We’ve of course got Trade Talk up for this week but thought we’d get a Fix My Team thread for those who feel their side is in need of a wholesale rework. If you feel you’re in that category, go ahead and post your full team and ITB and any areas, issues or pain-points that you need of shot of SCT guidance injected into.
5
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Def: Docherty, Ridley, Jones, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
Mid: Laird, Bont, Macrae, Green, Hopper, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Baker, Chesser, Davey)
Ruck: Darcy, Marshall (Madden)
Fwd: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Gulden, Bruhn, Sheezel (Ratogolea, Greene)
36 trades left and 60k bank
Looking at my current side there are a fair few names who id like to bring in and also trade out. One trade I have already locked in is Bruhn to Ziebell, leaving me with 2 more trades to make. From those two trades id like to bring 2 of Daicos, Setterfield, English, Worpel, Chandler with possible trade outs being Macrae, Jones, Ridley, Ratogolea, Darcy, Callaghan and Chesser.
Feedback on which two I should trade in and which two I should trade out would be appreciated!
Hi Jordy,
I’d be making Daicos a priority and I think the only way to get that move done is by moving on ridley so you could nearly pencil that one in.
All easy fixes, Jordy.
Bruhn -> Ziebell
Docherty -> Daicos
Cally -> Setterfield
Or, if you do want to bin Ridley and are happy to pass on Setters just go Riddles for Daicos and Bruhn for Ziebell like Mav suggested.
I really don’t get trading Docherty. He had one bad game and have we already forgotten Laird?
DEF: Doch Dawson Ridley Cole Ginbey Constable (Wilmot cowan)
MID: Bont Jelly Green Setters Hopper Callaghan Ashcroft Mackenzie (chesser bytel baker)
RUCK: Marshall Darcy (madden)
FWD: Dunks Rozee Taranto Guldeb Ziebell Sheezel (Greene Davey)
BANK: $47,900
Got a few moves in the pipeline just not sure which 3 of the 4 I actually follow through with.
DARCY->DCAM
RIDLEY-> DAICOS
JELLY-> LDU
CHESSER->CHANDLER
HOPPER-> ??
Starting to kick myself for not starting LDU so bit of a desperate move trading Jelly but has that concussion and injury history lingering but do believe he goes 110 avg over the year just not sure how many matches he plays.
Darcy is a migraine he’s well beyond a headache.. he looked just as bad round 1 for 3 quarters before going HUGE to salvage a 90.
Chesser->chandler purely cash generation
News fresh out of tigerland that Hopper may miss weeks with that knee if so he may go down to worpel or hold 1 week and have another look at Bowes..
Reckon Darcy to Cameron and Chesser to Chandler are great moves. I’ve only seen Hopper being doubtful this week but if he’s really out long term then you could certainly use the boost on him. Trading Kelly the week he could be coming back rather than last week if you had the doubts seems a bit late so Ridley to Daicos would probably be better in my opinion if you end up holding Hopper.
Any HELP greatly appreciated – I have done no trades to date so happy to use a boost this week. Should have pulled the trigger on one in R2, to give me some cash for R3.
DEF : Sicily, Docherty, L Jones, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
MID: Oliver, Bont, Neale, Green, Hopper, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Baker, Davey, Chesser)
RUCK : S Darcy, Marshall (Madden)
FWD : Dunkley, Rozee,Taranto, Gulden, Flanders, Sheezel (F Greene, N Long)
Mission – to get N Daicos. Going light on in the backline has hurt.
Problem – only $13,200 ITB.
Neale bleeding $32,400 this week hurts, but the premiums more often than not lose money initially.
Had thought of the following :
OUT : Darcy, Flanders & Callaghan (any update on his shoulder?)
IN : Daicos, D Cameron & Caminiti (with $4,900 left in the bank so can’t afford Chandler)
OR
OUT : Darcy, Flanders & Hopper (injury concern?)
IN : Daicos, D Cameron & O Hollands / Phillipou (with about $30,000 left)
Any other suggestions would be more than welcome!
Darcy and flanders are must trades, then id say the third one to consider is chesser, greene, Callaghan, hopper (if injured) or liam jones in the order. Out of those, whichever combo helps you get daicos, Cameron and one of phillipou, Chandler, long or Hollands, go for that. Caminiti will score very high and low so not the best option if you can avoid
Have you considered this Lisa?
Darcy, Neale, Flanders out
Ginbey to the Mids
Davey to the forward line
Daicos, Cameron & Setterfield in.
Adds $178K to the kitty
Funnily enough, I had penciled in trading out Neale but talked myself out of it after seeing what happened after so many coaches traded out Laird after one bad score. I think next season I will perhaps avoid the highest price premiums at Round 1 & keep $250,ooo in the bank, ready for round 3. Strongly considering this idea – can always target Neale (or Laird) later in the season, or aim for when they have dropped to their lowest price cycle.
