD
Fallen in a massive hole, lost 26,000 places in the last 2 weeks.
Everything I touch is turning to mud at the moment.
Looks like a good side but keeps getting smashed.
I warn anyone against bringing in Oliver this week because this is what I am doing.
Setterfield >> Oliver
Ginbey >> Cincotta
Phillipou >> Simpson
Pending team selections of course
Should I:
T/u use a boost this week to bring in a sub 550k player – Steele, Sicily, Coniglio
T/d wait a week and do a one up, one down to get in a Oliver, Cripps, Walsh
So with the impending rookie drought (hopefully temporary) in mind, I’m going to triple down this week and get rid of some red dots:
OUT Cowan, Greene and Roberts
IN Cincotta, Angwin and Simpson
Will be dependent on named teams, as always. Gives me $270K in the bank to go get Steele etc next week
Waste of a boost in my book Chillo
Angwin and Simpson no guarantee not to be Red dots in a few weeks anyway.
I would rather wait to correct rookies at the Byes when we need green dots.
Cowan to Cincotta makes sense. I would hold Greene if you can’t afford to upgrade him. He should go well V my mob Freo. He wont lose too much cash with a 57 BE.
Thanks FT. After more thought, I’m keen to get Steele in this week instead despite his BE. I thought he looked back to his best last week and should go big against the Roos.
Greene is actually my first option to trade out this week – the return of Mitch Lewis has completely changed his role and they hardly kicked it to him at all last week. Not to mention that he looked pretty sore after running full pelt into the goal post!
TU – Man of Steele
TD – Him Tarantino
Taranto looks to be F1 this year, that makes him a “must have”.
He also plays WC and is a VC Option this week.
Steele 126 BE should still be pretty cheap next week.
With a lack of rookies on the horizon and a high rank to maintain considering doing a triple downgrade this week.
Out Setterfield, Greene, Ginbey
TU:In Cincotta, Simpson, Teakle + 569k
My other thought is to load up on players with the good bye
Aka
TD In Noah Anderson, Fiorini, Cincotta
Thoughts?
I like Anderson with no Touk.
I got him in pre round 6 as I liked his DE and his Bye. Cincotta is a must have.
The other Rookies are pretty risky this week so I would tend to wait for Weddle next week. We had him in our sites preseason, so If he gets a decent run he should start scoring ok.
Would watch Fiorini for 1 more week before moving and get confirmation on Miller’s ETA.
Tu Sinclair
Td Steele
Would loop Wilmot and Cincotta with either pick
I like both Chezza
I voted Steele as its so much harder to find a Mid at his price than a defender.
Trade plans:
Greene – Cincotta
JVR – Simpson
Setters – Oliver
If Hopper spuds again i will change Oliver to Sicily which gives me the funds for Hopper to Steele next week.
tu-in day, Steele, cincotta (176k itb)
out worpel, baker, bowes
td- In Day, Cogs, cincotta (17k itb)
out bowes, phillopou, Baker
Two very different options this week
T/U
Trade out one of Setterfield/Ridley along with Roberts and Ginbey
T/D
All the fattened cows Cowan/McKenna/Ginbey and keep both Ridley/Setterfield who are still both likely to score more than recruits.
In both instances the trade in is Sic/Angwin/Cincotta. T/U leaves $97.4k, T’D leaves $32.0k Including Roberts in T/D doesnt allow Sicily.
T/U: Steele
T/D: Cogs
TU: Cripps
TD: Cogs
TU : Luke Ryan
TD : Sinclair
Cripps or Pay up for Clarry?
TU Cripps
TD Clarry
L Jones > Cincotta
F Greene > Simpson
Ratugolea > Oliver via dpp
1 down, 2 up for me this week.
F Greene to Cincotta
Phillipou to Rozee
Ginbey to Dawson.
Bailey dale real frustrating… just not where he was at last year.
T/U – Look to move him on
T/D – Hold for now, focus on getting rookies off field
T/U: Get in Simpson, Angwin and Cincotta this week
T/D: Two downgrades and a premo
bringing in one cheap m8 this week but can’t split the two, steele is tried and tested however green has had an uninterrupted year and is on the rise to a top 8 mid
TU Steele
TD Green
Will Angus Brayshaw come good and be a top defender? Or does he not look good this year?
