Lunchtime on Thursday…….time for a table for two!
Following on from our pre-season 2UP threads, Table For Two helps you with those tricky questions. Who better to field at D6 this week? Should we bring in Stack or Ross? Is it worth bringing in Reilly O’Brien? ……Brian O’Reilly? ………..O’Brian Reilly? The Adelaide Ruckman!
Whatever you need help with, enter it into the comments and the SCT Coaches will help out as best they can with the thumbs UP/DOWN…….
1
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Who to trade in fro Dev Smith at F3?
C Daniel T/U
Gresham T/D
cheers
I voted Daniel. He maintained his position behind the ball after JJ came back. Seems to be liked at the club (trying to renegotiate his contract at the minute).
But, I reckon you could split hairs on this call Simo.
Sheed commented this week saying he will be playing predominately HF
Thinking of trading to Rocky
TU:Yes
TD: No
Cheers,
Liebs,
If you started with Sheed, congrats! Upgrade to a premo… I’m not totally sold on Rocky, but if you are do it.
If you traded in Sheed, then think very carefully if you want to use another trade on the same position. And, then think who that trade justifies. If it’s still Rocky, go for it. Wish you luck.
Remember, FD says “Trades are air”
Thanks for comment,
Started with Sheed, article below making me nervy regarding Sheed, admitting will struggle for mid time. Trade to Rocky, I can still Moore > T.Kelly next week. Considering Merrett instead if not Rock.
https://thewest.com.au/sport/west-coast-eagles/eagles-premiership-hero-dom-sheed-ready-to-fight-for-place-in-west-coasts-best-22-ng-b881170608z
Personally, I’d bring in Merrett. Think Essendon are just about to hit their straps, and not entirely sure Port are the real deal. Plus, Rocky is just about to cop a hard Hutchings tag this weekend.
Good luck whichever direction you go 🙂
Is stack most likely a good trade or not?
I think he is a good trade I’ve got him in for Butters. Stack is playing really well obviously killed it game 1 & game 2 even though scored 40 could have scored 60-70, looks the goods to me
TU: Dunkley to Billings
TD: Hold
Comment: Dunkley to Boak
Refer to sc101 re sideways trades
If I had Dunkley I’d be getting rid of him. Sideways trading isn’t recommended but if there’s a significant role change like this case it’s acceptable imo. Eg Hibberd Billings last year.
TU – Hore
TD – Rotham
Let’s see those thumbs
Cheers
Out of the 2 Hore but…. they both have sort of scratchy JS I started Hore so hope he plays next few games
Rotham has been a late in both games so even less JS, he does have scoring potential though
Good luck whoever you choose or if you don’t trade.
hore was out due to an injury , should have good JS now
Rotham was only a late in for Jetta last week. I reckon he’s last in / first out.
Tough one….dees have jetta, lewis, lever to come back in def. I started hore so he stays, but to trade him in is a different issue.
Trading B.Crouch for Rockliff and Trading Butters to ROB.
TU Do them!
TD hold all your 30 trades!
I have to trade at some point peoples!!
I believe ROB will be a good trade 🙂
ROB only if you have 30 trades. Sauce gone for 6 weeks according to Crows…that could mean 8-10
Who says you HAVE to trade anyway !!
If Balta is dropped
Tu hold
Td trade to stack via dpp
Vice Captain Loophole
T/U – Grundy
T/D – Neale
With the news Port have selected Marshall which could free up Westhoff:
TU – hold but note another subpar score will take him into the $300s
TD – trade to Daniel because another subpar score will take him out of price range
With sauce Jacob’s set to be out for the next 4-6 weeks will ROB be a viable cash cow for our teams:
TU – Yes will make enough in minimum 4 weeks
TD – Won’t make enough in 4 weeks to be worth a trade
Best rookie to get in by a mile for quick reliable cash. Just waiting for teams to drop and snag him.
Agree…and js may go beyond sauce return.
Be great if he can play till round 13 too.
TU: Sweet to O’Brien, Setterfield to Baker
TD: Don’t make any trades
First one only. Setterfield great c loop for two weeks.
Only have 7k, could do Parker instead but that would leave me with Baker on the field.
TU: Butters to Stack and Crisp to Lloyd
TD: Butters to Stack and Crisp to Boak via DPP
Hold Crisp.
Treloar out for:
TU: Bont
TD: Rocky
Cmnt: Zerrett
Hold Treloar.
Trade which of the 2 :
TU: AngusBrayshaw
TD: Treloar
Hold both……… or the SC gods will send you a message..
The one you hold will go under 80 ,and the one you trade will go 120+
Both should average 100 /110+ for the rest of the season.
Don’t jump off now.
Parker to Obrien
then Williams to Hurn
TU – yes
TD – no
I dont have either Whitfield or Lloyd..
Alternative is keep williams so go
Parker to Obrien
then Parker to stack or Ross
WIll bank me 250 k
TU – williams will be okay this week
TD – need another premo next to laird like now
THanks
Sorry butters to Stack or Ross
Rotham likely out.
Will Hayes likely in.
Anyone know what Hayes being named means? Any chance of it somehow being beneficial for dunkly…
Well his a midfielder isn’t he. I assume he will play on a half forward. Depends who he comes in for. Id imagine little to no impact.
Yep, he’s a midfielder so… Bont may go fwd, pushing dunkley up the ground. Clutching at straws here lol.
I had Dunkley out for Marshall but ive reversed it.
Only thing stopping me doing that trade is that Marshall plays Gawn and Dunkley plays against Carlton.
I’m not trading dunkly, can loophole him later on as m-9, f-7.
But would love at leased 2 100’s for the season.
Williams to Lloyd – TU
Smith to Lloyd – TD
or hold?
Which is more of a priority to trade out?
TU: Parker (StK)
TD: Dunkley
Better overall trade in option
TU: Reilly Obrien
TD: Sydney Stack
Now Parker is playing, who to trade
TU Parker
TD Setterfield
Cheers
Need some help.
Butters to Stack
T/U Yes!
T/D No!
Who to start at M8:
TU: B Scott
TD: Z Butters
Comment: Gibbons or Atkins
Advice needed
ROB in R3
Bines to FWD (loophole)
Setterfield to MID (loophole)
Trade out
TU: Gibbons
TD: Atkins
Is Gibbons to Stack worth the trade?
TU: Go for it
TD: Don’t do it
Who to start at D6:
TU: M Hore
TD: S Collins
Comment: J Clark
Sheed>Merrett
Butters>O’Brien
Worth it?
TU: Yes go for it
TD: No – keep Sheed (Gibbons >O’Brien)
Trade out
TU: Parker (BE 40)
TD: setterfield (BE 20 has handy DPP)
i know setters is out for two but his loophole is handy
Cmnt: Butters (BE 45)
Well Scott did crap, so I won’t be taking his emergency score for Constable (So I’ll have to bench him for someone else). Who should I put on field for Constable?
TU: Stack
TD: Atkins