Cheers Domicile!
Just checked on the TRADE ASSIST function (as I am a Herald Sun customer) and it has suggested the following :
OUT : Callaghan, Doc & Neale
IN : Setterfield, Daicos & LDU, with $128,900 remaining.
Obviously so much of the decision making this week will hinge on injuries to Hopper & Callaghan
Still reckon you’ve got more important players to cut than Docherty and Neale who you might want to bring back in anyway. I’d agree with Joe that Flanders and Darcy have to go. Personally I think Chesser does to cause he’s not making cash putting out 20s but Callaghan definitely makes sense as a trade out of injured
Lisa,
I just tried the trade assist using SC gold (free trial until tomorrow!), and it recommended almost identical trades (I have Macrae, not Neale – which was the only difference).
Consider doing Darcy, Flanders & hopper to Daicos, Cameron & chandler? Leaves you with $60 K
And also think of phillipou scored 59 on the weekend even tho he kicked 3 snags he doesn’t kick those snags and his score will be lower, whereas chandler has had 2 70+ scores and only kicked 1 goal a game so isn’t as reliant on goals. I’d also look at scoring potential between Callaghan & hopper sucks tho cause both seem to be injured in some capacity
Yes Twitch – I have gone cold on the trading of Neale of Doc. Not even 100% sure of trading Darcy but leaning that way, as he can’t be trusted. Flanders is gone, and most likely Callaghan or Hopper – depending in teams lists and injuries. Chandler I’m worried about his JS.
DEF: Doch, Ridley, Jones, Ginbey, Mckenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
MID: Laird, Bont, Steele, Green, setterfield, NWM, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (chesser, baker, davey)
RUCK: Darcy, Marshall (madden)
FWD: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Gulden, Sheezel, Phillipou (chandler, greene)
158k itb
Pretty poor start to season so far. Missing too many top players – Daicos, LDU, Coniglio, English, DCAM, Ziebell, Worpel. Want to get three of those guys in.
Steele obviously has to go, not sure if I want to trade Darcy, he has been awful so far, but thinking that Freo will realise they have to play him Ruck and he has an easy game this week. Really stuck on what to do.
Some help would be greatly appreciated.
King,
how about Darcy, Ridley & Steel >> Cameron, Daicos & LDU plus $145k
Gets you 3 of the ones you want, fixes 2 problems and gives you $303k in the bank for next week.
Ridley -> Daicos
Steele -> LDU
NWM -> Ziebell (via Phillipou DPP)
Def: Docherty, Sicily, Daicos, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
Mid: Laird, Bont, Oliver, Green, Phillips, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Baker, Chesser, Davey)
Ruck: Gawn, Marshall (Madden)
Fwd: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Flanders, King, Sheezel (Phillipou, Greene)
so…gawn to Cameron, phillips to setterfield, chesser to chandler
Thoughts
Yep. That sounds good, Paul.
Any idea on Sampson Ryan JS?
Did himself with 3 goals but don’t think he’ll be a massive money maker or one you’d want to field.
Also not on the bubble yet, wouldn’t go early.
The downside of changing you side a thousand time before the start of the season is that you usually were rocking some of the guys who are tearing it up.
DEF: Docherty, Cumming, Campbell, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
MID: Oliver, Bontempelli, Anderson, Green, Warner, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Baker (Chesser, McKenzie, Davey)
RUC: Darcy, Marshall (Madden)
FWD: Dunkley, Moore, Rozee, Gulden, Flanders, Phillipou (Greene, Caminiti)
7K ITB
Gut feel is to go Flanders t0 Sheezel (or Chandler) and Cumming to Daicos.
Hey, Maaz.
Yeah, I started Cumming as well. Think we move him to Daicos pretty easily.
Then, yep, you absolutely need Sheezel.
Cumming -> Daicos
Flanders -> Sheezel
Darcy -> Tingles (or D. Cameron if you really want a bank)
Here it is before I screw it up even more:
DEF Sicily, Doc, Ridley, Ginbey, McKenna, Wilmot (Cowan/Chesser)
MID: Neale, Bont, Macrae, Greene, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Constable (Baker, Sinn, Gilbee).
RUCK: Witts, Marshall (Madden).
FWD: Dunkley, Coniglio, Taranto, Gulden, Sheezel, Phillipou (Davey, Greene).
After an earlier post about who to trade Macrae for (Setterfield or LDU), I’ve settled down a bit and reconsidered the wisdom of knee-jerk trades; while I’d love one of those two, I need to learn from my impulsive trades last week where I burned a boost and traded:
1) Laird for McKenna (yup, I said I knew he was a keeper but thought I was getting two premos for the price of one with this ‘clever’ deal).
2) Jones for Ridley (a sketchy gamble at best… his role, as has been dissected on this fine website, doesn’t look like it will be what I hoped for in my glass half full/bottle half empty decision).
