ROUND 11 (ALL TIMES AEST)
NORTH MELBOURNE v RICHMOND
Friday 31 May, 7.50pm at Marvel Stadium
KANGAROOS
B: Williams, Thompson, Pittard
HB: Atley, Tarrant, Macmillan
C: Dumont, Anderson, Polec
HF: Ziebell, Wood, Simpkin
F: Larkey, Brown, Thomas
FOLL: Goldstein, Cunnington, Higgins
I/C: Davies-Uniacke, McDonald, Turner, Zurhaar
EMG: Taylor, Hall, Hayden, Campbell
IN: Nil
OUT: Nil
TIGERS
B: Garthwaite, Astbury, Grimes
HB: Broad, Edwards, Houli
C: Ellis, Prestia, McIntosh
HF: Higgins, Castagna, Butler
F: Martin, Lynch, Balta
FOLL: Soldo, Cotchin, Vlastuin
I/C: Stack, Baker, Bolton, Caddy
EMG: Coleman-Jones, Rioli, Graham, Menadue
IN: Butler, Soldo, Cotchin
OUT: Rioli, Coleman-Jones, Menadue
COLLINGWOOD v FREMANTLE
Saturday 1 June, 1.45pm at the MCG
MAGPIES
B: Maynard, Roughead, Greenwood
HB: Crisp, Moore, Howe
C: Phillips, Pendlebury, Mayne
HF: Thomas, Reid, Hoskin-Elliott
F: Stephenson, Mihocek, De Goey
FOLL: Grundy, Sidebottom, Treloar
I/C: Beams, Brown, Aish, Varcoe
EMG: Wills, Quaynor, Daicos, Madgen
IN: Moore, De Goey, Varcoe
OUT: Madgen, Wills, Wells
DOCKERS
B: Hamling, Pearce, Ryan
HB: Hughes, Wilson, Bewley
C: Hill, Fyfe, Langdon
HF: Cerra, Cox, Conca
F: Walters, Hogan, Maters
FOLL: Lobb, Tucker, Mundy
I/C: Duncan, Brayshaw, Blakely, Switkowski
EMG: Jones, Crowden, Logue, McCarthy
IN: Nil
OUT: Nil
GWS GIANTS v GOLD COAST SUNS
Saturday 1 June, 1.45pm at Giants Stadium
GIANTS
B: Kennedy, Haynes, Davis
HB: Shaw, Keeffe, Whitfield
C: Tomlinson, Hopper, Finlayson
HF: Perryman, Cameron, Deledio
F: Greene, Himmelberg, Reid
FOLL: Mumford, Coniglio, Taranto
I/C: Daniels, Kelly, Cumming, de Boer
EMG: Hately, Bonar, Simpson, Lloyd
IN: Keeffe
OUT: Taylor
SUNS
B: Murdoch, Burgess, Ballard
HB: Joyce, Hombsch, Weller
C: Horlin-Smith, Martin, Powell
HF: Lukosius, Wright, Corbett
F: MacPherson, Sexton, Holman
FOLL: Witts, Swallow, Bowes
I/C: Fiorini, Miles, King, Schoenfeld
EMG: Brodie, Day, McLennan, Nutting
IN: Horlin-Smith, Schoenfeld
OUT: Harbrow, Ainsworth
GEELONG CATS v SYDNEY SWANS
Saturday 1 June, 4.35pm at GMHBA Stadium
CATS
B: Kolodjashnij, Tuohy, Stewart
HB: Blicavs, Taylor, O’Connor
C: Dangerfield, Kelly, Duncan
HF: Rohan, Ratugolea, Hawkins
F: Atkins, Dahlhaus, Miers
FOLL: Stanley, C. Guthrie, Selwood
I/C: Henry, Clark, Parsons, Parfitt
EMG: Fort, Smith, Fogarty, Bews
IN: Dangerfield, Ratugolea
OUT: Fort, Ablett
SWANS
B: Melican, Rampe, Mills
HB: McVeigh, Aliir, Lloyd
C: Heeney, Hewett, Florent
HF: Papley, Reid, Blakey
F: McCartin, Franklin, Hayward
FOLL: Sinclair, Parker, Dawson
I/C: Fox, O’Riordan, Clarke, Menzel
EMG: Thurlow, Knoll, Ronke, Rowbottom
IN: McVeigh, Menzel
OUT: Kennedy, Thurlow
BRISBANE LIONS v HAWTHORN
Saturday 1 June, 7.25pm at the Gabba
LIONS
B: Hodge, Andrews, Rich
HB: Witherden, Gardiner, Answerth
C: Robinson, Neale, McCluggage
HF: Rayner, Hipwood, McCarthy
F: Cameron, McStay, Taylor
FOLL: Martin, Zorko, Lyons
I/C: Keays, Robertson, Mathieson, Smith
EMG: Christensen, Walker, Allison, Cutler
IN: Keays, Robertson, Mathieson, Smith
OUT: Walker, Hinge, Lester, McInerney
HAWKS
B: O’Brien, Frawley, Burgoyne
HB: Stratton, Sicily, Hardwick
C: Scully, Shiels, Henderson
HF: Breust, Gunston, Puopolo
