Questions? Questionables? Questionability? Quizzes? Quizzing? Quizzed? Quandaries? Queries? Queried? Quagmires? Q & A? FAQs? Quick answers!!
Which rookie should I play at F6? Is it worth holding Duursma a little longer? Time to move Atkins on if he doesn’t play? Will there be a late out or two? Whatever you need to ask before the first lockout, this is the place…….
0
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
I have M Crouch, Coniglio, Atkins, Ross & Scott in my midfield all not playing.
At the moment I will be getting 2 zeros…
Think I’m going to have to get rid of cogs of crouch…
The question is who?
TU TRADE CROUCH
TD TRADE CONIGLIO
I would turn Atkins and Ross into Stocker and Hatley.
If you can hold your Premo’s do it.
When you know they out longer term, pull the trigger for sure.
Sometime you need to have a poor week, to have a great season.
Hatley not selected. 🙁
Crouch out.. Constable in now! Wow!
Have cover so do I still trade:
TU: Libba and Walsh to Jelly and Sicily
TD: hold trades
Is m.crouch out? I thought he was named
How long will Matt Crouch be out for?
T/U 1 week nothing to worry about
T/D 2-4 weeks
With whispers of surgery for Cogs how many weeks will he miss?
T/U just the 1-2
T/D GWS are hiding a serious injury and cogs will miss 3-8
Good news for Hately
Drew to Dunkley
Walsh to hatley TU
drew to Dunkley
Libba to hatley TD
Leaves me with 21 trades and 486000/476000 in bank
Thinking of either, trading out Walsh for Macrae, and downgrading a FWD option, or downgrading Walsh to Stocker and upgrading Parker to Dunkley.
Which option is the best one??
The Scott Brothers are so bloody annoying with their ‘mind games’
Which beer tastes worst?
VB = TU
West End = TD
HA thats Gold! (and not XXXX Gold either…)
Rowbottom.
Anyone know anything EG JS?
Not being considered, unlike Stocker.
Cheers.
Would like to bring in Hately and Macrae. Unfortunately, have both M Crouch and Coniglio on the bench this week.
Trade out options are:
TU Duursma + Walsh
TD Duursma + Libba
Comment Walsh + Libba
Cheers!
Love the look of either of Gaff or Yeo for a POD can’t choose between the two. Gaff May rack up more possies but Yeo loves a good contested ball.
Gaff more than likely the one to cop the tag as well.
TU/ Gaff
TD / Yeo
Beware the Rd 13 bye. But Yeo for what its worth.
Plan was to go Duursma/Constable -> Boak and then Steele -> J. Kelly.
With M. Crouch now out, should I consider trading him to J. Kelly instead of Steele?
Trading out Atkins. Have 3 choices.
T/U – Atkins to Luke Ryan
T/D – Atkins to Josh Kelly (would need to use a second trade Bailey Scott – Stoker)
Comment for Atkins – Dunkley
Cheers
TU: Duursma and Collins for Hately/Stocker and Laird
TD: Duursma and Constable for Hately/Stocker and Macrae
Option 2 was locked in until Constable was renamed. I suppose I could defer getting Macrae for one more week, with a BE of 98 he wont rise too much hopefully.
Constable renamed ?
Constable was originally dropped, but has now been included back in the squad for Tom Atkins.
Which option do I go for?
T.Up – Get Grundy in my team (Have S. Martin at the moment)
T.D – Trade Cogs to Macrae (thinking it could be a long term injury)
Trading out Atkins. Who to bring in?
T/U: Stocker
T/D: Hately
Injury concerns is the only reason I’m not jumping on Josh Kelly this week.
Is he a must if upgrading to a premo and have all the other familiar faces?
TU/ Yes
TD/ No
Who to trade out?
TU: Moore
TD: Walsh
Will be traded to Dunkley
TU Macrae
TD J Kelly
Everyone talking about Stocker. Is Rowbottom a downgrade option?
He is an option of course but of the 2 I would be going stocker.
Pretty low scores for Rowbottom across first couple games and JS is the same or worse than Stocker IMO
Trading to a premo with low BE:
TU: Sloane
TD: Oliver
T/U rowbottom
T/D stocker
Now that Drew hasn’t be named do I…
T/U – Stick with my original trade of Duursma > Zerret
T/D – Go with Drew to Boak
What do I do with Brayshaw?
TU – Hold and make improvements elsewhere
TD – Accept the loss and move him on
Who to trade for Macrae?
TU: Atkins (injured, close to BE)
TD: Drew (potential to be dropped, but typically scores more)
Looking at getting a Premo FWD or BACK, have about 500k so thinking between:
TU C.Daniel
TD T.Stewart
Ok I need help. Trading Atkins to which rookie?
Who is more important to get in this week?
TU- Drew to Dunkley
TD- Libba to Macrae
Hold cogs?
TU: yes
TD: No
Will be 20 trades left after this round either way.
Zerrett T/ U
J Kelly T/ D
Thoughts on trading Petrucelle for Rory Lobb in the forward line?
I have Grundy, Goldstein & Bines in the Ruck so could be used as Ruck cover too.
Only have $455,000 to spend so any other possibilities?
Who to VC?
T/up – Grundy
T/down – Gawn
Gawn into Grundy
stocker have good JS and worth gettin?
Fellahs – trying to decide between:
T/U J.Kelly
T/D Dunkley
Leaning towards Kelly but unsure about potential injuries. Also would like Macrae but that that can come next week given his 73.8 avg against GEEL and 82.5 avg at GMHBA
Which one to trade out:
T/U Petrucelle
T/D Drew
Cheers
Is having macrae a must seeing i already have bont,dunks?
Should i go for kelly, zerret, instead being bye friendly.
Cheers
IMO plan the byes
Need to trade Coniglio to avoid a donut
TU: Macrae
TD: Fyfe
Also what is good structure to have regarding how many players available for each round in the byes
8-10-12 is a basic one
Allsaints took an in-depth look at bye strategy earlier in the year: https://supercoachtalk.com/bye-strategy-2019/
Anyone know what stokers J/S is? Who comes back and kicks him out? When?
Good question.
Pretty good. The Blues rate him very, very highly. They risked swapping 2019 first-round picks (potentially a top-2 or3 pick by the looks of things at the moment) in order to secure him. Given his current half-back role, Simpson would probably be the one to force him out, although if he plays well enough, they’ll find someone else to turf out instead. If you’re looking to trade out a midfielder, or are able to work some DPP magic in order to do so, Stocker is a pretty good option. He may not be setting the world on fire, but, compared to his alternatives, his job security is very good.
Already traded Atkins to Stocker leaving me $240000. . I have both Crouch and Coniglio out. My 2nd trade between
TU: Collins to Sloane via dpp
TD: Coniglio to Macrae
Trading one of Steele or M. Crouch.
T.U: Steele
T.D: M. Crouch
neither? what is your goal with the trade?
Anyone heard anything official regarding darcy moore being rested?
Heard Quaynor will replace him this week. And Aish might replace De Goey
Lastly need to trade out Drew
TU: Dunkley
TD: Boak
Wait a week or two to get boak
Boak better for the long run I think. Also playing Gold Coast as a nice bonus tomorrow!
I know this is pure Lunacy and goes well beyond the Josh Glen rule, but……
Are any of the new rookies (listed to play first game) worth looking at.?
i.e. Oskar Baker (Mel)
Robbie Young (Stk)
Mitchell Hinge (Bri)
Darcy Fort (Gee)
Joel Garner (Pta)
Ben King (Gcs)
Any info on any of them? Anyone rated? Anyone with job security?
Desperate times call for desperate measures
Much appreciated
I wouldn’t touch King. Was homesick before the season started
Hinge
Have a look at Joe Atley. Mature age, was looking the goods for Rd 1 before he got injured. Plus having a look at Ports bench don’t think he’ll be the first one out when anyone returns.
Joe Atley… contested ball / inside mid so in other words plays nothing like his brother Shaun
T/U Duncan
T/D Yeo
Quick one
25 trades left
TU: 1 trade – Cogs to Sloane
TD: 2 trades – Drew to Stocker/Cogs to Fyfe ($129K ITB but lose FWD/MID DPP)
Comment: Hold Cogs
Constable is playing he is replacing Atkins
Stocker worth trading Scott out for?
Only gaining $50k
Worth it?
Tu / Td
Who’s better for VC
TU Grundy
TD Neale
U:Atkins-Rockliff
D:Drew-T.Kelly
Hey Crew,
Dunno much about Rowan Marshall. But if I can pay just $433k for someone who is gonna average 99 then sign me up.
What’s the general consensus about him
TU Just a purple patch. He’ll drop off
TD Looks the goods
Also I am aware he is up against Collingwood this week. But his BE is just 57 so I believe he won’t drop in value and it’s the difference between playing him onfield vs playing Hayes
W.Drew > Lachie Weller???should i get him
TU: cogs to macrae
TD: cogs to fyfe
Fyfe’s next 3 look more SC-friendly than Macrae’s, so T.D.
TU: Sloane and 70k left over
TD: JPK+25k leftover
Comment Merrett
Can’t work out who’s going to go better from here.
Ok, so I’m posting over here, because no one answered me on the trade, and now I REALLY need help with my team
DEF – Lloyd, Laird, Williams, Crisp, Hore, Duursma (Lockhart, Answerth)
MID – Neale, Cripps, Macrae, Oliver, M. Crouch, Walsh, Constable, Stack (Atkins, Hayes, Scott)
RUC – Gawn, Goldstein (O’ Brien)
FWD – Dunkley, Dangerfield, Heeney, Moore, Drew, Baker (Setterfield, Bines)
Salary cap rem. – $200,700
Trades left – 21
Anyone have any ideas on what I should do?
Don’t want to make anymore trades because I’ve used enough as it is, but I have no Crouch, Atkins, Scott, Moore or Drew playing. I have to trade someone or I’ll be taking donuts, and I refuse to do that.
In a similar situation myself………
OUT – Atkins & Drew
MOVE Duursma into MIDs, move Moore into DEFs……..now you can loophole Lockhart tonight with Darcy Moore. If he’s no good, then bring Answerth onto the field (or even Duursma)
IN – T.Kelly & Shai Bolton
Don’t have enough for Bolton. I’m 5k short. I can get Larkey if that’s a reasonable option. Leaves me with $68k spare too
Or I can get someone like Caleb Daniel instead of Kelly and then I’d have enough for Bolton. Which sound’s better to you?
My advice is to trade Scott. Recovering from concussion.
All the others are good chances to be playing next week
Who to trade in you ask?
In line with a guns/rookies strategy I would trade in Atley from PA. This is indeed a risky trade but out of all the rookies playing this week I think he is most likely to firstly score points and if he plays well that have solid JS
I wouldn’t normally advocate this strategy but there is form thats been seen in the SANFL and I reckon his role will be similar
I’m stuck.
I’ve got Atkins and Parker to trade but no mid/fwd swing to bring in a premo mid.
Are there any debut rookies worth taking a punt on on any line?
Begley for Essendon? I wouldn’t do it though
W.Drew , Atkin > Sloane , Stocker
I need forward premium option not named Boak! Need to consider byes but struggling to differentiate all the options from each other, any help?
Fwd line atm is: Danger, Kelly, Dunkley, Westhoff, Moore, Parker, Drew, Bines
Any Hawthorn fans give me an idea on Dylan Moore’s job security please. He gives me a forward bench option instead of bringing in Stocker to the mids where I already have bench cover.
T/U Should stay in for at least a few more games
T/D Likely to be one of the first out.
Larkey worth jumping on after a price rise?
TU : get larkey solid JS
TD: stocker
T Atkins (M9) out:
In
TU: J Hately
TD: L Stocker
TU: stocker
TD: J.Atley
TU: Libba to Boak
TD: Walsh to J.Kelly
Can’t afford Libba to J.Kelly
Many thanks!
With M Crouch out I’m in need of some rookie advice.
I can play either of theses guys on field. Swing Drew / Setters.
T/U Stocker v GWS.
T/D Corbett v Port.
Thanks.
Looks like it is going to be wet in Adelaide on Sunday which is not good for Corbett being a forward.
Who do I put emergency on if Darcy Moore is late withdrawl?
T/U Will Setterfield
T/D Josh Corbett
VC options
TU – Grundy
TD – Boak (can loophole Ross)
Collins >Stocker
Drew > Boak
Tu: Good trades go for it.
Td: hold trades.
Which rookies to field
TU: Corbett + Loophole Hayes/Gibbons
TD: Hayes + Gibbons
Churs
T/U M.Crouch > Neale
T/D Save Trade
TU: Stocker
TD: Larkey
Cmnt: Atley