3) Fyfe to Coniglio (vindicated).
I assume Laird will continue to fall in price and will be back in at some point if I trade smarter from now on. Macrae has to be worth another shot and I have to accept that I’m not going to get everyone I want. Bye bye Setts and LDU…
So, I figure:
1) Ridley to Daicos (I had the bloody option last week!) is a lock.
2) Sinn to Chandler looks the best rookie swap.
I’d like to go RoMo to Cameron (and make some coin too) but figure it isn’t absolutely necessary. It may be smarter to hold the boost or focus on switching an under-performing rookie (Greene/Chesser) for someone with better cash gen like Long (who I could bench for Phillipou).
Not sure… The lure of Cameron’s looming price rise and the fact he is seemingly going to continue to rack it up despite Cox is strong…
Honestly that rd1 trade doesn’t look so bad if you pick Daicos over ridley.
Also it’s more like Laird > Cogs which is a justifiable trade, Jones > McKenna which is a good trade and Fyfe > premium which would be a good trade if you picked a better premium.
Your Biggest Premium issues seem to be Macrae and Ridley. So
Macrae > Cameron (as a fwd)
Ridley (or Doc) to Daicos
Worst rookie to Setterfield/Worpel
Thanks! That’s certainly worth considering. This is exactly why this forum is so bloody useful – there’s always someone who sees something I can’t.
Cheers, JSG.
Couldn’t edit my post so I’ll reply again:
It would have to be Neale that goes, if I’m to free up the extra $20,000 I need. With Brisbane, Richmond, Port, Freo, Hawks, GWS in the next stretch, he looks OK if the role improves.
Neale has Dogs, Pies, North, GWS, Freo, Blues, so I’d say Macrae has the edge if Bevo doesn’t screw me…
How about Ridley Macrae & Sinn to Daicos Setterfield & Worpel. Those 3 seem more like must haves over DCam who gains value if fixing a Gawn/Darcy problem.
You don’t want to lose keeper in trades and that trade does -1 keeper.
Docherty, Dawson, daicos, Ginbey, McKenna, constable (Cowan, wilmont)
Oliver, bont, green, hopper, worpel, callaghan, ashcroft, mackenzie
(Baker, chesser, Davey)
Witts, Marshall (madden)
Dunkley, coniglio, rozee, taranto, sheezel, philipou (ratugolea, greene)
$31,500 ITB.
Thinking: Ratugolea > Chandler
Really want to get ziebell in this week, although looks like I will need to use a trade boost to make that happen.
Thoughts appreciated!!
Option 1)
Ratugolea > Chandler
Hopper > Ziebell (if hopper is out injured)
(Can always bring in hopper next week for Callaghan if need be as silly as it sounds. I will also get the Callaghan price rise)
Option 2)
Ratugolea > Chandler
Callaghan > Ziebell
Rozee > Gulden (3rd trade needs to happen to free up funds for ziebell move)
Option 3)
Ratugolea > Chandler
& Sit tight on trades and only use the 1.
Any other suggestions appreciated!
Really looking to land ziebell in my side as I believe he will be a keeper.
I’d really try to hold Rozee. Hasn’t done anything wrong and isn’t worth trading just for $40k so maybe option 1 cause Hopper is unlikely to be a keeper so if you think Ziebell is likely then you could do that
OUT-Gawn, Richards(Bevo strikes again), Powell(took a shot and missed).
IN- Cameron(real deal), LDU(top 4 on potential), Ziebell(likely keeper FWD or DEF).
Love it, TOF. Do it.
I’ll post my team since I didn’t really do research and only picked during tigers V blues game
Def: Daicos, Cumming, Clark, ginbey, McKenna,Constable (Wilmot, Uwland)
Mids: Neale, Petracca, BCrouch, Warner, Holmes, Callaghan, Ashcroft, McKenzie (baker, Chesser, Davey)
Rucks: Mcinerney, Draper (McAndrews)
Fwds: Dunkley, Cogs, Rozee, JHF, Sheezel, Phillipou (F Greene, Long)
$399K in the bank thanks to doing JKelly to McKenna last week also did Fyfe to JHF last week
Twitch, the rucks were obvious but I had a hard time finding a third because I could only seem to find sideways trades. Eventually hit upon one that I think made sense rather than just seeming like shifting deck chairs.
McInerney , Draper & Crouch >> Cameron, Marshall & LDU
Mcinerney I will probably keep and see how he goes and maybe wait for a Gawn type to bottom out crouch I will keep my third trade I could consider doing Callaghan to LDU
Draper & Callaghan to Marshall and LDU is great if you can pull it off.
Don’t have enough to get Marshall can only get Cameron if I pull the trigger on Callaghan to LDU
Cameron is still a good choice too. I’ve got both so either is good.