F: Wingard, Ceglar, Impey
FOLL: Pittonet, Worpel, O’Meara
I/C: Glass, Cousins, Lewis, Smith
EMG: Morrison, Brand, Jones, Moore
IN: Lewis, Smith
OUT: Scrimshaw, Morrison
MELBOURNE v ADELAIDE CROWS
Saturday 1 June, 7.40pm at TIO Stadium
DEMONS
B: Hibberd, Frost, Wagner
HB: Hore, O. McDonald, Hunt
C: Brayshaw, Viney, Baker
HF: Jones, T. McDonald, Petracca
F: Garlett, Smith, Harmes
FOLL: Gawn, Hannan, Oliver
I/C: Salem, Spargo, Stretch, Fritsch
EMG: Jordon, Kennedy-Harris, Weideman, Wagner
IN: Hibberd, Hannan, Salem
OUT: Lockhart, Petty, Wagner
CROWS
B: Brown, Talia, Hartigan
HB: Smith, Keath, Laird
C: Milera, B. Crouch, Atkins
HF: Seedsman, Walker, Lynch
F: Murphy, Jenkins, Betts
FOLL: O’Brien, Gibbs, Sloane
I/C: Greenwood, Gallucci, Kelly, Ellis-Yolmen
EMG: Knight, Mackay, Jones, Himmelberg
IN: Lynch, Jenkins, Gibbs
OUT: Knight, Himmelberg, Jones
ST KILDA v PORT ADELAIDE
Sunday 2 June, 2:20pm at Adelaide Arena at Jiangwan Stadium
SAINTS
B: McKenzie, Brown, Savage
HB: Wilkie, Battle, Geary
C: Long, Ross, Newnes
HF: Billings, Bruce, Sinclair
F: Kent, Membrey, Parker
FOLL: Marshall, Steele, Gresham
I/C (from): Coffield, Dunstan, Acres, Clark, Phillips, Joyce, Young, Marsh
IN: Geary, Coffield, Clark, Joyce
OUT: Nil
POWER
B: Burton, Clurey, Houston
HB: Jonas, Howard, Byrne-Jones
C: Duursma, R. Gray, Amon
HF: Farrell, Westhoff, Motlop
F: S. Gray, Ryder, Rozee
FOLL: Lycett, Powell-Pepper, Boak
I/C (from): Lienert, Rockliff, Butters, Frampton, Bonner, Hartlett, Drew, Broadbent
IN: Burton, Lycett, Bonner, Hartlett, Drew
OUT: Ladhams
ESSENDON v CARLTON
Sunday 2 June, 3.20pm at the MCG
BOMBERS
B: Francis, Hooker, Hurley
HB: McKenna, Ambrose, Saad
C: Redman, Merrett, McDonald-Tipungwuti
HF: Zaharakis, Laverde, Begley
F: Parish, McKernan, McGrath
FOLL: Bellchambers, Langford, Heppell
I/C (from): McNiece, Guelfi, Clarke, Baguley, Ridley, Clarke, Brown, Mosquito
IN: Clarke, Baguley, Ridley, Clarke, Brown, Mosquito
OUT: Stringer, Shiel
BLUES
B: Marchbank, Casboult, Stocker
HB: Plowman, Weitering, Newman
C: Gibbons, Cripps, Cuningham
HF: Silvagni, McKay, Walsh
F: S. Petrevski-Seton, C. Curnow, Fisher
FOLL: Kreuzer, Kennedy, E. Curnow
I/C (from): Garlett, Kerr, Schumacher, Polson, Fasolo, Lang, Dow, Setterfield
IN: Garlett, Kerr, Schumacher, Polson, Fasolo, Lang, Setterfield
OUT: Simpson, Thomas, McGovern
WEST COAST EAGLES v WESTERN BULLDOGS
Sunday 2 July, 5.20pm at Optus Stadium
EAGLES
B: Hurn, Schofield, Duggan
HB: Sheppard, McGovern, Jetta
C: Cripps, Shuey, Gaff
HF: Petruccelle, Darling, Sheed
F: Ryan, Kennedy, Rioli
FOLL: Vardy, Yeo, Redden
I/C (from): Waterman, Allen, Cole, Nelson, Ainsworth, Hutchings, Ah Chee, Smith
IN: Jetta, Ainsworth, Ah Chee, Smith
OUT: Nil
BULLDOGS
B: Johannisen, Trengove, Williams
HB: Daniel, Cordy, Wood
C: Hunter, Liberatore, Smith
HF: Suckling, Gardner, Lloyd
F: Bontempelli, Naughton, Gowers
FOLL: English, Dunkley, Macrae
I/C (from): Schache, West, McLean, Lipinski, Dickson, Dale, Smith, La. Young
IN: Gardner, Gowers, Schache, West, Dickson, Smith, La. Young
OUT: Crozier, Richards, Wallis
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Crouch should be in, Moore too.
Early news I’m hearing is that Williams will miss, Crouch SHOULD return & also for anyone who hasnt heard despite making the trip rocky is out
Crouch is doubtful
🙁
OUT Daniel Rioli Dylan Shiel Kade Simpson Mitch McGovern
IN Trent Cotchin
TU: O’Brien to Fort, Constable to Kelly (Josh)
TD: Scrimshaw to Hinge, Constable to Taranto
Or should I
TU: O’Brien to Fort, Scrimshaw to Hinge
TD: Upgrade at least one
Terrible year – worst on record – but I am doubling down.
Scrim —> hinge
Const —> Baker
| Zac Williams looks set to miss another week
Then Zac Williams looks set to become Whitfield. I’ve seen this GWS “one more week” hoodoo before.
No Hinge! I’ve been Josh Glenn’d! Brought him in last week over Young and felt like a genius lol.
Check the JS poll, you weren’t the only one
No Crouch, again. F**k it, should I just be done with him? He currently sits M6 in front of Walsh and Atkins.
I could swing Duursma into the midfield and trade Crouch to Houli, already going Moore to Ryan this week as well. That would finish of my defense with Hurn, Lloyd, Whitfield, Houli, Ryan and Hore at D6 for now.
Good idea or too impulsive?
On the fence with Houli GD
Could miss a game or two with injury
Jayden Short back in 4-5 weeks which could impact his scoring back end of season.
Liard, Stewart & Sicily all in the same price bracket.
In the flip side I got every call wrong this season with the Richmond rookies
Tough call
A good point, Bryson- one I’ve also considered.
Problem is there is only a tiny sample size for me to consider Short’s impact on Houli as they’ve only played in one game together this year: R1, Houli scored 112 off 24 touches.
Last three weeks he’s gone 106, 102 and 142 off 30, 35 and 37 disposals respectively.
Now, is that form or Short’s absence that’s leading to him getting so much of the ball?
Probably both. I think Short’s return will have an impact on the amount of disposals Houli gets, as Short’s usually the looser of the two. Unsure of how much that will hamper his scoring by, still playing a nice half-back role.
That said, Stewart is a no go for me bc of the R13 bye. Not liking Laird either, Smith stealing his thunder and Sicily hasn’t shown the ceiling nor consistency from last year.
Ty though, Bryson. Will let it percolate.
Who to downgrade to instead of Hinge??
O.baker?
good idea
(Only have 137k available)
O Baker is $123K.
Who to field? Baker or Gibbons (Oskar)
Bewley
Bewley had a low score because he had an injury which resulted in low game time, however with more game time he will get higher scores.
I reckon it’s worth going a week early on him
After Young last week, Im never going a 1 gamer again…
NO! Refer Josh Glenn rule … also to be known as R Young rule!!
Got the bye next week. Better to wait 2 weeks and get him if selected then.
Constable not even an emergency.
Because he’s injured. Listed as groin TBC.
What do people think of his chances of getting back before the bye? He misses this week, I would think he will get rested through the bye and they’ll re-evaluate then (he’s a younger guy, don’t want to overload first season).
TU: he’ll be back post-byes (if at all)
TD: he’ll slot in next week
what to do with m.crouch?
TU – Hold
TD – Trade
I’ve got him also. Only reason I’m holding is because I’ve held for this long, no point wasting that by trading him now. Hopefully back next week I assume?
Yeah that’s true. will probs hold.
Problem is they’ll ease him back in. His TOG has been sub par for an elite mid this year and coming back from an injury won’t help that…
Sunken cost fallacy.
Trade crouch straight to Taranto
Tu:yes
Tu:no
Another doughnut sitting in the mid thanks to, Crouch, Constable, Hately and Scott. Crouch or Constable looking to make way.
