For those last minute ideas that you may need a second opinion on! Put them down in the comments below and the SuperCoach Talk community will be happy to help out.
2
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Last Minute Queries – Round 5
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Luke Ryan keep or trade?
Zac Butters keep or trade?
Patrick Cripps keep or trade?
I’d personally go Trade,Keep,Keep
Getting N.O’Driscoll. who gets traded out though? Both annoy me
TU – Gibcus
TD – J.Ward
I’m personally waiting till selection.
Longmuir in a bind… has Alex Pearce, Caleb Serong and Darcy Tucker to come into his midfield. Does this push N O’D out, or reduces his field time big?
I’m hoping he still gets named- just haven’t pulled the trigger yet!
Trade out Luke Ryan for:
TU: Sinclair
TD: Hewett (bank $36,500)
Erasmus
Yes or No
Replacement for Ryan?
T/U – Sinclair
T/D – Hall
Its looking like 130 for Ryan !!!
Ha-ha , exactly what i was thinking.
TU: Get Gawn and it means I have to play Skinner or SDK if Hinge misses
TD: Get Hewitt and play Dixon or Hayes
Worth going Skinner > NOD or just hold Skinner in hope he get’s recalled & trade out MacDonald instead?
TU: Get rid of Skinner for NOD and generate cash, get of the piss it’s a no-brainer trade.
TD: Keep Skinner, he will play again this year & dump MacDonald who is a slow burn but possible handy DPP incoming.
Worth trading out Bowey a little early in order to get Docherty?
TU – Smart move
TD – Bowey still has cash to make & scores in him
Backline looking thin: Crisp, Ridley, Hewitt, Chapman, McCartin, O’Driscol (Hinge, DeKoning)
TU: Trade Ridley or Crisp
TD: Hold for now
Only line I have an issue with at the moment is defence. Current side is Short, Whitfield, Ridley, Sicily, McCartin, Hinge, Gibcus, De Koning
Think I will hold Ridley this week but he’s on thin ice.
Which improves my team more?
T/U – Whitfield and Hinge for Stewart and O’Driscoll
T/D – Whitfield and C MacDonald for Hewett and O’Driscoll (Gives me a D/M link)
Callaghan- GWS- will make his debut this week… nice to get some rookie turnover. Hopefully in a couple of weeks might be worth picking up- good form in twos, but priced high.
Still umming and ahhing over O’Driscoll.
If I do pull the trigger, who do I drop?
MacDonald ?
Ward ?
Stephens ?
Stephens the obvious one as not named this week
TU – D. Stephens to NOD
TD – Hold
What do we think.
TU) Stephens -> NOD (field SDK this week)
TD) Gibcus -> NOD (field Dixon / Hayes)
Whomst is a bigger priority to be cut this week
TU: D Stephens (seems on the outer now)
TD: M Hinge (omitted!?)
Hold Hinge a week if you have cover. Imo it’s a precaution, he is in their B22.
Anyone know the news with Hinge? Says omitted but surely it’s due to injury. If he truly got dropped I’d love to go to O’Driscoll but I’m not sure quite yet. Any news would be amazing.
yeah weird, he is emergency meaning I think he is actually omitted, maybe giving him a rest this week, but still naming him as emergency in case??
Must be a good chance of wearing the vest this week. Maybe they’re trying to limit his game time after that knock last week?
nvm, withdrawn from the squad with injury.
So for some reason I still have Darcy (BE of 235 and set to lose 63k)
TU: Trade to Gawn
TD: Trade to Pruess
Got Hinge, Skinner and Gibcus as my bench and D6. With Gibcus omitted, Hinge a potential Emergency and Skinner in extended bench…
TU: Hinge to NO’D
TD: Wait until finalised teams for Sunday and play Skinner if named.
Darcy Wilmot..
TU: trade him to O’Driscoll
TD: hold he will play soon
Half hour to decide
DEF: Crisp. Ridley, Hewett, Bowey, McCartin, Gibcus (Sinn, O’Driscoll)
MID: Macrae, Oliver, Steele, Neale, Crippa, JHF, N.Daicos, Ward (D.Stephens, Hollands, C.MacDonald)
RUC: Gawn, Grundy (Dixon)
FWD: Dunkley, Butters. Cogs, Brodie, Xerri, Rachele (Durdin, N.Martin)
$57,000 in the bank, 32 trades left
Any advice or feedback is appreciated!!
