Got questions as we head towards Round 11? Your fellow coaches are here to help.
Post your questions below, and answer them by using the thumbs up/thumbs down buttons. Simple!
2
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Table For Two – Round 11
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Better choice for the rest of the season:
TU: Fyfe
TD: Steele
Comment: Petracca (+ $38,000)
Steele simply due to his durability. Can’t trust Fyfe no matter how good he looks
Yeah. Bang on, LG.
Word of a foot complaint for Fyfe this week as well.
Have gone Satan over Gawn don’t have the Bont
T.U: Weightman
T.D: Madden
Tricky one this week. Weightman with rock solid JS and two nice starting scores but small pressure FWDs prone to some ass scores and comes at an elevated price. Madden basement price but don’t have a solid read on his JS and won’t kick a goal each week as a HB.
Have the same problem decided to go with Weightman, both have looked good but think Madden might have less JS with a few 1st choice(more experienced) players due back soon, was going to bring in both but trades are at a premium this year especially it seems,will hold the trade ( back rookies Jones,Highmore, Burgess,Young nth) just don’t think Madden will cover any lost money during the byes , thankfully Reeves and Coleman Jones have given me options to trade Draper (my long-term loop whole) for cash to upgrade Jordan and Warner to Macree and Ridley/ Bowes , what are your thoughts
Yeah, thinking Weightman as well.
Just has the JS and will get a cull-able price quicker.
Who to trade out
T/U Jordon (opponents next 2 weeks: Dogs, Brisbane)
T/D Warner (opponents next 2 weeks: Carlton, Saints)
This week
TU: paint the fence – Weightman/madden & gutherie
TD: double down – weightman & madden
1 up 1 down but I wouldn’t be rushing to get Guthrie in, wait and see how he goes with his shoulder. Could even be a late out
1 up 1 down or 2 down.
T/U Scott + Powell -> Macrae + Madden leaving $25,200 In the piggy
or
T/D Scott + Powell -> Weightman + Madden leaving a fat piggy with $473,000
I’m leaning towards Macrae because I need to make up ground but I also don’t want to miss a good cow opportunity
Already have Oliver, Macrae, Duncan, Steele, Merrett, and Cripps. Got $564k to get another mid. Trade Powell to:
T/up – Titch
T/down – Boak
Walsh?
Can’t afford him, only have $564k. I could trade jordon out but then I have to keep Powell, who could lose a lot more cash. Would rather trade Powell first.
Will there be any on the bubble rookies available next week? Trying to decide if I need to trade in both Madden & Weightman this week, or just one of them. Both have R13 bye which isn’t at all helpful.
Reeves from Hawthorn will be on the bubble next week.
Assuming he holds his spot and scores OK, I’ll look to go Flynn down to Reeves, and use the cash to upgrade elsewhere.
…but Reeves will be on the bye next week
Max Holmes will also be on the bubble and bye. It’s gonna be a hard week for downgrades
TU – Mills/Madden
TD – Whitfield/Weightman
Ooof. That is TOUGH, Grinter. Jeez, hmm.
Mills to score more than Whitfield, but Weightman better JS than Madden.
If you’ve got decent F7/8 depth, then I’d go Mills and Madden.
Madden should stick around for a while but if he is dropped, you’ll atleast have bench cover and in the meantime Mills will continue to pop off.
Good luck.
Yes, quite the dilemma GD. Obviously Mills and Weightman would be preferred but don’t have enough cash.
F7/8 are currently Waterman and Scott. Dogs are saying Scott is ‘managed’ so should be back next week to give me solid FWD coverage.
The other thing to remember with Scott is that his price is gonna plummet thanks to that 18 so I’d look at getting rid of him rather than holding onto him as cover for one more week
Good point. I can actually do Whitfield/Weightman from Scott as well.
TU – Jordon/Warner out, Mills/Madden in
TD – Jordon/Scott out, Whitfield/Weightman in
Would you have enough for Mills and Weightman if you traded out Scott and Warner?
I’d keep Jordon for the moment
No, not enough I’m afraid. Need Jordon’s extra $50k.
Isn’t Scott dropped this week won’t go down in price
Trade 1 is done – Scott to Weightman
Leaves me with 14 trades
TU: Do a 2nd trade to help with building some cash, trade Warner / Kos for Madden
TD: Not worth it, Madden has poor JS and Warner / Kos are still getting games
T/U Ridley and Heeney (sack Jordon)
T/D Heeney and Madden (Sack Scott)
Powell and bergman down to madden and weightman $361k in bank TU
Scott and bergman down to madden and weightman $292 in bank TD
Or TU Powell and Jordan out for Steele weightman/madden
T/U Scott, McCreery for Zorko, Heeney with $104,500
T/D Scott, McCreery for Bolton, Hall with $9,000
Table for three ???
V on Gawn, Bont, or Satan ???
Have gone Satan over Gawn don’t have the Bont
Gawn surely
Am getting rid of A.Scott but unsure which other rookie to dump. likely to upgrade the one I don’t dump next week
t/u – Jordon
t/d – McNeil
Need to get Oliver ASAP
Trade Jordan and Atkins and get Oliver and weightman
TU yes do it, (Oliver cheap and weightman on the bubble)
TD no don’t,( Jordan and Atkins are worth holding)
Thanks in advance
1st trade is done – Scott > Weightman
2nd trade ??
TU – McNiel > Bont
TD – McNiel > Walsh
G’day Boys,
I’m hamstrung this week again, with Alex Witherden.
I need help in replacing him, with $598,600
My backline is
Laird, Stewart,Ridley, Short,_____,Moore
Bench Highmore & Chugg
Mills
Yep, Mills 100%.
Who to dump?
TU: W. Phillips (Started the season with him and he’s made me -$3.2k)
TD: Brockman (Has made a small profit but not getting games)
Both
Ideally yes, but I’ve burnt too many goddamn trades. One has to sit in hope they eventually make money. Cheers coaches.
TU: Titch and Madden(F8 with Waterman)
TD: Whitfield(via Laird to mids) and Weightman (F8 with Waterman)
TU – Powell, Jordan >> Cerra, S.Bolton ($25k left)
TD – Powell, Scott >> Cerra, Madden (315k left)
Points on field V building a war chest & getting a bubble boy in.
Thoughts?
How injured is Hunter Clarke?
He’s not. He’s been dropped
TU: clarry + madden
TD: petracca + weightman +80k
TU – Warner & Scott to Heeney & Weightman $91,400
TD – Warner & Scott to Madden & Weightman $314,500 ITB (would help going into byes)
With option 2, Madden & Weightman will be on the field and basically replacing Warner, sending Poulter to MID bench. My team can be found in trade talk if it helps make your decision.
need help – apologies to format – but I have 4 and cannot choose between need a comment please
Mills – def – $578k avg 113
Steele – mid – $563k avg 112
Titch – mid – $553k avg 107
Libba – mid – $545k – avg 104
All getting lots of CBAs, all can go big and forgetting position and bye, I can get one of them in and at this price all tempting – but I cant separate!
Brains trust?
Steele the cream of the crop. Mills, if your backline is particularly thin.
Titch*
Should I keep Bergman or trade him to madden?
Tu do it
Td no
Thanks guys.
Who to field at D6?
TU:- Tom Highmore
TD:- Nathan Murphy
Who To Field up soon, Bruce.
TU: Kosi -> Ridley & Jordon -> Steele ($7k left)
TD: Kosi -> Madden & Jordon -> Bont ($300k left)
TU – Steele
TD – Walsh
If I get Walsh, I only have 10 premiums in round 13 and 15 in round 14.
Steele will make it 11 in round 13 and 14 in round 14.
TU: weightman
TD: madden
TU: mitchell
TD: petracca
TU: Ridley
TD: Whitfield
So here’s an interesting one folks:
T/U -Parish (avg 111 – 3rnd & 5rnd avg 134) – only 3.9% owned
T/D – Walsh (avg 116 3rnd avg 105, 5rnd 115) – 26.1% owned
Will Parish continue on strongly??
Yeah, looks to be on a tremendous development arc.
A touch expensive but if you suits your byes and you’re looking to splurge on a MID, think he’s a deadly POD.