Doc, Dawson, Ridley, Ginbey, Mckenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
Laird, Bont, Green, Hopper, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Callaghan, Phillipou (Long, Baker, Chesser)
Marshall, Witts (Madden)
Cogs, Dunks, Rozee, Taranto, Fyfe, Sheezel (Davey, Greene)
78k left
Planning to go Fyfe into Ziebell, Chesser to Chandler and then potentially Ridley into Fyfe. Be interested to know if anyone has any better ideas. Cheers
Doc, Dawson, Ridley, Ginbey, Mckenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
Laird, Bont, Green, Hopper, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Callaghan, Phillipou (Long, Baker, Chesser)
Marshall, Witts (Madden)
Cogs, Dunks, Rozee, Taranto, Fyfe, Sheezel (Davey, Greene)
78k left
Planning to go Fyfe into Ziebell, Chesser to Chandler and then potentially Ridley into Daicos. Be interested to know if anyone has any better ideas. Cheers
Reckon you’ve nailed the first two. Pending fitness, Hopper to Setterfield could be worth a shout for that third trade
DEF: Sicily, Docherty, Jones, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (wilmot, Cowan)
MID: Laird, Neale, Bont, Green, Hopper, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Davey, chesser, baker)
RUCK: S. Darcy, Marshal (Madden)
FWD: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Gulden, Sheezel, Phillipou (Greene, Caminti)
Really trying to get daicos in but struggling to find a way. Open to any other suggestions of other players I should be targeting. Have 113k in the bank after downgrading Flanders to phillipou last week
Thanks!
Darcy to Cameron , hopper to daicos
Dracy to Cameron, + Jones to Daicos should work.
60k short
Darcy to Cameron and Callaghan to either Setterfield or Ziebell perhaps? If Hopper’s out you can bring both in
Def: Docherty, Ridley, Rampe, Ginbey, Wilmot, Constable (Chesser, Cowan)
Mid: Laird, Neale, Bont, Green, Hopper, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Phililps, Baker, Davey)
Ruck: Darcy, Marshall (Madden)
Forwards: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Fyfe, Bruhn, Sheezel, (Ratugolea, Greene)
Looking to get rid of Fyfe and Bruhn mainly
Wanting to get in Daicos, Gulden, and McKenna or Chandler
I’m thinking:
Fyfe –> Gulden
Ridley –> Daicos
Bruhn –> Chandler
Let me know what you guys think.
Rampe, Fyfe, Bruhn >
Daicos, Ziebell, Chandler
Needs $28k in the bank but Rampe is not a keeper.
Might not be a keeper but with a break even of -45, Rampe needs to be kept at least for this week
DEF
S. Docherty, J. Dawson, J. Ridley, R. Ginbey, D. Wilmot, C. Constable (C. Chesser, L. Cowan)
MID
C. Oliver, M. Bontempelli, A. Brayshaw, T. Green, J. Hopper, W. Ashcroft, C. Mackenzie, O. Hollands (O. Baker, A. Davey, N. Long)
RUC
T. Nankervis, R. Marshall (N. Madden)
FWD
J. Dunkley, S. Coniglio, C. Rozee, T. Taranto, H. Sheezel, M. Phillipou (F. Greene, A. Caminiti)
$900 Remaining Salary
Haven’t used any trades yet. Hating the fact I went Ridley over Daicos in the hours leading up to Round 1.
Tossing up between 3 options at the moment.
Option 1
Ridley > Daicos
Option 2
Ridley > Daicos
Greene > Chandler
Option 3
Docherty > Daicos
Chesser > McKenna
Greene > Chandler
Would appreciate any feedback or suggestions for my team!
I lean option 2 here but it’s the first one I’ve seen where I’d really consider getting rid of Docherty
I want to get in Daicos and Sheezel for Fyfe and Hopper if Hopper is going to be out for a couple of weeks.
To do this I have to trade Macrae to LDU but I’m not sure if that would be a good long term move given Macrae’s consistency over a number of years.
T/U Keep Macrae
T/D Get LDU while he is cheap
I’d get it done and bite the bullet! Bevo seems to be playing macrae out of position
Hi all, would appreciate any help in fixing my team. $129k ITB.
Def: Doch, Ridley, Jones, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
Mids: Neale, Bont, Steele, Green, Setters, Hopper, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Baker, Chesser, Davey)
Rucks: Darcy, RoMo (Madden)
Fwds: Dunks, Rozee, Taranto, Ziebell, Brunh, Sheezel (Rat, Greene)
Steele, Darcy and Bruhn to LDU, Cameron and Daicos will really help your scoring
Agree with johnno
Cheers for the feedback Johnno.
I was thinking that but the other option was Steele, Brunh, Ridley OUT Daicos LDU and Gulden IN. I think Darcy can bounce back. Which do you prefer?
TU: Steele, Darcy and Bruhn to LDU, Cameron and Daicos
TD: Steele, Brunh, Ridley to Daicos LDU and Gulden
Cheers for the feedback Johnno and Twitch.
I was thinking that but the other option was Steele, Brunh, Ridley OUT Daicos LDU and Gulden IN. I think Darcy can bounce back. Which do you prefer?
TU: Steele, Darcy and Bruhn to LDU, Cameron and Daicos
TD: Steele, Brunh, Ridley to Daicos LDU and Gulden
Basically which do you think will improve your team more Darcy to Cameron or Ridley to gulden
What would you do?
Darcy to Cameron means I would have Rat/Davey as F6 keep in mind
Who’s on field I’m defence with the other pick.
Honestly not sure Darcy seems to be struggling with the addition of Jackson and Cameron looks decent but then again gulden looks pretty good and seems to be play midfield having CBA
I’d priotise Darcy tho as I think you would make more money off it and Ridley didn’t score too badly
If you believe in Darcy, then hold firm. We picked our promos for a reason. Ridley is just going to tank every time he has to be an accountable defender which looks like it’ll happen more often than we would’ve liked.
B: Dawson, Doc, Ridley, Jones, Ginbey, McKenna, int Willmott, Cowan
M: Laird, Miller, Bont, T. Green, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Constable int Hollands, Baker, Davey
R: Marshall, Cameron int Madden
F: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Gulden, Sheezel, Phillipou int F. Greene, Caminiti
I want to get N. Daicos in and LDU
I will just post this because I am genuinely curious as to what thoughts you all have to offer:
After three trades I have $127,500k in the bank:
Docherty to B.Cox
Oliver to LDU
Callaghan (DPP) to Darcy Cameron
My team currently stands at:
DEF: Lloyd, McGrath, B.Cox, J.Bowes, L.Jones, Ginbey | Constable, Cowan
MID: LDU, Green, De Goey, Setterfield, Hopper, Worpel, Ashcroft, Mackenzie | L.Henry, O.Baker, C.Chesser
RUC: Witts, Marshall | McAndrew
FWD: Dunkley, Coniglio, Taranto, D.Cameron, Ziebell, Sheezel | F.Greene, Madden
My deliberate strategy at the beginning of the season was mid-price breakouts with super rookies and value premiums.
Rd 1 I scored 2,051 in the Top 10% Top 16,053rd
After Rd 2 I am Top 2% Ranked 3,352nd – I scored 2,305 points.
Should I change the trades I have made?
Going against Daicos and Oliver given Melbournes run before you can get him in is very brave. Especially with every top coach rushing to get them
A safer move would be Doc to Daicos, Jones to McKenna,
Then see how much money you have. If you can bring in a premium going up from calahan then do it otherwise just wait a week and fix one of your cheap rookies. Calahan won’t lose money if he’s not playing
In that case I’ll just take your safe trades which left me with around 220k. I downgraded callaghan to chandler via dpp of liam henry.
I now have $330,600 in the bank to multiple upgrade when the prices go up. I feel hesitant on LDU because of the tags that will be coming. I have avoided all the carnage so far apart from jelly.
If what Richo is saying about hopper is true, I’ll just keep calli for one more if he’s not playing and upgrade hopper instead.
I feel like trading for Cameron is silly given you already have your 2 set & forget ruckman.
I would focus on getting Daicos & LDU in and then a high generating cash cow
Oliver to LDU seems a water trade I wouldn’t trade Oliver out unless injured
Could you do Callaghan and Jones to Daicos and Chandler? Hard to work out how much cash you have based on the wording
Def: doch, daicos, ginbey, McKenna, wilmot, Constable (Chesser, Cowan)
Mid: laird, Oliver, bont, green, hopper, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Hollands, baker, Davey)
Ruc: Darcy, Marshall (madden)
Fwd: Dunkley, rozee, taranto, gulden, Flanders, sheezel (ratugolea, Greene)
Unsure of what to do, but had thought about these two:
TU: Darcy, Flanders, Callaghan >>> Cameron, Chandler, LDU
TD: Darcy, Flanders, Callaghan >>> Cameron, ziebel, setterfield
Comment otherwise or thoughts. Cheers guys
Scers.
Gonna post cold as to not sway public opinion.
Interested in your thoughts playing for league.
Def: doc Dawson Ridley ginbey wilmot const
Chesser. Cowan.
Mids: Laird Oliver mcrae green hopper Callaghan Ashcroft McKenzie
Hollands Phillips baker
Rucks: Grundy Marshall – madden
Fwds: Dunkley cogs Toronto Flanders sheezel phillipou – Greene Davey
Salvageable? Pack it up? Let me know thanks guys.
Very salvageable.
McRae to LDU/Daicos or Titch or any premo in that range)
Callahan (if injured to setterfield)
Flanders to Ziebell or down to Rookie.
