Got questions as we head towards Round 2? Your fellow coaches are here to help.
Post your questions below, and answer them by using the thumbs up/thumbs down buttons. Simple!
0
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Table For Two – Round 3
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Holding Neale and Cripps.
Anyone else refusing to trade their premos this early?
Yep, holding Danger. Conserve trades early.
I’m biting the bullet on Neale.
I have given it a whole lotta thought.
It means next week ,I will have 13 premo’s on field.
Neale to Brayshaw
Brayshaw is scoring like Neale should be, If he remains heathy I’m not sure he will be this cheap again all year.
I certainly can’t say the same about Neale.
Sharp to James Jordan.
This is a no brainer even with the loss of DPP.
I will have then have all the good rookies and $314 K for an upgrade next week.
The highest BE between Dow, H.Young ,J Clark and even maybe Ziebell will be on the chopping block.
On Neale.
Rumours of injury, and the lions Ruck set up worry me.
Without a competent Ruck and no J Berry for a while ( the Muscle in the Lions engine room). I just don’t see Neale’s job getting any easier. I’m going to use his money while I still can.
Best of luck to everyone in Round 3 🙂
Trading out H Jones for
Tu impey
Td L McDonald
Was trading out NCox but with the Sharp news not so sure.
TU – continue with NCox to Impey via DPP
TD – keep NCox in DEF, got decent JS
Caldwell out
TU Tex
TD Impey
missing Jordon and Warner.
TU: Cripps & Bergman > Jordon & Warner
($393k ITB 10 keepers plus ziebell, Taranto and Phillips.
Bank to bring in Neale when he bottoms out
TD: Cripps & Dow > Brayshaw & Warner
($51k ITB) 11 keepers plus ziebell, Taranto and Phillips.
Comment:
Hold Cripps
Dow & Bergman > Warner & Jordon
$72k ITB
Bit of a revised repost as TD/TU was a tie
TU Macrae and Butters
TD Brayshaw/Walsh and Dusty
Trading out Gaff for
TU Butters
TD Bowes
Cheers
Going for league only. Missing Jordan and was looking to bring in Impey, but my initial plan involved trading Phillips who looks set to get a game so:
TU: Neale & Cox/Bruhn > Jordan & Premo Mid or Def (Ridley/Bowes/Brayshaw etc)
TD: Neale & Bruhn > Jordan & Impey (Pure ca$h gen trades)
TU: Andy Brayshaw
TD: Dusty Martin
Is it worth trading out Hunter for Flynn?
TU – Yes
TD – No
Tu:
Tom Green & Sharp -> Jiath & Jordon
Td:
Sharp & Jones -> Impey & Luke Parks
J.Treacy out
Flynn in
28 trades left
TU – do it
TD – save the trade
Trade out a fwd and swing Treacy to F8 so when you cash out Flynn you can swing Treacy back to R3
Yep great idea. I didn’t even think of that. Nice one.
Trading in either :
TU: Macrae & Butters (with $54,500 bank left)
TD: Ridley & Andy Brayshaw (with $84,100 bank left)
Would love to be able to do Ridley & Macrae but can’t afford that…
TU: Impey
TD: Sam Berry
Going H Jones to Berry. Own all of the other main rookies.
And am 93% sold on taking the gamble with Tex. Just need to decide who makes way for him.
T/u. dow out. ~70k in bank
T/d. Cripps out. ~400k in bank.
Jordon and warner only rookies I dont have. Is it silly to trade either mcneill or scott for one of them?
TU – yes trade
TD – no dont trade scott or mcneill
Is Round 3 such a valuable money/point making opportunity that one should make some otherwise slightly reckless trades?
Have all rookies but Berry, did burn 2 on danger/rowell last week. Been mulling over things like Neale -> Macrae, Cripps -> Brayshaw, Dow -> Berry/Impey (1k short for straight to Tex) all week, and will continue to do so right up to the lockout.
T/U: Press the advantage!
T/D: Whoa there cowboy…
Been doing my head…..Caldwell to Tex and chase cash, or to Butters/Heeney and hopefully save a later trade.
T/u Tex
T/d Butters/Heeney
Comment…Butters or Heeney ?
Butters
Concussion issues.
TU Fyfe >> Dunkley
TD Hold Fyfe..he’s back next week
Nah, it’s only one week. Hold him until his next injury.
Caldwell to
TU: B.Campbell
TD: Impey
Comment: Tex
Who to trade out for James Jordon
TU – lach McNeil
TD – Tanner Bruhn
Trade tom Phillips or not?
Is it worth trading Harry Jones -> Tom Powell?
Is it worth trading Gawn/Grundy to Flynn since I can’t afford him at R3 (Have Hunter there) and upgrade A.Fyfe (GC) to premo mid
TU – Yes
TD – No (hold)
Thanks
Which rookie correction is more important?
T/U – Hunter to Meek (r3)
T/D – McNeil/ Scott to Berry (M11)
Meek is not 100% to be named this week.
If he does play. I think he may.
Treacy may replace him the week after if Darcy stays fit.
I would go the Berry kid.
Is using 4 corrective/necessary trades in two rounds ok or should I just stick to one this week. (Traded out Rowell and Danger last week, am now trading caldwell out for impey) just cant decide on hunter to flynn
T/U: Hold Hunter you cant burn 4 trades already
T/D: Get rid of hunter it is worth the cash from Flynn
I have a two-parter for all of your beautiful SC brains to contemplate and hopefully help me decide before lock-out tonight…
Part 1 – who to trade out?
T/U: H. Young
T/D: P. Dow
Part 2 – who to trade in?
The answer to part 1 will change who is on-field for my other rookies / cow-like objects (CLOs) because of MPP, so I may make a 3rd part once the thumbs have spoken.
T/U: Impey at F4
T/D: S. Berry at M9, or M8 if people think he’ll score more than J. Clark).
Dow to Jordan ?
TU : go for it bank $80k
TD: no will average similar anyway. Save a trade
Bring in
TU: Heeney
TD: Butters
Thanks
Considering trading T Phillips to A Brayshaw
TU: Do it – Brayshaw will be a top 8 mid & has a low BE
TD: Hold off – no need to get rid of Phillips just yet.
Comment – trade to Impey instead.