You will be hoping NOD gets named otherwise a donut in defence
I would swing cogs to midfield and play Martin in field instead of MacDonald (ward will cover Crippa)
when do sunday teams get finalised?
About 5.30pm Friday
TU: Stephens to O’Driscoll
TD: Gibcus to O’Driscoll
T/U – Take Neale score for C via loophole
T/D – Role the dice with Macrae for C
Think I’m going to take Neales awkward score as I don’t have Macrae, still might go Max tho.
Take Neales. TU
Go for Max. TD
I’m going Max over Macrae
Bailey Williams from West Coast with Nic Nat out for next 3 months for cash generation:
T/U – Yes
T/D – No
TU: Take Daicos score
TD: Rachelle/Dow
TU: Get NOD for one of D. Stephens or Hough (but cop a zero this week in DEF and gain DEF/MID loop)
TD: Get NOD for Hinge (22 playing, no DEF/MID loop)
Trading Ryan. I’ve already got Short, Hewitt, Sicily
, Whitfield
Should I splash out and Get my mate Doch?
Docherty TU(I’ve got quite a few fist bye players)
Lloyd TD
Will Grundy, bowey and Perkins traded out this week for preuss, Hewitt and Doherty be a season defining move in a good way?…
My defense is very brittle.
HELP! Defense is a shambles
Both Ryan and Ridley inconsistent.. Hinge and Gibcus out so facing a donut.
Used 3 trades already. Traded out Chapman to free up enough cash to bring in Hewett and Heeny
TU
– Hinge to Chapman
-Gibcus to O’driscoll (if in final team)
-Hough to 102k mid/fwd (will allow me to loop a Fwd for Cripps)
TD
– Gibcus to O’driscoll
– Hough to 102k mid/fwd (will allow me to loop a Fwd for Cripps)
– Save a trade
Please comment for other ideas I am stuck!
6 trades this early scares me and I know I’ll have to trade Chapman out at some stage
Thank you!
I’d hold on Hinge, and just do Gibcus to NOD. What does your whole team look like?
Worth trading out Grundy, Cripps, Butters, Ridley, Xerri, Hinge, McCartin, McDonald, Stephens, Gibcus, and Ward???
With that many boosts, you better hope you can get wi-fi on the moon next round.
trade d. stephens> o’driscoll.
not sure if stephens gets back into the top team but also NOD’s JS is not the best. structural advantage of the trade is i can open up DPP links from mid-fwd and def-fwd by shifting de koning and rachelle around.
T/U worth the trade NOD will stay in the team
T/D don’t trade NOD’s JS is shaky and stephens will be back
cheers!
Hi All !
Anyone have any intel on Carlton’s Luke Parks other than his Bio on footywire ?
Cheers !
Doing a bench loophole.
Who will score higher if JHF flops against the dogs?
T/U – Erasmsmus
T/D – C. McDonald
^
For the above comment,
who should I loop (Who will score less?)?
T/U – Rowell
T/D – JHF
Bring in Bailey Smith. @ 500 K.
Good run ahead.
Tu
Td
With NicNat out is H Dixon still worth bringing in at $164.4k? Need cover for Cripps that isn’t Ward/MacDonald.
TU: Ward/MacDonald to Dixon Rachele into the mids to cover Crippa.
TD: Just deal with the fact you’ve gotta field one of the Hawk spuds.
If TU option who goes first?
TU: Ward
TD: MacDonald
Cheers coaches!
MacDonald to Dixon easy
Who to Trade Out?
TU:- Hinge
TD:- Gibcus
Was thinking Bowey > Hall, Stephens > NOD this week but after seeing Fremantle’s lineup I’m not even sure if NOD plays. Problem is that Hall plays before Sunday teams are confirmed and I can’t get him unless I trade Stephens for NOD.
Another alternative is that I can actually get Bowey up to Sinclair without a 2nd trade. Do I just go for that?
What to do?
TU: Risk it! (Bowey > Hall, Stephens > NOD)
TD: Play it safe and wait for Sunday teams to be released (Means I probably go Sinclair)
I’m in the same boat with bringing in Hall and NOD. I was also looking at Dawson (same price as Hall) – who plays later (after Sunday teams are finalized). McInerney also works for me because I can open up a D/M swing and trade him in now (then bring in NOD if named).
I might even just hold onto Bowey this week hoping that Hall doesn’t go too big as he’s likely to drop cash with a BE of 154. Wouldn’t surprise me at all if he goes goes 120+ today though.