You won’t get everyone but you should get a good start and can fix a premo next week with $$$ if you keep them
Would love some advice on what changes I should make to this team, 35 trades left and 60k in bank
DEF: Brayshaw, Ridley, Ginbey, McKenna, Wilmot, Constable (Cowan, Chesser)
MID: Oliver, Miller, Macrae, LDU, Green, Hopper, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Phillipou, Hollands, Baker)
RUCK: Darcy, Cameron (Madden)
FWD: Dunkley, Rozie, Taranto, Gulden, Sheezel, Davey (Greene, Caminiti)
Honestly not sure there’s anything you absolutely have to do but Darcy to Marshall would net you some cash and Ridley to Daicos before his price increases
Yep. That.
Docherty, Dawson, daicos, Ginbey, McKenna, constable (Cowan, wilmont)
Oliver, bont, green, hopper, worpel, callaghan, ashcroft, mackenzie
(Baker, chesser, Davey)
Witts, Marshall (madden)
Dunkley, coniglio, rozee, taranto, sheezel, philipou (ratugolea, greene)
$31,500 ITB.
Thinking: Ratugolea > Chandler
Really want to get ziebell in this week, although looks like I will need to use a trade boost to make that happen.
Thoughts appreciated!
Hey, Olie.
Only way to get Ziebell would be:
Cally -> Long
Greene -> Caminiti
Rat -> Ziebell.
Greene/Caminiti is fine but the Cally move gives you some risk at M8 and overall you’d miss on Chandler. It’s up to you whether you want to make those all in trades to get Ziebell.
You could pass on Ziebell all together and freshen up your CG with Long and Chandler for Chesser and Rat (as well as Green/Caminiti). Personally, that’s what I’d do. Your premiums and structure are solid.
Setters also on option, if you went:
Rat -> Chandler
Greene -> Caminiti
Cally -> Setters
Does leave you with Chesser however.
Gotta question whether 3 trades is worth it to end up with 2 rookies and a midpricer. Basically triple sideways.
DEF: Doc, Dawson, Jones, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (Cowan, Wimot)
MID: Oliver, Bont, Brayshaw, Greene, Rozee, Taranto, Hopper, Ashcroft (Mackenzie, Baker, Chesser)
Witts, Marshall (Madden)
Dunkley, D.Cameron, Bruhn, Allen, Daniels, Bruce (Greene, Davey Jr)
Moved Rozee and Taranto into the mids last week so Bruce and Daniels could play (Seen what defenders can do against the saints and thought Giants would continue on from last week)
First move is easy going Bruhn – Sheezel
Don’t know what else I can do unless I move Davey Jr to MIDs and trade Chesser – Chandler, unsure of his JS though?
DEF: Docherty, Ridley, Jones, Ginbey, Mckenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
MID: Laird, Steele, LDU, Green, Hooper, Callaghan, Ashcrost, Mackenzie (Baker, Cheeser, Davey)
RUC: Darcy, Marshall (Madden)
FWD: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Gulden, Ziebell, Braun (Phillipou, Greene)
TU:
Steele – Setterfield
Braun – Sheezel
Chesser – Daicos via Constable to mid
11,400K ITB
Roll the dice on Darcy going big against WC – Either way straight swap to Cameron next week.
TD:
Darcy – Cameron
Steele – Daicos via Constable to mid
Cheeser – Sheezal via phillipou to mid
144,500 ITB
Hold Braun for another week – shouldn’t bleed much coin.
Miss Setterfield and fielding Constable in the mids
No trades used so far – so happy to burn 3 this week.
In a bit of a hole with a few players that really shouldn’t be here…. and now the Hopper potential injury just makes things worse.
Current team – Bank $104,500
Def:
Sicily, Doch, Jones, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
Mids:
Laird, Oliver, Bont, Green, Hopper, Flanders, Ashcroft, MacKenzie (Philipou, Baker, Chesser)
Rucks:
Gawn, Marshall (Madden)
Forwards:
Dunkley, Rose, Taranto, Fyfe, Sheezel, Davey (Rat, Greene)
Current plan (assuming Hopper is OK or will only miss 1) is:
Gawn -> Cameron
Flanders -> Daicos via DPP
Fyfe -> Chandler
Leaving a fair chunk of cash for next week!
Is this really the best I can do….?
Thanks!!!
DEF: Docherty, Dawson, Ridley, Ginbey, Mckenna, Constable (Wilmot, Cowan)
MID: Laird, Bont, Green, Hooper, Callaghan, Flanders, Ashcrost, Mackenzie (Baker, Cheeser, Davey)
RUC: Darcy, Marshall (Rat)
FWD: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Gulden,bruhn, sheezel (Phillipou, Greene)
35 trades left 47.7k in the bank.
Was planning on going
Out- bruhn Flanders and Callahan
In- setterfield ziebell and chandler
Means I won’t have daicos this week
Yeah, as long as you can figure out a way to get Daicos the following week then those trades are great.
He will be a minimum of 550k next week though.
