24 thoughts on “Last Minute Questions – Round 17”

  1. Anyone got any idea how long Fisher will be out for?

    Down to 3 trade, full premium but unsure whether he needs to be traded or is he a keep?

    Cheers

    0

    0
    1. Was a test this week and didn’t get up. No structural injury. Cover. Should be back next week.

      6

      0
  2. when will st kilda bench be finalised? hoping to know if shoenmaker’s playing before game starts tonight or will likely cop a donut…….

    0

    0
    1. Sunday teams are announced at 5pm on a Friday, and Schoenmakers has been named to play. Whether he is the sub or not, that’s something we don’t know until about 30 mins before game time.

      5

      0
  3. Trading in Rankine this week (set on that decision)

    Who to trade out?

    TU: Fisher
    TD: Curnow

    11

    3
  4. Fisher out gives me a donut. Back-to-back weeks of donuts with TDK last week.

    I have 3 trades left and only 1K ITB (ie stuffed).

    Do I:

    TU: Cop the donut on the chin.
    TD: Trade Fisher to Rankine (which required a downgrade to Humphries) and go down to 1 trade to ride the season out.

    11

    2
  5. A bit stuck.

    My forward bench is McMullin and W. Dawson so I’ve got no real coverage for Fisher 1 week. Still had Frejiah in M8 that I needed to get up but wanted to wait the extra week for some more cash. 4 trades and 170K itb

    TU: Fisher & Frejiah -> Rankine & McKercher (2 trades left and no fwd coverage)

    TD: McMullin -> 102 Mid (3 trades left, Dowling F/M swing coverage, Frejiah to $550k Prem Mid next week)

    1

    5
  6. Sullivan to:
    TU Richards + $159k ITB
    TD Mannagh + 279k ITB
    Either way 7 trades left.
    Could use the cash to Trade up Martin to Sinclair or someone else

    2

    8
  7. With Fisher out do I?
    Use Dowling as cover?
    Or
    Trade Darcy Jones-Humphries and Fisher-rankine.
    Full premo and will leave me with 2 trades.
    Thanks

    8

    0
  8. Use
    2 trades to get Fisher to Rankine and leave me with 2 trades left.
    Or
    1 trade Fisher to Caldwell and leave me 3 trades

    0

    12
  9. Better defender rookie to bring in?
    TU: Logan Evans – named on field but JS shaky(?)
    TD: Schoenmakers – sub risk

    1

    4
  10. Whose trading Fisher?
    I more definitive timeline would be nice what do we all expect him to be out for?

    TU: 1-2 weeks, hold.
    TD: 2+ weeks. Trade.

    My preference is to hold as I have Liam Baker to move on before Fisher in the next fortnight

    5

    0
  11. Not sure what to do. Going into this week, I was 1 premo away from full premium.

    I could’ve gone Aleer + Richards to Humphries + Serong to complete the side with 3 trades remaining.

    Instead, I rolled the dice on Richards, thinking that if he scored well, I would be able to assemble enough cash to sideways Rowell to Dunkley this week and upgrade Richards to Serong next week, leaving me with 2 trades at full premium. Richards’ 34 has completely put a line through this plan due to lack of cash gen in the coming weeks.

    What do I do this week?

    TU: Aleer > Humphries
    Just cop it and field 2 rookies this week. Get Richards to Serong next week and have 3 trades at full premium.

    TD: Aleer > Humphries, Fisher > Serong
    Trade Fisher to Serong which will mean I only field 1 rookie this week. Sets me up to go Richards > Caldwell next week and I will complete the side with 2 trades remaining.

    Thoughts?

    2

    0
  12. 4 trades left and have Richards 34 covering Fisher
    T/U: trade Fisher to Reid and then Rowell to Dunkley
    T/D: take Richards score and hold

    1

    2

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *