12 thoughts on “Brownlow Chat”

  1. Can someone explain 3 votes here for Neale?
    Coaches votes for Lions v GWS, round 6:
    Cameron 10
    Kelly 7
    Payne 4
    Rich 3
    Coniglio 2
    Haynes 2
    Starcevich 1
    Daniels 1

    Votes: 3 Neale 2 Cameron 1 Rich

    5

    0
    1. Umps have no idea.
      I genuinely think if they want this medal to not drift to irrelevance they need to take it off them.

      3

      0
    2. You can’t compare coaches votes to umpires votes Nato.

      ie roles and expectations v actual presentation of skills and duties

      1

      0
      1. There is a corps that want the coaches to select the winner, last people who should do it imho.
        Journos can’t get out of the way of their own narratives. Leave it where it is, accept that it’s not an award for the whole year. 10/12 great games is enough to win the medal! Neale drove his owners nuts in terms of s/c this year, most notably GD and I admit to having bought him in for Clarry. But it should never be confused with the fact that for 18 games he was great and in a dozen of those he was amazing! Note to self,the umpires like Will Ashcroft.

        0

        0
    1. Atrocious count. Nothing against Neale but he was objectively just not the best player in the competition. Bont and Racca hard done by at the top end and then just some absolute memes like Dunkley with FOUR votes lmao.

      What a joke.

      Tabulating comp results now, all.

      3

      1
      1. I agree about Bont GD! Think it’s the fact that he looks like the big kid dominating in underage,so the umps think it’s not fair to vote him properly??

        0

        0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *