Stuck between two trade ins? Thumbs up vs Thumbs down
Not sure who to field? Thumbs up vs Thumbs down
0
0
19 thoughts on “Last Minute Queries – Round 23”
Should I trade Petracca and Marshall for Rankine and Hall?
I’ve got 2 trades left and am in a close cash league match. I have a second chance, but a win would put me straight into the GF.
Should I make these trades or hold off?
I need to make the Marshall trade to afford the Rankine trade…
Best replacement for grundy, except gawn or xerri? thinking jackson, cameron or marshall, but not really across who’s got the best match ups and if second rucks effect them that much……
cheers!
I have D Sharp’s 95 on the fwd bench as emergency. Do I take his score by fielding my non playing F8 and benching Petracca? I can then move Petracca to mid bench emergency as cover.
i’m tossing up between Petracca or Herbert on field as well.
my thoughts are that Petracca’s best 5 scores this year have been against, Eagles, Essendon, GWS, North and Collingwood. he is the classic flat-track bully. scores well against weaker teams.
Suns had a very easy run to start the season and has been a tough second half of the year, that is why he hasn’t scored well. He clearly has the ability, so i’m thinking i’ll back him to outscore Herbert.
Although herberts last two have been 130+, but prior to that he was a 70-80 scorer.
I would still take the 95 though, that is a decent score, that i’d be happy if petracca scored this week.
Should I trade Petracca and Marshall for Rankine and Hall?
I’ve got 2 trades left and am in a close cash league match. I have a second chance, but a win would put me straight into the GF.
Should I make these trades or hold off?
I need to make the Marshall trade to afford the Rankine trade…
Scrap that. Need to hold Marshall to cover Grundy now.
5 trades left 2 forwards short from full premo. Now Grundy out. Playing prelim final in final 6 set up. Grundy and Degoey for Jackson and JHF?
Best replacement for grundy, except gawn or xerri? thinking jackson, cameron or marshall, but not really across who’s got the best match ups and if second rucks effect them that much……
cheers!
Who to field at D6?
TU – Derkson
TD – Hall-Kahan
Can’t loophole the unfortunately
Captain choice
TU – Baz Smith v ESS at Geelong
TD – Nick Daicos v WCE at Perth
Trade out petracca/miller for Chad Warner?
TU: yes
TD: no
If so, which one?
TU: petracca
TD: miller
you must have a few trades to burn?
I do
On form, I’d trade out Petracca.
Fitzgerald was looking good at half time.
might have to now decide what score i will take, or if go with either petrracca or Herbert
Take score for Fitzgerald:
TU: over 80 is good.
TD: has to be at least 90
follow up question:
TU: Herbert
TD: Petracca
Hey Derek & SC Community,
I have D Sharp’s 95 on the fwd bench as emergency. Do I take his score by fielding my non playing F8 and benching Petracca? I can then move Petracca to mid bench emergency as cover.
TU – take the 95
TD – Petracca will beat that
i’m tossing up between Petracca or Herbert on field as well.
my thoughts are that Petracca’s best 5 scores this year have been against, Eagles, Essendon, GWS, North and Collingwood. he is the classic flat-track bully. scores well against weaker teams.
Suns had a very easy run to start the season and has been a tough second half of the year, that is why he hasn’t scored well. He clearly has the ability, so i’m thinking i’ll back him to outscore Herbert.
Although herberts last two have been 130+, but prior to that he was a 70-80 scorer.
I would still take the 95 though, that is a decent score, that i’d be happy if petracca scored this week.
i’m just not sure if GWS in Canberra are an easy team or not. GWS should win.
Herbert on field, playing in defence against Collingwood.
Now to decide between Miller and Petracca? Who plays on field?
Very annoyed I had already used E. Could have looped Petracca/Herbert with Ison.
TU: Miller
TD: Petracca
I would be careful about Herbert. Josh Lindsay is back in team, might hurt Herbert?
Decided to play Miller and Petracca both and bench Herbert