Dawson is definitely another option but personally with only 2 premium defender spots left I think I’m eying off Hall and maybe Lloyd.
Coin flip there.
I’m thinking about holding Bowey 1 more week then going Bowey > Pruess next week and then upgrading with that money.
If you think NOD has good job security and Bowey will score poorly this week then go for it
Hewett TU
Doc TD
TU: Xerri/ Rowell > O’Driscoll/ Hewett via ddp
TD: Gibcus> O’Driscoll
Who to trade for Odriscoll (assuming he is named)
TU: Stephens
TD: Gibcus
If Hinge is supposedly best 22, why is he dropped to play SANFL (clearly not injured)?
From “Injuries” post –
Mitch Hinge (hip) Test after being subbed out of the game in the third quarter after a direct blow his hip which also affected his abdominal area. Will be assessed at training on Wednesday.
“Mitch copped a pretty nasty blow to his hip and lateral abdominal area, and unfortunately he couldn’t continue the game,” Adelaide High Performance Manager Darren Burgess.
“He’s pulled up quite well. At this stage, he’ll be available. It was very much light duties today with him.” Matthew Nicks
The warning bell was the last line, that he was on light duties on Wednesday after receiving the heavy knock. Obviously Adelaide doesn’t think that he is able to play the rigours of AFL on a light preparations and a drop back to lesser intensity of the SANFL would be better. He would receive the benefit of a whole game versus the uncertainty of being a medical sub. Where he may have to play longer minutes in a harder game or maybe none at all?
I would envision a quick return to the seniors for Hinge after this precautionary return to the SANFL.
He’s not in the SANFL side so I think he’s just out hurt. The AFL site now has him listed as out injured so I wouldn’t be too worried. Reckon he should be back next week
Yes, you are right Johnno.
I see that the SANFL teams are updated and Hinge is not now on the list.
Legends, thanks all!
Filthy at myself for selling him when he was dropped (for Hayes), but is Dixon worth trading back in? Feels so wrong, but his JS appears better than O’Driscoll and I am simply looking to make maximum cash…
TU: Bring in Dixon
TD: Bring in NOD
Get Preuss next week
With news from Carlton that Cripps is no certainty to play rnd 6 and there still not sure is it worth it to take a risk or should I just trade to Heeney via dpp
TU: Hold and hope
TD: Trade to heeney
Patrick Cripps
“The assessment that we’ve had is he should be right to go next week. Certainly no major damage was there. That gives him a chance for next week at least. He has to come out & train.
“He’ll have a steady build-up. He’s already been out here doing some running so his recovery is on track. We didn’t want to push it any quicker than that. I think over the weekend we’ll have a bit more of an idea of where he’s at, when we come in Monday.”
Michael Voss.
Rowell > Hewett & Gibcus > Noddy ( can swing with Sinn )
Yay
Nay
Cheers
T/U – Gibcus to Saad
T/D – Gibcus to NOD (build bigger bank)
when does DPP change happen- is it after this round, and who is likely to get it? could daicos could become def/mid and macdonald become mid/fwd? anyone else?
This is what I wrote in Rare gems post.
After this round extra dual positions are allocated if a player spends 35% of his time in another position. Apparently you don’t have to have played every game. (four out of five are required)
Tristan Xerri, Nick Daicos, Brady Hough, Connor MacDonald, Zak Butters, Scott Pendlebury, Tom Liberatore, Nic Martin and Angus Brayshaw likely to be given dual positions.
Isaac Heeney and Bailey Smith are borderline.
It depends how much time Heeney has in the forward line with Buddy missing this week.
Smith is marginally just under the threshold and this round will be the deciding factor.
What about Luke Parker?
Luke Parker is pretty much assured Forward status atm.
He would have to play 100% mid this week to miss. he has hardly been sighted in the middle this year.
He has had a few stinkers this year and would really need to get back in the guts to be worth considering. Maybe when Papley is back ?
thanks CT!
Looking for a value defence upgrade with the aim to be a keeper:
TU – Hewett
TD – Sicily
Hinge-Rowell>. O’Driscoll-Hewitt
Trade hinge to Chapman
TU: Yes
TD: No
Who to field:
T/U – Dow
T/D – Hayes
Need help coaches have a feeling Cripps will be out 2 weeks
T/U Cripps > T.Miller
T/U Hold Trade (Rachelle Cover)
Thanks coaches
Any idea on Rosas js?