Wouldn’t consider him till he we see him get a solid scoring stream to lift his floor.
Last year it was huge marking economy coming off his opponent and excellent D50 stoppage grunt work.
Hasn’t had any of that so far.
Salem is listed as 1-2 weeks away.
If he comes in Brayshaw’s role might change and he may get some midfield time.
Worth trading ginbey to Simpson? Will be on field
Is himmleberg playing back now? Worth picking up ?
Just said this in reply to Steve:
Had a little patch in the 3rd where he was swung back but, no, still playing FWD.
In Taylor’s absence they just moved Haynes into more accountable role and moved their lockdown DEFs up an opponent.
worth trading out Grundy to English this week but lose an upgrade.
TU: two downgrades one premo
TD: two downgrades grundy to english
Depends on where your side is at, Tim.
Tingles obviously R1 but the 100k and need to keep pace with upgrades could warrant passing.
Have you considered dropping him to Gawn? Nets you 75k, then you can boost and comfortably do a 1 up 1 down.
Noticed Kemp from Carlton first game 93 SC points might be a possible down grade option see if he gets selected next week
Who looks the better pick?
TU- Brodie Kemp
TD- Rory Atkins
Just curious to see who is preferred. Will take another look this week at both
Apart from Cincotta on the bubble, not many others jumping out apart from Kemp & Atkins. And I don’t like their starting prices around $200k
Think most of us have some rookies who are spent and about to bleed cash- eg Phillipou, Gibney, etc, but those lucky enough to pick Chandler and Buckley are saving a few trades for them
>>> Is himmleberg playing back now? Worth picking up ?
I picked him up last week hoping he would play back. Unfortunately, he was playing FWD the whole time and taking some ruck contests – he was on like 20 SC at half time, and then picked up a few goals and goal assists to get a respectable score. But I am regretting my decision to add him.
Had a little patch in the 3rd where he was swung back but, no, still playing FWD.
In Taylor’s absence they just moved Haynes into more accountable role and moved their lockdown DEFs up an opponent.
Adam Kingsley said today, that they will persist playing Himmelberg forward in the short term.
TU: CRIPPS
TD: WALSH
This one really interests me
Who’s the better rookie option??
Price, Job Security, Role etc all included.
T/U – Simpson
T/D – Angwin
Cheers guys
Anyone heard an update re Touk? Wondering if there is a world where he is a hold. Thx in advance.
Hi Billioux,
We should have more clarity tomorrow, when clubs release updated injury lists.
Then we will know the timeframe for Miller’s return to play.
So check out the “Injuries Rd 8” post on Tuesday (shameless plug) for the injury news!
Thanks CT.
TU – Steele worth the gamble?
TD – Stick with Walsh/Petracca
Which combo?
T/U: Luke Ryan+Sam Simpson(bench)
T/D: Darcy MacPherson+Brayden Fiorini
Does Simpson actually have decent job security?
As a Cats fan I think he is safe until Stengle returns in 3-4 weeks. Thats providing he keeps up the pressure acts and snags a goal or two. Scott likes him and wants to give him a go.
It’s worth remembering that 2 years ago he played in a prelim for the Cats and got badly injured. He then suffered a bad concussion last year.
Has the ability just needs a clean run.
I’m another cats fan and I think you’ve summed that up perfectly Owen.
Well said, Owen.
Love the insight and seconding from Damo. Good stuff.
TU out michaelany, ginbey,
In cincotta, + 592k to go to Sicily, Sinclair, Steele, Day, Ryan etc
Pros: saves a boost, only one left before this round
Cons: misses out on Day
TD out Michaelany, ginbey, hopper
In cincotta, Steele, Day
Pros: get Steele and Day now whilst still cheap
Cons: all my boost gone, trading hopper one week to early, plays west coast
Which is better TD or TU
Out: Wilmot, F Greene, Phillipou
In: Steele, Cincotta, Simpson
Leaving me with 20 trades.