Yeah will have to be next week just think ziebell and setterfield will rise more this week so better to wait on daicos then those 2
Was thinking next week could go rat down to Samson ryan then ridley to daicos if all goes to plan.
My teams a mess boys, 94,000th after a few years off and a couple years in the top 1000.
My premiums are a mess
Backs: docherty, b.dale, Ginbey, mckenna, Wilmot, constable
Chesser, cowan,
Mids: laird, Oliver, bont, petracca, green, Callaghan, ashcroft, Mackenzie
Holland’s, baker, phillipou
Rucks : gawn, marshall
Madden
Fwds: dunkley, rozee, taranto, sheezel, josh Bruce, pedlar.
Davey jr, Greene.
Dale is going to daicos …
Plan A: If I trade gawn to tim English or witts , I can trade finn Callaghan to setterfield
Or plan B: if I trade to get Darcy Cameron, I can trade finn for LDU.
Or does someone have a better solution?
Any help is much appreciated
I also have 112k itb and 34 trades left
Plan B
Thankyou sir
Dale -> Daicos
Gawn -> D. Cameron
Those two moves leave you with 330k ITB, from there you can either get Cally straight up to LDU or get Pedlar/Bruce up to Gulden.
The appeal of Cally to LDU is obvious, especially after Cally’s shoulder, and if he’s out the decision is made but Pedlar/Bruce up to Gulden de-risks your team by getting a low floor rookie off-field and insures against Gulden’s high ownership and must have status.
fairly happy atm:
def: Doc, Dawson, Jones, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (Cowan, Chesser)
mid: Laird, Oliver, Bont, Green, Hopper, Callaghan, Ashcroft, McKenzie (Hollands, Baker, Cincotta)
ruc: Witts, Marshall (Madden)
fwd: Dunks, Rozee, Taranto, Ziebell, Bruhn, Sheez (Greene, Davey)
plan is Doc Callaghan Bruhn -> Daicos Gulden Chandler via davey dpp
thoughts?
Yep. Sounds good.
40K place.
Doc Dawson Daicos Gibney Mckenna Constable (Wilmot Cowen)
Laird Oliver Bont Green Call Ashcroft Mackenzie Baker ( Chesser Davie Long}
Darch Marshall (Loop)
Dunk Rozee Taranto Gulden Sheezel Pedlar (Caliniti Greene)
Thinking Dont panic hold you Premos.??
Darcy – English
Chesser – Chandler via DPP
Thoughts……
I do like grabbing English.
If you’re on board with Setterfield though, you could go:
Chesser -> Chandler
Darcy -> D. Cameron
Callaghan -> Setterfield
Will also need to fix your M8 at some stage. Dicey field options there.
Hi team, I am lamenting the wrong decisions on some mid-pricers (and Sean Darcy) and would love some advice:
DEF: Dawson, Doch, Day, Jones, Ginbey, Constable, Wilmot, Cowan
MID: Neale, Oliver, Green, Bont, Hopper, Callaghan, Mackenzie, Ashcroft, Chesser, Baker, Hollands.
RUCK: Darcy, Marshall, Madden
FWD: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Fyfe, Pedlar, Sheezel, Greene, Davey
Now, the obvious choices for me are Fyfe to Ziebell (wish I did this last week if I checked on Saturday that Fyfe would be a late out) and Jones to McKenna. Now I need help with my other priority. Would love to get Daicos in , but would mean trading out Doc or Neale which I’m not keen on. Darcy is the other issue in my team and tossing up Cameron (cash) or English (points).
What should my third trade be?
Chesser to chandler via Davey for cash generation will also depend on whether day, Callaghan & hopper are fit to play
Go 1 up 1 down with your midpricers and see who you can afford. Fyfe and either hopper or Calahan will get you a premo. Just watch your injuries and see who you’d rather have going forward
Yeah. Very much a wait and see on sheets re Hopper & Callaghan, Mark.
Thanks for the feedback everyone, really appreciate it . It will be a long wait until Thursday
My team is a mess, I started Stewart, Josh Kelly injured in rd1 and now Gawn, I burnt 3 trades after week one and there could be a couple trades this week. So any suggestions would be great.
Def: Doch, Young, H Clark, Ginbey,
Mckenna, Constable, Wilmot,Cowan. A
Mid: Laird, Bont, Green, Hopper, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Flanders,
Baker, Cheeser.
Rucks: Gawn, Marshall, Madden.
Forwards: Dunkley, Rozee , Taranto,
Gulden, Sheezel, Pedlar, F Greene, A Davey.
Thinking as a start.
Gawn to Cameron.
Gawn to Cameron
Clark to Daicos
Hopper to setterfield
I can do H Clark to Daicos
Unfortunately 6k short
Of Hopper to Settlefield.
Hopper to Worpel/sheed/Bowes then.