Trade Darcy to
TU: Gawn before tomorrow’s game
TD: Let him play this week and lose cash and get English next week
Take Paddys 68 or roll the dice with SDK ?
Hinge > O’Driscoll
Bowey > Docherty
Cripps > Brayshaw (freo)
TU: Chill. Waste of trades.
TD: Big move. Could pay off.
Trade Cripps?
Gibcus to O’Driscoll?
Folks, in need of your thumbs please!
Who scores more:
T/U – Rowell V Saints
T/D – Cogs v Demons
Thanks!
Trade Cripps to:
TU: Touk
TD: Boak
Comment: Parish or Laird
Touk top 3 mid and is a discount from his starting price, absolutely get him in.
30 grand cheaper next week
I know he will be cheaper next week but he’s trading to a premo this week. Touk scores 125-130 this week compared to a rookie 50 is a big difference.
Hold Cripps, everyone jumping off too soon
Haven’t made any trades so far. Going along allright.
Should I trade Maginnes to O’Driscoll just for the money.
TU: Yes
TD: No
T/U – Ward to O’Driscoll
T/D – Hold
Who to trade out between the two hawks
TU: Ward
TD: MacDonald
Trading Cripps. With Touk having a breakeven of 188 this week he is estimated to drop around another 30K
Should I:
TU: Leave Touk a week
TD: Bring in Docherty by way of Hewett moving into the middle
Def wait on Touk, just for price drop. Why not wait on Cripps, if you have some depth at MID he’ll be back in 2-3 weeks.
Hewitt might be a season long keeper at this rate, I’m holding on him for sure
Which Hawk should go for O’Driscoll?
TU-Ward
TD-McDonald
Does Sinn (PTA) get another run soon?
Or should I trade to NOD?
Josh Sinn has a groin injury and is out for 3-4 weeks.
Thanks CT much appreciated
Who to field?
T/U O’Driscoll
T/D SDK
Thanks Coaches
Is Hinge definitely out of Crows Team ? Need to knoiw for loophole .
⬆️ Take Dixon 54
⬇️ Loop Durdin
Thanks 🙂
TU: Take McCartin’s 68 as emergency
TD: Put De Koning on the field
PLay
TU: Ward
TD: O’Driscoll
Or comment – take rachele 49 pts
Thx
Have started 1W 1L in my league, looks like it will be a close finish this week. Can probably make sure of a win if I trade Cripps out to another Premo.
TU: Trade Cripps for the win
TD: Save trade, play the long game
Should I trade Luke Ryan out for
Hewett , I have used 4 trades so far.
Tu: yes
Td: no save the trade, get Hewett as
a upgrade later.
Need to trade Cripps to secure the win…..
TU Walsh
TD Parish
TU: Take Rachele’s 49
TD: Field Ward and hope he plays his best game
Can loop in Rachelle’s 49 but not keen. Do I loop in Macdonald or Ward, not sure who scores better or if they even get better than 49…
TU: Put Macdonald on field
TD: Put Ward on field.
Ward seems to be getting much more MID minutes than MacDonald at the moment – so he would probably be the safer bet to put on your field.
Although Ward hasn’t taken advantage of all those mid minutes / CBA’s yet 🙁
Hopefully tomorrow is the day!!
Anyone have projected price changes for Hall and Rachele?
have a look at a site called “TooSerious”
Joshua Rachele
Rd 5 Price $259k
2022 Scores: 118/58/36/106
Rd 5 BE 10
Rd 5 Score 49
Rd 5:$259k->$277k(+$17k)
Rd 6 BE 8
Projected Score 73
Rd6:->$306k ($29k) New BE 58
Rd7:->$312k ($7k) New BE 39
Rd8:->$327k ($15k) New BE 48
Rd9:->$339k ($11k) New BE 55.
Aaron Hall
Starting Price $573k
Rd5 Price $546k
2021 Av 105 (20 games)
2022 Scores: 129/123/70/97
Rd5 BE 154
Rd5 Score 71#
Rd5: $546k->$509k ($-37k)
Rd6 BE 132
Projected Score 98
Rd6:->$494k ($-15k) New BE 123
Rd7:->$483k ($-11k) New BE 90
Rd8:->$487k ($4k) New BE 92
#Hamstring injury. Waiting for result of scans. Will be updated ASAP.
All approx.. Should be within $5K either way.
Rachelle $275K
Hall $508K