T/U – Good trades, go for it!
T/D – Just go Phillipou for Cincotta
Random question but anyone reckon Stewart will get the tag from Keays like he did on Daicos last round? Cheers
Nuh – Stewart doesn’t push up central enough to cop a tag like Keays. If anything assign a defensive fwd like Jones
Which combo
TU: Sinclair + Simpson
TD: Cogs + Simpson
In my eyes, the name of the game right now is reading the CG landscape. There’s just no way we’re filling out our sides with every 600k+ option we love. Honestly, even consecutive moves north of 550k will put a strain on most teams.
Maybe it’s my team in particular given I don’t have Bont, Dawson or Stewart and missed Chandler but I see a cold wind coming.
We were thin on rookies to begin with and there’s really not much coming through rn besides Cincotta. Wagner, Roberts, Constable, Cowan, Davey and now maybe Mitchell all dead.
Just don’t see how anyone’s getting to full premo popping 600k players in every week.
My recent trades ins have been all sub 500k:
– Day
– Heeney (had Hawkins until 10 mins before game)
Got eyes on Hewett, Stringer and Steele currently. Plan is to race to full premium, finding a balance between value and viability and then use remaining CG on that last spot for a Bont/Dawson that I don’t own. Would be too much of a strain, I think, to be balling out for them now and risk not having the funds to finish a side.
After replacing Setters and getting a sub 500k premo this week, my remaining non-premo spots will be:
– D6: McKenna
– M6-8: Hopper, Ash & Hollands/Cinc
– CG: 200k from Cowan & Young, 70k from Mitchell assuming he’s dead, only Cinc live
Will definitely need a rookie refresher set of trades soon but the plan, on paper, is:
– R9: Ash and Hollands into Steele
– R10: Probably bank Cowan & Young
– R11: McKenna to whichever DEF premo
By that point it’ll be Hopper M7 and Cinc M8, full premo everywhere else, jump on any good rookies and then throw everything to get Hopper to Bont/Dawson if I can at the byes.
Anyway, maybe my team’s just cooked or I’m a fool but totally think a) reading the CG landscape is the play rn and b) it’s helpful to look at your team this way.
Thought I’d start my day despairing at my team lol. Have a good day, all. Ttyl.
I think you are slightly better off than you think you are with only 3 rookies plus Hopper to upgrade. But your dead-ish bench will be a problem, as it is for many sides. I think the dead bench will also cause problems in the bye rounds.
I have 5 rookies on field plus Hopper. (should be only 4 but I gambled and traded Sheezel last week. Was always genius or madness, and madness it proved to be). Now gives me one more hole to fill. I think this fills 4 X 500k premos. So I think Hopper stays and need some luck to fill the last spot. I can see a Hail Mary on a Wines at 400k or something similar.
The only redeeming feature for me is 10 live rookies plus Mitchell (who may or may not be alive). I have kept Chesser and Roberts. I think Chesser will get back. Roberts is a maybe.
I think one big outcome for me was not starting with a loophole rookie. I started Rat at R3. As you well said – cash gen is the game, and rookies started thin and got thinner. We get dead rookies quick enough. Definitely note to self for next year.
Starting choice regrets – Brayshaw and Docherty. Started Sheed instead of Day, but that gave me Dawson instead of Steele, so no complaints.
Trading regrets so far – trading Darcy to Cameron, and trading out Sheezel. Wish I had bought Ryan from Richmond (probably instead of DVR). Would be allowing me to cash in Rat now. Now my choices for Rat are Teakle this week, or wait for D Cam to come back as F6.
Good luck for the rest of the season.
LDU in doubt this week?
Thanks
Worth boosting to get Ridley out for another premo?
T U Danger
TD Steele
Just as we thought things couldn’t be worse than last year…..
30K ITB, 26 trades, 3 boosts left.
TU: Phillipou, Ratagalea -> Cincotta, Day
TD: Phillipou, Greene, Ginbey -> Cincotta, Simpson, Steele
Thoughts on the downgrade of grundy to teakle?? Only would need him to get to the byes or is his job security not good enough
If your going to have Teakle at R2 get there by downgrading a rookie ie Greene/Philapou/whoever
Then short Grundy to a fallen premium in the mid 400s/low 500s and get the equivalent cash of a trade down on that move as well
Trading in a juicy premo this week. What do ppl think?
