17 thoughts on “Polling Station – Round 16”

  1. Obvious one is best options for Tom Stewart trade

    Another one is if Tim English misses again this week do we hold or trade?

    0
    0
    Reply
  2. I know it’s a recurring ask but with 4 games left and then finals, I am curious to see where everyone is sitting with trades, whether they’re full premo or not, and how many trades you’ll be wanting to take into finals. I mean I finished my team two weeks ago with 9 trades, but with unlucky injuries and what not I’m down to 6 trades after this round, got me a bit nervous for what may come in the next few weeks tbh.

    0
    0
    Reply
  3. I’m not sure a Poll is the best way to handle these queries, though it will give most on community and idea of who the majority are thinking of but (and apologies as I don’t think this will show neatly below) but the idea of the poll and ALSO the reasons for:

    Who are people considering as a last upgrade in Mids (most likely)

    And I note for some replacement for Stewart (and why)

    It would be really handy if someone had the time / ability / knowledge to provide some analysis as to why the below may or may not be good options to look at (I tried to pick lower owned people below)

    Mids % owned / 3RA / Price
    Wines 5.1 / 103.7 / 553,400
    Libba 4.1 / 114.3 / 556,800
    Walsh 10.6 / 107.3 / 579,500
    Keays 8.6 / 99.3 / 531,100
    Mills 18.4 / 112.3 / 610,500
    Dawson 13 / 126.7 / 593,300
    Kelly 11.6 / 97 / 570,400
    Boak 9.1 / 101.3 / 501,900
    Guthrie 1.9 / 108.3 / 544,600

    Defenders % owned 3RA Price
    Dawson 13 / 126.7 / 593,300
    Rich 8.8 / 124.3 / 543,600
    Brayshaw (Demons) 7.5 / 120.7 / 530,200
    Redman (Bombers) 0.7 / 116.7 / 525,300
    Vlastuin 5.5 / 115.3 / 488,200
    Saad 5 / 113.3 / 539,300
    Hall 1.7 / 106 / 508,300

    Just a thought!!

    0
    0
    Reply
    • I like to look at some over/unders to get an idea of how reliable and how much potential they have to score. I try to find the player that will give the most points for the money I have, which is why I measure the cost per point at each line.
      As an example I’ll give you Oliver’s stats
      Oliver
      50% of his scores are above 128, and they will cost you $5.4k each
      80% scores above 112, and cost you $6.14k ea.

      The 50% is a bigger risk, as they are just as likely to go under.

      Hopefully that makes sense and the format is ok

      (Player, 50%,$/pt50, 80%, $/pt80)
      Wines, 101, $5.48, 95, $5.80
      Libba, 105, $5.33, 83, $6.71
      Walsh, 123, $4.71, 90, $6.45
      Keays, 112, $4.76, 100, $5.31
      Mills, 117, $5.22, 84, $7.27
      Dawson, 105, $5.65, 97, $6.12
      Jelly, 113, $5.05, 85, $6.71
      Boak, 110, $4.56, 87, $5.78
      Guthrie, 95, $5.73, 86, $6.33

      Dawson, 105, $5.65, 97, $6.12
      Rich, 106, $5.15, 81, $6.71
      Brayshaw, 99, $5.38, 72, $7.36
      Redman, 96, $5.47, 69, $7.59
      Vlastuin, 98, $4.98, 68, $7.18
      Saad, 109, $4.95, 73, $7.43
      Hall, 97, $5.24, 71, $7.20

      0
      0
      Reply
      • Looking directly at a Stewart replacement you can go a few ways depending on your budget
        Direct replacement ($530 or more)
        (Player, $, 50%,$/pt50, 80%, $/pt80)
        Dale, $535.7, 111, $5.1, 90, $6.26
        Saad, $539.3, 109, $4.95, 73, $7.43
        Rich, $543.6, 106, $5.15, 81, $6.71
        Sinclair, $577.7, 113, $5.27, 85, $6.98
        Hewett, $554.3, 116, $5.3, 104, $5.91

        Scim a little to upgrade elsewhere (450-530) without the 80% as they are risky so have low numbers for that measure
        (Player, $, 3RA, 50%,$/pt50)
        Young (Fre), $494.8, 114.3, 89, $5.64
        Baker, $493.9, 112.7, 77, $5.68
        Whitfield, $463.1, 107.3, 93, $4.93
        Daniel, $490.7, 98.7, 100, $4.97
        Blicavs, $509.2, 97.4, 103, $5.11

        0
        0
        Reply
  4. how does the afl deal with stewart incidents in the future?
    1-Red card, sent off (rest of game).
    2-Yellow card sent off for 1 full qtr(no sub). Applies following week if last qtr.
    3- As is.
    4-Team deducted Goals scored up until incident pending a guilty review/

    5- other scenarios?

    All of this is SC relevant, but also more so whats everyone take on these types of incidents moving fwd?.

    0
    0
    Reply

Leave a Comment