3 rookies playing this weekend, so far. Baker, Bewley and Gardner. Rule out Gardner due to 0 games, Bewley only played 1 but Baker with thin JS. Constable downgrade adds 200k to the bank.
Other hand Crouch could be traded to the likes of Fyfe, Bont, Sloane. However no strong confidence on durability.
Cover doughnut by
TU Crouch -> Premo
TD Constable -> Downgrade and plenty of cash for the byes
TU Baker
TD Bewley
I liked the look of Bewley and think he has much more upside and likely JS especially since Baker will likely be replaced by one of Lever or May in the next couple of weeks.
Seriously considering…
Had enough of Brayshaws scoring… unsure on Williams return, Whitfield & Boak set & forget…
Z Williams & A Brayshaw
To
L Whitfield & T Boak
TU OR TD
Feel free give me a reason why I shouldn’t do it ! Thanks all! Goodluck!
Harry – He doesn’t play as a tall back
Need to make a downgrade to ensure I get Lloyd this week:
T/u – Oskar Baker
T/d – Begley
Baker’s got the potential to score better, Begley’s got the JS.
Up to you.
Sick of this Adelaide BS! How can a player be ‘close’ to playing 3 weeks in a row?!?!?
Pack of rats toss bags!
Is Gardner straight into the Bulldogs side worth a punt? Not even on the interchange. They must be impressed.
Immediate entry into the side means a) they rate him, b) he’s going to be playing a much needed role and c) his JS should be solid.
Wait a week though. See if it all goes smoothly. After that, I wouldn’t see a problem going early.
What else could go wrong and taking the punt on Gardner for my wife’s team along with J Cameron for Scrimshaw and Petrucelle.
wait and watch him for 2 games.
don’t thinks it’s worth the risk going early on him.
What ever he scores has to be better than looking down the barrel at a Big Fat Zero. …So sick of S’Field sitting in the Fwd line like a Shag on a rock !
TU yeh take the punt
Td Nah, You’re off yr rocker
Thanx All
Arrrgggg what the f is Kade Simpson doing in my team. 90+ average for 10 seasons straight and 2x 105+ when Docherty was not in the picture. Picked him over Hurn who was $50k cheaper. By far my worst starting selection and hold this year.
Ooof! AND you’ve held him all this time?!
My condolences, bambam.
Yes sticking with my premos this year has mostly paid off…
Who to trade in as a downgrade:
T/U – O. Baker
T/D – Begley
Not to be burnt on another rookie must be the focus coming into the byes or for that matter anytime.
Why were the good rookies mentioned early doors, because they are good rookies ffs
Why do we take a punt on average rookies ? because we are stupid.
Bewley had wraps early and gee wizz im going early.
Surely ,straight in the side and showed plenty last week .
As the father says triple money back , im sayin great gamble.
Bewley will be available after his bye at the same price. Im waiting.
cash gen
What do you sick dogs rekon
TU
Rockliff to J Kelly
Gibbons to Bewely
TD
Petruccelle to J Cameron
Gibbons to Bewely
Feel like Rockliff will keep being “1 week away” for the next couple weeks so is tempting to say good riddance to the bastard and get Kelly, as this week is really the only week I can get him in before he pushes 700k.
However I feel like upgrading pettrucelle to Cameron is more responsible (would go Dunkley or boak but can’t afford) but don’t really trust Cameron.
If Darragh Joyce from the Saints is selected, should I trade Wilkie out for him?
T/up – Yes
T/down – No
Very doubtful he will get a game based on how he played in the 2s last week.
Why have they taken him mate? Is Geary likely a late out (not ready) with Paton still being managed. I’m surprised we’re going tall against PTA. Strange selection to me.
*PLEASE READ*
I’m doing a Comp with my brother and whoever ends up on more total points at the end of year gets $100 from the other one. He’s starting to get away from me and maybe like 200-300 points ahead and I need to make a move so I think getting josh kelly in is crucial even if I don’t get him from upgrading a rookie.
I have Rockliff and Crouch and they both sitting on bench so I feel like on of em gotta go.
TU
Rockliff to Kelly
TD
M Crouch to Kelly
Reply for other options. Opinion appreciated 🙂
Hinge being out has cucked me with my trades. Wanting to upgrade Constable to Duncan but I’m unable to if I can’t find a suitable downgrade from Wilkie. Any options lads?
Could go super early on Gardner making his debut for the doggies?
Good Dpp status aswell – Fwd/Def
Wanting cash for the next few rounds. Looking at trading out R O’Brien & Constable. ROB will only be helpful for 1/3 bye rounds (& that’s if he keeps his spot once Jacobs returns) whereas replacing him with a premium Mid or Fwd (that doesn’t have the R13 bye), helps out for 2/3 weeks.