TU: Luke Ryan
TD: Jack Sinclair
T/U: Phillipou, F.Greene and Ginbey to Simpson, Cincotta, T.Stewart
T/D: Phillipou and F.Greene to Cincotta and Sinclair
I think I’m sold on Phillipou and Setters out for Cincotta and Ryan.
TU – Boost and trade Ridley for Cogs/Steele
TD – Boost and trade Davey for Simpson
Comment – No Boost
Good luck to everyone with their trades thi week, feels like a minefield
No boost
Hi coaches, stuck on this:
T/U: Sinclair
T/D Steele
Cheers
23 trades left, 3 boosts.
T/U – Phillips, F Greene, Hopper —–> Coniglio, Steele, Cincotta using a boost.
T/D – Keep faith in Hopper and wait a week on Steele.
Comment – other.
Cheers
Would leave Hopper as a final/late upgrade. Rookies to premos are what needs to be happening now – nets you more points OA.
Hopper also has West Coast this week. Free ton for him and a third of Richmond.
Thinking of going Setters, L Jones, Grundy > Fiorini, Cincotta, S. Darcy
This banks me 250k and will allow me to go up to Steele in 1 trade next week (via Baker/Greene). Think this is ideal because there are no rookies on the horizon so I would hate to 1-down 1-up next week. Fiorini also has the R12 bye which is nice. Somewhat concerned that Fiorini is a trap but he had a massive tear at the end of 2021 so here’s hoping he can replicate that.
Value is the name of the game with no rookies on the horizon. Even if Fiorini only earns 100-150k and I dump him I think that is fine – it would take at least 2 trades to get a rookie up to a premo anyway. Been hunting value all season and it has caught me up since I missed Daicos – Haynes/Tomahawk/Day all coming good. Was also looking at Chayce Jones so anyone with him would be happy.
I guess for every Tomahawk there is a Redman though 🙂 🙂 🙂
Is Caleb Daniel good value, now that he’s returned to a midfield role. Under $500k & more than capable of averaging 100+, if he maintains this role!
TU: Yes, take a punt
TD: No, better options elsewhere.
Hi Le Savage,
Caleb Daniel was used at 44.4% of team centre bounces in Round 7 (Round 6: 6.5%).
Expect a decline when Tom Liberatore returns.
I am not completely adverse to the Daniels selection ( I have had him on my radar) but the Liberatore factor is a worry. Maybe watch this week with both of them playing.
Best of luck to you Le Savage with whatever you decide.
Thanks CT
Out: Ginbey, Phillipou and Greene
In: Cincotta, Simpson and…
TU: Petracca
TD: Walsh
Comment: Parish
Parish
who would you pick up as a defender have $520k in bank
T/u newman from carlton
T/d young from freo
Thinking of going crazy
Grundy, Cowan, Davey > Teakle, Cincotta, Oliver +40k
TU or TD
Any love for Noah Anderson? No Touk for the foreseeable future could see him explode…
Is will powell the real deal?
Where do you blokes go to get your BE stats etc.?
I find the SC site not very user-friendly.
Too Serious is good but slow to update… any better options?
https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/supercoach_breakevens
TU: Phillipou + Setterfield out, Cincotta + Taranto in
TD: Use a boost as well for F. Greene out, Simpson/rookie in (2 boosts left after)
Redman:
TU: Keep
TD: Trade
Traded Phillipou out for Cincotta and have $236,500 in the bank
Do I
TU – Setterfield > Cripps
TD – Use boost, downgrade Phillips (FWD) > Angwin and then upgrade F.Greene (unsure who to go to from there but will have $666,800 in the bank)
My FWD line is basically non existent currently with Taranto, Dunkley, Rozee, Sheezel, F.Greene, D.Williams, Roberts, Phillips
Setters to a Cogs/Gulden type perhaps? Depends on how your mid looks. Can still then go Greene/Phillips -> Simpson/Angwin with a boost
Pros and Cons for Ryan, Sicily and Sinclair?
Unlikely I’ll need all 3, but feasible 2 of the 3 come into my team @ some point.
Share your wisdom
Basically re-posting what I posted in the Fix My Team, because no one who’s asked for help there is really getting any answers on that page.
DEF – Dawson, Daicos, Stewart, McKenna, Ginbey, Wilmot (Mitchell, Constable)
MID – Oliver, Walsh, Macrae, Merrett, Green, Hopper, Ashcroft, Baker (Davey, Johnson, Cincotta)
RUC – English, Marshall (Madden)
FWD – Taranto, Dunkley, Coniglio, Ziebell, Sheezel, Green (Phillipou, Roberts)
$69,800K/22 trades/2 boosts left
Not sure what to do with my rookie situation, because there’s quite a few I need to get rid of. Which ones should I get rid of first, and who for?
I think the issue is that there is not really any great answers to your problem. You gave Cincotta already, so there is not really any other great rookie selections to be had.
Whilst ideally you would want to be shedding Philippou, Ginbey and Greene they are at least playing, if their cash gen is possibly dead. And your dead rookies are difficult to shift because they have made no money.
A total left field suggestion therefore is to trade a premo and a dead rookie for two mid pricers. Far from ideal, but maybe a solution. Especially since your premos are all performing. But at a pinch it would be Macrae and Davey for Wines /Clark/ JHF/ Bailey / Rampe if he’s back / Sheed/ Rachele combo.
Either that you go early on Weddle. But we know going early on rookies rarely works out. Or you are going to have to sit on these rookies and wait for others to emerge.
None of these are great answers. I hope other members of the community have a better suggestion. But that’s all I got.
I’d be seeing who plays out of Davey and Phillipou and trading 1 of them to Simpson (if he plays) to try and build up the cash. Stay away from using another boost.
You might have a stab at Fiorini due to his low cost.
At least McKenna, Wilmot and Baker are playing. No value in trading any of the other rookies.
Ideally, you neeed to get to focus on getting the worst on field rookies off the ground.
In order, I would be targetting Wilmot,Ginbey and Green. Our issue is the lack of rookies on the other side of that trade. On the positive side, they are all playing.
Is Day worth getting ? Would be using my last boost to do it
Yeah, still good value at sub 500k as a D6.
Okay, this is the plan…..
Out – Bowes, Cowan & Davey
In – Cincotta, Angwin &
Thumbs up – Walsh
Thumbs Down – Sicily & $60K
You already know the answer Shaggi 🙂
Sic for sure
TU: COGS + SIMPSON
TD: WALSH + SIMPSON
Dilemma whether to hang on to Davies-Uniacke or trade for a bigger fish…Dawson, Bonts,Laird,Sinclair,Walsh…a plethora of talent…or hang on.
Trade
Angwin
TU: Yes
TD: No
If we already have Cincotta , then who apart from Angwin
TD wrong imo
Hi guys.
Question ??
Do you think Rory Atkins will hold his spot as
he would be good cover and good for the byes
TU will hold his spot
TD flash in the pan
Comment please
Thanks Tony
Like other rookie-pricers, good idea to wait until there’s two games under the belt. Plus for his current price it would be agony if he fell out of the team now or next week. I have my eye firmly on The Rat for the reasons you’ve named
No reason to think Atkins will hold his spot now. He never seems to get a fair run.
Atkins is also a predominantly outside player that has low CPs which isnt ideal for SC
Who wins this trade in Draft league?
TU: Mills and Rankine
TD: T Mitchell and Dusty
Went TU because I love aiming for high-ceilings in draft leagues; we all saw what Mills did last year. If Horse moves the magnets in the right way, that’s an easy trade win. On the other hand if the rest of your team is already looking a bit shaky, getting the consistency of Titch would really help out. Rankine > Dusty if you really can’t decide
Love the trade though, great options on either side, kudos
Thanks for your detailed response. I’m currently last on the ladder with Mills and Rankine. Mills bas been disappointing given his potential. Titch will add the consistency i need. Who knows when Horse will move the magnets around. I’m losing patience.
Re Rankine v Dusty: Dusty has the eagles this week, so I’m optimistic. Rankine certainly more consistent this year.
Genuinely a tricky decision, one i need to nail to climb up the draft ladder!
I know it’s a while off but anyone else worried how SuperCoach will work when the Tassie side joins and I assume there’s a team having a bye every week??
I do NRL supercoach as well and they have a bye each week now. It started this year with Dolphins entering the comp. No big drama really
T/U Jones and Ratugolea to Simpson and Noah Anderson
T/D Jones and Ratugolea to Simpson and Steele
Better option
td – Simpson
td – D. Williams
Phillipou > Cincotta
Greene > Simpson
And give myself $270k for next round where can use that for upgrades
TU: Yes
TD: No
TU: Steele
TD: Sinclair/Sicily
Wow no TU
I need to get rid of Liam Jones asap.. There’s a spike in Wil Powell’s Kick-ins over last 2 weeks following Touk’s injury- Suggesting Weller is playing higher up the field and thus, Weller’s kick-ins have dropped.
TU: Powell- risk it for high ceiling + low BE and cash
TD: Ziebell- injury cloud but reliable scorer.
Comment: Titch in mids.
Powell and Ziebell probably not keepers (I have the latter and hoping he will be).
Titch a good enough M8
Walsh or P. Cripps
Tu-Walsh
Td- Cripps
Neither
For interest sake who are the other 8.
TU: Cowan, Phillipou, Setters- Cincotta, S.Simpson, Clarry
TD: Cowan, Phillipou, Greene – Cincotta, S. Simpson, Parish
Top one pros are getting rid of setters
Bottom pro is having an extra bench option but having to field setters and possibly lose money
Grundy was fun for a bit. Due to my team being just about cooked already, instead of Teaks how about a solo running Pitto instead?
T/U Pitto
T/D Teakle
Thx in advance.
Soldo
Food for thought Ninjas..Grundy not my most pressing issue, altho is gonna bleed cash. watch, wait 1 week on Soldo seems a prudent play
Going to be bringing in one Def premo this week, these two guys are about the same price :
T/D – Sicily
T/U – Sinclair
I think I lean Sicily slightly but Sinclair might be better for my bye structure
Sic now, Sinc after his bye
Which one to trade out :
TU : L Jones
TD : Wilmot
Been tossing this one around and still can’t decide –
TU – Trade in Day
TD – Trade in Cogs
Was trying to find a way of getting them both this week, plus Cincotta, but fall $1,000 short….
Both are keepers imo , cogs more important
Currently running Rucks of – Marshall and S. Ryan.
Traded Grundy last week with the plan to get Gawn this week but i’m not convinced.
Is Marc Pittonet a legit option at 357k
T/U – Yes, he’s cheap and will make money gives more time to decide between English, Darcy & Gawn.
T/D – No, waste of a trade just roll with S. Ryan for now and bring in English or Darcy within the next few weeks.
Thanks everyone.
If u want to gamble on a ruck man, I’d be choosing Soldo
Freo’s ins this week. Fyfe for Johnson , even for 30% Gametime. Young to midfield for clearance and distribution. Wilson for run off halfback. Wrong forum, right moves.
T/U:
Ginbey > Cincotta
Greene > Simpson
Phillipou > Anderson
$7k ITB, 19 Trades + 1 Boost
T/D:
Ginbey > Cincotta
Greene > Simpson
$312k ITB, 20 Trades + 2 boosts
Use a boost to trade Grundy to English?
Both risky but if going early..
TU: Weddle
TD: Rory Atkins
(Have Cincotta)
Cheers
T/u Setterfield to any uber mid or def via dpp
T/d Grundy to Gawn
Unfortunately I’m a Grundy owner.. for me it’s bank 75k and grab gawn or straight swap to a witts who before the injury everyone predicted would finish top 2-3 in the ruckline.
TU: gawn
TD: witts
Eventually I want Darcy Cameron at F6 and could probably swing max and DCam between lines when they both have DPP for injury cover.
TU: Grundy, Cowan, Davey > Teakle, Cincotta, Oliver
TD: Grundy, Cowan, Greene > Soldo, Cincotta, Oliver
Not sure between Teakle and soldo to get soldo have to offload Greene rather than Davey who isn’t rly getting game but I think Greene may have reached his end anyway?
Tu: Sinclair
Td: Sicily
With de koning out with concussion for 12 days that gives pittonet another 2 weeks gauranteed at least hopefully. Or are soldo and Teakle still the better options
T/U – Anderson
T/D – Sinclair
TU: Teakle
TD: Soldo
DEF: Dawson, Daicos, Sicily, McKenna, Wilmot, Mitchell, (McVee, Cowan)
MID: Neale, Laird, Walsh, Green, Coniglio, Hopper, Ashcroft, Baker, (Roberts, Gillbee, Cincotta)
RUCK: English, Marshall (Madden)
FWD: Taranto, Dunkley, Rozee, Ziebell, Sheezel, van Rooyen, (Phillipou, Drury)
I’m trying to figure out downgrade targets for Phillipou & Cowan but nothing seems clear.
I’m hoping that Constable gets another run or Dylan Williams starts in the backline again for Port and not a sub or Sam Simpson becomes a valid option.
Any suggestions would be awesome! :))
Simpson is the only viable rookie trade-in option this week (I went early on Cincotta last week!!).. Question is who to trade out for him?
TU: Phillipou
TD: Greene
Angwin on bubble
TU: Baker > N Anderson without Touk
TD: Baker > Steele abit risky
Or
TU: Baker > Oliver next week
T/u Setterfield/Grundy/Cowan > Cincotta/Gawn/Taranto $7.1k
T/d Setterfield/Roberts/Ginbey > Cincotta/Angwin/Sicily $97.4k
T/u could include Sicily instead of Taranto.
TU:Oliver
Or
TD: N Anderson and 100k
Steele or Sinclair/Sicily
Can get Steele and cincotta for michaleany and ginbey. Should I use my final boost and trade hopper to Day
TU or TD
TU: JVR (via dpp)> Sinclair, Greene > Simpson
Or
TD: Baker > Oliver next week, Greene > Simpson
Phillipou/Jones/Bobby Hill > Day, Simpson, Johnson (despite suspension)
TU: Yes
TD: Look elsewhere
Open to other ideas
Setterfield , F Greene , W Phillips for
Laird , Angwin , S Mitchell
Thoughts ?
TU
OUT: setterfield Grundy F.Greene
IN: Sinclair witts cincotta & 69k
TD
OUT: Setterfield F.Greene Cowan
IN: Serong Simpson cincotta & 40k
Does Grundy need to go?
I play for overall sitting 1100 OA
Yeah, Grundy about to get baked by Tingles.
Either grab him or go Gawn, bank the 75k and try to allocate that value real nicely as a way to match Tingles.
Hopper > Gawn ??
TU: petracca
TD: Sinclair
Thoughts please
T/U – Cowan/Greene to Cincotta/Steele
T/D – Above and also boost Grundy to Gawn
Thank you.
TU:
Grundy > Gawn
Greene > Simpson
Cowan > Cincotta (296k ITB to get oliver next week)
TD:
Grundy > Soldo
Cowan > Cincotta
Greene > Oliver (14k)
Currently ranked just under 500 so nervous to go really bold could make or break my season
Soldo out injured
TU: Anderson
Or
TD: Dangerfield
Or
TU: Oliver next week
Or
TD: Sinclair
Grundy, Greene >> Reeves, Owens
TU: Yolo, also helps complete my forward line so can fix issues on other lines.
TD: Reeves way too risky, plus im screwed once Meek comes back.
TU: sinclair
TD: de goey
Greene, Setterfield and Hopper for Oliver, Cincotta and Day locked in for me right now.
Tossing up whether to use my third boost and get Hopper up to Day and swing him into defence later, or hold Hopper for another weak with Weagles coming up.
Also I know Oliver is a must at seasons end, but should I be looking for more value now in someone like Steele instead..? Although Oliver probably won’t get much cheaper.
TU: Boost and Trade Hopper to Day w/ $17K ITB
or
TD: Hold Hopper w/ 63K ITB
sensible vs Silly
TU: Setterfield + Gibney > Anderson + Cincotta + 90k bank
TD Setterfield, Ginbey + Greene > Sicily, Stringer + Cincotta and $0 ITB.
TU: Oliver next week
Or
TD: Anderson this week
Havent loved the idea of grundy to soldo but if Dcam is back in 3-4 weeks and soldo can get to 380-400k it would only be a simple rookie downgrade of 100k to make that move
Means i can get grundy to oliver this week and then essentially hopefully trade soldo to Dcam as my R2 in a few weeks. Good or bad idea?
Prioritise which option?
TU- do 1 down 1 up and a sideways trade going Grundy to gawn or witts asap
TD – do 2 down 1 up and focus on cash generation & get simpson in
Trade out
TU: cowan – 75k in bank
TD: greene – $150k in bank
Greene because he could lose cash, trade Cowan next week
Out – Liam Jones, Fergus Greene, Rata
In – Walsh, Simpson, Teakle
Leaves me with only 2 rookies on the field (4 including Sheezel and Ashcroft) but i’ll still have Setterfield…
T/U – Yes
T/D – No
this is predicament, do i keep setterfield n get rid of a rookie or do i upgrade setterfield
I just want to get rid of all rookies first, Setters will drop price a bit for now but should climb back up, and his ceiling is much better than the rookies
As per the AFL website:
Blake Drury to debut for North Melbourne this week.
thoughts on fiorini? touk being out gives him opportunity. Thoughts of him getting back to his 2021 self excites me! LMK!!!!
Going against the grain this week but I think I gotta.
Ranked 1.7k, 22 trades left after these.
OUT: Setterfield, Roberts
IN: Fiorini, Cincotta
Bank 150k with these trades. Leaves me with 260k. Fiorini solid scorer when given the chance in the MIDS. Has a BE of 12 and with Miller out, I fully expect him to score 80+ most weeks and rise to hopefully 450k odd.
Next week will be Steele in for sure. Close eye on both Hopper and George Hewett this week, in a potential trade swap.
Have got a few trades on hand so I’m happy burning through some if it means I can generate cash and some stepping stones.
Who to Trade Out?
TU: Constable
TD: Sturt
Best job security ???
TU Rory Atkins
TD Sam Simpson
Thanks …..
Scott loves Simpson. He is a lock for a spot with Stengle out, may be a different story when that time comes but we’ll see
T/U: Long > Drury
T/D: Davey > Angwin
Thanks
TU: Get rid of Phillipou and only be able to bring in Steele
TD: Get rid of Ginbey (but be stuck with Phillipou) and bring in Taranto
Ginbey is a lot less likely to lose a lot of money and is a rookie that’s getting games. Phillipou is going to potentially end up back where he started, but I feel like this might be one of the last chances for Taranto. Not keen on using boost to do both.
Help needed please: am i better off to trade out cash cows who seem to have peaked but are at least getting a gig (the likes of F Greene, Phillipou, Ginbey) or to trade out cows who aren’t playing but who MAY return to the paddock (the likes of Roberts, Phillips, Constable)
TU: get rid of fattened cash cows
TD: get rid of non points scoring cows
thanks in advance
It depends, BM.
Obviously points on field and the strength of your team is the first thing, so 100% trade the necessary rookies to finance upgrades. All the ones you mentioned have, yes, peaked and are good to cull.
That said, if you can make the same upgrade happen by getting rid of a dead rookie over a live one then absolutely do that.
I have finally decided on these trades:
Out – Bowes- Cowan – Roberts
IN – Steele – Cincotta – Drury
Yes I am going early on Drury for a number of reasons. The kid is a ‘goer’ and gets involved. I reckon he has greater job security than Angwin as well.
These trades ( and any future ones) are also made with an eye to the byes and trying to make sure I have enough ‘warm bodies’ to get me thru.
TU: Drury and Oliver
Or
TD: Simpson and Oliver next week
TU : Atkins
Or
TD: Fiorini