23 thoughts on “Game Chat – Melbourne v Richmond”

  1. Not liking the sight of M Carroll in extended squad for Carlton on Sunday, and like even less the inclusion of Cohan & Doc. Feeling Carroll won’t make the cut. But need to trade in a rookie this week to be able to complete the upgrades I want.
    TU: Trade in Tunstill instead (at least he’s in the team – even if its only game 2)
    TD: Trade in Carroll anyway – at worst he’s a dead rookie until he gets another shot

    5
    1
    Reply
    • It depends on what the rest of your team looks like. He’s holding his price and scoring, unless you get super lucky, only like 20-30 points less than most proper premos would likely score. Like if you don’t have dead rookies to trade and needed it to get naicos or something sure, but theres no rush getting rid of him.

      2
      0
      Reply
  2. Oliver 100% gone next week, I had enough of LDU last week & this week it’s Oliver I’ve fallen for him 2 years in a row based on memories of the player he used to be.

    He is nowhere near it, not even sure if a fresh start at a new club would rejuvenate his career.

    6
    0
    Reply
  3. Then Olivercomes out and has multiple tackles and about 12 disposals in 3rd quarter. Think the Tigers still to come out from the change rooms after half time!

    5
    0
    Reply
  4. Anyone know if Bo Allen is close for WCE? Don’t have a VC loophole for Gawn, unless Knevitt isn’t named.

    Smart thing is to let it go and C Brayshaw though.

    2
    2
    Reply
    • He’s getting closer, Ash. 23 touches in WAFL last weekend.

      He’s one we want to play but are trying to develop right. Plays at some point.

      I’ve just gone and stalked your team. Your bench is pretty live.

      I reckon do it.

      3
      0
      Reply
  5. I was going vc Gawn, c naicos this week. I don’t have any rookies not named but a few on extended benches that might be dropped (knevitt, gross, Cleary). Teams won’t be named until after the Anzac game

    Do I take the C off naicos and hope one gets dropped to loophole, and if none get dropped then C on xerri/rozee/b smith? Or go c naicos

    3
    0
    Reply
    • Personally would take the c off naicos and put it on xerri and if one of those are not in the side bring on and name c, if all are named make a trade to an Allen type

      3
      0
      Reply

Leave a Reply to Jonezy Cancel reply