So, Trade out – ROB & Constable & Trade in –
TU: Sweet & J Cameron $190k left
TD: Sweet & Sloane $75k leftover
Think I may hold fire this week as I don’t see anything that will make my team better short- or long-term that would not be better to do over the byes. I am going to need some downgrade targets pre-byes and I am going to have to target some budget options post-byes if I am to get to full premo (otherwise, I don’t see where the cash will come from).
17 trades left, 169k in the bank
D – Hurn / Whitfield / Sicily / Laird / Rozee / Hore // Answerth / Quaynor
M – Macrae / Neale / Cripps / Yeo / Sloane / Walsh / Stack / Duursma // Hayes / Constable / ScottB
R – Gawn / Grundy // ClarkeZ
F – Kelly / Dangerfield / Heeney / Dunkley / Parker / Corbett // Young / Cavarra
Young STK and Setterfield CAR are both named to play Sunday 🙂
No Drew 🙁
Hey AS any chance you could post those Sunday changes or point a non-HS subscriber where to find them?
Cheers!
ST KILDA v PORT ADELAIDE
Sunday 2 June, 2:20pm at Adelaide Arena at Jiangwan Stadium
SAINTS
B: McKenzie, Brown, Savage
HB: Wilkie, Battle, Geary
C: Long, Ross, Newnes
HF: Billings, Bruce, Sinclair
F: Kent, Membrey, Parker
FOLL: Marshall, Steele, Gresham
I/C: Dunstan, Phillips, Young, Marsh
EMG: Coffield, Clark, Joyce, White
IN: Geary
OUT: Acres
POWER
B: Burton, Clurey, Houston
HB: Jonas, Howard, Byrne-Jones
C: Duursma, R. Gray, Amon
HF: Farrell, Westhoff, Motlop
F: S. Gray, Ryder, Rozee
FOLL: Lycett, Powell-Pepper, Boak
I/C: Lienert, Butters, Frampton, Bonner, Broadbent
EMG: Frampton, Hartlett, Drew, Rockliff
IN: Burton, Lycett, Bonner
OUT: Ladhams, Frampton, Rockliff
ESSENDON v CARLTON
Sunday 2 June, 3.20pm at the MCG
BOMBERS
B: Francis, Hooker, Hurley
HB: McKenna, Ambrose, Saad
C: Redman, Merrett, McDonald-Tipungwuti
HF: Zaharakis, Laverde, Begley
F: Parish, McKernan, McGrath
FOLL: Bellchambers, Langford, Heppell
I/C: McNiece, Guelfi, D. Clarke, Baguley
EMG: Ridley, Z. Clarke, Brown, Mosqutio
IN: D. Clarke, Baguley
OUT: Stringer, Shiel
BLUES
B: Marchbank, Casboult, Stocker
HB: Plowman, Weitering, Newman
C: Gibbons, Cripps, Cuningham
HF: Silvagni, McKay, Walsh
F: S. Petrevski-Seton, C. Curnow, Fisher
FOLL: Kreutzer, Kennedy, E. Curnow
I/C: Fasolo, Lang, Dow, Setterfield
EMG: Garlett, Kerr, Schumacher, Polson
IN: Fasolo, Lang, Setterfield
OUT: Simpson, Thomas, McGovern
WEST COAST EAGLES v WESTERN BULLDOGS
Sunday 2 July, 5.20pm at Optus Stadium
EAGLES
B: Hurn, Schofield, Duggan
HB: Sheppard, McGovern, Jetta
C: Cripps, Shuey, Gaff
HF: Petruccelle, Darling, Sheed
F: Ryan, Kennedy, Rioli
FOLL: Vardy, Yeo, Redden
I/C: Waterman, O. Allen, Cole, Hutchings
EMG: Nelson, Ainsworth, Ah Chee, Smith
IN: Jetta
OUT: Nelson
BULLDOGS
B: Johannisen, Trengove, Williams
HB: Daniel, Cordy, Wood
C: Hunter, Liberatore, Smith
HF: Suckling, Gardner, Lloyd
F: Bontempelli, Naughton, Gowers
FOLL: English, Dunkley, Macrae
I/C: McLean, Lipinski, Dale, La. Young
EMG: Schache, West, Dickson, Smith
IN: Gardner, Gowers, La. Young
OUT: Crozier, Richards, Wallis
I can not post the ins and outs for Sunday teams, only the full teams. I have been having this problem for a month now.
Full teams is great cheers mate!