If setterfield is a must have get him next week with Calahan/Flanders and treat him as a M8
Can’t help properly unless we know your ITB but Gawn -> Cameron definitely the go to free up some cash.
After Gawn to Cameron (197K Itb)
Hunter Clark to N Daicos (only 10k left)
Maybe Gawn, Clark and Callaghan to Daicos, Cameron and Chandler which will leave you with some cash. If Callaghan is healthy, maybe do Chesser out instead. Just be good to get Chandler for cash gen
Gawn to Cameron
Flanders to Setterfield
Clark to Bowes
sicily, doc, ginbey, mckenna, wilmot, cowan (chesser, cincotta)
laird, bont,oliver, petracca, hopper, ashcroft, mackenzie, baker (phillips, constable, long)
grundy, romo (rats)
dunkley, cogs, taranto, cameron, sheezel, bruce (davey, greene)
i would like to get LDU and daicos but the only way i can see me doing that is trading grundy and doc and really that’s making me feel ick. the other one is chandler who i thinking could move in fairly easily.
any advice? leave as is? pull the trigger? i’m not after the grand prize or even weekly’s – just bragging rights lol
$147,000 in the bank
Doc to Daicos would open up Hopper to LDU (or get pretty close)
It’s good value for a trade especially if hopper is out so watch teams/news.
Given that everyone will have Daicos it’s better to be on trend then not.
Your other options (assuming Hopper is injured) is to correct him to the best moneymaker Setterfield/Worpel/Sheed/Whoever and trade one of your rookies for someone you don’t have
Rat -> Madden
Racca -> LDU
Baker -> Setterfield
60k ITB
Deal with Daicos next week.
Can I please have some help I am eyeing off worpel, daicos, chandler, D.Cameron and McKenna. Got them in no particular order just get who ever fits my structure best without tearing it apart.
DEFENDERS: Docherty Dawson Ridley Ginbey Constable Cole – Wilmot cowan
MIDFIELD: Bontempelli Kelly Green Setterfield Hopper Callaghan Ashcroft Mackenzie – chesser baker Bytel
RUCK: Darcy Marshall – madden
FORWARD: Dunks Rozee Taranto Gulden Ziebell Sheezel – Greene Davey
ITB: $34,500
1. Darcy to Cameron
2. Ridley to Daicos
3. Bytel to Chandler via Davey DPP
or 3. Bytel to McKenna via Ginbey DPP
DEF: Sicily, Doch, Goater, Ginbey, McKenna, Constable (Wilmot), (Cowan)
MID: Laird, Bont, Green, Setterfield, Hopper, Worpel, Callghan, Ashcroft, (Mackenzie), (Baker), (Davey)
RUC: Darcy, Marshall, (Madden)
FWD: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Gulden, Bruhn, Sheezel, (Ratugolea), (Greene)
Thinking of going Goater, Darcy, and Bruhn to Daicos, Cameron, and Chandler at this stage. It gives me a big upgrade in Daicos down back to balance me out with 3 premos there, also gets me out of the Darcy pick with DC who’s a great option at that price, and Chandler who has the -94 BE and should make bulk coin. Only thing is I’d miss out on Ziebell but you can’t get them all.
Thoughts lads?
TU Trade Flanders first
TD Trade Chesser first
Both let me get the guys i want
Need some help please guys, what moves do I make?
DEF: Brayshaw, Ridley, Ginbey, McKenna, Wilmot, Constable (Chesser, Cowan)
MID: Oliver, Miller, Macrae, LDU, Green, Hopper, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Phillipou, Hollands, Baker)
RUCK: Darcy, Marshall (Madden)
FWD: Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto, Gulden, Sheezel, Davey (Greene, Caminiti)
60k in bank, 35 trades
Need some assistance $106K in the bank.
DEF: Docherty Daicos Day Ginbey McKenna Wilmot ( Constable, Cowan)
MID: Oliver Brayshaw McCrae Green Hopper Callaghan Ashcroft Mackenzie
(Phillips, Baker, Chesser)
Rucks: Witts, Marshall (Madden)
FWD: Dunkley Rozee Taranto Flanders Horne-Francis Sheezel
(Greene, Davey)
Thinking
1. McCrae to LDU
2. Flanders to Zeibell
3. Hopper to Setterfield
I’d look to keep Macrae and swap JHF instead. May need to do without Ziebell?
JHF to LDU
Flanders to Chandler
Hopper to Setterfield
Current team. 76.300iTB ( 232.500 after Gawn to Cameron)
Def Doc Dawson Daicos Clark , McKenna , constable (Wilmont, Cowan)
Mids Clarry, Bont, Holmes, Setterfield, Calahan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Gibney (Philapou, long, Chesser)
Ruck Gawn, Marshall, (madden)
Fwd dunks, Rozee, toranto, gulden, Ziebell, Sheezel (Davey, Greene)
Outs need to be Gawn and Clark for obvious reasons